Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step daughter and bedroom size

607 replies

Squeakysqueal · 15/07/2021 23:36

I would appreciate some advice on this situation. We have Step DD who’s 11 and lives 50/50 between ours and her mum’s, DS also 11, and DD who’s 6, who live with us full time and a baby on the way. We’re moving house and our new house isn’t quite as big, the same amount of bedrooms but smaller. The plan has been for Step DD to have the smallest room and DS and DD to have the slightly bigger rooms. Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that. There’s only really space for a single bed and a wardrobe or drawers. DH has suggested DD going in the smaller room with her being quite a bit younger but I think it makes sense with living arrangements for step DD to have it. Especially as when the baby is old enough she’ll be sharing the bigger room. Step DD says she wouldn’t mind sharing with the baby in the future but I think she definitely will, she’ll be a teenager by then. We could have DS in the small room but again with him being here full time and step DD part time it makes sense. She feels like there’s some favouritism going on and I can see why it feels that way from her perspective but that’s definitely not the case. I’ve said we can decorate the room however she likes but she’s just not happy with the situation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
roguetomato · 16/07/2021 07:32

Being there 50% of time isn't a choice made by the dsd though. It's arrangement between her parents.
So I think it's unfair to give her the smallest room because of that.
I think you need to have a talk with all the children together to decide who gets which room, with consideration that big room need to be shared in future.

daisypond · 16/07/2021 07:32

@Foxglovesandlilacs86

Oh god since when do kids get a say in which room they have. She’s only there half the time so doesn’t need as big a room as the ones who are.
By that logic she’d only be entitled to the tiniest room at her mum’s too - as she’s only there half the time too.
MargaretThursday · 16/07/2021 07:32

I would say younger ones need more space than older ones.

For those that are saying the 11yo needs double bed/bigger room, then what about the 6yo? When's she's 11yo, step sis will be 17yo and still presumably staying 50/50 so still in the bigger room.
However she's going to be 11yo, in the smaller room, sharing with her 5yo sister.

I'd put the two that share in the bigger room, and I agree that a 11yo in principle might be happy to share with a baby but the reality of being woken, unable to leave things out, baby stuff, waking to a smelly nappy etc will not be appreciated.

Foxglovesandlilacs86 · 16/07/2021 07:30

Oh god since when do kids get a say in which room they have. She’s only there half the time so doesn’t need as big a room as the ones who are.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/07/2021 07:28

You need to ask your ds what he wants. You say it’s a waste of a good room to put him in there. But he may choose it.

Despite someone calling Oziani outrageous, it may be true that your dsd has more stuff than your ds. That should be factored in, including giving her enough space to store her suitcase and study.

DifferentHair · 16/07/2021 07:25

I think if you give DSD the smallest room then it sets a tone that this is less her home than it is the other children.

I think you should be mindful of this tone or culture in your house in general. She's about to enter adolescence and will probably have more and more opinions and autonomy in terms of how she spends her time.

If she feels second fiddle in your home then your DH shouldn't be surprised when she decides to spend less time there and more at her mothers.

It also creates a tier 1 and tier 2 system between the 100% of time children and the 50% of time child, which puts pressure on the sibling relationship. This relationship will be there, for good or bad, long after you and your DH leave this earth so think about it.

Approaching this as a purely practical space issue is missing the wider point IMO.

Aprilx · 16/07/2021 07:24

@Shadedog

I would be very pissed off as the 11yo boy if my same age stepsister got the big room even though she was there half the amount of time I was. He would be sitting in the box room doing his homework in his bed as no room for a desk and looking across the hall at a large, empty room. If the 6yo was a boy I guess the boys would be together in the big room and dsd in the other big room and baby in the tiny room. I don’t think you can give one of your 11 yos room to study and not the other
The 11 year old boy presumably has a father elsewhere (unless OP’s husband had children with two women simultaneously) and hopefully one he sees. In which case he has a home elsewhere too.

I find it sad that the OP’s dilemma seems to be about which girl should take the small room, but the options do not include the son having it.

I feel very sorry for the stepdaughter, she is clearly being treated less favourably to the OP’s biological children. If her mother applied the same rationale as her father, that she doesn’t need a decent room because she is only there 50% of the time, she could end up in a broom cupboard whichever house she is in.

PatchworkElmer · 16/07/2021 07:22

I’d put DSD and the 6yo together in 1 room, DS in the other big one, baby in the box room. Give DSD the option of the box room if she’s unhappy with the realities of sharing. Don’t decorate as she’s likely to change her mind.

daisypond · 16/07/2021 07:17

I don’t get the loathing for small rooms. I used to pick the smallest room as my favourite - cosy. My nephew also picked the box room as his preference. Have you asked your DC if they have a room preference? Or are there any plus points to the small room that you could emphasise?

Chittychittybangbang123 · 16/07/2021 07:17

YANBU.
Give the bigger bedrooms to the children who are there 100% of the time.
She will get over it. Children do not need their own room, not alone a huge one.

DeathStare · 16/07/2021 07:16

@funinthesun19

Is DS there all the time, though? Or is he not your DH's and sees his dad sometimes?

Even if he isn’t there full time, that’s his main home if op is the RP to her son, the same way dsd’s main home is with her mum. I doubt her mum is quick to give her a box room in her main home either.

DSD is there 50/50. This is her main home just as much as the other home is.
jeanne16 · 16/07/2021 07:15

I was the youngest child and got the smallest room in the house. I also obviously became a teenager but still stayed in the smallest room. This, and other things, made me feel like the least important member of the family.

I’m just pointing this out as whatever the OP does, she will create potential issues.

DeathStare · 16/07/2021 07:14

I'd give one of the bigger rooms to DD and put a cot in it from day 1 (even if it's just a travel cot) to make it clear that this is a shared room, not her room.

Then DSD and DS can pick between them who gets which room, and if they can't decide, toss a coin.

DinosaurDiana · 16/07/2021 07:12

The SD will soon be a teenager and glad of her own space, however big it is. And she won’t be wanting to share with a baby/toddler.

Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 16/07/2021 07:11

The resident child should have the best bedroom. The other child has a bedroom in her other home. Why she she have two good bedrooms and the child whose full time home it is suffer? Far too much pandering to SC goes on here.

Uramaki · 16/07/2021 07:07

Small room is fine. If they were all your kids one of them would need the small room and not have a whole other room!

CallMeRisley · 16/07/2021 07:06

@lovethisjourneyforme

Baby goes in your room.

6 year old in box room.

DS in big room.

DSD in other big room.

Maybe consider doing up the attic in the next year or so? Then shove one of the 11 year olds in there. Teenagers like to be quirky and independent so maybe a funky caravan for the garden when they're a bit older?

A caravan in the garden Hmm Would love to see the thread in a few years time AIBU to put DSD in a caravan in the garden when she’s here 50/50?
newnortherner111 · 16/07/2021 07:04

Probably the best choice given the house and the situation you are in. Any option would not be great for one child.

ElderMillennial · 16/07/2021 07:03

People arent having a go at OP for failing to provide a mansion for her kids; they are having a go at her for having MORE kids when she currently only has space for the ones she's got.

She has got space for them and isn't even expecting DSD to share a room. I see so many posts on mumsnet about OPs having more children when they don't have enough bedrooms and people are generally supportive. It's also common for one child to have a "box" room or smaller room.

Because this situation involves a step child the bar is unreasonably high.

funinthesun19 · 16/07/2021 07:01

People arent having a go at OP for failing to provide a mansion for her kids; they are having a go at her for having MORE kids when she currently only has space for the ones she's got.

Oh no the world might end now.

Draineddraineddrained · 16/07/2021 06:53

People arent having a go at OP for failing to provide a mansion for her kids; they are having a go at her for having MORE kids when she currently only has space for the ones she's got.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 16/07/2021 06:47

The OP is providing a plenty big enough house for her family. Typical UK 3 & 4 bed houses nearly always have a box room and it's often a teen who is put in it as younger children have much bulkier toys etc.

To me of course the person who is only there 50% of the time does not get first dibs on a room. Where is the sense in a large room unused for half the week? I do think it's worth asking your DS if he wouldn't mind, since she clearly feels strongly. I would also consider the option of the two girls sharing and having the box room for the baby eventually. I would also say that if either of your children are away with their dad for some of the time that also changed things.

But someone has to have the smallest room in any house and that person isn't being "put last" it's based on a sensible consideration of the facts.

ElderMillennial · 16/07/2021 06:44

OP I think it makes sense for DSD to have the smaller room

funinthesun19 · 16/07/2021 06:39

Is DS there all the time, though? Or is he not your DH's and sees his dad sometimes?

Even if he isn’t there full time, that’s his main home if op is the RP to her son, the same way dsd’s main home is with her mum. I doubt her mum is quick to give her a box room in her main home either.

CallItLoneliness · 16/07/2021 06:23

Is DS there all the time, though? Or is he not your DH's and sees his dad sometimes? Either way as long as your DH is happy to see less of his DD, who is close to an age at which she can choose, it's totally fine to make her unwelcome and put her in the box room.

If that's not the case, you might want to rethink things, with perhaps you and DH taking the box room longer term, and the 6yo and the baby sharing the master.