Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put weedkiller in a water pistol and nuke neighbours lillies?

161 replies

Mumteedum · 15/07/2021 21:22

Obviously I won't. I just want to vent.

Next door neighbour is a gifted gardener. He grows monster lillies. Each plant is 7-8 feet high (it's above the fence). The plant nearest my house is right next to the fence and about 2 metres from my back door.

I can count over 20 budding flowers already in the bit above the fence. There are at least 6 of these plants..maybe more. So I would estimate that each plant must have up to 80 flower heads. That's 480 liliies.

Its hot and I need windows open but I'm sat wheezing and I've got a headache. I never have to take my inhaler apart from now.

My house stinks of them.

Can I nuke them? Please 🙏 😁

OP posts:
chesirecat99 · 16/07/2021 13:16

They aren't oriental tree lilies, they are martagon lilies.

I love lilies and cats. I've never known a cat to get lily poisoning and I come from 3 generations of lily growing, multiple cat owners cat ladies Grin I don't think the risk was widely known until recently. Realistically, whether your garden is full of beautiful cultivated flowers or just weeds, there will be plants in it that are toxic to pets if they eat them unless you just have a totally sterile, wildlife-unfriendly plastic lawn. Tomatoes are just as toxic but nobody ever suggests no one grows tomatoes in case cats eat the leaves.

The biggest risk is from the pollen getting on to their fur and the cat licking it off. If he is a keen gardener, I would assume he is deadheading the flowers and picking up any fallen flowers so they don't spoil the look of his lovely garden. Unless a cat is sitting under the flowers repeatedly beating the stems until the pollen drops off, it is unlikely to get any pollen on it. It can't accidentally brush against a flower that is 6 feet in the air. Most cases of lily poisoning are from lilies in a vase. They are a far bigger risk as they are cat height.

I'm sure he won't mind if you ask him to move the pots. You can get pollen free tree lilies that he could grow there instead, so he doesn't need to spoil his garden design.

www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Orange-Marmalade.html?gclid=CjwKCAjw3MSHBhB3EiwAxcaEuyM6VoFSO_eL5Wq_pdVNlu4kPM-FdF2XSb7QrtrAXSN3-iGEd3jqPxoCTC0QAvD_BwE

www.thompson-morgan.com/p/tree-lilyreg-crystal-collection/p92241TM?source=aw&affid=4255&awc=2283_1614850054_688d7914c76b38cd028a62cb198f5035

Porcupineintherough · 16/07/2021 12:49

@Warmduscher cats arent getting out they are being let out. By people who apparently think this is a fine way to treat an animal you are supposedly fond of. I'm old enough to remember when dogs were treated like this too. That stopped being acceptable a while back, bought time cat owners caught up.

rjacksmiss · 16/07/2021 12:33

I'd probably buy a new house 😂 what a shame though, I've had to throw a few bouquets out because of the smell. Absolute reeking cat piss fuckers.

Warmduscher · 16/07/2021 12:33

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Warmduscher any cat owner who is worried about the safety of their cat can take steps to keep them in their own property. If they care so little they fail to do this, why should I mind? Do all our gardens have to be safe for all our beighbours children and pets now, in case they fancy a wander?[/quote]
Let’s hope your dogs don’t ever run out into the road in front of a driver with the same attitude to you about pet safety.

GrolliffetheDragon · 16/07/2021 12:14

@TheTallOakTrees

I'm allergic to cats but no kills the blighters off to help me.

So YABVVU use antihistamine etc

Other peoples cats wouldn't be there for weeks or possibly months at a time though.

If I was OPs neighbour I'd be horrified if I found out my plants were causing her to need to take a pile of extra medication and avoid her garden. Yes, there's lots of crap situations we all just have to live with, but in this case it's easy to change. I don't think I'm unusually reasonable, surely most people wouldn't want their neighbour to suffer debilitating symptoms when moving a few plants would prevent it?

BecauseMyRingBurnsSheila · 16/07/2021 12:09

I grow lilies on one side of my garden and if that neighbour told me it gave her hayfever I absolutely would be happy to move them. Hope your expert gardener neighbour is equally reasonable OP.

AutistGoth · 16/07/2021 11:54

It might be a good idea to try to get a telephone consultation with a doctor since you're having such a strong reaction. You can't live this way in your own home.

Can some medical personnel prescribe strong anti histamines, painkillers and asthma medication for you?

PS: My DMum always loved lillies all over the house. They really offended my hyper sensitive sense of smell as a youngster!

TheTallOakTrees · 16/07/2021 11:37

I'm allergic to cats but no kills the blighters off to help me.

So YABVVU use antihistamine etc

Emilyontmoor · 16/07/2021 11:28

If lilies are so toxic to cats I don’t understand why my cats have lived to at least 16 years in spite of them being in the garden, in bouquets etc. None of the neighbour’s cats seem to be struggling either. Perhaps the cats have more sense than their humans, and don’t try climbing up the stems to get at the poisonous pollen….. Obviously you shouldn’t leave them at their level but commanding the world to not grow them is taking it a bit far.

mumteedum As they are in pots I would definitely politely let him know how it is affecting you. I have pots of lilies that I love and I wouldn’t hesitate to move them if an allergic or even slightly hysterical cat owning neighbour asked me. Also as he must know it is only the oriental lillies that smell strongly, asiatic lilies have no smell and look just as good. So he could easily switch to those for his display next year…..

Whatamesssss · 16/07/2021 11:26

@TheQueef

Are they too close *@Whatamesssss*? I've put them all high in pots and cut the pollen out so ranging cats can't brush against, is it still dangerous?
Yes, every part of a lily plant is toxic.

I know it is unlikely, but they could eat some of the leafs. Best not to take the chance. But then again, I am over anxious about my cats Grin

Livpool · 16/07/2021 11:25

Ugh I hate lilies so agree with you OP

Porcupineintherough · 16/07/2021 11:23

Parts of lots of plants are poisonous to cats. What is it about lilies that makes them so dangerous? Do cats preferentially eat them or something?

AlanThePig · 16/07/2021 11:23

@SilverOak

Does this help from the RHS

The recently-introduced 'tree lilies' are monster Orientals and they really are dramatic. Carrying dozens of 15-20cm flowers on stems up to 2.5m tall, if you’re looking for impact look no further. They persist well from year to year and their stems are so stout that they rarely need support

These would grow wonderfully in my garden, might stick a few bulbs in and see what happens. No close neighbours or cats to annoy.

Cattitudes · 16/07/2021 11:20

@Whoarethewho

I plant them to keep away cats. But not tree Lilly's on the boundary of another garden.
As far as I know they do nothing to deter cats but all parts of them are poisonous to cats.
Soubriquet · 16/07/2021 11:17

I love lillies. My favourite kind are oriental/stargazer lilies and tiger lilies.

But I appreciate they can be strong. My dh buys them occasionally and only having the one bunch in the house can spread the smell. I usually cut the pollen off as I have a cat. She doesn’t chew the leaves so it’s just the pollen I have to worry about.

But damn that’s a lot of lillies

Porcupineintherough · 16/07/2021 11:15

@Warmduscher any cat owner who is worried about the safety of their cat can take steps to keep them in their own property. If they care so little they fail to do this, why should I mind? Do all our gardens have to be safe for all our beighbours children and pets now, in case they fancy a wander?

Mumteedum · 16/07/2021 11:14

@Tunnocksmallow

I totally sympathise OP. I love lilies, but lilies do not love me. I get a migraine and an instant severe asthma attack. I only have to walk past a bouquet in a supermarket and I’m needing to reach for my inhaler. But ya know, I’ll pop an antihistamine and stop being selfish.
Ok great 🌟 well done.

I'll try a be a better human and not moan on anonymous forums while continuing to be a very nice neighbour. Halo

I'd forgotten aibu is a bit bonkers Grin

OP posts:
Tunnocksmallow · 16/07/2021 11:10

I totally sympathise OP.
I love lilies, but lilies do not love me.
I get a migraine and an instant severe asthma attack. I only have to walk past a bouquet in a supermarket and I’m needing to reach for my inhaler.

But ya know, I’ll pop an antihistamine and stop being selfish.

Ironmanrocks · 16/07/2021 11:07

@NeverDropYourMoonCup

You misunderstand....I bought bulbs/plants/seeds and stuff. They just don't grow for me for whatever reason! Slugs admittedly being one of the reasons!

Mumteedum · 16/07/2021 11:02

It's not something an antihistamine will solve unfortunately. It's just the smell is so strong. It's not hayfever like allergy with itchy eyes. My asthma gets triggered by really strong perfumes too sometimes. I think lillies cause migraines in some people too.

Yes ..ok.. guilty for moaning before speaking to him I did just want a moan to be honest as I'm not sure whether I could broach it without upsetting him.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMoonCup · 16/07/2021 10:59

@SilverOak

Tree Lillies can Nonsense. Each plant in that photo has about 10 flowers at most. Certainly not 80.

I will not avoid plants I like because they might be poisonous to cats, sorry. I don't have cats, if you want your cat to be safe keep it home.
I’m afraid I agree. There are many things in my garden that would be dangerous to a trespassing cat. Such as lilies, mousetraps, chemicals that I feed the plants with, and my dogs. Other people need to keep their animals off my property.

30 per bulb/plant, Thompson and Morgan sell them in packs of three bulbs or larger 'collections'. If you look them up, their write up is very clear about the number of flowers per plant. It's also a reason why they are used in bouquets, as they are prolific flowerers and people think they're very expensive.

This seems such a peculiar hill for you to choose to die on.

Mumteedum · 16/07/2021 10:58

@SirGawain? Nope. Not guilty. I'm quiet and helpful and lovely thanks. Just venting on here because the smell is making me poorly. Haven't been mean or difficult in any way!

OP posts:
SirGawain · 16/07/2021 10:56

Are you the neighbour from hell?

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 16/07/2021 10:55

@Ironmanrocks

I'm just bloody jealous. I would do anything for pretty flowers in my garden - spent a fortune. Dahlias didnt come up. Lilies, lupins eaten by slugs. Lily of the valley and gladioli only has leaves. How does he get GIANT lilies????? 😭
Buys the thirty quid for 18 bulbs from Thompson and Morgan, then shoves them into pots, I would imagine.
pussycatlickinglollyices · 16/07/2021 10:53

I hate lilies.
Every time I am bought them, as soon as I get home, I carry them around the house rather than through it and straight to the garden waste bin.
NDN proudly presented us some as a thank-you and as soon as she left they had to go too.
I've 2 indoor only cats and refuse to pretend to be grateful for something really toxic for them to nibble.