Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step daughter and bedroom size

607 replies

Squeakysqueal · 15/07/2021 23:36

I would appreciate some advice on this situation. We have Step DD who’s 11 and lives 50/50 between ours and her mum’s, DS also 11, and DD who’s 6, who live with us full time and a baby on the way. We’re moving house and our new house isn’t quite as big, the same amount of bedrooms but smaller. The plan has been for Step DD to have the smallest room and DS and DD to have the slightly bigger rooms. Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that. There’s only really space for a single bed and a wardrobe or drawers. DH has suggested DD going in the smaller room with her being quite a bit younger but I think it makes sense with living arrangements for step DD to have it. Especially as when the baby is old enough she’ll be sharing the bigger room. Step DD says she wouldn’t mind sharing with the baby in the future but I think she definitely will, she’ll be a teenager by then. We could have DS in the small room but again with him being here full time and step DD part time it makes sense. She feels like there’s some favouritism going on and I can see why it feels that way from her perspective but that’s definitely not the case. I’ve said we can decorate the room however she likes but she’s just not happy with the situation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
DifferentHair · 16/07/2021 13:53

A child that age needs a desk and some privacy IMO. Especially with a bunch of step and half siblings running around, I don't see how she can compete academically while studying at a kitchen table in a busy house.

If you can't get one of those desk/bunk bed combos then she needs the larger room purely for this.

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 13:51

dont agree with this - with this logic, DSD never will have a good room as she spends 50% in the other house 50% in the OP's house. Through zero fault of her own.

It's not that SD automatically qualifies for the 'worst' room based on time spent wherever she is, but just in this specific household somebody has to have the box room because there are 4 children in the picture. Even if there wasn't a baby on the way, someone would still have to either have the box room or share.

In this scenario it makes sense that it's SD who is offered the box room because she spends the least time in the home, and whichever girl has the bigger room will need to share with a baby within the next 18 months. Would she really want to be 13 and sharing with a small baby?

Presumably SD would be welcome to share a bigger room with DD? But it's just not reasonable for her to want the bigger room for herself.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 16/07/2021 13:39

dont agree with this - with this logic, DSD never will have a good room as she spends 50% in the other house 50% in the OP's house. Through zero fault of her own

she has two bedrooms to herself, the other kids only have one - she wont "never have a good room" in fact she has two and just isnt happy about the size of one, well tough, in reality.

Teenyton · 16/07/2021 13:38

"SpongebobNoPants

I think my post has been misunderstood…
I think giving a room for the sole purpose of a child who is there only half the time is madness, I also think it’s ridiculous to give a full time resident child the smallest room whilst another larger room sits empty for 50% of the week. Best case scenario I think is either SD gets the box room to herself or she shares the largest of the bedrooms with DD half of the time and baby has the box room as a nursery. Full time residents of the house take priority as it is their only home."

dont agree with this - with this logic, DSD never will have a good room as she spends 50% in the other house 50% in the OP's house. Through zero fault of her own.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 16/07/2021 13:37

@Definitelynotem

I agree with PP, if it was only weekend then fair enough but 50/50 is a lot of time in a small room, especially when she’s becoming a teenager and needs space for herself and to study
but then who else gets it, considering they live there FT?
Bibidy · 16/07/2021 13:29

@SpongebobNoPants

I think my post has been misunderstood… I think giving a room for the sole purpose of a child who is there only half the time is madness, I also think it’s ridiculous to give a full time resident child the smallest room whilst another larger room sits empty for 50% of the week.

Best case scenario I think is either SD gets the box room to herself or she shares the largest of the bedrooms with DD half of the time and baby has the box room as a nursery.

Full time residents of the house take priority as it is their only home.

I agree with you.

But I don't even see it as a matter of priority, just as a matter of common sense. If a room is going to sit empty 50% of the time, it should be the smallest room.

Dillydollydingdong · 16/07/2021 13:28

Full timers have the biggest rooms. No point leaving a big room empty most of the time and having a full time family member squished up.

Heartofglass12345 · 16/07/2021 13:26

I don't understand this. My room was small growing up, some of my friends rooms were tiny. It's just one of those things you have to deal with as a child and nothing to do with being a stepchild. She either shares or has the box room!

SpongebobNoPants · 16/07/2021 13:23

I think my post has been misunderstood…
I think giving a room for the sole purpose of a child who is there only half the time is madness, I also think it’s ridiculous to give a full time resident child the smallest room whilst another larger room sits empty for 50% of the week.

Best case scenario I think is either SD gets the box room to herself or she shares the largest of the bedrooms with DD half of the time and baby has the box room as a nursery.

Full time residents of the house take priority as it is their only home.

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 13:21

@DuchessDarty

OK. I naturally assumed you must have seen that comment since you responded to my post where I quoted *@SpongebobNoPants* saying that.Smile
Oh I see what you mean! Sorry got proper crossed wires over here.

I do think it would be unfair on him to be in the box room given he's in the house 100% and is the same age as SD, but my responses were more based on him being unfairly advantaged in any scenario, rather that it being super unfair on him.

It's difficult as well when we don't know the context of the other children - eg does DS spend any time with his dad, assuming his dad isn't OP's DH? Is DD6 his full sibling or is she OP's & DH's as well?

I do think the emotions need to be taken out of it to make the best decision, but think if people are considering SD's feelings they also need to consider DS's to the same extent, given he's (presumably) also a stepchild and is also dealing with the arrival of a new sibling.

DuchessDarty · 16/07/2021 13:16

@AbsolutelyTerrific

The DS gets a room to himself whichever the scenario because he's the only boy. That's just how the chips fell and is completely reasonable.
Yes it is. Who is saying it isn’t?
DuchessDarty · 16/07/2021 13:16

In fact @Bibidy you yourself quoted that comment by Spongebob when you cut and pasted to reply to me…

AbsolutelyTerrific · 16/07/2021 13:14

The DS gets a room to himself whichever the scenario because he's the only boy. That's just how the chips fell and is completely reasonable.

DuchessDarty · 16/07/2021 13:09

OK. I naturally assumed you must have seen that comment since you responded to my post where I quoted @SpongebobNoPants saying that.Smile

Bibidy · 16/07/2021 13:06

@DuchessDarty

Hi *@Bibidy* I get all that about the DS. But I repeat, how is any of this unfair on the DS, which is what a PP said and what I was responding to?
Oh I don't think it's unfair on him, think I must have missed the previous comment on that score. Was just saying I didn't see why he was especially advantaged here. But admit I didn't think about how he doesn't have to share in any scenario.
ittakes2 · 16/07/2021 13:05

I have boy/girl twins - my son always gets the smaller bedroom but we make up for it by giving him more space elsewhere in the house ie the playroom is pretty much used extensively by him where he plays his playstation. Maybe that's an option for you if there is space elsewhere in the house he can call his own to make up for a smaller rooms? All children are different but I found my son had nothing in his room but a bed and clothes while my daughter had a myriad of things.
I would give your DSS choice ie a) the smaller room with a special bed / desk thing or b) the bigger room but she needs to downsize when you move the baby in with your other daughter. Children like choice makes them feel more incontrol. even if she doesnb't like her choices given her choice would be better than telling her your decision as at that age they have a tendency to rebel....

DuchessDarty · 16/07/2021 13:03

Hi @Bibidy I get all that about the DS. But I repeat, how is any of this unfair on the DS, which is what a PP said and what I was responding to?

tallduckandhandsome · 16/07/2021 13:02

@claralara42

I would put 6yo in the small room, smallest child gets smallest room

This makes no sense at all

That's how it worked in our house of 6 kids.
Bibidy · 16/07/2021 12:59

Ah you’re pivoting now that you’ve seen your argument that DS was potentially losing out is bogus. Good-oh.

DuchessDarty - Sorry, I actually hadn't seen your reply when I posted that!

I do get your argument that he won't have to share or get the box room, but the not sharing is just by virtue of all the other siblings including the baby being the opposite sex, which isn't his fault or choice.

I guess he could be considered for the box room, but I don't really see the logic in that if it's just so that SD can have a bigger room to herself instead. They are the same age and he lives in the house all the time. I genuinely can't see the sense in him having a much smaller room just for another bigger room to sit empty half the time.

But putting everything aside, I genuinely think the parents need to make a decision based on what's practical, not on what suits one child the best.

That to me is either SD gets the box room to herself, or she shares the bigger room with DD6. Putting myself in her shoes, I'd much rather have the box room to myself, particularly thinking over the next few years when she is 13/14 sharing a room with an 8 year old who's going to bed much earlier.

I think she has just seen the size of the room when it's empty and been unhappy, rather than being helped to consider how much better it is for her to have her own room rather than sharing.

claralara42 · 16/07/2021 12:59

I would put 6yo in the small room, smallest child gets smallest room

This makes no sense at all

tallduckandhandsome · 16/07/2021 12:56

I would put 6yo in the small room, smallest child gets smallest room.

You may well move in 5 years time.

TheCraicDealer · 16/07/2021 12:54

If the box room is really that small you could put her wardrobe in DS's room and she could just have a bed, desk and a small chest of drawers/beside table in the box room. Hook on the back of her door for this visit's clothes so she's not constantly going in and out of DS's room (which would be annoying for both).

DuchessDarty · 16/07/2021 12:51

@Bibidy

Things can't always be planned around one child's feelings, sometimes decisions have to be based on practicality.

An 11 year old sharing with a baby when it's not necessary is nonsense. SD may well say she's happy to do this but she doesn't understand the reality of not being able to use the room after a certain time, or being disturbed through the night and having to get up for school the next day.

She needs to understand that taking the box room is the only way she gets a bedroom to herself. Otherwise she shares one of the bigger rooms with DD6 and the baby gets the box room down the line.

Ah you’re pivoting now that you’ve seen your argument that DS was potentially losing out is bogus. Good-oh.
Bibidy · 16/07/2021 12:48

Things can't always be planned around one child's feelings, sometimes decisions have to be based on practicality.

An 11 year old sharing with a baby when it's not necessary is nonsense. SD may well say she's happy to do this but she doesn't understand the reality of not being able to use the room after a certain time, or being disturbed through the night and having to get up for school the next day.

She needs to understand that taking the box room is the only way she gets a bedroom to herself. Otherwise she shares one of the bigger rooms with DD6 and the baby gets the box room down the line.

stellaisabella · 16/07/2021 12:47

Logically you're completely correct, she should have the smaller room. Otherwise one of the children who always lives with you will have to be in a smaller room 💯 of the time, and that's not fair either. All the children are equal as you've said, so you have to make a decision which is difficult, but I think it's the right one.
As a stepmum you'll be made the villain whatever you do.
Could you maybe pop a wardrobe for her in your dds room, so she could have a bit more space in the small room?

Swipe left for the next trending thread