Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Picking up children from nursery at finish time

108 replies

Crowtooyo · 15/07/2021 14:54

I saw a video on tik tok. It's a jokey account from a lady who works in a nursery (or used to... can't quite remember!)
Anyway, she made a video about parents turning up in the car park but then sitting there for 45 mins to collect their child on the dot at 6pm and then expecting a 10 minute handover.
I wondered what people's opinions are on this?

I'll start by saying I work in childcare and am paid X- X and I feel that if a parent wants a full blown handover then they need to have that within the time frame that they pay for.

I am not bothered about parents waiting outside, they probably have work calls, etc... to catch up on. And they are paying for their child to be in the nursery. So that isn't the question.

The question is specifically about whether the parent should collect at closing time and then expect a 10-15 min handover.

Voting:

YABU - a handover should not be paid for
YANBU - parent should collect within time frame and handover included in that.

I can link the tik tok if people want. Not sure whether allowed?

OP posts:
Mulhollandmagoo · 15/07/2021 16:39

Yeah, I agree with the majority here YANBU. If I had anything I would need to chat about I would be there early, people expect way too much from nursery staff. I don't use a nursery I use a childminder and as much as I like to have a (usually non child related) chinwag my daughter is spent by the time I collect her at 5:30 so I think its unfair in that respect too, we're straight out, straight in the car and straight home.

Ozanj · 15/07/2021 16:34

I am a nursery practitioner. We have a policy that we only provide handovers for children picked up before 17:45. Those picked up afterwards will have to wait until the following morning or another day if they want to catch up. It’s harsh but we would lose staff if we insisted nobody could leave until 6pm.

switswoo81 · 15/07/2021 16:31

No handovers in our crèche since covid . Every point of info is on the app .
Cannot image sitting in the car outside though, I pay for a full day till 6 but collect at 2:45.

EssentialHummus · 15/07/2021 16:29

Why on earth would you need a five minute handover as a routine thing? I get that on very, very, very, very rare occasions you might need that long, but not often. Handover for DD is typically 'here's DD, she had a lovely day didn't you DD? Bye now!'

This! DD has the world’s most talkative key worker and I can never get a word in even to indicate that I don’t need the info / that she gave the same info to DH when he dropped her off and he already told me. She’s lovely and I stand there being gently lulled by her sing-song Welsh accent but really when another lady comes out and says “Here you go LittleHummus, there’s your mum” I breath a bit of a sigh of relief. This past Monday I got 4-5 minutes about how she was planning to make the kids’ jelly for the end of term party Confused.

HumunaHey · 15/07/2021 16:27

@wineandcheeseplease

I work in childcare and we have had parents rock up at 6pm then moan when they don't get given a proper handover. It's crazy.
Aside from parents who just sit in the car, there are parents who can just about get to nursery for closing time (e.g.6pm). If a nursery advertises childcare available until 6pm, they should honour that. Thats part of the reason some parents choose a certain nursery - the hours can accommodate tgeir needs. Once the parent has arrived, the nursery shouldn't be responsible for the child's welfare. So a few mins handover (5min max) should be expected.

It's not the parents to blame imo, it's the nursery management. A bit daft to advertise childcare hours 7-6pm (for e.g) and have staff finish work at 6. That's cutting corners and being cheap.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 15/07/2021 16:24

I'm a childminder and I get this regularly. Not that people sit outside the house, but they turn up at exactly the time of hand over, and a lot of them come slightly later, and then want to hang around chatting g letting the kids at around while they watch, taking them to the toilet (even although I do that before I get them ready to leave. Some let them take sides and jackets back off and then spend 10 mins just trying tk get them back on.

Kanaloa · 15/07/2021 16:23

At lots of nurseries, there isn’t a buffer time built in. From 5.30 one member of staff will be reading stories/doing handover/wrangling kids while the others do closing paperwork, clean and try to get sorted to get out the door as close after 6 as possible, as their shift ends at 6pm.

Enwi · 15/07/2021 16:23

I’m a childminder and whilst it doesn’t bother me at all if parents decide to sit outside and do other things until it’s time to collect their child, it does annoy me that quite a few of my parents will always drop their child a couple of minutes early and then pick up a couple of minutes late, despite being sat in the car for the last 15 minutes. It’s only a couple of minutes so not really a lot I can say without appearing rude, and I always want to do a good handover regardless of what time a child is collected, but it does annoy me.

I’m super grateful to my daughter’s preschool staff and if I can do anything to make their lives easier I will. For me, I know my child going home that little bit earlier than that really busy pick up time is going to help their day a little bit, so I would always go and get her if I didn’t have something I absolutely needed to do in the car. But I do understand not everyone has that mentality towards their childcare provider.

Chubbychubkins · 15/07/2021 16:21

@SilverOak

Why would you sit in the car park for 45 minutes? Why not just collect your child and go home?
I do it sometimes. I leave work on time so I don't get stuck in traffic and risk being late but then if I get there early I may respond to a few emails or make some work calls. It's much easier pre-collection than once we get home.

I don't wait until 6pm though. Or expect a handover of any description unless it's particularly noteworthy.

Mansplainee · 15/07/2021 16:21

Is it usually the parents asking for or expecting a lengthy handover though? IME it’s the nursery that does that. I’m not sure I really need to stand every day and listen to a detailed description of my child’s bowel movements.

sotiredofthislonelylife · 15/07/2021 16:21

@UrAWizHarry

Yeah, that's really dickish, but then I don't understand why parents want to spend 15 minutes hearing the tedious details of the kid's day. If the kid is still alive and relatively unscathed that's good enough for me.
🤣🤣🤣
Marmite27 · 15/07/2021 16:20

@cindarellasbelly

In our creche, you pick up at x time, then staff do tidy up after. So if one staff member is spending five minutes saying 'they actually didn't sleep/eat their food today' its not a big thing. They've currently shortened their times to enable 'covid deep cleaning' and so with working hours I am just there five minutes before pick up. I don't think I've ever had a 10-15 minute handover, the wriggly toddler wouldn't allow it, but I think its a bit disingenuous to act like at 6pm everyone goes home. There will be a buffer time built in. But yes, if someone wants a discussion more than the basics I think they should be told to make an appointment.
Yours sounds fab!
HumunaHey · 15/07/2021 16:20

I personally think it's silly for a nursery to close at 6pm if staff are only paid until 6pm. I can understand parents collecting at 6pm if that's what they pay for.

It's not really on for parents to want a 15min handover though! What is there to even say that would last 15mins! I assume the tiktoker is exaggerating.

Marmite27 · 15/07/2021 16:19

Look at from the flip side. The kids that are picked up at closing time, in my experience aren’t allowed to play with the toys as ‘they’re set up for tomorrow’, not allowed to make a mess because ‘it has to be tidy for tomorrow’ and are pretty much sat there with their coats and bags while the staff watch the clock down to pick up time.

IMO the last collection time shouldn’t be closing time. There should be at least 15 minutes after last pick up to tidy up, and sort out. The hand over would be possible in that time.

BabyFartsDoStink · 15/07/2021 16:19

I really just want to know if he's had a poo or not (he's somewhat infrequent) and do they need anything from me.

wineandcheeseplease · 15/07/2021 16:18

I work in childcare and we have had parents rock up at 6pm then moan when they don't get given a proper handover. It's crazy.

20viona · 15/07/2021 16:16

That's crazy. I turn up get my kid and get a 2 minute handover at best. That's fine by me I don't need a verse on what she's done, as long as she's alive and fed that pretty much means she's had a great day.

Kokosrieksts · 15/07/2021 16:15

I quite often sit in the car park, because I can get stuff done without being disturbed, but also don’t have to worry about being late for picking up my child.
I think 6 pm is closing time though so staff should not be expected to stay after.

Lunde · 15/07/2021 16:13

The nursery that my children attended had the policy that you had to be out of the door (or on your way) at collection time. So if you wanted a handover, chat or to look in the spare clothing bag etc - you needed to arrive earlier to account for this,

Kanaloa · 15/07/2021 16:08

And it’s rarely the odd latecomer, it’s usually the same parents who show up at 6pm on the dot and want to have a chat.

cindarellasbelly · 15/07/2021 16:07

In our creche, you pick up at x time, then staff do tidy up after. So if one staff member is spending five minutes saying 'they actually didn't sleep/eat their food today' its not a big thing. They've currently shortened their times to enable 'covid deep cleaning' and so with working hours I am just there five minutes before pick up. I don't think I've ever had a 10-15 minute handover, the wriggly toddler wouldn't allow it, but I think its a bit disingenuous to act like at 6pm everyone goes home. There will be a buffer time built in. But yes, if someone wants a discussion more than the basics I think they should be told to make an appointment.

Kanaloa · 15/07/2021 16:07

You absolutely shouldn’t expect a handover if you show up after the end of your child’s session. Parents often used to say if I had to tell them they had a late charge ‘but I pay until six!’ Yes, and that handover is part of what you pay for and should be done before six. People don’t expect to be served in a shop after it’s shut, or to stay chatting to the doctor after their appointment slot so I don’t know why they think nurseries want to be chatting to them after closing time. It’s very annoying as in many nurseries the staff shifts are ridiculous, so you might be on shift from 9am-6pm but the nursery closes at 6pm. Of course you’re never going to get out on time.

BabyFartsDoStink · 15/07/2021 16:05

Ours has that as a rule. You want a detailed handover, you allow time for it.

Radio4ordie · 15/07/2021 16:02

If staff are only paid until 6pm then the nursery isn’t open until 6pm. It’s open until 5.30pm and then 5.30-6pm is shut down time when you ensure customers are out of the building and everything is tidied up.
I really think it’s a communication/CF thing for day care nurseries to claim to be open to 6pm but not pay staff beyond that. Very unfair to staff as they will no doubt often need to stay later, or to parents if staff get annoyed with them for picking up at pick up time.

jwilf · 15/07/2021 15:59

I voted YANBU. If parents are sitting in the car for 45 minutes then expecting a 10 minute handover after closing time, yes they are being unreasonable.

If they are also sitting in their car for 45 minutes with the engine running right outside a kids nursery, they are being unreasonable as well as thoughtless, selfish twats who are harming kids health.

Sorry, just can't stand idling drivers and I see them a lot when picking up DS. Just had to get that off my chest.