Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a child who has never been camping is not necessarily from a ‘deprived’ background

513 replies

Urbandweller · 16/07/2021 20:57

DD’s school organised a camping trip for Y5. DD is younger and didn’t attend but her class teacher went to chaperone. I was chatting with her about it today and she said she was so glad the school was able to organise the trip as so many of the Y5 kids had never been camping and would never otherwise get the chance to go. It was clear that she felt sorry for the children who hadn’t been before and was shaking her head sorrowfully, saying many of them are the same poor kids who have never been to the beach and this is one of the saddest aspects of deprivation...

AIBU to not see the link between camping and deprivation? We’ve never taken DD because it’s my idea of hell, nothing to do with lack of funds!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Newmumatlast · 17/07/2021 07:06

@Ozanj

She is probably only talking about specific kids who are on FSM or cared for. She won’t be meaning anything beyond that.
Agree. I doubt she is so out of touch that she thinks any child who hasn't camped is deprived. I dont think its as literal a comment as that.
PumpkinPie2016 · 17/07/2021 06:56

I think the teacher was probably referring to children who had perhaps never been on any sort of trip away and whose families possibly wouldn't be able to afford to go away.

Personally, camping isn't my thing so we have never been but my son is far from deprived.

SarahBellam · 17/07/2021 06:45

We once camped at a camp site about 10 miles from home. I hated it. It was cold and uncomfortable. In the middle of the night I got up, went home, slept in my bed, had a shower and a nice proper coffee and then went back.

Solidaritea · 17/07/2021 06:38

@Urbandweller

I have personally found that teachers who grew up in the Home Counties/outside London and work in areas of high deprivation sometimes have a slightly patronising attitude towards the “poor kids” they teach. There seems to be an assumption that these kids are missing out because they don’t take part in outdoor activities like sleeping in a draughty tent in the middle of a freezing field or other “enriching” experiences.

Most childhood experiences are just part and parcel of the environment they live in. Does anyone think a child growing up in a rural area is missing out because they haven’t taken the tube through central London?!

What a weird post.

Do you think there's no deprivation in the home counties?

And yes, we organise trips to central London on the tube so that we give them that experience.

The teacher is trying to provide an opportunity for anyone who wants it. The more experiences a child has, of all types, the more they can grow to understand the world and themselves.

Some children may never have been on a holiday of any sort. Some may have always wanted to go camping but never been due to finances. Some may never have been camping because parents are unable to take them. Some will really love camping. Some will really hate camping. They can find out by trying it.

It's sad you're using this to judge the teacher and assume that she's being patronizing. It's a lot of work to organise something like this (and that extra work won't be compensated). When parents act like you, it makes teachers feel like we oughtn't have bothered. Hopefully, you've not made these sorts of comments to the school or teacher.

speakout · 17/07/2021 06:30

*Wallpapering
Camping is not cheap if you don’t have equipment ie tent.

As someone who is in poverty and recently was using food banks it’s really fucking offensive the way keep referring to poor and camping*

I agree.

Wallpapering · 17/07/2021 04:22

Camping is not cheap if you don’t have equipment ie tent.

As someone who is in poverty and recently was using food banks it’s really fucking offensive the way keep referring to poor and camping

Wallpapering · 17/07/2021 04:19

The kid that done camping in garden with has done beavers camp trip whilst yay joy fun was had all the kids had face like smacked arsed when picked them up. They was tired & miserable.

Oh poor here none of kids would choose camping over 5. They only ever asked about 5 holidays.

We survived the hell of butlins tots holiday twice that more hardcore than camping

Bananarice · 17/07/2021 04:15

Yabu, if you read between the lines, it is aimed at children who can't afford any type of holiday. Camping holiday is seen as cheap, but for some people who attend food banks, they have other priorities than scrimp and save for a holiday.

Wallpapering · 17/07/2021 04:11

Camping with a child alone when you don’t have a car is fucking hard but had great time only cos meet other single parents but one time it was fucking terrifying as tis was night gails and rain floods came.

Getting older and camping with next child was fucking joyless and we only made back garden the 2nd time 4am dragged kid and wrestled double air bed out tent to sleep in front room, as someone trying to get in back gates.

I’m with my elder it’s 5* or nothing now. Does child care who never been theme park get head tilt pity because one kid never been

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 03:54

@Susannahmoody

Oh god I can't stand all this faux horreur, I need a suite at the Marriot ffs, no camping for little ol me, hell to the no

Get over yourselves.

Well. Camping sucks and I can't see many adults picking it over the Marriot given a choice. Would you?

A little bit of inverse snobbery in your post, perhaps, which adds nothing to the discussion other than vitriol as far as I can see.

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 03:50

I wasn't "arguing with things you haven't said" but your defence of the implication of your post, given the OP you were responding to, was that somehow your relative's children are deprived by society,, rather than being deprived as a result of having shitty parents. Is anybody doing anything to either give those children a decent childhood or move them to homes where that will be provided? If not, that is the tragedy. Not a lack of camping.

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 03:45

@ZZTopGuitarSolo

The fact you describe someone who treats their children in this way as a friend is disturbing.

Reread my posts a bit more slowly. She's not a friend. She's a relative. That was literally the first thing I said about her.

I agree that her approach to having and raising children is appalling - I'm not sure where you've got the idea that I don't. You seem to be arguing with things I haven't said.

Right. So you are saying that the issue is your relative not looking after her children properly, not deprivation as a result of poverty.
lovablequalities · 17/07/2021 03:31

I never went camping as a child. My parents are not holiday people. We only ever went away to visit family really. A caravan in Ayr once. My mother LOATHED it! We weren't deprived but we weren't well off.

I think the teacher means more in the sense of a holiday. Lots of children have never been on holiday. I'm a secondary teacher and I've led lots of school trips where they have never been more than a few miles from home. I would assume she thinks of camping as a "basic" holiday that should be accessible to most kids but obviously it's not.

I took 40 kids camping to the beach (Confused) and the ones who had never been before were mostly all from less financially secure homes. Camping is cheaper than going abroad/hotels but it still costs a fair bit and requires time, patience, planning, equipment, confidence etc. That's pretty tough to sort if your folks work several jobs or have chaotic stuff in their lives and have never been before.

0None0 · 17/07/2021 03:21

I can sort of see what the teacher means. A lot of children spend hours every day on phones or gaming.
Camping with no electric hook up is so completely different to their normal life, it certainly can broaden their experience of life hugely.

When I’ve taken children camping ((my own, and foster children) they have enjoyed the experience, but even if they hadn’t, it would have been enriching, widened their education, given them a different perspective, for example on farming, wildlife, basic amenities, etc

And yes, if children aren’t experiencing a range of different perspectives and situations in life, they are growing up narrow minded, and in that sense, deprived

Susannahmoody · 17/07/2021 03:21

Oh god I can't stand all this faux horreur, I need a suite at the Marriot ffs, no camping for little ol me, hell to the no

Get over yourselves.

Mypathtriedtokillme · 17/07/2021 03:12

We spent 4 weeks camping in tents at a beach every summer when I was a kid.
It was mostly fun, it was occasionally hot and stuffy or pouring rain as very wet.
Camping and a month of a long drop toilet has only given me a really low bar of unacceptable facilities, the ability to put up tents quickly, a higher than average ability st lighting fires and I’m really good at sleeping anywhere.

We also went hiking a lot and slept in bivys or huts. I prefer walking all day to a hut than spending all day carrying my stuff to then have to sleep on a barely blown up self inflating “mattress pad” on the ground in a half tent.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 17/07/2021 03:09

I wouldnt think it meant every child who has never gone camping is because of deprivation, but that children in deprivation may not get to go camping. I work in a school with many children from low income families (more then 50%). You may be shocked to know that a large amount of those children have barely ever even left their city, and have never been places like camping or to the ocean which is not very far from us.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 17/07/2021 02:58

The fact you describe someone who treats their children in this way as a friend is disturbing.

Reread my posts a bit more slowly. She's not a friend. She's a relative. That was literally the first thing I said about her.

I agree that her approach to having and raising children is appalling - I'm not sure where you've got the idea that I don't. You seem to be arguing with things I haven't said.

StripyGiraffes · 17/07/2021 02:55

Someone asked why a parent wouldn’t just borrow a tent and take their kid camping. I have an example of why. I know plenty more families like hers. Those are what I’d class as deprived.

That isn't deprived families, though. The kids are deprived, yes. By their parents intentionally creating that situation for them. How awful.

I've worked in poor countries where the parents do everything possible for their children and are torn apart when they can fulfil their responsibilities to them: to provide for them and give them a good childhood.

The idea that somebody in the UK could be so blasé about parenting their own children - with all of the support here that parents in those places do not have - to me is disgusting and indicates a moral vacuum on their part, if they care less for their children and do less for them than people with no welfare, no free healthcare, no free education, etc.

I am repulsed by that people who are among the 1% richest who have ever lived on Earth (whicj easily includes even the poorest on the UK in 2021) can behave like this to their own children. It is shocking and disgraceful and we should not make excuses for it. Ever.

MarianneUnfaithful · 17/07/2021 02:55

@TryingToBeLogical

I don’t live in the UK, but where I live there’s no snobbery about camping being a “budget holiday.” It’s more associated in people’s minds with families enjoying the outdoors together, exercise, introducing kids to nature, and the kind of independence/teamwork skills learned in scouting. Families who camp would more likely be viewed as having a healthy lifestyle, parents investing quality time with kids, etc. than being less advantaged (I’m not saying camping is the only way to do that). My daughter and I are in fact camping out tomorrow night at our outdoor club. Some of her friends’ parents don’t enjoy it at all and never camp. If you think all camping equipment is cheap, try visiting a high end sporting or hiking store. It can be cheap, or or it can be very pricey. The lesson from this thread seems to be not to judge anyone else’s idea of what’s normal or luxurious. Some kids don’t get to spend much time in nature, and activities some people turn their nose up at might be a treat for another’s family.
Good post.
0None0 · 17/07/2021 02:53

*never had a car

0None0 · 17/07/2021 02:52

@speakout

A camping holiday is not cheap. You are being very naiive OP. It requires quite an investment. Taking a family with a couple of young children on a camping holiday takes resources. A car- very hard to take a family of 4 camping on public transport. Tent, sleeping bags, mats, torches, cooking equipment. All very costly. If you are living hand to mouth this is not possible. I grew up in poverty. A camping holiday was a pipe dream.
Well I’ve never had a cat and have taken the family camping by public transport every year for 25 years.

It can be expensive, but it can also be done very cheaply.

Also, decent equipment can be expensive, particularly if you are carrying it all, abs it needs to be light.

But you can build it up little by little, and add to it every year

It’s also worth knowing that many campsites offer huge reductions to families travelling by public transport , and in many cases have special zones for non car drivers, where there is no parking, but the quality of the pitches is much better

Maggiesfarm · 17/07/2021 02:46

@Itsmemaggie

I fucking love camping, and have had some amazing experiences where at the end of the day I went and either slept in a tent or stayed out under the stars.
That sounds lovely.

I wouldn't bash camping but I hate the idea of having to share toilet and shower blocks and insects coming into the tent. Also I think I would be nervous and not sleep.

Each to their own.

Maggiesfarm · 17/07/2021 02:43

@EvenRosesHaveThorns

I'm always surprised.how unembarrassed the Mumsnet snob brigade - who are out in force on a camping thread..?! - are.
Yes! I've never seen it before but it is obvious on this thread, sneering at campers being 'middle class' and all that.

Though I don't, and would never, camp, I know loads of people from all walks of life who do enjoy it.

Anyway what is wrong with being middle class (a broad spectrum)? We are what we are.

TryingToBeLogical · 17/07/2021 02:41

I don’t live in the UK, but where I live there’s no snobbery about camping being a “budget holiday.” It’s more associated in people’s minds with families enjoying the outdoors together, exercise, introducing kids to nature, and the kind of independence/teamwork skills learned in
scouting. Families who camp would more likely be viewed as having a healthy lifestyle, parents investing quality time with kids, etc. than being less advantaged (I’m not saying camping is the only way to do that). My daughter and I are in fact camping out tomorrow night at our outdoor club. Some of her friends’ parents don’t enjoy it at all and never camp.
If you think all camping equipment is cheap, try visiting a high end sporting or hiking store. It can be cheap, or or it can be very pricey.
The lesson from this thread seems to be not to judge anyone else’s idea of what’s normal or luxurious. Some kids don’t get to spend much time in nature, and activities some people turn their nose up at might be a treat for another’s family.