Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TheHateIsNotGood · 17/07/2021 00:51

It's just another theory/idea/social policy framework that teachers are advised about. Whilst a bit true it isn't the full picture of many circumstances.

Unfortunately, Teachers are forced to think that they are the gatekeepers/watchmen of all of society's ills and being a good/great Teacher doesn't necessarily mean a Teacher is great or good at understanding 'society', and all the different people that make it, beyond their 'school' workplace.

I don't blame anyone for this situation, just know that a young, new grad Teacher doesn't have enough life experience to understand nor judge the lives of the pupils she/he teaches.

ThatWasThat · 17/07/2021 00:50

@MrsToothyBitch I find this odd, to celebrate not having experienced something that other people clearly like and claim that as an achievement. I'm sure you're right, you wouldn't like camping, but to have avoided it is hardly an achievement.

MrsToothyBitch · 17/07/2021 00:42

I have never been camping and I like it that way. I view this as an achievement, not a tragedy. Can assure you I was a far from deprived child.

ThatWasThat · 17/07/2021 00:42

Camping can be very cheap for kids if part of an organised group. Perhaps the point was this might be the only experience for some kids to have a break. Having said that, I personally think that there are many great things about camping and everyone should give it a try, especially as kids. It may or may not not be your preferred style of holiday in adulthod but it shoudl be a good childhood experience.

Eeiliethya · 17/07/2021 00:34

Went camping once.

Would rather slam my tits in a drawer than do it again.

Schnauzersaremyheros · 17/07/2021 00:30

As a child growing up in a single parent and FSM household, I never went camping. My mum was broke, didn't own a car (or was able to drive), and definitely did not have spare cash for tents, sleeping bags, ect. I would have loved camping too.

Alot of people on this thread really have no frigging clue Angry

Eatenpig · 17/07/2021 00:18

I'd assume the teacher meant any type of holiday.

BoredZelda · 17/07/2021 00:18

Well, I don't think its "deprivation" in the traditional sense, but it's truly a wonderful experience for children, and it's sad that some children don't get to experience it.

I loved camping as a child. My sister hated it. My husband hated it too and that is why we’ve never taken our daughter. I think she’d enjoy parts of it but hate others. I do wonder why people think one size fits all when it comes to what they will enjoy.

Comtesse · 17/07/2021 00:09

I am 46 and have never been camping. Family not rich as a kid, but doing just fine so it’s not like we can’t afford it. I did sleep in a caravan once though, does that count??

EmeraldShamrock · 17/07/2021 00:09

What does it mean to be deprived anyway ? If a child is on FSM it doesn’t mean that parents don’t try to give their offspring good experiences such as reading to them from a young age, teaching them to read, doing crafts and hobbies, helping them to experience nature and yes camping.
I don't think anyone is considering that as deprived, you don't need lots of money to enjoy different experiences.
I think you're being naive assuming all parents put the effort in, as long as they're fed with a place to sleep the bar is pretty low for interventions from SS.
It isn't always poor DC who are deprived but the poor ones who are get nothing but the basics.

THisbackwithavengeance · 17/07/2021 00:06

The families I know who camp regularly are very middle class and take it very seriously. A lot of money is spent on kit. It's not a cheap option by any means.

We went camping with friends who lent us a tent but DH refused to sleep in it so booked a yurt or whatever it's called on the same site.

Basically we ended up paying £stupid to sleep in a shed...

Friendofdennis · 17/07/2021 00:02

What does it mean to be deprived anyway ? If a child is on FSM it doesn’t mean that parents don’t try to give their offspring good experiences such as reading to them from a young age, teaching them to read, doing crafts and hobbies, helping them to experience nature and yes camping. I did all of these things with my daughter. Also although we were entitled as a family to FSM we didn’t avail ourselves of that because I was aware of the opinions (pity) which some teachers have towards children on FSM.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 17/07/2021 00:02

Obviously there will be extreme cases. How does somebody end up a single parent to six children, some of which have additional needs? Did her partner die? Did they not have life insurance?

Oh I love how middle class this response is.

She is a single mum to 8 (2 have left home, of whom 1 is in prison, so she has 6 left at home) out of choice. They have multiple fathers. They have no money.

This I suspect is the deprivation that the teacher in the OP was referring to. I wish it was truly extreme, but it is not.

Mamanyt · 17/07/2021 00:00

YABU for those children who desperately want to go camping and cannot because of funds. But for those who could not care less, YANBU. It isn't an either/or situation.

Frankly, although I used to LOVE camping, at this point, I agree with my younger son...roughing it is only one premium channel to watch on the cable tv when room service brings my meal.

There was a time, though, when I'd do "Mom's TIme." I'd take off for four days during the dead of winter, often with snow on the ground, and camp in a nearby national park right by myself. I had an excellent tent heater, and I loved the aloneness of it all. I'd curl up and read all day long, and dream by the fire in the evenings. No insects or snakes then, either.

Justajot · 16/07/2021 23:58

I've taken sixth formers on their first trip to London. It's about 1 hour by train. I was quite surprised.

My DDs have friends who first went on a train with their primary school (10 min walk from here to our nearest station).

Friendofdennis · 16/07/2021 23:56

I don’t think the teacher should have been talking about her students to you in that way. It is very patronising.

SarahAndQuack · 16/07/2021 23:56

You have to be really oblivious not to realise that camping is a cheap holiday, and the teacher is thinking of children who've not had even the cheapest holidays. She isn't pitying your child who always stays in the fanciest boutique in Paris!

Amaizing · 16/07/2021 23:54

What a privilege to be able to be snobbish about camping because you can afford something ‘better‘.

NoSquirrels · 16/07/2021 23:52

Most childhood experiences are just part and parcel of the environment they live in. Does anyone think a child growing up in a rural area is missing out because they haven’t taken the tube through central London?!

Interesting. My DH took a group of Yr8s to London and for over 50% of them it was their first experience of the capital, going on tubes etc. So yes, I guess I would consider that missing out in a similar way.

Round here (rural) you’re much more likely to have camped out as a kid than done cultural stuff in a city that urban dwelling kids take for granted. Neither is ‘better’ per se, but you’re definitely not having as rounded childhood experiences as the kids that do both. And it does usually come down to money.

Longdistance · 16/07/2021 23:51

I’ve never gone camping. I’ve travelled the world and stayed in some fancy hotels. Camping? Over my cold dead body. Dds have been to a chalet type caravan on holiday, but never camped.
But, from the teachers point of view, I think she meant that the kids otherwise wouldn’t have gone on holiday at all.

Mycatisthebest · 16/07/2021 23:51

@GreyhoundG1rl

Odd. Skiing, yes. Camping, no. I wouldn't go camping if you paid me.
My thoughts as well
Justajot · 16/07/2021 23:51

@beattieedny

I've never camped. My kids haven't either. I'm Jewish, we just don't do that sort of nonsense Wink
Isn't there a festival where you're meant to build a temporary structure and sleep in it?
knitnerd90 · 16/07/2021 23:48

@BrozTito

If jewish people dont camp how did they manage to wander the desert for years with Moses?
They did it for 40 years so we'd never have to do it again Grin
Justajot · 16/07/2021 23:47

I suspect that if you live in overcrowded and uncomfortable conditions then you'd not prioritise going on holiday to somewhere even moreso.

LyndaSnellsSniff · 16/07/2021 23:46

There speaks a teacher who loves to camp.

Seems an odd baseline for the definition of deprivation or cultural experience.