Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why SOME women wait around for a man to propose to them

111 replies

Flipfloppingaround · 15/07/2021 17:32

It comes up time and time again on MN.
Woman wants to get married but is waiting for The Proposal from The Man.

Surely, once you've been dating long enough to know he's The One, the pair of you have conversations about your future and whether you want to get married or not and you proceed from there, rather than waiting for him to get down on one knee and whip out a ring?

OP posts:
Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 15/07/2021 21:44

YANBU

The “it’s traditional” thing is a bit weird when they are living with someone. That’s not traditional yet they expect the man to be bothered with tradition. Bizarre really.

LolaSmiles · 15/07/2021 21:40

But many people on here are suggesting that if a man hasnt proposed then he isnt that invested?
If he knows his partner wants to be married and is kicking the issue into the long grass, won't get married, but also won't come out and say he doesn't want to marry her (because it means the end of home conforts) then he isn't that interested.

There's an awful lot of men out there who are quick to move in and happy to have children with women, happy to encourage their partner to go part time/be a SAHP, but when it comes to marriage and making sure that their partner's contribution to the household is valued and their partner is protected legally they have cold feet, declare nobody needs a party to show they love each other, or more amusingly become selectively traditional and need enough money for a big white do, the right ring, the right time.

If two adults are happy remaining unmarried then they can 100% have a happy, committed religion that's fulfilling for both of them. It's totally different to the situations the OP is referring to though.

HarrisMcCoo · 15/07/2021 21:23

Went shopping for an engagement ring. Got married at registry office a few months later.

HarrisMcCoo · 15/07/2021 21:23

I didn't wait. I made it clear I wanted marriage so we went shopping for an enga

therocinante · 15/07/2021 21:15

@Bluntness100

I think in reality most of them have had the conversation in some way, thr man knows she wishes to marry, deep down she knows he doesn’t, but because he didn’t spell it out, so she keeps waiting.

I don’t get some of these comments, you do have a conversation but this doesn’t mean there is no proposal. My husband and I discussed marriage, we both agreed that’s what we wanted, we decided to buy our house first, he proposed, it was a surprise, yes, but not in thr way I had no idea he wanted to marry me, but a surprise as I’d no idea he was planning to do it at that time.

That makes sense (and is lovely!) - I think my feelings about it are that it seems like, and is made to seem like by the kind of people OP is talking about, as though it's actually asking the question. When it's not, or I don't think it should be - if my DH had proposed to me out of the blue before we'd discussed marriage I'd have been taken aback and a bit annoyed that he effectively used a 'cute romantic' moment to have an important conversation about the future of our lives together. So really, if he had proposed after we'd had those conversations, it'd have felt like a staged moment because it's what you're 'supposed' to do and I would have hated the idea that he was performing 'man asks woman because society says that's how it should be'.

But I'm a cynic and hate anything traditionally romantic and I really wanted us to get married on holiday and not tell anyone so nobody should really listen to me Grin

DrSbaitso · 15/07/2021 20:46

Just my observation, but every relationship I've seen where the woman had to be the one to move it along rather than the man indicating his keenness to commit himself, has been a relationship I wouldn't want. The guy always seems unengaged and only there for the ride, and is usually useless as a father.

IsThePopeCatholic · 15/07/2021 20:44

@EmergencyHydrangea

Because patriarchy is still insidious and toxic
Yes. It’s about time women became more proactive.
PattyPan · 15/07/2021 20:41

@Borisjohnsonshairbrush fortunately we don’t get that question too often, probably because of the PhD thing! But yes it’s such a stupid question, if a couple knew when they were getting married presumably they would have announced the wedding date 😂

@PearlNextDoor I definitely agree society allows men to grow up more slowly than women, but there is an actual biological basis as well - men’s brains take longer to finish developing, and they finish puberty later. My DP still has the metabolism of a lanky teenager! Apparently his dad was the same and filled out when he hit his 30s. It’s actually been quite amusing watching all my male friends suddenly gaining weight over the past couple of years after them being able to eat whatever they wanted when we were at uni and staying skinny while I gained half a stone from licking an envelope Grin

ViciousJackdaw · 15/07/2021 20:30

[quote PlanetTeaTime]@Borisjohnsonshairbrush

I love your handle [/quote]
I had no idea there even was such a thing!

Bluntness100 · 15/07/2021 20:13

I think in reality most of them have had the conversation in some way, thr man knows she wishes to marry, deep down she knows he doesn’t, but because he didn’t spell it out, so she keeps waiting.

I don’t get some of these comments, you do have a conversation but this doesn’t mean there is no proposal. My husband and I discussed marriage, we both agreed that’s what we wanted, we decided to buy our house first, he proposed, it was a surprise, yes, but not in thr way I had no idea he wanted to marry me, but a surprise as I’d no idea he was planning to do it at that time.

LolaSmiles · 15/07/2021 20:12

YANBU. In can't imagine being in a healthy relationship where the couple didn't discuss their future.

My DH proposed to me but we had spoken about our future and our desire to be together and have children with each other, so it was more sumbolic/romantic than anything. We essentially were 'engaged' before that
Same here. We knew we were on the same page and same time frames before he proposed so it was a nice symbolic gesture, but not entirely out of the blue.

I'd not be happy being in a relationship where ether we couldn't openly discuss our plans, or where each time I tried the man kicked everything into the long grass with empty words.

PearlNextDoor · 15/07/2021 20:10

I dont know if men "mature more slowly", they simply have the options to put off commitment and put off parenthood so they can and they do. It creates a power inbalance if the woman doesnt really know that she's better off single than being a man's starter relationship

Borisjohnsonshairbrush · 15/07/2021 20:06

@PattyPan But like me don't you hate the whole "oooh but when are you getting married remarks?

It's so boring.

Zlk02 · 15/07/2021 19:56

Why would you need to “understand” though, OP.

Different things are important to different people. Call me old-fashioned, but if a man can’t even be bothered to ask me to marry him in a meaningful way, then he’s not the one for me. My husband proposed on some cliffs by the sea. He had chosen the ring and got down on one knee and said some beautiful things.. He had also asked my dad. To this day, I’m glad he made the effort. Nothing wrong with a bit of romance and effort in life. Start as you mean to go on Grin 20 years later and I can still picture it in my mind. I’m glad we didn’t “sit down and have a mutual discussion” or whatever. So boring. We can do that over other things, like taking out a mortgage.

PattyPan · 15/07/2021 19:21

I’m waiting for my DP to propose to me. We have discussed marriage and know that we want to marry each other. We’ve been together for 5 years. However, we are young and I am a year older than DP - 26 and 25. I am ready and have been working for a couple of years so feel like an adult. Men mature more slowly, he is already younger, and he is still finishing his PhD and establishing his career so doesn’t feel ready/like a proper adult who can get married. He’ll propose when he is ready and he knows I’ll say yes. I don’t see a problem with that tbh. If he takes another 5 years that would be taking the piss a bit but at the moment waiting makes sense.

baldafrique · 15/07/2021 18:53

Yeah that must suck. I think people do need to be super upfront if marriage isnt really their thing (or at least not imply that it might be their thing!) so at least the other person knows what to expect and can decide how much of a deal breaker it is for them.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 15/07/2021 18:53

@MrsTophamHat

As I saod above though, if both partners do not wish to get married that is fine for them. Presumably it has been discussed and agreed upon quite happily.

The issue is when one person very much does want to get married, but waits around for their partner to do the asking. That does suggest discord

Exactly. This thread isn't about people who are happy to not marry. This is about women who are upswt and keep waiting while getting more upset. Which is ridiculous. Not wanting to marry? Not ridiculous

Obviously

therocinante · 15/07/2021 18:53

And in the context of the OP, my point still stands - I agree. If you've been with someone years and you're waiting around wondering if they're going to propose or not, why? Either you've agreed you would both like to get married (cool, book it then), one or both of you doesn't (either fine, a deal breaker, or one of you compromises) or you haven't had the conversation (in which case why are you expecting a proposal??).

I think people want life to be romantic and fairytale all the time and I completely understand that - life is hard, I understand wanting to be swept off your feet and live the stupid rom-com dream we've been sold. But marriage is a legal contract. You should be talking about it before you decide to do it, not waiting around hoping they'll show a sign of commitment that you've decided is coming. And if you have talked about it and they're prevaricating then it's on you to decide whether you can live with that or not instead of just hoping they'll suddenly become Price Charming and get down on one knee having not previously shown signs of wanting to get married.

MrsTophamHat · 15/07/2021 18:51

As I saod above though, if both partners do not wish to get married that is fine for them. Presumably it has been discussed and agreed upon quite happily.

The issue is when one person very much does want to get married, but waits around for their partner to do the asking. That does suggest discord

WorraLiberty · 15/07/2021 18:51

@RiverSkater

They want a romantic proposal story to tell everybody about?

It's been conditioned in women, blame our history, culture. Mills and Boon.

It's been conditioned in women, blame our history, culture. Mills and Boon.

Nah, I'm not buying that either.

It still means women and picking and choosing the parts of history and culture that suit them.

And that's their choice but it very often puts them in a dodgy position if they've chosen children first.

baldafrique · 15/07/2021 18:48

I guess some people see having children and buying a house together as a bigger commitment, I'm not sure.

MrsTophamHat · 15/07/2021 18:47

@baldafrique

Your partner can still want to spend the rest of their life with you yet not want to be married, surely?
Maybe but I don't know why you wouldn't.

I completely get why people might not want the fuss of a wedding as such, but a marriage is about more than one day and I would question why someone would not want to take that step, but yet would be happy for me to have his children, buy a house with him.

therocinante · 15/07/2021 18:46

@onlyhereforthecake

well, if a man can't even be bothered to make the effort to propose, there's not much hope for the rest of the relationship is it?

Forcing the hand of someone is not really the way to start a marriage.

I dunno, I judged the potential of my future marriage with DH on whether he was caring and kind and loving in our day-to-day life, if he stepped up when I needed it, if we were compatible in outlook and sex drive and politics and humour, whether he was there when the shit hit the fan and how he dealt with it.

Not whether or not he was willing to fake-ask me to marry him in a weird charade when he already knew the answer because we'd discussed marriage like adults.

If you want a proposal, that is fine - I can't say I understand it but it's your decision. But let's not pretend unwillingness to stage 'a proposal' is an indicator of your marriage's chances.

PlanetTeaTime · 15/07/2021 18:45

@Borisjohnsonshairbrush

I love your handle

RiverSkater · 15/07/2021 18:45

They want a romantic proposal story to tell everybody about?

It's been conditioned in women, blame our history, culture. Mills and Boon.