Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are "barely there" dresses acceptable in high profile public?

265 replies

Nothingyet · 16/07/2021 07:49

Are "barely there" dresses acceptable? I saw this this in the Mail this morning, and there were the usual comments: "and they wonder why men sexualize them..." etc.
I wondered if there were any views? www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-9792613/Cannes-Film-Festival-2021-Kimberley-Garner-flashes-bottom-Georgina-Rodriguez.html#comments

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blossomtoes · 17/07/2021 21:06

@HalzTangz

Don't see the issue. They are showing less flesh than men who think it's ok to walk round topless
The men at the event where these pictures were taken were all in black tie. 🤷‍♀️
HalzTangz · 17/07/2021 21:04

Don't see the issue. They are showing less flesh than men who think it's ok to walk round topless

SoMuchForSummerLove · 17/07/2021 21:03

Yes, it's not the looking that's the problem as such. It's that for some men how women look seems to be twisted into an invitation to shag her regardless of whether she's interested or not.

Or at least that seems to be an acceptable claim to make in order to get away with sexual crimes.

RiverSkater · 17/07/2021 17:35

She wants people to admire her body. It's not an open invite for men to shag her.

If I see a man wearing his jeans round his arse showing me his coin slot I don't assume he wants me to jump him for sex.

Those that think it is have a problem. And it's usually men. Often women too. Confused

Piffle11 · 17/07/2021 17:06

Not fussed on the dresses, ‘cos I prefer to be more covered up. Personal choice. BUT … I remember Kimberley Garner from MIC, and always thought she came across very well: rather a sweet person. Wearing revealing clothes is surely for one reason only - to be photographed. I’m not a prude and I think people should be able to wear what they want (provided it’s not obscene or insulting): I think the worst - in my opinion - was Kendall Jenner in a La Perla dress: beautiful woman, fab body, but just … too much. For me. But wouldn’t slag her off for her choice.

Nightlystroll · 17/07/2021 13:45

These women want to get publicity for a chance to be successful. Putting body parts on display increases the likelihood of having their pictures being reported on. The more titillating flesh they display, the greater probability their picture will be published. They've got their photos in national newspapers. Job done.

They put themselves out there to be photographed and talked about. If some of the commentary is negative, that's the price if their choice.

TableFlowerss · 17/07/2021 13:29

@Blossomtoes

FFS, no we shouldn't be having a conversation about the messages clothes send. If we're talking about sexual assault we should ONLY able having a conversation about male entitlement and power relations that leads them to sexually assault and rape women

This thread is entirely about what clothes say about us. It’s not about sexual assault or rape.

Absolutely agree. Always some that try to turn it in to something it’s not!
zukiecat · 17/07/2021 13:13

The lilac dress is beautiful, or would be without the two splits and without such a low cut neckline.

I've never heard of the actress though.

Grellbunt · 17/07/2021 12:12

FFS

I don't like it and it's shite but of course clothes send out messages. As does flashing my arse in public.

It's one thing how we would like the world to be, quite another how it really is.

Grimacingfrog · 17/07/2021 11:47

@Blossomtoes

Well you haven't read the whole thread then

I certainly have - half the posts on it are mine!

Well I don't know what to say to you then. Perhaps you struggle with reading comprehension.

If you think that by people saying that women are sending a message, that juries may be affected and bringing Harvey Weinstein into it is nothing to do with sexual assault and how people blame the victims, there's no point in me wasting my time responding to your posts.

Have a nice day Smile.

Blossomtoes · 17/07/2021 09:53

Well you haven't read the whole thread then

I certainly have - half the posts on it are mine!

TableFlowerss · 17/07/2021 09:51

[quote smokeball]@tableflowerss

But as humans we judge. Everyone judges and makes assumptions based on all sorts of thing. How you dress can say a lot about a person so if you dress a certain way, then it’s likely people will perceive you in a certain wayWhether that’s a true reflection of who you are or indicative of the message you may want to portray, people will judge. So people can’t complain if they dress a certain way and people form opinions.
different people will judge differently - there is not one immutable truth here and how each person judges says more about them, the person judging, than about the person being judged. I doubt very much the way I would judge is going to the same as the way you would judge.[/quote]
But the onus isn’t on the person judging, everyone judges differently. It’s not them that is going to suffer the ‘consequences’. The person judging is indifferent.

What you have to bare in mind however is that some will judge. So if you turn up for a job interview in shorts/T-shirt and flip flops there’s a high probability that you won’t get the job because they’ll assume you’re not taking the time seriously.

Now that’s a reasonable judgement is it not? Some would argue it’s not, as what difference does clothing make to how well someone could do a job?! That’s a fair point.

So you see, it’s not the interviewer that will suffer the consequences, even though he’s the one judging. It’s the person wearing the clothes.

Grimacingfrog · 16/07/2021 22:59

@Blossomtoes

FFS, no we shouldn't be having a conversation about the messages clothes send. If we're talking about sexual assault we should ONLY able having a conversation about male entitlement and power relations that leads them to sexually assault and rape women

This thread is entirely about what clothes say about us. It’s not about sexual assault or rape.

Well you haven't read the whole thread then.
Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 22:31

FFS, no we shouldn't be having a conversation about the messages clothes send. If we're talking about sexual assault we should ONLY able having a conversation about male entitlement and power relations that leads them to sexually assault and rape women

This thread is entirely about what clothes say about us. It’s not about sexual assault or rape.

smokeball · 16/07/2021 22:10

@tableflowerss

But as humans we judge. Everyone judges and makes assumptions based on all sorts of thing. How you dress can say a lot about a person so if you dress a certain way, then it’s likely people will perceive you in a certain wayWhether that’s a true reflection of who you are or indicative of the message you may want to portray, people will judge. So people can’t complain if they dress a certain way and people form opinions.
different people will judge differently - there is not one immutable truth here and how each person judges says more about them, the person judging, than about the person being judged. I doubt very much the way I would judge is going to the same as the way you would judge.

Grimacingfrog · 16/07/2021 22:04

*is not an excuse for rape

Grimacingfrog · 16/07/2021 22:03

@DrSbaitso

I'm not saying women are to blame as such, OF COURSE NOT, but I do think we need to be able to talk honestly about the messages that clothes send.

Ooh, "as such". How....sinister.

How do you reconcile the first part of your sentence with the second part?

It's depressing and scary in equal measure.

Messages that clothes send? Terrifying. So who decides what level of exposure is unacceptable and 'asking for it'? Is it culturally driven, so in some countries where women are very covered up, is a flash of ankle to excuse sexual assault?

FFS, no we shouldn't be having a conversation about the messages clothes send. If we're talking about sexual assault we should ONLY able having a conversation about male entitlement and power relations that leads them to sexually assault and rape women.

Whether an outfit is tasteful or not should be an entirely different discussion and we should not mix up the two, EVER.

If women aren't saying that 'she asked for it because: drunk/revealing clothes/sexual history etc' there's no hope that things will ever, ever, change.

doingadisservice · 16/07/2021 21:05

Not clicking on the link.

My view is that if you have to spend any amount of time 'fiddling' with the clothes to keep your dignity then you shouldn't wear it in public.
So hoiking tops up, skirts down etc

If it fits comfortably go for it.

shrumps · 16/07/2021 20:54

I just know men don't feel the need to flash their arses for attention. I don't know what the answer is anymore

FindingMeno · 16/07/2021 20:40

I'm underwhelmed.
Neither shocked nor in awe.
Nothing to do with the 'exposure- I just don't think they look very stylish.

TableFlowerss · 16/07/2021 20:36

For example someone wears sporty clothes often. People will likely assume they like sports.

TableFlowerss · 16/07/2021 20:35

[quote smokeball]**@CandidaAlbicans2* @TableFlowerss* I don't like women being manipulated into allowing themselves be sexualised by others, or thinking that being sexualised is necessary for success, but at the same time, critising a dress at Cannes isn't the way of changing that happening. The show of flesh in itself should not be made the problem.[/quote]
But as humans we judge. Everyone judges and makes assumptions based on all sorts of thing. How you dress can say a lot about a person so if you dress a certain way, then it’s likely people will perceive you in a certain way.

Whether that’s a true reflection of who you are or indicative of the message you may want to portray, people will judge. So people can’t complain if they dress a certain way and people form opinions.

DrSbaitso · 16/07/2021 18:56

@comebacksunshines

So you would have been aged around 8 when Kurt Cobain from Nirvana died and early teens at the end of the 90's ? I agree that women have always been objectified, but they are now willingly objectifying themselves, under the guise of empowerment. I think I prefer the former, at least it was honest and you knew what you were fighting against.
Yes, I was a young 90s teen but I have an older sister who was always on some crap diet or another and watched a lot of music television. I read "heroin chic" in the newspapers and when I read her magazines they were full of diets and how to get thin. And the early 00s weren't massively different from what I recall. I remember the Spice Girls and Gina G being criticised for wearing scanty clothes but I liked them and I don't recall anything inappropriate for a tween audience. And lots of women in bikinis in men's music videos. Rap and hip hop especially. Some horrible shots, really degrading. I remember Ali G's Me Julie song (2002, so not quite 90s), which in retrospect I realise was a piss take. But it featured Shaggy, who did that kind of thing for real, so I'm not sure how subversive all the jiggling tits and arses really were. Now, had he done it in his mankini...

There was one video, definitely 90s, that even got half blurred out during the daytime. Can't remember for my life what it was called or how it went (I remember not liking it).

smokeball · 16/07/2021 18:52

@CandidaAlbicans2 @TableFlowerss I don't like women being manipulated into allowing themselves be sexualised by others, or thinking that being sexualised is necessary for success, but at the same time, critising a dress at Cannes isn't the way of changing that happening. The show of flesh in itself should not be made the problem.

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 18:48

Objectification of women has always happened. I was young in the 70s when page 3 was in full swing. One of my friends did a nude session for a men’s mag called Mayfair and says it’s the one thing she bitterly regrets. It makes her feel dirty just thinking about it.

I'm having such a hard time teaching my daughter that she can enjoy playing with clothes and fashion and still enjoy reading books, doing sport and being clever. Please don't make it harder still

I completely get this but enjoying fashion isn’t remotely the same as wearing something that exposes almost all of you. Would you be delighted to see your daughter dressed like those DM photos? Because I wouldn’t. I’d wonder where I’d gone wrong.