Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step daughter and bedroom size

607 replies

Squeakysqueal · 15/07/2021 23:36

I would appreciate some advice on this situation. We have Step DD who’s 11 and lives 50/50 between ours and her mum’s, DS also 11, and DD who’s 6, who live with us full time and a baby on the way. We’re moving house and our new house isn’t quite as big, the same amount of bedrooms but smaller. The plan has been for Step DD to have the smallest room and DS and DD to have the slightly bigger rooms. Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that. There’s only really space for a single bed and a wardrobe or drawers. DH has suggested DD going in the smaller room with her being quite a bit younger but I think it makes sense with living arrangements for step DD to have it. Especially as when the baby is old enough she’ll be sharing the bigger room. Step DD says she wouldn’t mind sharing with the baby in the future but I think she definitely will, she’ll be a teenager by then. We could have DS in the small room but again with him being here full time and step DD part time it makes sense. She feels like there’s some favouritism going on and I can see why it feels that way from her perspective but that’s definitely not the case. I’ve said we can decorate the room however she likes but she’s just not happy with the situation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TatianaBis · 16/07/2021 12:44

My dd went to Uni abs never returned.
Wouldn't let ds have her big room.
So it stood empty for 2 years.

Well you’re complicit if you let a teenager walk all over you.

GreyhoundG1rl · 16/07/2021 12:43

I don't understand how OP's DS is doing best out of this?

At best he is equal to his younger sister if he gets one of the bigger rooms, at worst he's in a box room 100% of the time in order that SD gets to have a bigger one.
Isn't the other bigger room shared in some combination?

DuchessDarty · 16/07/2021 12:43

@Bibidy

Why on earth should a child who lives there full time have the box room when a much larger room sits empty 50% of the time?? It’s ridiculous and unfair on your DS. DSD also has her own room at her mum’s so has the benefit of 2 bedrooms being solely hers.

Why is it unfair on the OP’s DS? He’s the one that does best out of this.

I don't understand how OP's DS is doing best out of this?

At best he is equal to his younger sister if he gets one of the bigger rooms, at worst he's in a box room 100% of the time in order that SD gets to have a bigger one.

Because the OP has decided on her solution. A fact which many posters either haven’t registered or have chosen to ignore in order to continue arguing.

The OP’s plan involves either her DD or SD sharing with the baby in due course and the other getting the box room. DS will be neither sharing nor getting the box room. Hence he is doing best out of it.

TheCraicDealer · 16/07/2021 12:42

I'd give her a choice between having the box room completely to herself (with DD6 eventually sharing with the baby- agree a cot should go in ASAP to reinforce that this isn't just DD6's room), or sharing the bigger bedroom with DD6.

She might say she's happy to share with the baby, but being in with a much, much younger sibling just won't be practical even in the medium-term. I wouldn't be playing musical beds with a toddler half the week because DSD wants to stay up later than 7-8pm but also have the perceived privilege of having the bigger room.

I suspect that she's thinking she could argue for the bigger room thinking that she'll somehow get that and not have to share. That wouldn't be fair to the other three children who spend the majority of their time at this house.

randomlyLostInWales · 16/07/2021 12:40

My dd went to Uni abs never returned.
Wouldn't let ds have her big room.
So it stood empty for 2 years.

I find that odd - DD1 already knows when she head off she and DD2 will be swapping rooms they agree it makes sense and when DS moves on we'll see what's best then for everyone living here.

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 12:38

@HeckyPeck

I would much rather have had my own small room than have to share with a baby!

People are all seeing the smaller room as the worst, but I would rank the rooms as:

Best: middle sized room to yourself
Second: smallest room to yourself
Worst: biggest room sharing with baby

If your DD isn't bothered about room size I'd flip a coin for DD and DS to see who gets middle size and who gets small, then DSD can share with baby.

I would speak to DSD though and make sure she understands what the reality would be of sharing with a baby, i.e. baby's stuff will take up half the room, likely to wake several times in th night etc.

Then if she didn't want the big room I'd give her the smaller room and DS then middle as she already has a big room to herself half the time anyway.

Completely agree. The worst bedroom for me is the one that's shared!!

I would 10000000% rather be in the smallest room and have it to myself rather than share with anyone.

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 12:35

Why on earth should a child who lives there full time have the box room when a much larger room sits empty 50% of the time?? It’s ridiculous and unfair on your DS.
DSD also has her own room at her mum’s so has the benefit of 2 bedrooms being solely hers.

Why is it unfair on the OP’s DS? He’s the one that does best out of this.

I don't understand how OP's DS is doing best out of this?

At best he is equal to his younger sister if he gets one of the bigger rooms, at worst he's in a box room 100% of the time in order that SD gets to have a bigger one.

randomlyLostInWales · 16/07/2021 12:32

@Chikapu

Is anyone genuinely scarred from having a small bedroom? Are children really using space as an indicator of their worth in a family?
When we moved here - IL just started making noises along those line that were were unfair to DD1 not giving her the biggest room - we'd alrwady made our decsion and kids were happy.

In our view - DS went from box room to bigger room -over a room where we'd less likely to hear him get up and down all the time - and DDs got a room each and no longer had to share.

We're not a blended family, there wasn't a new baby on the way, and there's no resentment or worry between our kids - so their views weren't upsetting our kids and it was easy to say butt out.

I think DSsi found it harder with her children and step child as competeing views were aired in front of the children - by various relatives some of which chidlren took onboard including idea they should just rent somewhere bigger depsite lack of such propeties and massive rent hike.

HeckyPeck · 16/07/2021 12:32

I also would have though it was ridiculous for my step sister to be in a box room and me to have a big room to myself when I was only there half the time!

funinthesun19 · 16/07/2021 12:31

That would be her mum’s in terms of what’s wrote down as her address but she’s always spent just as much time here as she has there.

She’s just as much part of our family as everyone else is, it’s strange people are judging the entire dynamic of our family on one decision we have to make

OP I haven’t said she’s not part of your family.

BUT it is relevant where her main home is, if it just on paper. Your children deserve to have a bedroom to call their own just as much dsd does at her mum’s. I know you think I’m being unreasonable in my approach to this but I’m actually sticking up for you.

Robin233 · 16/07/2021 12:30

Room 1: mum and dad
Room 2: Boy
Room 3: 2 girls
Room 4: Baby
If sdd is 11 in 7 years time she'll be 18.
My dd went to Uni abs never returned.
Wouldn't let ds have her big room.
So it stood empty for 2 years.
We even moved house abs had a room fir her there (not the biggest)

HeckyPeck · 16/07/2021 12:29

I would much rather have had my own small room than have to share with a baby!

People are all seeing the smaller room as the worst, but I would rank the rooms as:

Best: middle sized room to yourself
Second: smallest room to yourself
Worst: biggest room sharing with baby

If your DD isn't bothered about room size I'd flip a coin for DD and DS to see who gets middle size and who gets small, then DSD can share with baby.

I would speak to DSD though and make sure she understands what the reality would be of sharing with a baby, i.e. baby's stuff will take up half the room, likely to wake several times in th night etc.

Then if she didn't want the big room I'd give her the smaller room and DS then middle as she already has a big room to herself half the time anyway.

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 12:28

@SomeNameorOther

Actually, sharing with the baby is not necessarily that impractcal. You could put baby to bed in your bed, and then move him into his cot later. I know people think this is ridiculous, but it's terribly easy to move a sleeping child without waking them, just be gentle, murmur to them in your quietest most loving voice and they might stir a bit but that's it. It meant, for us, that dd could fall asleep anywhere and we could put her in bed later on. My parents did it with me and my siblings too; i do have very warm memories of being picked up from the back of the car and carried to bed, just vague and safe and warm and happy, snuggling into dad......

I could walk dd to the loo in the middle of the night and back into bed, when she was two or three without her properly waking throughout the entire operation!

Not all children are like this at all. Some wake very easily when moved.

Also, look at the amount of threads on this site about people who struggle to get their child to go to sleep and stay in their own bed. A young child needs to learn to go to sleep in their own bed, not that they can just drop wherever/in mum's bed and be carried to their own bed...that's a recipe for chaos.

Anyway.....people are only saying it's not ideal to share with a baby FOR SD. She is the one who will be impacted more by that, not the baby.

I would have thought most children of 11+ (and even younger tbh) would rather have their own private, smaller room where they can sit up reading or watching TV until they go to bed, rather than not being able to use their room after 6.30/7pm because a pre-schooler is asleep in there.

FortniteBoysMum · 16/07/2021 12:28

Could DD and DSD share the bigger room. Leaving the small room as a nursery for baby. DD would have the room to herself half the time anyway and DSD will not feel like she's in a box. If she said she's happy to share with a baby surely sharing with dd will not be an issue?

CecilyP · 16/07/2021 12:27

SleepingStandingUp, don't worry, that situation only lasted for a year or so until the eldest, son in law and baby moved to their own house. The small back dining room was used as a sitting room and a conservatory used for dining (and playing darts!)

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 12:24

@aSofaNearYou

And what's wrong with moving them around again at a later date?

The fact that it's not necessary and sends a strong message that one of the bedrooms is better and should be coveted by the other child?

Moving them around at a later date is bound to cause resentment.

How is it worse for SD to be able to take and decorate the box room now then to come to her in 18 months and say "right, baby needs to be in this big room now so you're moving into the box room"?

It makes zero sense for SD to be in the bigger room unless she's going to share with DD6.

CecilyP · 16/07/2021 12:20

However, that would risk waking a sleeping teenager - that would definitely be far from ideal!

SleepingStandingUp · 16/07/2021 12:18

@CecilyP

No, he was just very happy there and liked being part of this lively family! He did later get married and move away!
Tbf id judge the parents in that situation if that adults were all just there for fun. Presumably eldest, dsil abd dgc in one, lodger in box, other 3 in second double? No one can stay up late or get up early because theres no where to be other than a bedroom full of people.
SomeNameorOther · 16/07/2021 12:15

Actually, sharing with the baby is not necessarily that impractcal. You could put baby to bed in your bed, and then move him into his cot later. I know people think this is ridiculous, but it's terribly easy to move a sleeping child without waking them, just be gentle, murmur to them in your quietest most loving voice and they might stir a bit but that's it. It meant, for us, that dd could fall asleep anywhere and we could put her in bed later on. My parents did it with me and my siblings too; i do have very warm memories of being picked up from the back of the car and carried to bed, just vague and safe and warm and happy, snuggling into dad......

I could walk dd to the loo in the middle of the night and back into bed, when she was two or three without her properly waking throughout the entire operation!

aSofaNearYou · 16/07/2021 12:15

I don't think there's always an issue with sharing per se. The dynamics of OP's particular family set-up mean that sharing situations fall too far short of ideal, IMO. And as the parents have made the decisions that led to the situation, they should, again IMO, be the ones to accommodate.

Why? A house with a bedroom each for each child and two sharing does not "fall too far short of ideal", it basically is ideal. Why on earth is that bad enough to merit parents needing to give up their room?

Chikapu · 16/07/2021 12:14

Is anyone genuinely scarred from having a small bedroom? Are children really using space as an indicator of their worth in a family?

CecilyP · 16/07/2021 12:12

No, he was just very happy there and liked being part of this lively family! He did later get married and move away!

GreyhoundG1rl · 16/07/2021 12:09

@CecilyP

One PP said she and DH slept in the dining room for 3 years so all their DC could have their own space.

Family friends once had mum and dad, 4 kids, eldest daughter's husband and baby plus a lodger in a typical interwar 3 bed (2 doubles and and a box) semi. In addition, I use to sometimes stay for a sleepover. They used the front living room as a bedroom but that's what I would call overcrowded.

The lodger must have been absolutely desperate for a roof over their head Confused
MitheringSunday · 16/07/2021 12:08

OhWhyDidTheyDoIt: 'Fucking hell. No wonder there are so many entitled children in the world. It would be nice for them to have their own space. They don't need it.

Surely sharing a room is not the end of the world for children. But fucked backs and bad sleep for people who have to work is OK?'

Ours did all need their own space, for various reasons. Before that, the older two shared for years, but there came a point when it was no longer working well. And i can't quite work out why no bedroom = fucked backs.
We're now moving and everyone will have a room.

I don't think there's always an issue with sharing per se. The dynamics of OP's particular family set-up mean that sharing situations fall too far short of ideal, IMO. And as the parents have made the decisions that led to the situation, they should, again IMO, be the ones to accommodate.

WellLarDeDar · 16/07/2021 12:07

I think it's quite logical to give her the smallest room as it will be used the least. I dont think you're doing it to be mean. But alas, kids rarely understand that pov. Good luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread