Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you 100% believe your partner has never cheated?

535 replies

zaraaraz · 15/07/2021 22:57

I think cheating is very common. I was with someone I loved, would have done anything for and he left me and was declaring his love for someone else the next day. Obviously he was seeing her behind my back. My boyfriend before him was going through a divorce because his wife had cheated.

My sister met her husband when they were both with other people. My fathers first wife cheated on him.

I’ve seen a particular colleague cheat twice on his girlfriend.

It’s just very common in my opinion. I’m currently single but whosever I date next then I wouldn’t be shocked if I found out if they were a cheater.

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 17/07/2021 15:49

But it would be kind of nuts for me to state unequivocally that I can prove he never has or that he never will.

Who said anything about proof? The OP didn't ask for proof and nobody has claimed to be able to give proof. The OP asked us what we believed to be true.

lazylinguist · 17/07/2021 15:46

Because anyone who hands this much power to another person is setting themselves up for failure.

How? I 100% believe my husband has never cheated. That's a conclusion I've reached based solely on my knowledge of what he's like and how he behaves. Can you explain to me what 'power' that gives him? Because I don't understand that at all. He has no more 'power' in our relationship than I do.

Also, how am I setting myself up for failure? If he were going to cheat, he cpuld do so whether I believed 100%, 50% or 0% that he wouldn't!

hookiewookie29 · 17/07/2021 14:01

1000% sure. His first wife cheated on him. He'd never cheat on me.
Besides, he can't cope with one woman ( me) never mind two Grin

OhWhyNot · 17/07/2021 13:58

Everyone can act completely out of character for a number of reasons

Everyone regardless could cheat iso many things can change in life

thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2021 13:39

@lazylinguist

True. But I still don't understand why the doom-mongers are soooo keen to spread their message and mock people for trusting their partners, and what they think this will achieve. It just sounds like sour grapes tbh. Turning out to be wrong about something that you were convinced wouldn't happen isn't really an uncommon occurrence in general. I'd rather live in trust with my husband, even if I turned out later to be wrong.

Besides, the thread was asking how certain people are that their partner hasn't cheated. Being sure of that is not claiming to be able to look into the future.

Of course its better to live in trust. Otherwise what's the point of being in a relationship. I totally agree with this.

But that isn't what was asked: the question was how many people are 100% sure their partner has never cheated. And a staggeringly large number of people have come on to say they are 100% sure.

There's two reasons this bothers me:

  1. Because it simply isn't possible to know this 100%. Most people must at some level know this so they are therefore choosing to delude themselves about something this important. Its far better for your mental health to recognise this and allow for the possibility that you could be wrong than to brainwash yourself into believing something cannot possibly happen, setting yourself up for a hideous shock if it doesn't happen. It just isn't a healthy way to build resilience or self knowledge.
  1. Because anyone who hands this much power to another person is setting themselves up for failure. It's not fair to expect a relationship with another person to provide totally copper-bottomed insurance. You have to trust the person you're in a relationship with them while you're in a relationship with them. But you also have to be able to allow for the possibility that the relationship may cease to work for them. You are throwing all your eggs in one very unreliable basked by doing this.

I'm not a huge fan of marriage generally for many reasons anyway and this probably colours my outlook. But its not sour grapes. I'm in a very good, happy relationship ATM with someone who I trust as far is its possible to do so. I have absolutely no current worries that he's going to cheat. But it would be kind of nuts for me to state unequivocally that I can prove he never has or that he never will.

lazylinguist · 17/07/2021 13:19

True. But I still don't understand why the doom-mongers are soooo keen to spread their message and mock people for trusting their partners, and what they think this will achieve. It just sounds like sour grapes tbh. Turning out to be wrong about something that you were convinced wouldn't happen isn't really an uncommon occurrence in general. I'd rather live in trust with my husband, even if I turned out later to be wrong.

Besides, the thread was asking how certain people are that their partner hasn't cheated. Being sure of that is not claiming to be able to look into the future.

thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2021 13:00

@lazylinguist

They are making a judgement on how likely or unlikely they think something is to happen.

Right. But they are all magically coming up with 100% certainty (or 99% in some more realistic cases). Anyone with a basic grasp of statistics can tell you they can't all be right.

lazylinguist · 17/07/2021 12:57

But they clearly don't know this, or at least won't admit to this or they wouldn't be insisting that they can see into the future.

They are not insisting they can see into tye future. They are making a judgement on how likely or unlikely they think something is to happen. People do that about all kinds of things in life all the time. Some are more optimistic than others.

thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2021 12:16

Everyone knows they don't have 100% control over another person's behaviour.

But they clearly don't know this, or at least won't admit to this or they wouldn't be insisting that they can see into the future.

I'm not advocating remaining in a state of constant suspicion and vigilance I've said people should trust until there is evidence otherwise: I'm saying that people insisting they have a crystal ball into the behaviour of other people for the benefit of strangers on the internet is a bit deluded.

Why not just accept that you can't know everything but will act in good faith until you know otherwise?

I just think its quite unhealthy...

lazylinguist · 17/07/2021 12:09

It's not about trying to upset people. I'm sure in the majority of these 100 percenter cases the partners won't cheat.

It's about trying to get people to confront the fact that they can't ever control other people's behaviour and impose wishful thinking onto the future behaviour of another living individual.

No it isn't. Everyone knows they don't have 100% control over another person's behaviour. It's not about control at all. It's about knowing a person well, using your best judgement. They believe their partner won't cheat . What are they supposed to gain from being convinced by posters doggedly insisting 'You can't know that!'? I doubt it will make them any less devastated if their partner does end up cheating!

If 'most of the 100 percenters' partners won't cheat', then on balance the 100 percenters will have been right then, won't they? And they'll have been happier living without the constant suspicion that tyeir partner would cheat.

VienneseWhirligig · 17/07/2021 10:37

I know mine didn't, he was destroyed by his ex's cheating and told me he had a one night stand with the wife of one of the men his ex cheated with once he knew about their affair, but it was awful and he hated himself. He would never have cheated on me. Not being naive, he genuinely was too honest. He would have left me first.

jihhy · 17/07/2021 10:34

Posters on here are projecting their own temptation to cheat onto other posters by saying well you or you partner may cheat one day who knows. Stop it.

🤔
I've never cheated & don't think I've been cheated on. I trust DH & don't think about cheating but trust 100%? no.

Things change, people change, people make mistakes, shit happens.

If someone asked me in 2019 did I believe schools would close, we would have to lockdown etc in 2020 due to a virus I wouldn't have believed them.

thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2021 10:25

@Kitten189

Stop trying to tell people they or their partners might cheat in the future. What’s the point of trying to upset people like that. We aren’t all selfish pricks.
It's not about trying to upset people. I'm sure in the majority of these 100 percenter cases the partners won't cheat.

It's about trying to get people to confront the fact that they can't ever control other people's behaviour and impose wishful thinking onto the future behaviour of another living individual.

Tons of people have come on here saying "he won't cheat because he's not like that" or "he's got too much integrity" or "he's been cheated on before and he knows its a dick move". Well, sorry, but these things aren't cast iron, empirical guarantees of future behaviour, they are subjective interpretations of a facet someone is choosing to present to you.

It's a bit like people saying "I know I'm never going to develop a serious disease because I pray to God not to let it happen" . Or sticking your fingers and saying "la la la if I can't hear it it can't be there." There's a big element of self-delusion here which isn't going to be helpful if, god forbid, he does cheat. It also slightly scares me the amount that's being invested in these relationships which - by definition - are uncertain.

Its much healthier simply to accept that you can't ever really control the behaviour of another person, that you trust them implicitly when they are trustworthy but that if the trust is ever broken you have the strength and self-believe you need in yourself to walk away.

Mrstamborineman · 17/07/2021 10:23

And neither have I. 23 years together.

Mrstamborineman · 17/07/2021 10:22

I am sure as eggs is eggs he hasn’t.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/07/2021 10:17

@MrsLion it's really not that rare. There are lots of men and women that don't cheat.

IcedPurple · 17/07/2021 09:58

@FuckUcuntychops

No I’m not 100% sure. You can never truly know someone no matter how close you are to them.
I agree with that.

I don't think anyone could be absolutely certain that their partner has never and would never cheat on them. By its very nature, cheating is secretive.

Anybody - male or female - has the potential to cheat.

TrixieThunder · 17/07/2021 09:54

To say I’m 100% certain*

TrixieThunder · 17/07/2021 09:53

I don’t think anyone is trying to upset posters and trust in your partner is the most important component for it to work, but I think it’s also healthy to realise humans are fallible and can do stupid things.

I trust my partner. I trust he has not cheated in our 14 years together and I will continue to put my trust in him but I’m 100% certain it will never happen is naive. I can instead say I fully believe he wouldn’t cheat but I can’t say I know, because I don’t. I can’t.

U2HasTheEdge · 17/07/2021 09:49

Impossible= possible

U2HasTheEdge · 17/07/2021 09:46

@Kitten189

Stop trying to tell people they or their partners might cheat in the future. What’s the point of trying to upset people like that. We aren’t all selfish pricks.
It is a discussion board.

Of course not everyone will cheat and I don't think anyone has said otherwise, but some people disagree that it is impossible to see into the future and predict the actions of another human being.

Who knows what the years will bring, and if people are upset by that very basic truth then they can hide the thread.

Member984815 · 17/07/2021 09:42

Yes I'm 100 % sure , but I can't see in to the future and nor would I want to .

MrsLion · 17/07/2021 09:37

I am 100% sure my dh hasn’t. We have had some very serious problems but despite being blindsided by other things, I am sure about the non cheating.

It’s rare but not all men cheat.

Kitten189 · 17/07/2021 09:34

Posters on here are projecting their own temptation to cheat onto other posters by saying well you or you partner may cheat one day who knows. Stop it.

Petrarkanian · 17/07/2021 09:33

100% sure he never has or will cheat on me.
We lucked out when we met each other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread