Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are "barely there" dresses acceptable in high profile public?

265 replies

Nothingyet · 16/07/2021 07:49

Are "barely there" dresses acceptable? I saw this this in the Mail this morning, and there were the usual comments: "and they wonder why men sexualize them..." etc.
I wondered if there were any views? www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-9792613/Cannes-Film-Festival-2021-Kimberley-Garner-flashes-bottom-Georgina-Rodriguez.html#comments

OP posts:
comebacksunshines · 16/07/2021 18:45

So you would have been aged around 8 when Kurt Cobain from Nirvana died and early teens at the end of the 90's ?
I agree that women have always been objectified, but they are now willingly objectifying themselves, under the guise of empowerment. I think I prefer the former, at least it was honest and you knew what you were fighting against.

DrSbaitso · 16/07/2021 17:42

@comebacksunshines

*I think it was worse back then. We were expected to be pin thin and the aesthetic was even called "heroin chic". Nowadays there is a strong push for body positivity and I see much more variation of size, even if we still have a way to go.

Women were still wearing sexy dresses then*

Don't remember the 90's like that. I lived in dungarees, oversized T shirts and jeans, went clubbing dressed liked that too.
Heroin chic was heavily criticised and not held up as a beauty standard in the circles I mixed in. i.e. working class, it was more of a rich girl problem.
Lots of strong female singers, PJ Harvey, Bjork, Macy Gray. The female indie bands garbage, catatonia, the cranberries. All intelligent, powerful women.

I think things have gone backwards. What started out as a move towards empowering women, by acknowledging them as sexual beings has been commercialised and turned into an out of control monster. I sincerely hope there is a backlash against it ,as I feel very sorry for young women today.

Well, we may have had different backgrounds. Plus someone else mentioned Nirvana shirts, so I think I may also be a slightly different age (mid 30s). I definitely remember feeling an intense pressure to be thin, and failing miserably (I was a healthy weight, but very curvy, and I rarely saw any representation). Fad diets and eating disorders were all over the place.

Objectification of women most certainly happened then as it does now. I suppose my general rule of thumb (not perfect, I realise) is: is the scantily clad woman doing her own thing, or is she supporting a male act? Miley Cyrus sometimes gets criticised for being too sexual, but it's her work: her voice, her songs, her videos, and she is most definitely a talented singer and actress. (She's probably just setting up for a "more mature" image change in her 30s anyway.) I feel very differently about all the scantily clad women jiggling around Robin Thickasshit or whatever his name is while he sings about sexual coercion and "I know you want it".

DrSbaitso · 16/07/2021 17:28

@MyGhastIsFlabbered

Ok *@DrSbaitso* you've obviously decided I'm wrong and you're right so you crack on. I've got better things to do with my time than argue about this
You are indeed wrong to suggest that wearing wearing a leggy dress on a red carpet is akin to being a sex worker, or that it makes it impossible to have any other talents. I can't believe you don't see that.

checks date on calendar

comebacksunshines · 16/07/2021 17:03

*I think it was worse back then. We were expected to be pin thin and the aesthetic was even called "heroin chic". Nowadays there is a strong push for body positivity and I see much more variation of size, even if we still have a way to go.

Women were still wearing sexy dresses then*

Don't remember the 90's like that. I lived in dungarees, oversized T shirts and jeans, went clubbing dressed liked that too.
Heroin chic was heavily criticised and not held up as a beauty standard in the circles I mixed in. i.e. working class, it was more of a rich girl problem.
Lots of strong female singers, PJ Harvey, Bjork, Macy Gray. The female indie bands garbage, catatonia, the cranberries. All intelligent, powerful women.

I think things have gone backwards. What started out as a move towards empowering women, by acknowledging them as sexual beings has been commercialised and turned into an out of control monster. I sincerely hope there is a backlash against it ,as I feel very sorry for young women today.

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 16/07/2021 17:02

Ok @DrSbaitso you've obviously decided I'm wrong and you're right so you crack on. I've got better things to do with my time than argue about this

DrSbaitso · 16/07/2021 17:01

@MyGhastIsFlabbered

Bullshit is it not selling their bodies. If she's turned up in a shapeless hessian sack from chin to ankle do you think she'd have got the column inches she did? Of course she wouldn't. I'm not the one being misogynistic and offensive here.
Wearing a glamorous dress (which is all most of those are - did you see them?) at a red carpet event in the hope of appearing in the press is not selling your body, and nor is it a sign that you literally can't do anything else.

It is intensely misogynistic and offensive to suggest otherwise.

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 16/07/2021 16:58

Bullshit is it not selling their bodies. If she's turned up in a shapeless hessian sack from chin to ankle do you think she'd have got the column inches she did? Of course she wouldn't. I'm not the one being misogynistic and offensive here.

DrSbaitso · 16/07/2021 16:54

maybe I'm getting old but in my opinion women don't sell their bodies if they've got other options.

I'm having such a hard time teaching my daughter that she can enjoy playing with clothes and fashion and still enjoy reading books, doing sport and being clever. Please don't make it harder still.

It's nothing to do with being old, it's just reductive, misogynistic and really quite offensive. They're not "selling their bodies" by showing a leg on the red carpet.

SoMuchForSummerLove · 16/07/2021 16:49

What about professional women who just enjoy fashion and feel good about themselves? I'm a marketing director with great tits; if I wear a low cut top or dress that doesn't mean my brain can no longer function.

Can we stop fuelling the 'beautiful OR smart' dichotomy please?

I can't tell you how shit it makes my short-sighted daughter feel to sit and watch a film where the premise is a nerd takes her glasses off and therefore become shaggable.

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 16/07/2021 16:45

@Deathsquito

My favourite comment was the ‘Humph! Either you want to be treated as professionals and not a sexual object OR you want to flash your body to men to make money. You can’t have it both ways! I give up!’

I love the fact this bloke thinks he is personally the arbiter.

That because these women on this occasion wore revealing dresses, that it means that no woman actually wants to be treated as a competent professional at work. Or worse, deserves to be.

I kind of agree though...maybe I'm getting old but in my opinion women don't sell their bodies if they've got other options.

All I could think when seeing that lilac. Umber was what a pain in the arse it must be to walk in...all that fabric flapping around your feet.

KarenofSparta · 16/07/2021 16:44

Don't we all Wink

SoMuchForSummerLove · 16/07/2021 16:32

My figure certainly envies better ones Grin

KarenofSparta · 16/07/2021 16:19

@Guavafish

She has a envious figure. I don’t see any reason why she should wear that dress to the premier of a film festive.

If you got it

Grin

Who is her figure envious of? Does it have its own personality?

Grellbunt · 16/07/2021 16:17

@OutwiththeOutCrowd

I quite like these vintage photos of equal opportunity exhibitionism at Cannes film festival. Plus ca change ....

1954: Simone Silva (British actress) goes topless and is asked to leave but not before one photographer breaks an arm and another a leg in a photo-taking scrummage.

1953: Kirk Douglas strips down to show off his hairdressing skills on Brigitte Bardot.

1977: Arnold Schwarzenegger comes over all coy.

They're on the beach though.
SoMuchForSummerLove · 16/07/2021 16:15

Yeah there was the heroin chic thing, that's true. I'd forgotten about that. I was thinking about how I dressed when I went clubbing; long skirt and tshirt, jeans, trainers, hardly any make up, hair straighteners weren't even a thing. We wore ex-Army shirts over baggy jeans and Nirvana tshirts.

Didn't stop any shitty things happening to us though. In one year I had nine incidents where I felt in danger from a man. Nine. I'm writing a book about it now.

I still think it feels more dangerous now. Maybe the advent of social media makes things tougher as your image is out of your hands as soon as its online.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 16/07/2021 16:13

I quite like these vintage photos of equal opportunity exhibitionism at Cannes film festival. Plus ca change ....

1954: Simone Silva (British actress) goes topless and is asked to leave but not before one photographer breaks an arm and another a leg in a photo-taking scrummage.

1953: Kirk Douglas strips down to show off his hairdressing skills on Brigitte Bardot.

1977: Arnold Schwarzenegger comes over all coy.

DrSbaitso · 16/07/2021 16:06

[quote SoMuchForSummerLove]**@Blossomtoes* I know all of that about Kate Winslet and Mare of Easttown. My point was all of that and* yet we still have gratuitous female nudity and objectivity of female corpses.

I don't just sit back and shrug. I am an activist in my own ways. But I don't see the point in pretending that things are so much better now when they aren't. I actually think things were better in the 90s for girls; we weren't expected to be beautiful and doll like, at least.[/quote]
I think it was worse back then. We were expected to be pin thin and the aesthetic was even called "heroin chic". Nowadays there is a strong push for body positivity and I see much more variation of size, even if we still have a way to go.

Women were still wearing sexy dresses then.

SoMuchForSummerLove · 16/07/2021 15:31

@Blossomtoes I know all of that about Kate Winslet and Mare of Easttown. My point was all of that and yet we still have gratuitous female nudity and objectivity of female corpses.

I don't just sit back and shrug. I am an activist in my own ways. But I don't see the point in pretending that things are so much better now when they aren't. I actually think things were better in the 90s for girls; we weren't expected to be beautiful and doll like, at least.

MiaowMiaow99 · 16/07/2021 15:16

Its Cannes, not the G12.

Iamthewombat · 16/07/2021 15:08

They are amateurs.

Diana Dors (RIP) turned up at a film festival in the 1950s reclining in a GONDOLA and wearing a MINK BIKINI!

That’s how to seek this sort of attention, if it is (sadly) your thing.

Mochudubh · 16/07/2021 14:51

The white & purple one looks like it's made out of old sheets and towels.
The leather one is horrible.
I quite like the drapey, nude coloured one.

The absolute best one is the short white one worn by Blanche? somebody - (can't be bothered to go back into the link). I love that she's standing with her hands in her POCKETS!

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 14:50

It’s interesting that you use Mare of Easttown as an example @SoMuchForSummerLove because Winslet’s role in it pretty much disproves this:

They know they'll only get acting roles if they have breast implant/lip fillers/whatever. They know they are not allowed to age, have body hair or eat much if they want to have a career in the public eye

Winslet is make up less and devoid of any glamour. She refused to have her body airbrushed in the nude scene because she wanted to look real. Her performance is universally praised, to the point where some reviewers say it’s the defining moment of her career. It’s completely the antithesis of what you said above.

It’s sad that you refuse to accept that women working collectively can effect change and deny the very real work that a highly respected female actor has done to model that change. While we just sit back and say we can change nothing women will continue to be used and abused. To quote someone or other if we’re not part of the solution, we’re part of the problem.

comebacksunshines · 16/07/2021 14:36

@SoMuchForSummerLove

That's the issue isn't it *@Blossomtoes*

The Meryl Streeps of the world can protest but someone at the opposite end of the food chain is in no position to do so, assuming they've got a mortgage etc.

These are highly privileged women, trying to access a much sought after career by using their bodies, or whatever means they can. Not your average woman trying to get a bit of career progression at Morrisons.
ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 16/07/2021 14:30

@ SoMuchForSummerLove

Good post and answer. I agree but add international show business is also quite nuanced and complex. Many of the big money men movers and shakers supposedly have very varied wild lifestyles and some with a sinister taste of illegal predatory fluid sexual orientations including children and same sexy amongst many drug and money fuelled excessive behind closed walls casting sessions. It’s apparently a very mixed up surreal world for actresses to get to the top by satisfying all the weird controlling demands for fame and fortune for and a brief me too moment on the competitive red carpet catwalk before the next new talent takes the stage.

SoMuchForSummerLove · 16/07/2021 14:30

I just watched Mare of Easttown. In it there was a sex scene where Winslet was on top naked. It added literally nothing to the story. The man's body was not seen, in fact he still had his shirt on.

It was about a 17 year old girl who gets shot in the head. When she is found she is naked. There is no explanation for this, she wasn't assaulted, she was shot and then the person moved her body.

She was only naked for the long panning shot.

Even dead women's bodies are decorative.

Call it defeatist all you like but I'm just stating facts.

Like I've said loads of times now, it's all shite. It is. And I don't think it's changing. If it is, it's not fast enough, or enough in any way actually.

My 11 year old daughter asked me yesterday why men rape women. I had to have that conversation with her. This is the climate our daughters are growing up in.