Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step daughter and bedroom size

607 replies

Squeakysqueal · 15/07/2021 23:36

I would appreciate some advice on this situation. We have Step DD who’s 11 and lives 50/50 between ours and her mum’s, DS also 11, and DD who’s 6, who live with us full time and a baby on the way. We’re moving house and our new house isn’t quite as big, the same amount of bedrooms but smaller. The plan has been for Step DD to have the smallest room and DS and DD to have the slightly bigger rooms. Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that. There’s only really space for a single bed and a wardrobe or drawers. DH has suggested DD going in the smaller room with her being quite a bit younger but I think it makes sense with living arrangements for step DD to have it. Especially as when the baby is old enough she’ll be sharing the bigger room. Step DD says she wouldn’t mind sharing with the baby in the future but I think she definitely will, she’ll be a teenager by then. We could have DS in the small room but again with him being here full time and step DD part time it makes sense. She feels like there’s some favouritism going on and I can see why it feels that way from her perspective but that’s definitely not the case. I’ve said we can decorate the room however she likes but she’s just not happy with the situation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2021 14:22

No, but a decent room shouldn't really be considered too much should it? Those things are hardly comparable.

Whatever happens, she is getting a decent room.

Cam2020 · 17/07/2021 14:20

Step DD is upset that we don't have an indoor pool only a outdoor one and that the cleaner only works 3 days. We've justed suggested 10 days skiing in the Alps and she's complaining she wants to go for 2 weeks. Aibu to think we have inadequately housed her and shouldn't have had her if we couldn't meet her every demand?

No, but a decent room shouldn't really be considered too much should it? Those things are hardly comparable.

SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 13:56

@Cam2020

Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that.

Inadequate.

Inadequate and "not up to her 11 year old standards" are not the same.

Step DD is upset that we don't have an indoor pool only a outdoor one and that the cleaner only works 3 days. We've justed suggested 10 days skiing in the Alps and she's complaining she wants to go for 2 weeks. Aibu to think we have inadequately housed her and shouldn't have had her if we couldn't meet her every demand?

CastawayQueen · 17/07/2021 13:54

*OP’s biological daughter. Of course the baby can’t express a preference 😂

CastawayQueen · 17/07/2021 13:53

@Youseethethingis

The 11 year old step child deserves the bigger room. They will be a teenager soon. They need a desk. They need privacy. They don't get to see their dad all the time. They are having to deal with step and half siblings. It must be so hard for them. They shouldn't be stuck in the smallest room, they will feel sidelined, unwanted and unloved, so OP might as well stick them in the shed or under the stairs.

Fine. But there are two children all of the above applies to. OPs DS and her DSD. Only one is there 100% of the time and the other is there 50%. Awkward to the narrative, isn't it?

So how do you then justify one of these equally deserving 11 year olds being in a box room for his one and only bedroom, while the bigger room sits empty half the week and his step sister is in her second bedroom?

This. Quite a few posters haven’t bothered to read the thread properly (or I don’t know , lack the reading comprehension skills). And haven’t realised that:
  1. There are two stepchildren here, of the same age
  2. Decision was made by OP and her DH, both of whom have one stepchild
  3. If not sharing box room SD would have to share room with a younger sibling.
  4. SD is already getting a better deal than OP’s own daughters who aren’t even asked what they prefer. SD chooses whether to share or have box room and the other two get what’s left over.
SleepingStandingUp · 17/07/2021 13:52

@Cam2020

Personally, I wouldn't be having another baby if I couldn't adequately accommodate all the children, but I realise that's not helpful.

Is there a shed DSD could use?

They are and will be adequately accomodated the. Being part of a family means you don't get to habe everything you want all the time forever without compromise. She can have a large room but will have to share on the future. She can never share and have the small room. She's getting choice whereas the other two will habe to fit around her. Hardly a neglected and unloved child locked in the basement.

The odea that sharing a room or having 5he box room makes you inadequacy housed is just beyond ignorant.

Youseethethingis · 17/07/2021 13:41

The 11 year old step child deserves the bigger room. They will be a teenager soon. They need a desk. They need privacy. They don't get to see their dad all the time. They are having to deal with step and half siblings. It must be so hard for them. They shouldn't be stuck in the smallest room, they will feel sidelined, unwanted and unloved, so OP might as well stick them in the shed or under the stairs.

Fine. But there are two children all of the above applies to. OPs DS and her DSD. Only one is there 100% of the time and the other is there 50%. Awkward to the narrative, isn't it?

So how do you then justify one of these equally deserving 11 year olds being in a box room for his one and only bedroom, while the bigger room sits empty half the week and his step sister is in her second bedroom?

aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2021 13:36

@Teenyton What on Earth is your argument? What do you want to happen? If your entire argument is just that you think people aren't being empathetic enough, maybe consider that they are talking to other adults about practical solutions, not demonstrating how they would plan on speaking to the child about it. Making statements like people are suggesting she should feel grateful to set foot in her dad's house is just making you look ridiculous

Teenyton · 17/07/2021 13:29

"What a shame for your stepdaughter. Try and imagine how she must be feeling - unwanted and unloved and not part of the family. She might be sensitive about that anyway, given that she is split between two families all the time."

My thoughts are much the same. I really can't understand the lack of empathy here and all these people talking about technicalities, oh she's there only 50%, oh but it's not her main address where she's registered to a gp, (wtf?!), oh having a room itself is enough (she should just be thankful being able to set foot in her dad's house I guess...)

Teenyton · 17/07/2021 13:22

@Getyourarseofffthequattro oh I see now! That's why you guys were commenting that you saw me messaging in another thread etc? You think the only people who criticise your thought process could be ex wife! You got me wrong, I'm happily married with three kids, and have never been an ex. Lol...

3Britnee · 17/07/2021 12:42

@amission

Don't blame her.

She's feeling sidelined.

Justifiably.

One of the kids will (although I don't think a smaller bedroom is a reason to) and sd is only there part time 🤷‍♀️

Why should a child that is there full time give up a bigger room to a child that is only there half the time?

Yanbu op.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 17/07/2021 12:30

@ImmyMc

What a shame for your stepdaughter. Try and imagine how she must be feeling - unwanted and unloved and not part of the family. She might be sensitive about that anyway, given that she is split between two families all the time.
Can you explain why it is a shame for her to have the smallest bedroom? Can you explain why it would make her feel unwanted or unloved?

Can you then explain why it would be perfectly fine for one of the other children to have this room? And why they wouldn't feel unwanted or unloved?

ImmyMc · 17/07/2021 12:28

What a shame for your stepdaughter. Try and imagine how she must be feeling - unwanted and unloved and not part of the family. She might be sensitive about that anyway, given that she is split between two families all the time.

MarrymeTomHardy · 17/07/2021 11:50

@SleepingStandingUp

The other option is to put the girls into the bog room together and set the box up as the nursery
This is what I was going to suggest
Blondeshavemorefun · 17/07/2021 11:35

How small is room

Our box is 9.6 x 7.3

And I lived in one that size for
15yrs full time

Notcoolmum · 17/07/2021 11:30

My DS had the box room for years. He did grumble at times but when it actually came for him to move he said he liked his cosy room. DSS whinged it was a bit small when it became his but I don't have infinite space or money!

I agree it makes sense for the younger girls to share as they will be closer in age. Have early baths/bedtimes etc.

TomHardysPyjamas · 17/07/2021 10:51

@Cam2020

Personally, I wouldn't be having another baby if I couldn't adequately accommodate all the children, but I realise that's not helpful.

Is there a shed DSD could use?

So she'll feel more part of the family shunted off to a shed in the garden while the three resident children have their own bedrooms inside the house.

Got it.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 17/07/2021 10:41

@Cam2020

Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that.

Inadequate.

Lol. So what about every resident child who has a small room? Every child that has to share?

You are clearly very privileged and naïve.

LizzieW1969 · 17/07/2021 10:00

All the children are adequately accommodated, either by having a room of their own or sharing one. Sharing a bedroom is completely normal. One to yourself is a luxury.

^Exactly. It was completely the norm to share a room with a sibling when a lot of us were growing up. I didn’t even have my own room until I was 12 years old.

I’d say that the small bedroom is fine for DSD, as it means she’ll never have to share. Just let her decorate it the way she wants. She might say that she’ll be happy to share with the baby, but she won’t like it when she’s born, as it will mean that she has no privacy.

aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2021 09:59

@Cam2020

Step DD is upset by how small her room is, it is a small room so I understand that.

Inadequate.

Inadequate would be no room. 11 year old's are also upset about not having mansions and ponies, it doesn't mean they aren't provided for adequately.
aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2021 09:58

The people who keep coming on and insisting this set up is really unfair and discriminatory towards DSD consistently seem to do so because they think her 50/50 status means she, and children like her, often get the raw end of the deal. What I want to know is what their perceived solution is. Are they saying they think she should be given the bigger room purely to compensate for that?

The reality is that upset over being 50/50 and all that ensues is not the only thing at play here that could cause upset. Any one of the children, given the box room, could conjure up a perfectly valid reason to find that upsetting, not just DSD. (Certain) people seem to be acting like anyone not prioritising DSDs feelings about being between part of two households above everyone else's, is being cruel and just doesn't care about her, but I would say those people need to think a little harder about how either of the other children might feel in the small room, and realise that actually there's no one child whose emotions "trump" the others, leaving only practical considerations with which to make this decision.

And yes, also remind themselves that box rooms are not actual cardboard boxes. They are small rooms.

Cam2020 · 17/07/2021 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

aSofaNearYou · 17/07/2021 09:43

@Cam2020

Personally, I wouldn't be having another baby if I couldn't adequately accommodate all the children, but I realise that's not helpful.

Is there a shed DSD could use?

They are more than adequately accommodated, what a ridiculous slant.
daisypond · 17/07/2021 09:38

@Cam2020

Personally, I wouldn't be having another baby if I couldn't adequately accommodate all the children, but I realise that's not helpful.

Is there a shed DSD could use?

All the children are adequately accommodated, either by having a room of their own or sharing one. Sharing a bedroom is completely normal. One to yourself is a luxury.
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 17/07/2021 09:32

@Cam2020

Personally, I wouldn't be having another baby if I couldn't adequately accommodate all the children, but I realise that's not helpful.

Is there a shed DSD could use?

But they are adequately accomodating all the children. What part of having your own bedroom isn't adequate?
Swipe left for the next trending thread