Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
budgiegirl · 17/07/2021 17:41

What an idiot. We stopped going camping because we bought a cottage by a lake in a forest. My daughter has never been camping. The poor, poor child

There are some very odd, and frankly ignorant, comments on this thread. I know you are being sarcastic, but of course your child is not deprived because they've not been camping. But that doesn't make the teacher an idiot because she has said/implied that some children don't get the opportunity to go camping because of deprivation. She's 100% correct - some don't. It doesn't mean that all children who haven't been camping are deprived.

I feel like many people are deliberately misunderstanding what the teacher was saying/implying.

Ifitquacks · 17/07/2021 17:39

Confused just pointing out why adults who really dislike camping might choose not to use their valuable annual leave and holiday budget going camping.

Starbar66 · 17/07/2021 17:38

I don't think it's a competition... not sure why you are so defensive

Ifitquacks · 17/07/2021 17:36

@Starbar66

YABVU. Lots of adults posting here hate camping. Their kids might love it (in my experience working with kids and teens many really do). The teacher was right that kids miss out on finding out if they like camping (as any other experience) if their parents don't, won't or can't take them. Hence it's great that they get the chance to try it some other way. Same applies to any experience where people can't afford something, or parents don't do something with their kids because they themselves don't like it. As a parent personally I've endured a fair few things I didn't enjoy so the kids could try it, but whichever, she has a point. Not sure why you're so riled about this...
Ah well you’re far more virtuous than me. I have limited annual leave and limited funds so I’m not going to use it doing something I hate.
Starbar66 · 17/07/2021 17:32

YABVU. Lots of adults posting here hate camping. Their kids might love it (in my experience working with kids and teens many really do). The teacher was right that kids miss out on finding out if they like camping (as any other experience) if their parents don't, won't or can't take them. Hence it's great that they get the chance to try it some other way. Same applies to any experience where people can't afford something, or parents don't do something with their kids because they themselves don't like it. As a parent personally I've endured a fair few things I didn't enjoy so the kids could try it, but whichever, she has a point. Not sure why you're so riled about this...

Pretzelcoatl · 17/07/2021 17:23

They’d be deprived if they never had the chance to find out if they liked the experience.

RIPwalter · 17/07/2021 17:22

We live on the side of a mountain in a national park and within 20 minutes drive of a beach. My DD is 3 and hasn't been camping yet because I'd rather sleep properly in our own beds than camp somewhere with midges, no black out blinds, soaking wet everything or overheated tent in the early morning, just for the sake of it.

She is definitely not deprived!

tartanblanketdog · 17/07/2021 17:21

@Lokdok

This isn’t about you. And here, the housing cap is 1000. You can’t rent 1 bedroom for that, let alone house a family! So yes people live in terrible poverty and overcrowding and many don’t have cars. But none of this is relevant to the OP. There are many kinds of deprivation, not all financial.
That is very true - financially secure but emotionally neglected is deprivation.
Lokdok · 17/07/2021 17:14

This isn’t about you. And here, the housing cap is 1000. You can’t rent 1 bedroom for that, let alone house a family! So yes people live in terrible poverty and overcrowding and many don’t have cars. But none of this is relevant to the OP. There are many kinds of deprivation, not all financial.

tartanblanketdog · 17/07/2021 17:09

I took my kids camping because they were privileged. I wanted them to be able to camp so they could enjoy some of the amazing experiences we've had whilst we have been travelling around the world, I wanted them not to be scared of getting dirty or a bit uncomfortable, of walking in the rain, of not being pampered in a 5 star hotel - I wanted them to embrace variety and adventure.

Fimofriend · 17/07/2021 17:02

What an idiot. We stopped going camping because we bought a cottage by a lake in a forest. My daughter has never been camping. The poor, poor child.

ineedaholidayandwine · 17/07/2021 17:00

My daughter has had some amazing holidays and is far from deprived but she has never been camping and i will never take her, i hate it!

PlateSpinnerJuggler · 17/07/2021 17:00

Thought of camping to me - 🤢
Don't worry they've druck mocktails on the beach in Greece instead 🤣

EssentialHummus · 17/07/2021 16:44

(DD is nearly four and has never been camping - though I've been without her! But she has been to different museums and galleries, to the theatre and cinema, holiday activities in DH's language, tried unusual food, seen farm animals etc etc - so not camping is neither here nor there.)

EssentialHummus · 17/07/2021 16:38

I’d have interpreted the teacher’s comments to be about the limited experiences that are often associated with poverty. It’s irrelevant whether kids not in poverty go camping every holiday/occasionally/rarely/never - they’re presumed to have experienced a range of enriching activities to broaden their world view.

I live 6/7 minutes on the train from Tower Bridge, and under 30 minutes on the bus from Greenwich. There are kids locally who have never seen the tower, or the Thames. There are kids living in the rougher bit of our postcode who have never been to the nicer park “up the hill” 5 minutes away. If I’d have been in earshot of that teacher OP, that’s how I’d have interpreted her comments.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 17/07/2021 16:29

Campings shit we went glamping once I hated it. Much prefer a 4 or 5 star hotel. My poor deprived kids.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 17/07/2021 16:27

@SarahBellam

We once camped at a camp site about 10 miles from home. I hated it. It was cold and uncomfortable. In the middle of the night I got up, went home, slept in my bed, had a shower and a nice proper coffee and then went back.
Heh - I managed similar - DS1 and DH camped about 15 minutes up the road, with extended family (in another tent, not the same one). I had DS2, who was still a baby and breastfed at the time. I chose not to stay at all, but drove home with DS2 for a nice quiet night in comfort, leaving DS1 and DH to stay in their tent. Apparently a possum tried to break in, so there was that - I was quite happy to have slept at home and gone back the following day! Grin
Maggiesfarm · 17/07/2021 16:27

@topcat2014

Surely this is what Scouts and Guides are for, so no parent has to suffer!
Yes and some school trips. Mine did that, later on one went camping with friends a couple of times and enjoyed it but tends to look back on those experiences as things you do when you are young.

I know I would have been too nervous to camp and found the whole thing a bit much. I feel the same way about glamping which I have seen on TV - mainly misgivings about toilet and bathroom issues in that case.

However my husband camped from school days, not with parents but with scouts and school, and into young adulthood, here and abroad, up until and including the age of 23. He liked it well enough at the time.

What this thread illustrates is we are all different, so are our chldren. There is no right or wrong about camping, you either like it or you don't.

Urbandweller · 17/07/2021 16:19

@Honeybeebloom

In all honesty OP I'm getting more of a patronising/judgemental vibe from your posts than anything that you say the teacher has said or done. You don't like camping or getting wet, that's fine, however children will not get sick or ill from being in the rain if they have the correct clothing so she's doing nothing wrong in trying to arrange fundraisers to raise money to ensure children have them available for outdoor activities (which are hugely beneficial to children btw, for a number of reasons, and there are plenty of studies that show this to be true).
Please show me where on this thread I have said I dislike getting wet? We holiday in Pembrokeshire every year and the first items packed are our raincoats, waterproofs and wellies. The DC love our holidays there, rain or shine, and we all have fond memories of walking through the lovely coastal national park in the rain.

We also visit friends who live on a farm there. My DC have very little understanding of what life on a farm entails and our friends similarly aged DC enjoy showing them the animals, explaining things to them. On the flip slide when our friends visited us, DD took great delight in showing off her knowledge of the “magic train with no driver” (Docklands Light Railway) and other London specific highlights. Neither set of children are lacking because they have little day to day experience of how the other set live.

And of course outdoor activities are beneficial to children. Again, where have I said otherwise?Confused

OP posts:
Bluedeblue · 17/07/2021 16:13

I would see a link, but in a different way, ie. a camping holiday might be the only type of holiday that some families might be able to afford. I would hate to go camping and I never took my kids camping. They have however been all over the world, staying in nice hotels or hired holiday homes.

topcat2014 · 17/07/2021 16:04

Surely this is what Scouts and Guides are for, so no parent has to suffer!

Urbandweller · 17/07/2021 16:02

@rantymcrantface66

Who would be ‘fine’ after spending 8 hours in the rain, with or without waterproofs? Parents were voicing perfectly valid concerns. I volunteered on several of the trips and it was horrid when it rained, the kids had to eat their packed lunch on a sodden freezing ground. But Ms Outdoors Lover decided that any parents who objected were culturally deficien

Of course they'd be fine in proper waterproofs. There are dc who attend forest schools full time all day 5 days a week. The more you update the more I sympathise with this teacher who it sounds like it's trying to offer great opportunities for all dc

Don’t be absurd. As said, I’ve volunteered several times as a parent and have seen what it’s like when it pelts down with rain (I’m not talking about a light drizzle). I personally love forest school as do both DC. However there are no structured activities (by design) so when it rains the children are wandering around the wet and muddy forest for hours. No toilets so they pee and poo in the rain in small portable potties. I have seen children fall to the ground sobbing in discomfort and spent hours consoling and trying to cajole them into ‘enjoying’ themselves when I volunteered. DS was ill on two occasions after such episodes. And before you ask, he was adequately dressed. There are forest schools where children are outdoors 5 days a week but the DC’s school is not one of them so expecting all children to enjoy it in all weathers is ridiculous. Some children love the mud and rain, others don’t.

The teacher was dismissive of the parents complaints because of their background. There was no need for her to reference their ‘culture’
I can guarantee if the complaint had been raised by one of the middle class parents she would have listened and taken on board the comments. Instead her response was “oh let’s get the PTA to raise money for waterproofs as the poor children of these complaining parents obviously do not get taken outdoors.

One of the mums who complained is from a wealthy family in the Middle East and has a PHD. Her concerns were nothing to do with her socio-economic background!

OP posts:
Shmithecat2 · 17/07/2021 15:24

@EmeraldShamrock

And you think I don't? Quit your virtue signalling and stop being so bloody patronising. You have absolutely no idea what I do or don't know about. I'm not being patronising. If that is what you want to take from it, fine.

Shmithecat2
My son is as far from deprived as you can get he doesn't know he's bloody born, and he's not been camping. Because I don't like it.

Your point being? I was taking about my experience of deprivation, not my sons.
regularbutnamechangedd · 17/07/2021 15:20

@Devonchills

I taught in a very deprived area a few years ago. Hardly any of the kids had been camping, they did go to Butlins, Pontins, Center parks etc, so money didn't seem to be the problem. Also taught in a much 'posher ' school, where camping every summer was the norm for many.
Deprived kids don't go on holiday. Deprived kids' parents starve themselves so their kids can eat. I think you need to appreciate the difference between kids from low income families and kids who are truly deprived. You're describing the former.
Devonchills · 17/07/2021 15:08

I taught in a very deprived area a few years ago. Hardly any of the kids had been camping, they did go to Butlins, Pontins, Center parks etc, so money didn't seem to be the problem.
Also taught in a much 'posher ' school, where camping every summer was the norm for many.

Swipe left for the next trending thread