Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you 100% believe your partner has never cheated?

535 replies

zaraaraz · 15/07/2021 22:57

I think cheating is very common. I was with someone I loved, would have done anything for and he left me and was declaring his love for someone else the next day. Obviously he was seeing her behind my back. My boyfriend before him was going through a divorce because his wife had cheated.

My sister met her husband when they were both with other people. My fathers first wife cheated on him.

I’ve seen a particular colleague cheat twice on his girlfriend.

It’s just very common in my opinion. I’m currently single but whosever I date next then I wouldn’t be shocked if I found out if they were a cheater.

OP posts:
SchrodingersImmigrant · 17/07/2021 21:11

@Ohhyeahright

It’s the naïveté that upsets me. I know no one ever wants anyone’s pity but I can’t help it. I just feel so, so sorry for those who are ‘100% sure’ when some of you will absolutely have had your blind faith and trust betrayed.
Well that's quite patronising
LemonRoses · 17/07/2021 21:08

@Ohhyeahright

It’s the naïveté that upsets me. I know no one ever wants anyone’s pity but I can’t help it. I just feel so, so sorry for those who are ‘100% sure’ when some of you will absolutely have had your blind faith and trust betrayed.
And it’s the truly sad cynicism that upsets me. I truly pity anyone who hasn’t experienced total trust in another person, their partner. It’s almost encouraging them to wander having such a doubting attitude and definitely not how to build a lifelong marriage.
EspressoDoubleShot · 17/07/2021 21:07

That’s what faith is, an immutable belief rooted in hope and not subjected to scrutiny

Ohhyeahright · 17/07/2021 21:03

It’s the naïveté that upsets me. I know no one ever wants anyone’s pity but I can’t help it. I just feel so, so sorry for those who are ‘100% sure’ when some of you will absolutely have had your blind faith and trust betrayed.

lynsey91 · 17/07/2021 20:44

@MoiraRose4

Unfortunately I think most people here are really naive. I’ve been there, with someone who would ‘never’ cheat because they’d had it done to them and it had broken them. Guess what? 🙄
I am not naive thank you. I just know DH really really really really well and know he would not cheat.

Sorry to hear you were cheated on but anyone with morals doesn't cheat

catsjammies · 17/07/2021 20:19

My DH wouldn't. I can say that flat out. I know he works with a lot of men who have cheated (the partners are notorious), but I would be very surprised if any of our friendship group was.

TrulyOutrageousJem · 17/07/2021 20:15

I worked in construction and it totally changed my view on men, forever. Even the most loving partner where I knew their wife and I could see how in love they were still cheated.

I’m not saying everybody cheats but A LOT do and never get caught.

Kanaloa · 17/07/2021 20:12

Mine hasn’t. We’ve never got the bloody time to have affairs.

BasedInDublin · 17/07/2021 20:11

I don't think mine has, but I'll never be sure. I'd imagine it is the same for my DH.

I've never cheated on DH, but could easily have done so at different times. I'm fairly certain he'd never have known.

WeHaveComeSoFar · 17/07/2021 20:08

@MoiraRose4

Unfortunately I think most people here are really naive. I’ve been there, with someone who would ‘never’ cheat because they’d had it done to them and it had broken them. Guess what? 🙄
That’s your opinion
Darkchocolateandcoffee · 17/07/2021 19:32

I'm sure mine hasn't cheated.

MoiraRose4 · 17/07/2021 19:25

Unfortunately I think most people here are really naive. I’ve been there, with someone who would ‘never’ cheat because they’d had it done to them and it had broken them. Guess what? 🙄

2LostSoulsSwimmingInAFishBowl · 17/07/2021 19:23

Absolutely it’s common but I do trust my current partner totally and completely not to cheat. He’s never given me any reason not to trust him and I’ve also had a lot of therapy to get over my abusive cheating ex which also helps.

felulageller · 17/07/2021 19:20

I think you've just had a disproportionate experience with cheating.

LemonRoses · 17/07/2021 19:06

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@lazylinguist

They are making a judgement on how likely or unlikely they think something is to happen.

Right. But they are all magically coming up with 100% certainty (or 99% in some more realistic cases). Anyone with a basic grasp of statistics can tell you they can't all be right.[/quote]
It’s called trust and faith in your own judgment. It’s also entirely possible that those of us who have that level of conviction are right - the section of people answering this question aren’t necessarily representative of the statistics, given we’ve chosen to comment and are a tiny cohort.

lynsey91 · 17/07/2021 19:06

@bullyingadvice2017

Every person has it in them. Given the right mix of circumstances. Only takes a moment for two people feeling emotionally vulnerable to click.
Absolute bullshit rubbish.

Lots of people would never cheat. All this bollocks of "circumstances". NO circumstances whatsoever would make me cheat. It would just never happen.

Two people might "click" (how sad is that phrase) but there is no need whatsoever to take it any further. We are humans with brains and morals and it is not difficult to not cheat.

As I said earlier, no one ends up in bed naked with someone who is not their partner and not know how they got there do they?

lynsey91 · 17/07/2021 19:03

@U2HasTheEdge

Admitting to inability to see the future, human frailty and uncertainty is just human. You don't make yourselves stronger or more resilient by pretending you can see the future.

Absolutely! You see it on MN all the time. People who were in the 100% camp, completely floored when they find out they were wrong.

Do people who have 100% trust in the fact their partners will never cheat think they are better judges of character or something than the people who also thought like them and were then proved wrong? It is pretty arrogant really.

Life is uncertain and you have absolutely no control over what someone else does and you can never predict the future actions of someone else with 100% accuracy. You can pretend to yourself all you like, but it is still a fact that you do not know what the future holds.

Ok I can't see into the future but I am absolutely 100% certain DH would not cheat unless he somehow had a complete change of personality, morals, views on infidelity etc.

I guess something like a brain tumour could cause such a change but otherwise he just would not cheat.

I don't think I am a better judge of character although I have been spookily correct many many times about different people (friends, work colleagues, family) and not just regarding cheating.

I do however know DH very well. I literally can almost read his mind. He says himself that he can't work out how so many times I know what he is thinking, what he is going to say etc.

He has very strong morals, views on marriage and infidelity. The same as I do. They are not going to suddenly change when he is now in his 60's.

I am certain I would not cheat because of my views, morals etc and, as DH shares all those, I can be equally sure he will not

TomPinch · 17/07/2021 18:53

@bullyingadvice2017

Every person has it in them. Given the right mix of circumstances. Only takes a moment for two people feeling emotionally vulnerable to click.
Yes yes yes yes this.

And once again, the stats...

Loneliness is the most common reason for cheating. It's a killer. I remember it absolutely gnawing at me. That's why I'm not in the 100% crowd, even though despite this I have never cheated. If I neglected DW enough, the two possible outcomes would be a) she left or b) she cheated because she didn't want to break up the family unit and we've had some very tough times.

thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2021 18:41

@lazylinguist

I’m not making any particular assumptions about you and your relationship or the relationships of any other the other posters on this thread.

But I can’t get past the fact that people are unnervingly happy to stick their necks out with a statistic like 100% for something as intangible and unpredictable as the fidelity of their partners.

You can argue that it doesn’t matter and it’s none of my business and on an individual level this is true.

But it does matter and to see why it matters you only have to saunter onto the relationships board where on any given day there will be three threads from women who were 100 percenters whose husbands have cheated.

There’s no way to protect yourself from this of course and being cynical is no more likely to keep it at bay than being gullible.

But blindly insisting that you have this degree of visibility into something when you very plainly don’t suggests a lot of people are quite divorced from reality and, critically, are not able to plan ahead and imagine an alternative universe. And that is a problem.

Clydesider · 17/07/2021 17:01

I'm 100% sure. He'd never cheat; not in a million years.

lazylinguist · 17/07/2021 16:59

The thing about power is that by giving someone that much trust you are basically saying you're so invested in them that you're unable to have any agency in your own life and your ability to plan for and dictate your own life. I don't think its healthy.

I'm not feeling defensive about my own relationship, I just think it just sounds as though you are imagining the relationships of the '100 percenters' to be of a particular type, when I don't think they necessarily are. And imagining the women in those relationships to be romantic, idealist, dependent wives devoted to the husband they imagine is perfect.

That's not how I feel at all. I'm not a romantic, I'm a pragmatist. My husband isn't perfect. I can imagine him potentially doing all sorts of things that would seriously piss me off Grin. But not cheating. Let's be clear - I don't say that in an idealistic 'he adores me so much that another woman could never turn his head way at all. I say it because I'm certain he would leave me rather than stray. I fail to see how that deprives me of agency in my own life. If I'm wrong and he cheats, I don't see how the fact that I was certain he wouldn't would make any difference to the outcome.

I don't give a monkey's what anyone thinks of my own relationship, I just think you keep making statements that don't make any logical sense. Like the one I quoted in this post. How would I be able to plan for my own life better, or have more 'agency' if I had only an 80% belief that my husband had not cheated?

I mean... my husband could get run over by a bus tomorrow. Or a million other things could happen? How would that affect my 'agency'? Why do you think that the mere percentage of belief in fidelity is what would determine my ability to support myself, move on with my life etc? I'd be very sad/angry, but I've no lack of agency or ability to plan.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 17/07/2021 16:44

It's not a question that's ever been a preoccupation in my marriage. But I think this thread is quite revealing. One or two points PPs have made resonated with me in particular. Especially this:

No one ever completely knows the Heart (or mind) of anyone else.

Quite true. I also don't buy the naive observations that someone will/won't do something because they are/are not the type. Given the wrong set of variables coming together in any one situation, I suspect most things are possible for pretty much everyone. That isn't to say they necessarily will. But 100% is a big figure; it's not a balance of probabilities but total certainty, And I've never thought life was that simple.

I don't live in a state of paranoia thinking 'what if he cheats on me, or what if I have my head turned?' I like to think neither of us would; I've also no reason to believe this has ever happened.

I also can't claim to know even myself with 100% certainty, let alone another human being. We are more complex animals than that.

SirenSays · 17/07/2021 16:38

Lol at lemming like assumption. Maybe they just know their partners and relationships better than you do, stranger on the Internet. I can say I'm 100% my partner won't cheat. Just like I can say I'm 100% sure my DH isn't going to start burning down orphanages, become a famous astronaut or rock outside and start practicing WWE moves on passing grandmothers. Of course it could happen, I'm not a psychic wizard but I'm sure it won't.
Why does having trust in your partner mean you can't have agency in your own life?

bullyingadvice2017 · 17/07/2021 16:23

Every person has it in them. Given the right mix of circumstances. Only takes a moment for two people feeling emotionally vulnerable to click.

thepeopleversuswork · 17/07/2021 16:08

@lazylinguist

Because anyone who hands this much power to another person is setting themselves up for failure.

How? I 100% believe my husband has never cheated. That's a conclusion I've reached based solely on my knowledge of what he's like and how he behaves. Can you explain to me what 'power' that gives him? Because I don't understand that at all. He has no more 'power' in our relationship than I do.

Also, how am I setting myself up for failure? If he were going to cheat, he cpuld do so whether I believed 100%, 50% or 0% that he wouldn't!

I just think as a matter of principle 100% trust in anyone at all is foolhardy. You wouldn't trust anything else 100%. A car, an insurance policy, a work contract. Why should something as mercurial and unpredictable as a person, who has their own identity and independent intelligence to you, and subject to forces and influences you don't know about, be capable or worthy of 100% trust? It just doesn't make sense. The thing about power is that by giving someone that much trust you are basically saying you're so invested in them that you're unable to have any agency in your own life and your ability to plan for and dictate your own life. I don't think its healthy.

The OP didn't ask for proof and nobody has claimed to be able to give proof. The OP asked us what we believed to be true.

Yes and about 85% of 300+ respondents said they believed 100% that their partner or husband had never cheated. This just cannot - due to the law of numbers -- factually be accurate. If you're going to state unequivocally that you are 100% certain of something you have to have proof!

Look I'm not trying to say trust in a relationship is invalid or to make people think their partners are cheating on them. I'm just trying to get people to question this slightly lemming-like assumption that just because they are currently happy with their partner he can't ever and won't ever cheat. You don't need to be that defensive about it. No-one is ever going to be 100%. Just be happy and accepting that your levels of trust are currently high enough and carry on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread