Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Maggiesfarm · 17/07/2021 02:36

knitnerd90, take a look at this:

www.campingkosher.com/

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 02:34

@Paddling654

Surely the whole point of camping is living a voluntarily deprived lifestyle.
GrinGrinGrinGrinGrin
Maggiesfarm · 17/07/2021 02:30

i never went camping either, neither did my parents (though I did once sleep in a tent overnight). People either camp or they don't, I'd hate it. My kids and nephew did it a couple of times but they certainly wouldn't have been deprived had they not.

The teacher is obviously one of those people who consider it an essential rite of passage and does not understand why anyone wouldn't be enthusiastic about it.

I can imagine that some children would find it great fun but it's all a matter of taste.

Paddling654 · 17/07/2021 02:23

Surely the whole point of camping is living a voluntarily deprived lifestyle.

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 02:20

@ZZTopGuitarSolo

How did this person end up with so many children that she couldn't support financially and give these basic childhood experiences of travelling a couple of miles to the beach or sleeping in a tent? 8 kids you are saying now? By multiple fathers. Why did she do that to those children? Not an oooopppps that was an accident situation, is it?

Yes it is a horrible situation. I have spent many years in horror at her choices.

Someone asked why a parent wouldn’t just borrow a tent and take their kid camping. I have an example of why. I know plenty more families like hers. Those are what I’d class as deprived.

Right. So let's be clear, those children are not deprived because of poverty, in most cases. But by "parents" who deliberately have children they cannot provide even basic decent living standards for, let alone trips/ holidays. Why would somebody do that to not one, but SIX children? It's not an accident, six times. With multiple men as you said. Fucking hell. Those poor children having such a selfish mother whp clearly doesn't care about them whatsoever.

That is the problem, you expressed it really well. Nobody can fix that unless you are advocating that social services massively raise the bar and kids like that go into care, or these parents take some fucking responsibility for the children they bring into the world.

You're not talking about sudden tragedy and therefore unexpectedly becoming a single parent in a shit situation, which I'd always have huge sympathy for. What you are describing is somebody who doesn't give a shit about their kids and that is disgusting. The fact you describe someone who treats their children in this way as a friend is disturbing.

TheHateIsNotGood · 17/07/2021 02:17

Ditto - days at the beach, apparently 1 in 10 children in Plymouth haven't been to The Beach. Sounds really bad as an headline, seeing as Plymouth is on the coast, but how many 'beaches' are there in Plymouth? None. Any 'beach' near to Plymouth means transport arrangements that a minority of families have difficulty accessing.

Never mind places like Birmingham that aren't even near the Coast. Then factor in the many families that aren't "deprived" that choose not to go to the beach/camp.

So, the need is not as great as some assume. But yes some children would really benefit from camping and beach trips, we just need to make sure that all resources available are targeted to those children that really need them,

Not a big brush, tick-box exercise that misses the point.

flirtygirl · 17/07/2021 02:12

Holiday Inn and Premier Inn are cheaper than camping. Why on earth would you suffer camping and pay money to do so? There are many cheaper ways to holiday than camping.

A child who has never been on holiday may well be deprived. But a child who have never been camping just has sensible parents.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 17/07/2021 01:59

@TheHateIsNotGood

Yes, ZZ the example you describe does exist, I've known a few parents that act similarly to your description myself, but absolutely such families are the minority and yes, opportunities such as camping should be directed to them.

But, claiming 'doesn't camp' as an indicator of deprivation or poor parenting really doesn't 'cut it' in the real world, maybe in the microcosm you currently find yourself in, but overall, no.

Yes - it was actually the fact that the teacher used the example of never having had a day at a beach that really struck me as more of an indicator.
TheHateIsNotGood · 17/07/2021 01:56

Yes, ZZ the example you describe does exist, I've known a few parents that act similarly to your description myself, but absolutely such families are the minority and yes, opportunities such as camping should be directed to them.

But, claiming 'doesn't camp' as an indicator of deprivation or poor parenting really doesn't 'cut it' in the real world, maybe in the microcosm you currently find yourself in, but overall, no.

EmeraldShamrock · 17/07/2021 01:50

I'd assume the teacher meant any type of holiday.
Me too, I'm not sure why posters aren't getting that? WC deprivation is a world away from many mnetters however it is fact some DC never get any sort of holiday or outing unless the school provides it.
it was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation.
Which is very true and why wouldn't you feel sorry for those DC. Why is unbelievable that poverty and social environments stop many DC having the basic life experiences.
Some of them probably had the best time of their life on the trip.
I see many DC around here whose life is empty and hopeless, the joy school events bring them is priceless and a treasured memory.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 17/07/2021 01:48

Well I don't drive so my poor little dc who are entitled to fsm won't be going camping any time soon 🙄

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 17/07/2021 01:44

How did this person end up with so many children that she couldn't support financially and give these basic childhood experiences of travelling a couple of miles to the beach or sleeping in a tent? 8 kids you are saying now? By multiple fathers. Why did she do that to those children? Not an oooopppps that was an accident situation, is it?

Yes it is a horrible situation. I have spent many years in horror at her choices.

Someone asked why a parent wouldn’t just borrow a tent and take their kid camping. I have an example of why. I know plenty more families like hers. Those are what I’d class as deprived.

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 01:42

Wow. I am so shocked at some of the responses here. 🤯

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 17/07/2021 01:39

@PolkadotZebras I haven’t name-changed - what makes you think I have?

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 01:33

That was @ZZTopGuitarSolo

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 01:30

That's so sad, the best day of his life. A child should not be living with parents who clearly do not give a damn about him. I suspect is far more of a common issue than people not being able to borrow a tent for a day; parents just not bothering to think about their children's needs and making their worlds so, so small.

It sounds like a classic case of this TBH. Not giving a shit about how to provide for the existing children or give them experiences, unable to support them but keep having more? 6? And some with additional needs? It's obvious some will suffer massively from this simply from the parental effort and time being split so many ways. Just so unfair on the kids. Who would keep having more babies in this situation that was remotely responsible enough to be a good parent? And given what you've said about not even being able to take them out camping, just so fucking selfish. Those poor kids. Sad

SomeNameorOther · 17/07/2021 01:29

I love camping. When I was a child my parents took us camping every year and it was always the only time of the year I was truly happy. That feeling juct comes over me when pever I've been camping throughout my adulthood, and I am incredibly sad that my disability now makes camping so hard that I shan't be able to do it again. There's something so comforting, so connected to the world, about lying in a tent in the early mornings listening to the birdsong.

I can absolutely see why some people see it as another form of Hell though!

TheHateIsNotGood · 17/07/2021 01:28

ZZ the example you give is extreme, yes in the extreme the circumstances you describe do exist and various less hyperventilating, lurid circumstances too.

It is not the norm and 'access to camping' shouldn't be used as a 'baseline' for forming judgements on schoolchildren and their families.

PolkadotZebras · 17/07/2021 01:15

@ZZTopGuitarSolo

Obviously there will be extreme cases. How does somebody end up a single parent to six children, some of which have additional needs? Did her partner die? Did they not have life insurance?

Oh I love how middle class this response is.

She is a single mum to 8 (2 have left home, of whom 1 is in prison, so she has 6 left at home) out of choice. They have multiple fathers. They have no money.

This I suspect is the deprivation that the teacher in the OP was referring to. I wish it was truly extreme, but it is not.

Also great name change fail.
PolkadotZebras · 17/07/2021 01:15

@ZZTopGuitarSolo

Obviously there will be extreme cases. How does somebody end up a single parent to six children, some of which have additional needs? Did her partner die? Did they not have life insurance?

Oh I love how middle class this response is.

She is a single mum to 8 (2 have left home, of whom 1 is in prison, so she has 6 left at home) out of choice. They have multiple fathers. They have no money.

This I suspect is the deprivation that the teacher in the OP was referring to. I wish it was truly extreme, but it is not.

It's not remotely middle class. Wind your neck in. I lived in absolutely poverty for years, constantly at risk of becoming homeless because no money for rent, electricity cutting off, no heating, living on plain pasta for months on end. Your poverty competition is massively boring.

How did this person end up with so many children that she couldn't support financially and give these basic childhood experiences of travelling a couple of miles to the beach or sleeping in a tent? 8 kids you are saying now? By multiple fathers. Why did she do that to those children? Not an oooopppps that was an accident situation, is it?

SRS29 · 17/07/2021 01:09

I was not put on this Earth to camp...the end Grin

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 01:08

@LyndaSnellsSniff

There speaks a teacher who loves to camp.

Seems an odd baseline for the definition of deprivation or cultural experience.

This sums it up really! Grin
LostInTheColonies · 17/07/2021 01:06

Kids being deprived of camping IMO has nothing to do with social deprivation! Teacher clearly bonkers on that front. It's a shame if kids from anywhere on the social spectrum don't get a chance to camp (note kids, not parents who prefer more comfort!).

Sleeping outside, fires, marshmallows, being far too grubby - what's not to like if you're a kid? ⛺ And it's what all the posh kids do in story books clearly read way too much Enid Blyton, Arthur Ransome and the like as a child

salviapages · 17/07/2021 01:02

I've worked in a school that does similar. There's a difference between not taking your children camping because you don't like it, and not being able to take them camping or on any kind of holiday because you live in poverty. Those are the children the teacher is referencing. She's not saying that your children are 'deprived' because you personally don't like camping

Justajot · 17/07/2021 00:56

It's presumably part of the policy to provide "cultural capital" to all pupils. I'm on the fence on this one as it seems to mean going on slightly shit versions of the stuff we do as a family or going to a different place of worship each year.