Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Urbandweller · 17/07/2021 10:59

@LyndaSnellsSniff thank you, this is my point. The teacher enjoys camping. She camped as a child. She has therefore decided that the children at DD’s school who haven’t are deprived. She may have meant ‘culturally deprived’ but in any case, she has extrapolated her childhood experiences and applied them to children who grow up in an entirely different environment from the one she grew up in.

And thank you to those who realise how patronising this teacher is.

She is honestly very much of the opinion that children who don’t do “certain things” are deprived and therefore makes a lot assumptions about what deprivation looks like.

Like most areas of London our borough has high levels of deprivation and pockets of gentrification and affluence. There are children in DD’s class who are MC (and haven’t been camping!) and some who qualify for FSM but they are not necessarily deprived: their parents work, they have opportunities to go on days out, holidays etc. Those children may not go camping but that is mostly due to personal family choice. This teacher seems to have applied a broad brush definition of what deprivation is to children in the school because they are working class. Case in point, she seemed genuinely surprised when I mentioned we took the DC to a National Trust venue. I get the impression she thinks families like us wouldn’t have NT membership (we are working class and we are not white).

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 17/07/2021 10:51

@EmeraldShamrock

That's my point. Everyone does. I wasn't special or entitled to more. If they don't have their full. *@TwinsandTrifle* Twins you come across as an educated person, surely you can understand if everyone gets the same amount surely you realise people spend differently and manage money differently? They may not having budgeting skills - they more than likely were brought up similar- some are feckless parents spend it on takeaways, alcohol, drugs, high cost loans are a major issue after Christmas around here. They might be excuses however it is a lifestyle for the DC. I can't believe the amount of Mnetters who missed the point, have taken the teachers statement to be about a tent experience. It is very Ivory Tower 😕 "Let them eat cake"
Agreed @EmeraldShamrock. It is shocking the amount of posters who can't understand what the teacher is saying. It's not difficult. She is saying, as numerous people have already explained, that some children don't even ever get a day trip in their local area area so camping is a big deal and a holiday for them. The teacher cares and is glad that the children at least get some holiday. It's not the camping per se, it's the experience. Countless pp's twittering "Oh, camping is hellish, not a holiday", 'my poor dc cried, hated camping'. Others actually criticise the teacher. Why are posters taking everything at face value as if they can't see the bigger picture? I'm sure all those criticising camping have taken their dc on many, varied holidays. A pp actually called people who "camp in a crowded field for a tenner a night and call it a holiday", 'plebes' (it's spelt pleb!). Unless they were being ironic that's vile. Some people don't have a tenner. Or transport. Or the will. Or the organisational skills. Or have been very poorly parented themselves... The list goes on. Yes, it's very sad and wrong and some people are just terrible parents but mostly, there a reason behind not having a holiday even just camping. Please could some pp have some more EI and empathy.
SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 10:45

Actually you fuckers saying about poor and camping the teacher actually meant most of these privileges darlings will never have to slum it thanks to middle class arse parents without op clarifying the socio economic makeup of the school, you have no idea whether it's MC or not. Jist because they aren't all getting FSM doesn't mean its a well to do area.
It seems far more rational that the teacher means "some of these families are so economically deprived they cant afford holidays" than "oh its so sad all these rich children have never slept on a soggy field in Wales"

AcrobaticCardigan · 17/07/2021 10:40

I’m sure she doesn’t mean any child who’s not been camping is deprived, but it sounds like there are children in the class who are deprived in general and don’t really get to go anywhere / do anything and she’s glad to be able to do this for them.

toffeebutterpopcorn · 17/07/2021 10:37

Anyway - I think it’s great that kids get the chance to go off on an ‘adventure’ without their parents and siblings.

wedswench · 17/07/2021 10:36

@TwinsandTrifle

Not everyone might have £100 spare. But one month they may have £40. Another, £20 etc. They don't need to buy everything at once. Then, when they have it, have got it to use repeatedly

And yes, as someone who has lived out of London for 30yrs, I can confirm pretty much everyone has a car! Swap "London" for "big towns/cities". I live on the outskirts of a small town. I would not be able to get a pint of milk without a car. I don't know anyone locally who doesn't have a car. Of my friends in London, I only know one that does.

I spent a period of time, with one DC on benefits, and it truly baffles me how people are in this level of poverty. I almost couldn't believe the amount of money I was just being "given".

They pay your rent, council tax, your water bill is capped, you get free fruit/veg/milk vouchers. I honestly couldn't believe it, and lived no differently (day to day) than when I was in employment. I wasn't treating myself to shoes I didn't need perhaps, but we were very comfortable. I truly don't understand, how when I was on the same benefit income, I was more than covered, and yet people on the same, are in such poverty that they can't find £20. With the exception of the initial delay when enrolling for UC (and that's a one off temporary thing) after a couple of months, I don't get how people have "no money". I've been there, I'm not a special case. It was more than enough.

They don't pay everyone's rent. It depends where you are. Here rent is capped at £800 bit even a one bed is £1000.

Nor do they pay your council tax. We do they food vouchers either although the kids get fsm.

It depends on your circumstances as to whether benefits feels a lot or not

toffeebutterpopcorn · 17/07/2021 10:36

-ah, maybe it’s memories...

I still remember (almost 50 years on) arriving at the campsite late in the evening in torrential rain and a massive thunder storm.

Dad and my brother were trying to pitch the (massive) tent as the rain pelted down and mum stomped up and down ‘that’s it - I’m going home!’ and my eldest sisters mooched about complaining about getting wet (with the sensible one helpfully giving tent-pitching directions to my dad and brother).

Us younger kids just ran about, jumping in the mud and shrieking at the thunder (as mum tried to find our coats in the back of the car, telling us not to be scared - we lived storm though).

Jesus - we all used to pile onto the car - we were in the boot (it was an estate)!

SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 10:20

@DSGBT

If I’m depriving my kids by not going camping long may it continue! It’s my idea of hell.
Have they ever had any other holiday or trip out beyond your area? So seaside if you're inland, mountains if you're coastal etc
EmeraldShamrock · 17/07/2021 10:19

That's my point. Everyone does. I wasn't special or entitled to more. If they don't have their full. @TwinsandTrifle
Twins you come across as an educated person, surely you can understand if everyone gets the same amount surely you realise people spend differently and manage money differently? They may not having budgeting skills - they more than likely were brought up similar- some are feckless parents spend it on takeaways, alcohol, drugs, high cost loans are a major issue after Christmas around here.
They might be excuses however it is a lifestyle for the DC.
I can't believe the amount of Mnetters who missed the point, have taken the teachers statement to be about a tent experience. It is very Ivory Tower 😕
"Let them eat cake"

SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 10:19

@megletthesecond

Yanbu. Camping with dcs is utterly miserable and requires lots of decent equipment. We did it once 7 years ago and I had a sobbing ds at 2am because his sister was keeping us awake. No holiday and days out is better than camping.
We did it with a tent and a one ring stove. We Did need a car. No other equipment. Blankets from home to sleep in, bucket of cold water for fridge. We brought food from a cash and carry.
pleasedonttextmyman · 17/07/2021 10:17

There's camping and camping...

The plebe goes to crowded fields to plonk a cheap tent for a tenner a night, and call it a holiday because they can't afford anything else,

the more wealthy let the children camp on their land, or their friends land for a laugh, or venture on these glamping campsites to stay in their pitch costing a few hundred £ a night (before covid),

And some people in between...

DSGBT · 17/07/2021 10:12

If I’m depriving my kids by not going camping long may it continue! It’s my idea of hell.

Wallpapering · 17/07/2021 10:09

I’d like to know how much money twinsandyrifle had thrown at her?

Surprised it took so many pages before benefit bash started!

How’s secure your future? Btw

megletthesecond · 17/07/2021 10:04

Yanbu. Camping with dcs is utterly miserable and requires lots of decent equipment. We did it once 7 years ago and I had a sobbing ds at 2am because his sister was keeping us awake. No holiday and days out is better than camping.

NoSquirrels · 17/07/2021 10:01

I could not believe how much money was being thrown at me. That's why I have little appreciation of people who've been given the same but say they have no money. They should have.

But it’s not just about the money - the amount of it. Some kids have poor parents with poor parenting skills and live chaotic lives and some of that is systemic - education, ambition, opportunity. You don’t sound at all sympathetic to the fact that it’s hard for some people regardless of the number on the benefit cheque. Poor choices aren’t always just down to individuals doing ‘better’ or trying harder.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 17/07/2021 09:59

@SleepingStandingUp true!! Camping when my kids were small was very cheap, it’s not these days.

mashawithbear · 17/07/2021 09:57

Yanbu!! I hate the idea of camping, it's so not my thing! The teacher is ridiculous to think camping is something everyone enjoys and therefore all children would go and if they don't it's because they are deprived

bigbadbluewhale · 17/07/2021 09:56

Are you really this obtuse?

Experiences like this are often used as markers of deprivation,
because whilst they fall within the normal range of experiences for most people, they are out of reach for those who are more deprived. This is particularly the case if they involve a certain cost, as camping does.

That is not the same as saying that any child who has not been camping is deprived.

You'd rather go away in a caravan or to a hotel or your holiday home? Fine, good for you. That's called personal preference. Some people don't have any options when it comes to taking their children on holiday. This is obviously what the teacher was implying.

Looubylou · 17/07/2021 09:54

BrozTito - Moses was quite a long time ago- it's not inconceivable that habits, needs, or preferences, might have changed since then. 😂

SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 09:52

@BigSandyBalls2015

I would have thought the opposite .... we camped loads when our kids were small because we we’re skint!
Now imagine being so skint you couldn't even afford that
wedswench · 17/07/2021 09:45

Did she mean that some of the kids hadn't even been camping. Like, it's sad they haven't been on holiday so at least now they've been camping

Wallpapering · 17/07/2021 09:43

Oh here we go, go on please tell us poor parents the price of bag pasta and loaf of bread whilst doing price of camping items

Because poor are obviously thick as shit and don’t have a clue how much items cost.

As for the no car posts, when you working in zone 1 London a fucker to drive and when your job means lots of work socialising you tend no need fucking car.

Then you end up in circumstances and where u having to move about keeping your kid safe and roof over head driving goes out fucking window because money runs out. Please fucking tell me how much driving lessons cost and test fees oh rural prives cos poverty - poor means thick a shit

Btw I’ve passed theory

Actually you fuckers saying about poor and camping the teacher actually meant most of these privileges darlings will never have to slum it thanks to middle class arse parents

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 17/07/2021 09:39

Not at all OP. I love camping and would have gone every other week with my DS when he was young but he hates it and everything about it.
He dislikes roughing it and would rather stay in a cheap air B&B. He's always been the same.
I loved camping holidays with my aunt and uncle when I was a child.

yourestandingonmyneck · 17/07/2021 09:38

I don't think this is what she means. I think she means "some have never even been camping, let alone taken on any other type of holiday".

She's not meaning kids are deprived unless they've gone camping. She's meaning that some poor kids get taken nowhere and experience nothing.

toffeebutterpopcorn · 17/07/2021 09:37

Maybe by ‘camping’ she meant ‘taking the kids and nanny to our villa/cottage in Cornwall/South of France/Tuscany’ or ‘glamping at Glasto yah, in our renovated gypsy caravan (with shower, toilet and fully fitted kitchen’)?

Because camping in the south of France in a tent with 6 other family members after a 2 day drive from Scotland, night on the ferry on 40* heat is not my ideal of a luxury holiday!