Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Picking up children from nursery at finish time

108 replies

Crowtooyo · 15/07/2021 14:54

I saw a video on tik tok. It's a jokey account from a lady who works in a nursery (or used to... can't quite remember!)
Anyway, she made a video about parents turning up in the car park but then sitting there for 45 mins to collect their child on the dot at 6pm and then expecting a 10 minute handover.
I wondered what people's opinions are on this?

I'll start by saying I work in childcare and am paid X- X and I feel that if a parent wants a full blown handover then they need to have that within the time frame that they pay for.

I am not bothered about parents waiting outside, they probably have work calls, etc... to catch up on. And they are paying for their child to be in the nursery. So that isn't the question.

The question is specifically about whether the parent should collect at closing time and then expect a 10-15 min handover.

Voting:

YABU - a handover should not be paid for
YANBU - parent should collect within time frame and handover included in that.

I can link the tik tok if people want. Not sure whether allowed?

OP posts:
Tossblanket · 15/07/2021 19:08

15 minute handover what more need to be said other than they ate a banana and had a shit?

3Britnee · 15/07/2021 18:42

Childcare should be til 6. Staff should be paid til 6.30. If handover shouldn't be done on staff time (after 6), the close down shouldn't be done on parents time (before 6).

Crowtooyo · 15/07/2021 18:41

@BusyLizzie61

I don't think that the parents are being unreasonable. It's an employer issue imo, if they only pay until 6pm. That's the issue that needs challenging. Tesco would still be expected to pay their staff for serving the customers in their store post 10pm....
We didn't say the staff are only paid until 6pm. But the nursery CLOSES at 6pm. So there shouldn't be any children left on site.

No I wouldn't expect staff to serve me after 10pm if the shop closed at 10pm.

OP posts:
PurpleMustang · 15/07/2021 18:39

I dont think its been mentioned yet (mine brought in late fines as parents were taking the piss turning up late) but the manager had to explain they are only insured to be open till 6pm, so need the kids off site. All these parents will get a shock when kids start school as they are there the parent is spotted and kid is released, no cost handover at all.

BoredatHome321 · 15/07/2021 18:33

@BusyLizzie61

It's not unreasonable to expect feedback on your child's day!
No, but it is after the nursery is closed, if you want one, get there earlier.
BusyLizzie61 · 15/07/2021 18:28

It's not unreasonable to expect feedback on your child's day!

BusyLizzie61 · 15/07/2021 18:27

I don't think that the parents are being unreasonable. It's an employer issue imo, if they only pay until 6pm. That's the issue that needs challenging. Tesco would still be expected to pay their staff for serving the customers in their store post 10pm....

Crowtooyo · 15/07/2021 18:25

@Radio4ordie

If staff are only paid until 6pm then the nursery isn’t open until 6pm. It’s open until 5.30pm and then 5.30-6pm is shut down time when you ensure customers are out of the building and everything is tidied up. I really think it’s a communication/CF thing for day care nurseries to claim to be open to 6pm but not pay staff beyond that. Very unfair to staff as they will no doubt often need to stay later, or to parents if staff get annoyed with them for picking up at pick up time.
But I'm not talking about when the staff are paid to? We are discussing the fact that the nursery closes at 6pm so there should be noone other than staff left in the building after 6pm.

The nurseries may well be paying their staff until 6:15 pm, that doesn't mean parents should be staying there past 6pm..

OP posts:
Crowtooyo · 15/07/2021 18:16

@want2bemum

If nursery closes at 6 then they should have last pick up at 5.45.

Or they have last pick up at 6 and close at 6.15.

It's not rocket science!

Exactly. This is the point. The nursery CLOSES at 6pm. Whether or not the staff are paid til 6:15pm. Parents can't expect a 10 minute handover after 6pm because 6pm is the cut off.
OP posts:
Crowtooyo · 15/07/2021 18:14

@strawberrydonuts

If the child finishes at 6pm and the staff also finish at 6pm, that doesn't seem like great management and it's going to cause confusion. Obviously, most parents are going to want to hear how their child got on that day.

Perhaps the nursery need to account for it in their hourly cost that staff will need to be there for a 10 minute handover.

No one should be working for free but the nursery should know how to manage this, surely it's a very common occurence.

I think you're missing the point. It isn't about the nursery managing the time. It's parents expecting a 10 minute handover at 6pm. The point is, kids should be gone at 6pm. The staff are probably paid until 6:15. Therefore the cut off time for kids being out is 6.
OP posts:
MrsTophamHat · 15/07/2021 18:12

I don't get handovers.

Have they had a good day?
Yes, no problems.
Great- bye!

Absolutely do get sitting in the car though. You could do the food shop on your phone or renew your phone contract sitting in the car these days. Why not take some quiet time for a bit of life admin before the dinner - bath - bed routine starts?

EllaMayGrace · 15/07/2021 17:40

@UrAWizHarry

Yeah, that's really dickish, but then I don't understand why parents want to spend 15 minutes hearing the tedious details of the kid's day. If the kid is still alive and relatively unscathed that's good enough for me.
I used to be a nursery teacher and this made it laugh out loud! Grin

We had 52 children, 5 members of staff, two big rooms, about 15 different areas within these rooms + huge outside area and parents would ask me how much their child had to drink that day. Fruit and water was available at all time so it was down to them to drink and snack when they needed it - I couldn’t possibly track the water intake of 52 children!

glitterelf · 15/07/2021 17:33

I'm a childminder and agree with the other minder that it's the dropping early that bothers me the most. Late pick ups I ask that parents notify me so that I know they are ok and all hand overs are done at the front door because I've seen with other minders the struggles of getting parents and children to leave.
IMO staff should be paid till 6.15 but pick ups for 6 so that staff are covered pay wise.

want2bemum · 15/07/2021 17:31

If nursery closes at 6 then they should have last pick up at 5.45.

Or they have last pick up at 6 and close at 6.15.

It's not rocket science!

strawberrydonuts · 15/07/2021 17:29

If the child finishes at 6pm and the staff also finish at 6pm, that doesn't seem like great management and it's going to cause confusion. Obviously, most parents are going to want to hear how their child got on that day.

Perhaps the nursery need to account for it in their hourly cost that staff will need to be there for a 10 minute handover.

No one should be working for free but the nursery should know how to manage this, surely it's a very common occurence.

SonicStars · 15/07/2021 17:23

No wonder parents find adjusting to school hard if they're used to 15 mins of bowel movement talk at the end of each day.

I think with my first it was 5 weeks before I spoke to the teacher. (Of course with number 2 she came out for a chat with "Satan's mummy" every night. Wasn't I lucky). I appreciate with kids that don't talk communication is more important but notable points can be conveyed in the time it takes the child to run and hug parent unless there's been a serious incident.

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 15/07/2021 17:19

Play around, not at around, and shoes off, not sides 🙄 bloody phone!

Picklesbaby · 15/07/2021 17:16

On the day’s I finish work at 5.30 i literally rush there and get ds as quick as I can ( 5.45 for 6pm close )and I still feel like need to apologise for being so late! , I don’t hang around &just ask his has all his info on a daily diary sheet to save time at handover .
On my 4.30 finish days I’m always last min for dd (after school club that closes at 5) but theres always a que anyway and its generally just a grab and run🤣

wineandcheeseplease · 15/07/2021 17:14

@HumunaHey

It's not cheap or cutting corners, ther has to be a cut off somewhere. We are open til 6pm. If you come at 6pm that's fine, collect your kid and go. But why should staff stay longer for handover. I mean.. we do of course, but we shouldn't have to.

Songoftheseas · 15/07/2021 17:14

It was a revelation when my DD moved from a private preschool to a school nursery. At preschool it became a competitive sport to collect children up to 30 minutes before the official finishing time. I found it hilarious. I would often get there early just because I am always early for everything, but then wait until the allocated finish time to go in. I didn’t love my daughter any less but as far as I was concerned I was paying through my nose for her to attend and I relished the bit of extra time to catch up with emails etc as she was very full on as soon as she came home.

At school nursery the doors literally wouldn’t open until bang on official finish time, so there was no competition between parents over who collected the earliest.

Regarding handovers, I would never expect more than a minute covering what sort of day she had - good/bad - and what she got up to. It’s interesting to note that her preschool keyworker told me that I was one of literally a handful of parents who would ask this and she admired the fact that I showed interest in what sort of day she had Confused

1forAll74 · 15/07/2021 16:50

Never heard of all this handover palaver, it must be very annoying for the staff.

igelkott2021 · 15/07/2021 16:49

Totally agree that if you close at 6pm that's when you close, not 15 minutes later.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 15/07/2021 16:45

My understanding is 6pm is the doors shut-I collect my child as close to 5pm as possible just because any later screws up our evening routine. But if I ran until 6pm I wouldn’t dream of chit chatting

Scubalubs87 · 15/07/2021 16:41

My nursery have always operated strict timings that I'm allowed to collect at. Currently, its 17:10 and I have to be at the door then but am not allowed to knock. At 17:10 the door opens (in theory - sometimes late) and that group of children are let out. So for those reasons I'm often sat in the car park for a while as I need to make sure I can get there through the traffic on time which I can't exactly time to the minute.

I actually think its poor wording/management from the nursery. Parents will, rightly or wrongly, interpret closing at 6 as they can collect at 6. The nursery should either be paying you to around 18:15 or making it very clear that last collection is 17:45 to allow for the handovers. I know the staff at my nursery are paid for around 30mins after last collection to factor in handovers and sorting rooms.

gogohm · 15/07/2021 16:41

My DD's nursery school fined $1 a minute late fees for the first 10 mins then $5 a minute thereafter. Still some were late. Staff did get overtime though, one family was notorious for being 30 mins plus late multiple times a month!