Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 13:48

Also @TwinsandTrifle you are using the online calculator which is incredibly inaccurate. You need to do a manual calculation for UC to get an accurate result. There are so many variables. I never said I was hard done by because I live in Scotland but costs of living vary massively between Local authorities and even areas within them let alone from country to country. Fwiw I did a manual calculation for UC the other day which worked out I'd be around £3/4 pw better off on UC than the tax credits and small amount of housing I still receive now I work. Not worth the 6 week change over, so I agree that the difference appears minimal whether you're on legacy benefits or not. I can't say what I'd get if I wasn't working and I certainly can't be bothered to do a manual calculation just to find out, but I know that they haven't increased CT benefit as council tax rates have been frozen for quite some time so that would be the same as before.

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 13:29

I mean, this is just complete nonsense now. The band makes a difference whether you claim on the legacy system, or via UC. You understand that surely?

@TwinsandTrifle I think you're the complete nonsense. Of course I know the band affects how much you pay but UC and CT benefit are entirely separate. You don't put your council tax band in to a UC calculation because you apply separately through your local council for that. You understand that surely? Anyway all of this is irrelevant. I'm telling you what I paid, for my own personal circumstances, when I was claiming IS, not UC. I don't need you to believe me but I can assure you I'm not making it up. I do wish that people would realise that everyone's circumstances are different but it's a very mumsnet trait that people can't imagine a life outside of their own small experience. You see it all the time and it gets frustrating.

DoubleTweenQueen · 18/07/2021 12:24

You don't need to sleep on the floor. We have slightly raised cots and luxury inflatable mats.
Camping teaches children lots of useful soft skills.
Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean it can't be fun and rewarding :)

Ifitquacks · 18/07/2021 11:55

Woah, what's 'utterly miserable' about star gazing and campfires and marshmallows?

Sleeping in a tent afterwards.
I can do all those things in my garden then sleep in my nice comfortable bed!

Nanny0gg · 18/07/2021 11:14

@EvenRosesHaveThorns

Woah, what's 'utterly miserable' about star gazing and campfires and marshmallows?
Sleeping on the ground? Sharing facilities? Freezing in bad weather?

I'd much rather stay at home

msby · 18/07/2021 10:52

@Urbandweller

I have personally found that teachers who grew up in the Home Counties/outside London and work in areas of high deprivation sometimes have a slightly patronising attitude towards the “poor kids” they teach. There seems to be an assumption that these kids are missing out because they don’t take part in outdoor activities like sleeping in a draughty tent in the middle of a freezing field or other “enriching” experiences.

Most childhood experiences are just part and parcel of the environment they live in. Does anyone think a child growing up in a rural area is missing out because they haven’t taken the tube through central London?!

Whilst we aren’t really rural, we don’t live near a major city. Both DC were selected for school trips to London (including a tube ride!) on the basis they’d never experienced it. They also got places on school trips within Europe as it was known by the school that family holidays weren’t something we were able to offer them.

I’m in my 40’s, I’ve never been on the tube, have never had what people consider a ‘proper’ holiday (certainly not one that involved flying) and now as teenagers, my children have both travelled more than I will probably ever do. I’m forever grateful they were identified as ‘missing out’ as they both gained so much from the experiences offered. I really believe it has inspired them to want more from life.

All that said, they also got taken camping by the school - they hated every second! Grin

ItsOverFlo · 18/07/2021 10:50

My kids love it and so do I. They've never been abroad though as couldn't afford travel, hotels etc.

Even camping is usually 25+ quid a night with a toilet block and I've collected all the necessary camping stuff over the years. Then there's travel, food, trips out etc. So have to save up each year.

Children who are deprived are those whose families can't/don't go anywhere at all for various reasons.

Are you going to run out and buy a tent? 😆
It is a lot of people's personal hell and bloody hard work too!

Urbandweller · 18/07/2021 10:45

@SleepingStandingUp

Its really worrying that so many people who you would assume are fairly intelligent cannot work out the difference between "choose not to" and "cannot choose to"
No. It was the teacher who failed to distinguish between the two. She expressed pity for children who had not been camping and linked it to deprivation. There was no caveat such as “some low income families might choose do something else rather than camping so their children are not deprived”.

She wasn’t talking about children who haven’t been on any kind of holiday. I’ve already said she sneered and talked in disparaging terms about plebs people who go on All Inclusive holidays rather than educational ones. So yes, she might feel sorry for children who haven’t been to the beach but she’s thinking of a visit to a nice beach, maybe a trip to Broadstairs followed by a visit to the local Charles Dickens museum perhaps. Not a beach in Costa del Sol. That isn’t a valuable experience for a child.

I’m not sure how to explain this better, how certain teachers apply their values to lower income children and expect families to participate in activities they think are worthwhile. I’ve seen it over the years as I was educated by some of those teachers in a deprived area and continue to see it today.

If any of you have a moment I’d point you towards an excellent podcast called Nice White Parents (NY times). It’s based in New York but it might enlighten some of you: affluent, white parents enrol their children en mass in a predominantly Black/Hispanic school to save it from closure, take over the PTA and begin imposing their worldview of the ‘right’ types of activities the school has to organise. So camping is enforced (one tearful white dad says his heart ‘filled with joy’ when he saw the poorer Black children sleeping in a tent for the first time next to his privileged white child. The white journalist who led the podcast described the moment as excruciating) and the new parents make the school introduce an English/French programme although Spanish is the predominant second language. The opinions and preferences of the lower income parents were routinely ignored.

OP posts:
Ohanaa · 18/07/2021 09:56

@Eatenpig vast majority of people don’t take their privilege for granted. We make good life choices and work hard to do things such as holidays/days out/ trips abroad.

We prioritise certain elements in our lives so our kids have experiences.

Eatenpig · 18/07/2021 09:52

@Purpleberet

Wow lots of disheartening responses here, some people need to check their privilege.

I think the teacher didn't articulate themself very well, seems the intended point was that some kids don't get to go anywhere on holiday. They don't get to turn their nose up at camping, because they simply don't go away at all! Not everyone has the luxury of choosing to stay in a hotel or go abroad.

This. Vast numbers of kids never leave their own estate or immediate area. They didn't experience things that others take for granted. That's why school trips are a massive thing for a lot of kids. I too am sure all the teacher meant
WalkingOnTheCracks · 18/07/2021 09:38

My children come from a pretty affluent background, and they have never been camping.

The reason they have never been camping is that I was made to do it a couple of times when I was a child and I hated every fucking minute of it.

If they ever want to do it, I wouldn't stop them, but I'd have nothing to do with it, apart perhaps from transferring them money when they wanted to call a cab to get them the hell out of there.

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 09:05

CT benefit is entirely separate to UC, still through local council so the band you chose makes no difference.

I mean, this is just complete nonsense now. The band makes a difference whether you claim on the legacy system, or via UC. You understand that surely?

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 09:01

*Ok - I don't live in Aberdeen and I'm not on UC. When I was on benefits I was on income support and UC did not exist. Your calculations are irrelevant"

And neither was I when I gave the details of my actual benefits from way back. UC didnt exist then.

They are absolutely relevant as you were suggesting someone is far more hard done by the system if they live in Scotland. But evidently, when you can see using UC now, the comparison is like for like, but on tax credits, the like for like would have been you hundreds of pounds worse off.

But it's ok. The calculator has the option to flick the results into what you would have received on the legacy system. This is where I'll suddenly jump hundreds ahead, you say...

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 08:28

Also there was no Scottish child payment back (and I don't qualify now) CT benefit is entirely separate to UC, still through local council so the band you chose makes no difference.

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 08:23

Ok - I don't live in Aberdeen and I'm not on UC. When I was on benefits I was on income support and UC did not exist. Your calculations are irrelevant

BatshitCrazyWoman · 18/07/2021 08:20

I hate the thought of camping. My (now adult) DC felt the same. None of us are deprived. If you enjoy it, crack on Grin

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 08:16

Funnily enough, the band I picked for my calcs was band D. So that makes things even more in line.

StColumbofNavron · 18/07/2021 08:15

I’ve camped once overseas by a beautiful beach in a foreign country that had almost guaranteed weather with actual beds as a child about 35 years ago. We went with my aunt who lived there. I don’t remember an awful lot but I’ve never had the desire to go since, I also have no desire for skiing, even though we could afford it. We are just not interested in those types of holidays.

We did pick a school that does camp every year and a ski trip though so that if DC want to go they can.

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 08:14

I picked Aberdeen. With all my other details identical.

I get £1168 in UC and need to make a £52 contribution to my cover my rent. But then they cover 100% of my council tax bill. I get the same £213 child benefit. But I also get an extra £87 "'Scottish child payment"

Giving my overall total after rent and ctax as £1416. My overall total as above, using my address in England is £1,373. I'd be £43 per month better off in Scotland.

That's a direct like for like comparison. I thought it sounded odd to be so dramatically disadvantaged. Turns out, the calc is identical, even with a slight gain.

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 08:06

Yes the council tax payments are per month - well 12 months CT paid over 10 months at least. I don't care what your friend in Cambridge paid. I don't know what band she was on or what the rates are for Cambridge and it's not relevant to me. This is what I pay.

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 08:04

But where I live ALL the 2 bed homes are in excess of the 2 bed housing allowance when renting privately. I don't live in an extravagant house - it's a tiny 2 bed shoe box flat which hasn't been modernised since it was built in the 80's and the old inefficient heating system costs more than a lovely new boiler and system. You doing yourself a UC calc is irrelevant seeing it's based on individual circumstances and individual LA areas for housing allowances. How much CT you pay is based on the band your house is classed as - mine is band D and you pay a percentage (plus as I said full water and sewerage rates) You can argue all you like and do calculations based on your own circumstances but doesn't change the fact that others circumstances vary massively

tartanblanketdog · 18/07/2021 07:58

You didn't really answer my question, the £80 ctax was per month? And the £200 you pay now, is that per month too? The 3 bed my friend just moved out of in Cambridge, a notoriously expensive area, was £140p/m. The 5 bed I'm in now is £170 p/m. You are on low income (which by definition entitles you to benefits) and you are paying £200 a month?

I don't think Council tax costs are positively related to the expense of the area - in fact the opposite might hold, less deprivation - lower council tax - doesn't Westminster have one of the lowest rates - with some pretty expensive real estate. I lived in Scotland in the 90s - my council tax was eye watering - 20% of my gross salary for a one bed tenement flat! It's less than 1% of our household income now in a very expensive area in England - not exactly what you'd ca;; a progressive tax!

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 07:38

Referencing that I'm an accountant is for the exact reason I already stated. That I have a knowledge of benefits. And saying I don't know the exact rent allowance for each district, it is a bit irrelevant, because they all use the same principle. The average affordable rent for the size of house you qualify for. Where I live, the housing allowance I would get now is £700 less than if I moved to London.

Again, not all bills are identical. But one adult, one DC living in a 2 bed, should generate the same kind of bills. That's why you can draw direct comparison. And query why if family A, have the same income, and same generated living expenses, how are they comfortable, when family B is in poverty.

I refer only to England though. I've got no knowledge of the Scottish system. If you were in England, with no income, your ctax would not be £80 a month.

And I had no other income, no CM. I have stated I had one DC when I had the spare £400 a month, the calc now, I have 3DC and would have about £500 left over. I was better off with less children. Which again makes perfect sense, as you receive a certain amount for the first child, and a reduced amount for subsequent. Also, you can make any situation suddenly use up the spare £400. Again that's what I mean. I could have moved to a house £400 over the average rental price. Does this mean I can't afford anything and don't even have £10 to spare? Because I would have had enough, but I picked a house hundreds in excess of the average 2 bed property in my area. My water bill was capped at £32. It was only £40 before I claimed benefits.

You didn't really answer my question, the £80 ctax was per month? And the £200 you pay now, is that per month too? The 3 bed my friend just moved out of in Cambridge, a notoriously expensive area, was £140p/m. The 5 bed I'm in now is £170 p/m. You are on low income (which by definition entitles you to benefits) and you are paying £200 a month?

Sorry, something isn't adding up here. I know you're coming out with figures, but they don't add up to that level of difference. It's possible you are financially penalised to that extreme purely by being on Scottish benefits than English. I'll do my calc again, with an address in Scotland. See how much it reduces by ....

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 06:52

What has you being an account got to do with anything? That's doesn't mean you know each local authority's CT benefit policy or what council tax band I am in. I also live in Scotland where you don't pay water separately. It's itemised in you CT and that doesn't qualify for any CT benefit discount, neither does the refuse and sewerage part of the CT so you pay that part in full. Telling me I had income? No I didn't, that's why I used the term full benefits. I do now though - a low one but now pay full council tax of over £200. So you have one more dc so you got more CTC and CB. I got 110 CT you had a spare 3-400, I didn't, I had less as less dc, deduct the 330 for rent and CT. not all bills are identical, paid for DC's swimming lessons and basic food. I can assure you I had left exactly what I told you which lucky if it was £5 each week. I also got on child maintenance. Something you are forgetting to mention which may well have been why you had so much spare

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 01:46

TwinsandTrifle but when you were on maximum benefits you had your full rent and council tax paid and presumably no debts from before you needed to claim. When I was on maximum benefits I still had to pay £250 pm rent and £80 council tax.

I had full rent yes. And my council tax was about £150 for the whole year, so essentially a tenner a month.

I can't understand how you had council tax of £80 a month. You were on no income and yet that was calculated as your monthly contribution? Sorry, that's incorrect. Which I say as I'm a qualified accountant, and frequently help people with benefits etc. Were you working? When I say I was on maximum benefits, I mean zero income. Sorry there may have been a little confusion between us there. If you were working, your benefits wouldn't cover (virtually) all of your council tax. I wouldn't call that circumstance, maximum benefits. For your council tax to have been £80p/m you had income of some kind.

I honestly can't remember what I got. It was tax credits. But it was over £200 a week. Plus my child benefit. And my two biggest bills were rent and council tax, and they were both eliminated. Let's say it was £225, tax credits and child benefit. That would average at £975 a month. Which sounds about right, I'm pretty sure it was just under £1k p/m from memory.

After gas, elec, water (capped because I was on benefits) car tax and insc, sky and food/groceries, I still had £300/400. £50 on DC needing shoes/clothes that month perhaps. I think I paid about £60 off a credit card too We lived pretty well. And from an accounting background means I know how to budget ...but I didn't. I didn't need too. This is why I get baffled at people who continually say they can't afford anything. Of course, a one off like the boiler blowing up, might cause problems for a few months. But it's those who say "I can't afford this, or that" all the time....and I think, yes you can, I know people's entitlements, I've even lived it myself, you just can't afford it as well as whatever you're spending it all on.

I just did a calc for me and 3DC if we were to bolt from DH and claim as of today. I'd get fsm, double milk/veg vouchers. £213p/m child benefit. Rent paid. £8.39 council tax p/m to pay. Then £1168 UC. So after rent and ctax, I've got £1,373 a month. After all bills and food, leaves me over £500. I think £500 after all bills and food, is quite a lot per month. And I can certainly afford to go camping. I can't understand where this £500 goes, every single month, for people to say they haven't got £10. It's quite the difference.

If I was working, they'd reduce part of my UC to account for this but I'd be better off every time. So the example I use above, is worst case scenario.

Swipe left for the next trending thread