Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I wrong to be upset?

86 replies

GreenFlipFlop · 15/07/2021 11:55

Usually a lurker but had to seek some advice on this one because it’s been giving me a few restless nights. Sorry it’s a bit long.

It was my friend’s birthday so I popped over to drop a card. It was a doorstop visit, quick hello. She asked her 4YO son to come and say hello and he was playing so refused which didn’t bother me at all. Friend’s partner who I’ve not seen in around 5 years and I’ve never really gotten on with as he has historically treated her badly (she knows this so tends to keep us apart) came to the door to say hello which was fine. However, when son refused to say hello, he said ‘say hello otherwise 'GreenFlipFlop' will think you’re racist’ (I’m black). I was really taken aback by this as it was really random and I was a bit upset by it because it implied to me that black people think that everything and everyone is racist. I think my face changed and my friend sensed this but neither of us said anything and partner had walked away by then, I talked to her for a bit then said my goodbyes.

She text me 2 days later thanking me for card and normally I’m quite a non-confrontational person so don’t say anything however, this had been playing on my mind for 2 days and I was actually quite angry the more I thought about it because I thought it was a really inappropriate thing to say to a child and about me. I asked her what he meant by it and she apologised to me and said he gets really awkward when he hasn’t seen anyone for a while. She then forwarded me a message that was ‘supposedly’ typed by him apologising to me. I told her I accepted the apology, but basically that generally having a family that had felt the effects of racism, it wasn’t very nice and had upset me.

Friend understandably very upset by everything that happened and told me she had been crying since I sent the text as she was upset and didn’t think I’d want to be friends anymore. I said that wasn’t the case but I was just sick of holding these things in when they happened because its always me that gets upset and dwells on it and just wanted to make her aware.

Her mum later messaged me upset that I had called her daughter a racist and saying that neither of them were racist and that I had taken what was said the wrong way. Felt very victim blaming and I didn’t understand why her mum was getting involved when me and friend had had an amicable conversation between us. I forwarded mum last message sent to friend and she apologised that she had accused me. I accepted apology because cba with the drama and didn’t want to communicate with her any longer. However, I’m now left feeling like I tried to speak up for once about something that upset me and became the unreasonable one, like me being upset about what was said was less important than my friend being upset which is exactly why people don’t speak up about these things in the first place. Haven’t spoken to friend or mother since which was a couple of days ago. Feel very odd about the friendship now.

Did I make too big a deal of the partner’s comment?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nietzschethehiker · 16/07/2021 09:13

OP you didn't do anything wrong. I actually think you were remarkably understanding in how you dealt with it. He is a giant twat. Ergh I can't bear the " Fner Fner I'm going to say a tatty thing under the guise of a joke because I am so spineless I can't stand by my statements" at the best of times but when it's a racist statement it's bloody unacceptable.

Her mum getting involved is simply batshit. Ian my mother is batshit but even she would think getting involved would be insane and has done since I was a teenager.

I think you are very decent for wanting to be there for your friend who isn't blameless but you clearly think there is some psychological impact from her DP (sounds right certainly) I would just remove yourself from interacting with her DP and DM and if she forces the issue or brings it up I'd be honest that you still want to be her friend and support her but those two were off the table.

If she wails about that I'd be quite clear that it's a boundary there. Friend without interaction with those two or no friend at all. Up to her.

I mean personally I'd feel like going scorched earth on the bloody lot of them but I'm not known for my diplomacy so I am trying to counter my unreasonable instincts.

Either way you have no obligation to make racists feel better about themselves as I am sure you already know. You didn't do anything wrong. They did. This is absolutely 100% not on you in any way.

LittleMG · 16/07/2021 08:58

People don’t like being called out as racist and they try and argue they’re not but it just makes it worse! Hidden racism needs calling out. You were right, hopefully they’ll think next time!!!

Looubylou · 15/07/2021 21:09

He sounds like a racist dick having a dig. He also sounds awful for doing this on friends birthday - he would know she would be upset too. I'd still be friends but not visit, and avoid all contact with awful racist dickhead. 💐

QueenBee52 · 15/07/2021 20:25

Her behaviour is disgusting from beginning to end..

Rest assured @GreenFlipFlop you did absolutely nothing wrong... She on the other hand is obviously blocking you through sheer shame.. and knows it..

She has finally did the right thing.., she's now just someone you used to know ...

Onward and upward 🌸💕

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/07/2021 20:19

He's tried and succeeded in isolating her from you by being racist. And yes, as if you needed confirmation, he's a big racist.

She's not going to leave him so it's all for the best. Try not to lose sleep, the only arsehole here is him.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/07/2021 20:19

He's tried and succeeded in isolating her from you by being racist. And yes, as if you needed confirmation, he's a big racist.

She's not going to leave him so it's all for the best. Try not to lose sleep, the only arsehole here is him.

Notaroadrunner · 15/07/2021 20:18

Her loss! You really can do without peoole like them in your life.

GreenFlipFlop · 15/07/2021 20:08

@QueenBee52 Thank you ❤️ I'm still a bit upset tbh but I'm annoyed at myself for being upset cos I definitely don't think I did anything wrong? She's blocked me now on WhatsApp. Either as a defense mechanism cos she thinks I'm gonna end the friendship so wanted to get in first or because her partner and mum have convinced her that I overreacted and it's not worth sorting out 🤷🏾‍♀️ so I guess that's the end of that..

Also more annoyed that if this was the resulting situation anyway that I didn't go in harder, I was way too nice to her and her mum. My husband says at least there's no real comeback on me behaving badly which at least is something

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 15/07/2021 20:00

Her partners an arse but you know he is already. Sounds like he is trying to isolate your friend even more

Doublestar · 15/07/2021 19:58

*Think not the

Doublestar · 15/07/2021 19:58

Not rtft but I the dickhead dh said it because your friend has probably said something to him in the past like "greenflipflop will think you're racist if you don't say hello/be nice to her".
So he said it passive-aggressively to you using the son as a conduit - to let you know he's "on to you"- Absolute idiot.
And I can't get over your friend and her dm!! - who even does that? I don't know who comes off worse in this!

QueenBee52 · 15/07/2021 19:50

@GreenFlipFlop

how are you OP 🌸

JonahofArk · 15/07/2021 16:53

Honestly I'd call it a day with this friend. So he's moved on from abusing her to abusing her friends? You don't have to put up with his behaviour. And as for her mum-she wasn't there, she didn't witness the situation, and she needs to butt out.

ohthatbloodycat · 15/07/2021 16:47

What a pack of twats.

YADNBU Thanks

NoMoreCovidPlease · 15/07/2021 16:40

Just distance yourself away from her. You tried to help, she didn't want it. She's a grown woman and she can reach out if she ever leaves him. You should not put up with this kind of behaviour- both the racism and the unnecessary drama afterwards, they're all as bad as each other.

You've done nothing wrong and yet she has made you feel that way. She's made sure you'll never bring it up again in case you make her cry again

Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 16:28

If that man was my husband - well, he would stay my husband.
I would be mortified.

Piffle11 · 15/07/2021 16:27

I don’t think you made too much of a deal of it. In fact, I think conversations such as yours are often not had for fear of ‘rocking the boat’, or creating confrontation… And this is why a lot of casual racism goes unchecked. It’s time to start pulling people up about things like this. I completely understand why you didn’t tackle him: first of all, sometimes we think about these things in the hours and days after the meeting, rather than at the time. Should you have contacted him? Why? You don’t get on, he’s not a nice person, and he sounds like he doesn’t like you … Your friend contacted you, you told her what was on your mind, and she became upset. You can’t control how people react when you tell them how you feel. As long as you are not deliberately mean – which you weren’t – I really don’t think you have anything to feel bad about. Your friend is living with someone who is not good for her or her child, and yet she chooses to be there, knowing what he is like. The thing about crying and thinking you didn’t want to be friends is like something out of the playground. I would be angry that her mum decided to get involved and turn it back on you: It would be interesting to know whether your friend knew her mum was going to contact you. I would be taking a step back from this friendship.

WellLarDeDar · 15/07/2021 16:08

Such a weird thing for your friends partner to say! Sorry you had to put up with such a weird and awkward situation. Irks me as well when fully grown adults have their mums sending people messages on their behalf. I would steer clear of them from now on, you dont need that sort of drama in your life!

todaysdilemma · 15/07/2021 14:32

As a person of colour myself, I'm normally quite thick skinned with odd comments but this would have made me livid. The fact that skin colour has even popped into his head! Worse that he's teaching a small child to view you through the colour of your skin as well. He's the worst kind of racist, with insidious comments like this that have you questioning whether you overreacted. Racism isn't always abuse, it can also be being singled out pointedly as 'different' for no reason. It also shows a passive aggressive mocking of racism by him, by indicating a 4 year old could be deemed racist for just not talking to you.

I think your friend's reaction is genuine, but honestly, she cannot expect to keep friends with her partner and mother getting so involved. Don't cut her off as it seems she's in a bad position with this man, and may need help further down the line. But definitely take a lot of space and only meet her in situations where you won't come across him, or her mother. You are not her keeper.

Really sorry you had to deal with this, especially with a friend.

RowanAlong · 15/07/2021 14:16

You were right to speak up, he was rude and odd, and sounds like you handled it all very well. Your friend sounds like she cares very much what you think so yes stick to just seeing her (not him) and keep up the honesty!

Cloudninenine · 15/07/2021 14:15

He’s racist, and she is trying the classic trick of making herself into a victim - ‘you’ve made me feel bad about what happened which means you’re just as bad as me or worse’.

You did nothing wrong, and I’m sorry your friend wasn’t decent enough to stand up to her husband in front of you, or at least to acknowledge that what he did was shitty and wrong.

VodkaSlimline · 15/07/2021 14:14

YANBU. 4yos don't know what racism is, nor does it occur to them to treat people of other ethnicities differently unless someone puts the idea in their head. He is a racist and he's grooming his son to be the same. Distance yourself.

hardboiledeggs · 15/07/2021 14:09

You took it the way he intended for you to take it. He's a racist, nasty man. Her Mum is an enabler and your friend....well I can't decide if she is just as bad or being abused. That poor kid is going to grow up thinking saying stuff like that is ok.

Uramaki · 15/07/2021 14:07

which is what her mum messaged me saying she was so disappointed in me saying all this for because everyone else has 'turned their backs one by one') but you are in no way responsible for everyone else abandoning her.

NCJuly2021 · 15/07/2021 14:05

When it comes to racism, people make much more of a big deal at being told their behaviour is racist, than actually acknowledging the racism. It’s as if being called a racist is so much more offensive than being on the receiving end of racist behaviour. I find it really really odd.

That’s what seems to have happened here. Instead of acknowledging his behaviour was racist, it’s more how dare you accuse it of being racist. You did nothing wrong, he’s the racist twat, and your friend is indeed victim blaming to make it seem like you’re the difficult one.