Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 21:57

You sound insufferable, flourescentstar

WalkingOnTheCracks · 18/07/2021 21:56

EvenRosesHaveThorns
Woah, what's 'utterly miserable' about star gazing and campfires and marshmallows?

All the above.

flourescentstar · 18/07/2021 21:55

Don't be daft. Privately educated dc have all sorts of luxuries not afforded to non private schooled dc. My dc is at a boarding school! If a deprived dc went there (nowadays it's very rare for a primary aged dc to be sent without paying fees, hardly any I know have bursaries or scholarships for under 11s) they would most likely have the opportunity to do all of the activities mentioned but it's a choice. No one I know in my dc year has gone camping over the holidays though. Poor souls if they do.

Camping imo is not something most people would choose over a nice hotel or at least people that have experienced both. That for me is the link between camping and deprivation. My link anyway. My own experience and that of the people I know.
And to whoever said I got the wrong end of the stick and it's dc who can't even go camping, is this because they aren't signed up to any clubs, my parents loved shoving me of to Cub Scout camp for free every year. One of the benefits of being poor, show you're from a low income family and it's all for free! Maybe that doesn't happen anymore.

Either way I thank goodness I will never again know what it is to run across the grass after a cold rainy night in a tent Grin

tartanblanketdog · 18/07/2021 21:34

@flourescentstar

Because it's so untrue about the no camping being a sign of deprivation. I haven't met any deprived dc at our school? Unless that's unusual for a private school. I'm from a 'poor' background, no heating at home, no new clothes, blah blah, holidays involved camping so for me I relate that as a deprived childhood and the equivalent holiday, Now I am not living in poverty, I have to have a nice clean hotel now and it's a sign of no deprivation for me to no longer having to go camping, each to their own though as this thread is clearly showing!
Sure, not going camping is not a sign of deprivation, a missed experience maybe but you are missing a trick at thinking that privately educated kids cannot be deprived. Your experience limits your view of how it is defined. Knowing people who attended private boarding schools from the age of 5 - knowing people who's parents had no interest in parenting them but enough money to pay for other people to "care" for them - some of those people describe themselves of being deprived of love - not things - they got loads of things, too many things but it doesn't make up for a lack of love - that deprivation sits heavy and long and money can't relieve it..
SleepingStandingUp · 18/07/2021 20:39

@flourescentstar

Because it's so untrue about the no camping being a sign of deprivation. I haven't met any deprived dc at our school? Unless that's unusual for a private school. I'm from a 'poor' background, no heating at home, no new clothes, blah blah, holidays involved camping so for me I relate that as a deprived childhood and the equivalent holiday, Now I am not living in poverty, I have to have a nice clean hotel now and it's a sign of no deprivation for me to no longer having to go camping, each to their own though as this thread is clearly showing!
No one on the thread is saying that not going os a sign of deprivation. Its the not EVEN being able to do that. No EVEN affording to go camping.
HTH1 · 18/07/2021 16:32

😂 my DC (and I) have never been camping but I don’t think many would shake their head sadly if they knew what kind of holidays we go on instead...

Wallpapering · 18/07/2021 15:59

Last worked for DWP June 2017

My case against DWP ended Jan 2019

Am sure your knowledge also knows that be not everyone on UC as some are still on old system the deadline to have everyone on UC has been constantly changed atm it’s still voluntary request those on old system to move over in some areas

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 15:35

I actually (through history as qualified accountant) volunteer with a program who help single mothers starting their own businesses. I advise with financial aspects. There are various other women, one with a legal background for example, who advise too.

This is why I have quite a current knowledge of the system. DWP forward their UC information to the council, who then reduce their ctax accordingly. I don't really know what else to say? Here, as in England, it's done for you as part of the UC application. If their income increases (which they report each month via the UC portal) then the DWP forward that on, and their ctax is adjusted accordingly. They don't contact the council at all??

Oblomov21 · 18/07/2021 15:32

Did she mean poverty? Deprivation? Slightly different things.

A child not having been to the beach/seen the sea, seems sad.

Being young and sleeping for one night in a comfy tent, with all the right gear, isn't uncomfortable.

My two did it with the Cubs/scouts.

Many people haven't done many things. It is a bit odd. I'm always surprised by those Facebook lists of things you haven't done. I've done most of them! And things you won't eat. I eat nearly all of them.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background
flourescentstar · 18/07/2021 15:31

Because it's so untrue about the no camping being a sign of deprivation. I haven't met any deprived dc at our school? Unless that's unusual for a private school.
I'm from a 'poor' background, no heating at home, no new clothes, blah blah, holidays involved camping so for me I relate that as a deprived childhood and the equivalent holiday,
Now I am not living in poverty, I have to have a nice clean hotel now and it's a sign of no deprivation for me to no longer having to go camping, each to their own though as this thread is clearly showing!

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 15:26

And 5* hotels 😂

GreyhoundG1rl · 18/07/2021 15:25

Why shoehorn in private school?

flourescentstar · 18/07/2021 15:22

Hahahaa well if that's the case my dc who is a private school is severely deprived. I will never ever take her camping.

I felt deprived as a dc being taken camping. It was the most awful thing. We had to share the showers for a start, and carry our wash bags across a grotty muddy field . I'm sure things have changed but it's 5* hotels all the way in this household and if that means my dc is deprived than so be it.

cardibach · 18/07/2021 15:21

@Ifitquacks

Woah, what's 'utterly miserable' about star gazing and campfires and marshmallows?

Sleeping in a tent afterwards.
I can do all those things in my garden then sleep in my nice comfortable bed!

Yup. I agree with this. All those things can be done while staying at home/in a hotel/in a cottage. Sleeping in a tent with dark schlepps to the loo , no privacy, other people’s snoring keeping you awake, no respite from the damp if it rains, suboptimal comfort (whatever sleeping arrangement you have, it isn’t as comfy or easy to access as a bed) etc etc etc is not enjoyable for me and I question how it can be for anyone. I think it’s like all the people who progress to love autumn who are thinking about a crisp sunny dating kicking through leaves when it’s usually, cold , wet, muddy and foggy. Camping may well be tolerable, even a laugh, if you are in your 20s, not bothered by insects, don’t need to wee in the night, are a bit of an exhibitionist so like public shower blocks etc etc. Not for most.
cardibach · 18/07/2021 15:17

But that's not the way kids see it - it's about the kids not you.
All kids, @tartanblanketdog? Are you sure?
And actually, family holidays aren’t just about the kids anyway. They are about the family enjoying something together, so if a major component of the holiday - where you are actually sleeping - gives one member of the family (adult or child) the horrors, then you don’t do it.

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 14:52

@HeyDemonsItsYaGirl you could have pm'd that... 😆. Joking - sorry. I know I shouldn't have got sucked in but it's annoying to be accused of lying when I'm only sharing my experience, and when someone is giving false information and adamant they are correct. In that instance it is actually useful for some people to see the correct info (ie as stated by the dwp or council websites). Apologise again, I won't engage further.

Wallpapering · 18/07/2021 14:51

Hey HeyDemonsItsYaGirl

The private message system has a history about being as private as public forum here

SmashingBlouson · 18/07/2021 14:49

I get what your DD is saying and I think it's misconstrued. People below the poverty line wouldn't be able to afford the kit and the site fees, but yes once you have it it's a cheaper holiday than going abroad. So it's a low cost holiday if you are on a low income, but if you are going to food banks like some families are it is out of the question.

FWIW we haven't been skiing or centre parks (skiing is my worst nightmare to be honest) so I guess that makes us deprived. We go camping because my youngest would be absolute hell on a plane or ferry Grin

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 18/07/2021 14:42

Hey TwinsandTrifle and rantymcrantface66, you know there's a private messaging system here?

rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 14:36

Use the calculator "policy in practice" it will be spot on to the penny.

The experts at universal credit essentials always tell you to do your own manual calculation as all the calculators are inaccurate. I had my own calculation looked over and was correct only 3 weeks ago which was very different to the calculator prediction so I understand exactly how it works. They were very clear (as is DWP website and all the LA websites) that it DOES not include council tax benefit/reduction and that you apply for that separately through your council. I do not qualify though , for school meals for any Scottish government grants. I earn 9k pa. the reason I checked the UC entitlement is because my tax credits were dropped £100pw in April (430pm) because of a £400 overpayment. Not sure why I have to pay 5k (12 months of 430) back because of that but they insist it's right so.....

Wallpapering · 18/07/2021 14:23

u went where curtesy of benefits Hmm

This is my council tax bill I get single person discount & I have one dependent child

my bills start from new tax year April as because I pay d/d my bill spread over 11months, but my council revised bill as everyone got £150 discount due to covid this says June-Jan (I had already paid April)

I pay rent as well as all standard usual utilities bills: water, gas & electric.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background
To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background
rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 14:11

Seems it is you not understanding. Anyway none of that is relevant to what I paid on legacy benefits, which is very honestly what I paid. Only students got full council tax covered in our LA. Everyone else kid something which increased depending on the band

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background
rantymcrantface66 · 18/07/2021 14:07

You're wrong! You apply to your local council for council tax benefit (now council tax reduction). UC only took over housing benefit

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background
TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 14:06

Right. Just read your other post, and you are on the legacy system. So you deal, separately for tax credits and CT benefit at each separate department. And it seems you genuinely don't understand how UC works, because of things like you don't think you put your council tax band into the calc. You do. It amalgamates lots of benefits that were historically claimed separately.

Use the calculator "policy in practice" it will be spot on to the penny.

I hope this helps you...

TwinsandTrifle · 18/07/2021 14:02

Also @TwinsandTrifle you are using the online calculator which is incredibly inaccurate.

It's actually spot on.

You don't put your council tax band in to a UC calculation because you apply separately through your local council for that. You understand that surely?

Er, yes you do. UC directly replaces the old CT and housing benefit that you had to apply through the council to get.

If you were still on the legacy system, you'd apply to the council. If you are on UC they replace that with their equivalent benefit.

Literally, Google "UC" and it tells you this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread