Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
BigSandyBalls2015 · 17/07/2021 09:34

We later on had some amazing foreign trips but our adult DCs never mention those but have very fond memories of camping.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 17/07/2021 09:33

I would have thought the opposite .... we camped loads when our kids were small because we we’re skint!

CounsellorTroi · 17/07/2021 09:32

YANBU. We had a seaside holiday every year but the only camping I ever did as a child was in the back garden. As an adult I don’t get the attraction.

FreekStar2 · 17/07/2021 09:32

YANBU

IMO there two schools of camping: those who camp because because it's cheaper than other accommodation, and those who camp because they see it as 'character building, fun, a great 'experience'. or something like that.

Then there's the rest of us who think a holiday should be about having a little luxury and can't imagine anything worse than sleeping in a cloth building, lying on the floor and not having a private bathroom or toilet for a week.

Inanun2 · 17/07/2021 09:31

I think it very clear the teacher was referring to Children who will never have the opportunity to go anywhere, because their parents could not care less or can really not afford anything, which you must realise. It was not a dig at anyone who does not go camping. If you have so little empathy to understand this then I am surprised you are at the same school as it must be all around you and you turn a blind eye.

However, if you ask about my opinion of camping. I grew up in a camping / caravanning family so it was completely natural to me, my DH didn’t so I had a hard sell to persuade him to try it. I wanted to give my kids the freedom that I had growing up, visiting all areas of the UK, playing , freedom, and making lots of new friends. Camping is a great leveller for Kids and such fun. However when they got a little older about 10 we stopped and started to do different type of hotel / apartment holidays which we also love love. It is an effort to go camping to set up, pack it all down, but so pleased we did it.

In turn my teenagers now do camping and walking hols with their friends and so the cycle continues I hope.

Ps. I know people who do not drive and get taxis or buses and we live rurally - it costs a lot to run a car and for some completely unaffordable.

Manzanilla55 · 17/07/2021 09:29

I hate camping. Ds is 16 and is going away for four days with his army cadets soon. He has never been in the past.

beigebrownblue · 17/07/2021 09:28

Perhaps with the aftermath of covid and the devestating impact of austerity a little reset and clarity regarding 'deprivation' might be hoped for.

1 in 5 kids in this country are on free school meals currently. (FSM)

Many more are probably borderline as families with someone in employment are close to the threshold and many going to foodbanks.

Personally I prefer to speak in terms of economic deprivation, as many who are on a low income number amongst the most cultured and wise people I know.

We don't have a television, and no car. Live in social housing. In an area of multiple economic deprivation.

I have come across different stereotypes on my journey. Early on in my life i taught myself how to cook and there is a big focus on food and nutrition in our home, as opposed to many other things we could have spent money on.

In my DD's class there are kids who have never got on a bus.

I'm shocked by this, and see it as deprivation, as navigating public transport is an essential life skill, surely?

There are many houses without books. Earlier in DD's life we went to the library twice a week and she got through at least six books a week.

As someone has said, camping can be very expensive if you don't have the kit. Or not doable if you don't have a car.

Or perhaps not a real holiday anyway for a parent who is trying to hold everything down and just wants a break from household chores like cleaning.

If I could afford it, give me a hotel anytime.

TwinsandTrifle · 17/07/2021 09:28

Your post sounds very close to benefits bashing, despite having been on them yourself.

That's pretty much my point. I could not believe how much money was being thrown at me. That's why I have little appreciation of people who've been given the same but say they have no money. They should have. I mean, I could have bought myself a new wardrobe each month, and said "I've got no money to go camping" but what I mean is I do have the money but bought myself loads of clothes instead, not that I couldn't afford it.

It's like the PP. Well some people don't get the food vouchers you don't get them after age 4.

Correct. And misleading like I was getting extra.

Because the vouchers are replaced by FSM. A two course hot meal, 5 days out of 7, and supermarket vouchers out of term time, which far surpass the value of the milk tokens per week.

But it's this mentality of portraying, "oh I don't get this, I don't get that" but hiding "I get this instead"

It reminds me of my friend. Long term single. Always complaining about it.

"Go online?"
No. It's all weirdos.

"Ok, you could try, just once?"
No.

"Maybe socialise more?"
Can't. Haven't got anyone to look after DS.

"Then get a babysitter?"
I don't want a babysitter I don't know.

"Then get to know one, or one from a professional agency"
No. That will be expensive.

"Then join some clubs or just get out in the day while DS is at school"
What clubs.

"I don't know?! Look it up, see what you like the look of!"
I can't be bothered.

Then don't whine all the time that you're single when you won't do any of the things you could be, that might change that.

OhRene · 17/07/2021 09:16

Ugh. Camping. Hate it. I don't see how someone not having gone camping has been deprived. That said, I've never given any thought to kids who've never been abroad either. It's not something which DH and I do. We've been abroad once, at my father's request, but we had to take a large loan out for it. (I don't regret it because it was great fun and my father passed away not long after) but I don't feel bad that my kids had never been abroad before then and perhaps won't get the chance again until they are adults themselves.

We do own a good tent. We've were given it years ago but we have never felt a strong enough urge to use the bloody thing.

NoSquirrels · 17/07/2021 09:10

In thirty years, I have not met anyone who doesn't drive. I've lived in 8 non city locations, not a specific area. I'm sure they do exist, but I've never come across anyone without a car. As apposed to my city dwelling friends, where only one out of the lot of them has a car.

Gosh. I can immediately think of half a dozen people without even trying.

TwinsandTrifle · 17/07/2021 09:07

Why are you making this all about you and your individual circumstances?

I'm applying my own circumstances because I've been in a low income situation. And the comments being made, that people in those circumstances can't afford in any way to go camping, weren't correct. As I was in that situation. And could.

Just because you don't know anyone without a car in your specific area far from means that most people have a car.

In thirty years, I have not met anyone who doesn't drive. I've lived in 8 non city locations, not a specific area. I'm sure they do exist, but I've never come across anyone without a car. As apposed to my city dwelling friends, where only one out of the lot of them has a car.

Not to mention that a high concentration of people in the UK do live in cities or towns. I grew up rurally and plenty I. The villages etc had no car

Ok. I've experienced the opposite.

When I claimed benefits they fat from paid all my private rent or all my council tax.

Well, they calculate what you get on the average rental price in your area. So you must be choosing a property that is well above that, in order for the amount to "far from" pay it. And c.tax, is virtually wiped out. So was it that you had some benefits and a job as well? In which case, of course your benefits didn't cover all your rent, they taper them in line with your income.

Milk and fruit vouchers stop when the dc reach age 4, that's no help to families of primary age or teen dc.

That's why they are replaced with free school meals after age 4.

Great you got all that - not everyone does

That's my point. Everyone does. I wasn't special or entitled to more. If they don't have their full rent covered then it's not because they are disadvantaged. They've chosen a house in excess of the local average. Or they are working, and have to make a contribution to their rent. Rightly so. Don't get free milk because your kid's 6? No, but let's not point out you get the higher value of FSM instead.

NoSquirrels · 17/07/2021 09:06

I truly don't understand, how when I was on the same benefit income, I was more than covered, and yet people on the same, are in such poverty that they can't find £20. With the exception of the initial delay when enrolling for UC (and that's a one off temporary thing) after a couple of months, I don't get how people have "no money". I've been there, I'm not a special case. It was more than enough.

Because they’re bad at managing money, for a variety of reasons, some of them what some people might say is personal responsibility and some which are systemic. Please, open your eyes. Your post sounds very close to benefits bashing, despite having been on them yourself.

3Britnee · 17/07/2021 09:02

Camping is (was, before covid) relatively cheap. Maybe she meant kids that don't even get the cheapest camping holiday.

But I wouldn't count not going camping as the bastion of deprivation. A holiday is a nice extra but not essential. If kids didn't have food, warmth and a roof, then theres deprivation but having all the essentials but just not going on holiday, is not deprived.

And then you have the kids that have never been camping because they go on 5* foreign holidays. Those kids certainly aren't deprived.

rantymcrantface66 · 17/07/2021 08:59

Oh and fwiw our campsite was £180 for 4 nights.

ViceLikeBlip · 17/07/2021 08:55

Ps that's in absolutely no way a dig at the parents at all.

ViceLikeBlip · 17/07/2021 08:54

You're all seeing it from your non-deprived view. Yes of course lots of non-deprived kids have never been camping-they've been on all inclusive to the Maldives etc.

But most deprived kids absolutely wouldn't get the opportunity to go camping without school trips. It's cheaper than a foreign holiday, but it's still not actually CHEAP. And as a teacher, to see kids having that sort of carefree freedom and fun that they wouldn't otherwise have the opportunity for? It's bittersweet for sure.

Whatafustercluck · 17/07/2021 08:54

I imagine she probably meant those children have never been on any kind of holiday/ trip - camping or otherwise. She probably sees camping as slightly more accessible to less wealthy families. That is all.

We enjoy camping, albeit we have a caravan and not a tent. It is more affordable - particularly this summer when the price of self catering accommodation has sky rocketed. Totally get it's not everyone's idea of a holiday. But I wouldn't get worked up about comments that are clearly directed at children who are actually deprived, rather than just deprived of camping experience.

Pinnerbrat · 17/07/2021 08:47

Sounds like she was making the assumption that its a shame if kids don't get that experience, as with many other broad life experiences. Mine is that most little kids really love camping, and it's a fairly special experience, exciting, sleeping out etc. So it's great if they can get that experience if it's not available at home. Personally I loved it as a kid/Guide, and took my kids camping as a single parent which was hard work but I had a car and the kit so was fortunate. Generally it strikes me as cheap once you're set up, assuming car. I still like the outdoor aspect, but campsites can be pretty hellish and noisy so the lack of sleep has reduced my interest in middle age. But I'd have no problem with teacher noting that, like other experiences (such as getting into the countryside from cities), its good to see kids getting a taste of as broad a life as possible and if school or clubs can do that, great.

rantymcrantface66 · 17/07/2021 08:46

Just because it's possible manage basic camping on public transport for a reasonable price doesn't mean many will do that or any other trip or holiday. Those who are suggesting it likely don't have any concept of true deprivation. Not to mention dragging a load of heavy kit on the bus with young dc and cramming in to a £60 Tesco tent that will leak when it rains and buying expensive basic food from a campsite shop because you not have a car to drive to the supermarket once you're there, all sounds pretty miserable. We've just got back from a fabulous camping trip but every inch of the car was occupied and everything we brought was needed and used.

ouchmyfeet · 17/07/2021 08:42

YABU. Camping is a massive adventure for kids. Some of my strongest happy childhood memories are camping holidays.

GalacticDragonfly · 17/07/2021 08:36

You can save up and buy the kit a bit at a time, but you are never going to do that unless you are confident you will enjoy it. That’s exactly why schools offering experiences like this is so important. Children need to try out as many opportunities as possible to learn which ones are important to them, so that their choices and priorities as adults aren’t so constrained.

DahliaBlue · 17/07/2021 08:34

Camping requires quite a bit of organisation. Easier to book a cheap package Costa holiday. Costs probably about the same when equipment and transportation considered. For me, the greatest appeal of camping is the openness, being next to nature, the fresh air, and space. Agree it can be grim if things go wrong though.

rantymcrantface66 · 17/07/2021 08:31

@TwinsandTrifle

Not everyone might have £100 spare. But one month they may have £40. Another, £20 etc. They don't need to buy everything at once. Then, when they have it, have got it to use repeatedly

And yes, as someone who has lived out of London for 30yrs, I can confirm pretty much everyone has a car! Swap "London" for "big towns/cities". I live on the outskirts of a small town. I would not be able to get a pint of milk without a car. I don't know anyone locally who doesn't have a car. Of my friends in London, I only know one that does.

I spent a period of time, with one DC on benefits, and it truly baffles me how people are in this level of poverty. I almost couldn't believe the amount of money I was just being "given".

They pay your rent, council tax, your water bill is capped, you get free fruit/veg/milk vouchers. I honestly couldn't believe it, and lived no differently (day to day) than when I was in employment. I wasn't treating myself to shoes I didn't need perhaps, but we were very comfortable. I truly don't understand, how when I was on the same benefit income, I was more than covered, and yet people on the same, are in such poverty that they can't find £20. With the exception of the initial delay when enrolling for UC (and that's a one off temporary thing) after a couple of months, I don't get how people have "no money". I've been there, I'm not a special case. It was more than enough.

Why are you making this all about you and your individual circumstances? Just because you don't know anyone without a car in your specific area far from means that most people have a car. Not to mention that a high concentration of people in the UK do live in cities or towns. I grew up rurally and plenty I. The villages etc had no car. When I claimed benefits they fat from paid all my private rent or all my council tax. Milk and fruit vouchers stop when the dc reach age 4, that's no help to families of primary age or teen dc. Great you got all that - not everyone does.
SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 08:28

@Whywonttheyhelpme

I would rather cover myself in honey and staple my tits to a beehive. However it is safe to say my children are definitely not “deprived” by their lack of camping experience.
Have they ever been on holiday, even overnight? A day trip to the sea or the mountains?
Griefmonster · 17/07/2021 08:23

@Urbandweller You have misconstrued what the teacher has said. You have entirely flipped the causal relationship she was (admittedly clumsilly) trying to express.

Children who are "deprived" (usually meaning economically) are less likely to have experienced certain things. In the case of "deprived" children living in a big city - spending extended time outdoors and in nature.

For "deprived" children living in rural areas I imagine a similarly minded teacher would talk about trips to museums and galleries.

The barriers to a child experiencing something far outside their environment when they are living in poverty are significant. - access to a car, access to equipment, time off low paid work, physical disability, other caring responsibilities (huge correlation between disability and poverty).

She said equivelant to "it is nice to give the children who haven't had the opportunity to at home, an experience of camping" she hasn't said - "the fact these children haven't camped is because they're poor".

She wasn't making a judgement on people who don't camp!

Swipe left for the next trending thread