Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a ridiculous reason for DS to be put into isolation?

211 replies

varskudd · 15/07/2021 11:13

DS(15) came home from school very annoyed yesterday, he said he was put into isolation for having a drawing on his hand/wrist. He got bored so he drew on his hand with a pen, but it's not just scribbles.

Apparently, he was told to go to the toilet and wash it off and he tried to but it wouldn't come off so they sent him to isolation. He tried to get it off at home and it wouldn't, I tried to this morning and it slightly faded but it's still there.

Aibu to think this is ridiculous?

OP posts:
blueberryporridge · 15/07/2021 16:22

*No child should ever be put in “isolation”. It is absolutely barbaric, and the total opposite of attachment and trauma-awareness.

Effective schools do not need this crazy zero-tolerance prison authority style discipline. It’s not even real discipline, it’s ruling by fear and shame.

How does having a hair bobble on your wrist cause low level disruption @elishaeva?*

This. No wonder there are such high levels of mental health problems in our children. What a miserable environment to have to spend so much of your time.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 16:16

@lazylinguist

I'm all for rule-following in schools, I just think that some schools need to be a lot more selective about how many and which rules they put in place.

The rules should be about things that are fundamental and important enough that they should be blindly followed. Because we don't want pupils acting on their own interpretations of things like bullying policies and safety rules. Most of us are quite happy for adults to be expected to 'blindly' obey laws, speed limits etc. Same applies to important rules in school.

Completely agree. That’s what I was attempting to say and you’ve summed it up perfectly.
StrawberryLipstickStateOfMind · 15/07/2021 16:13

Mine are 8 and 6 and I really worry about them going to secondary. Primary seems much as it did when I was at primary (I'm 33)- a few issues more to do with curriculum than anything else but I don't think my kids school is unreasonable with rules.

The things I read about secondaries on here really concern me- they sound more like prisons than schools. I know one person IRL who has taken their DD out of secondary school for this reason.

I know I'm going to be butting heads with them all the time if my kids are sent to isolation for stupid crap like putting a biscuit in their pocket or having a hair bobble on their wrist.

lazylinguist · 15/07/2021 16:11

Presumably the teacher would have preferred him to concentrate on the lesson than doodle.

He didn't doodle in the teacher's lesson. And it's perfectly possible to doodle and concentrate.

Terhou · 15/07/2021 16:04

Meh....I couldn't get het up about this. Presumably the teacher would have preferred him to concentrate on the lesson than doodle.

That would be very silly of the teacher. Many children need to doodle or fidget in order to concentrate - it's an indicator of sensory problems.

lazylinguist · 15/07/2021 16:02

I'm all for rule-following in schools, I just think that some schools need to be a lot more selective about how many and which rules they put in place.

The rules should be about things that are fundamental and important enough that they should be blindly followed. Because we don't want pupils acting on their own interpretations of things like bullying policies and safety rules. Most of us are quite happy for adults to be expected to 'blindly' obey laws, speed limits etc. Same applies to important rules in school.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 15:56

[quote SparrowNest]@Blossomtoes do you think there is a general trend in this direction, then? I’ve been worrying about it (I’ve got one toddler and another baby on the way) but wasn’t sure if it was just a lot of media coverage of a minority of schools.

Parents of secondary school age kids (and primary, actually) is this kind of strict enforcement of trivial or arbitrary rules the norm?[/quote]
I honestly don’t know. It’s a long time since our kids were in education. It does look that way to me. You only have to look at the approval for mindless rule following on MN to see that it must have been around for a while. I find it really worrying.

SparrowNest · 15/07/2021 15:50

@Blossomtoes do you think there is a general trend in this direction, then? I’ve been worrying about it (I’ve got one toddler and another baby on the way) but wasn’t sure if it was just a lot of media coverage of a minority of schools.

Parents of secondary school age kids (and primary, actually) is this kind of strict enforcement of trivial or arbitrary rules the norm?

georgarina · 15/07/2021 15:49

@Blossomtoes agree with this.

I think it's stupid how children are expected to unquestionably follow rules like this.

I have always been a more creative thinker and think better when I'm doing something like drawing on a paper - I still do it now. To be sent to isolation is both pointless and shaming a natural behaviour which might be how your DS learns best. Children aren't robots and to expect them to be is to teach them there's something 'wrong' with them for being individual.

I also work better when I'm standing up. As a child I was punished for this repeatedly at school. As an adult I have a standing desk. The shaming was unnecessary and only made me feel like there was something wrong with me for no reason.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 15:48

So presumably wouldn't sit in a lesson doing colouring in on their own hands

Why on earth not? What good reason lies behind such a trivial and pointless rule? I’m just glad I and my kids were out of the education system before it got like this.

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 15:40

@Blossomtoes

If it’s the rule then it’s the rule whether we agree or not

I just don’t get this. I brought mine up to obey rules if there’s a good reason for them and not to just mindlessly follow them if they made no sense. As a result they’re skilled in risk assessment and capable of independent thought.

So presumably wouldn't sit in a lesson doing colouring in on their own hands 😂
Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 15:38

If it’s the rule then it’s the rule whether we agree or not

I just don’t get this. I brought mine up to obey rules if there’s a good reason for them and not to just mindlessly follow them if they made no sense. As a result they’re skilled in risk assessment and capable of independent thought.

SparrowNest · 15/07/2021 15:34

@SeaPinks thanks

@GreyhoundG1rl the kind of school that would put a child in isolation because they scribbled on their hand. I think that’s unnecessarily harsh and it wouldn’t be my preference for my kids.

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 15:13

@SparrowNest

Has anyone got any advise on how to avoid sending my kids to a school like this, or is it increasingly that they’re all like this? That Birbalsingh woman makes my blood run cold.
School like what?
Soubriquet · 15/07/2021 15:13

@SpiderinaWingMirror

My nephew was put into isolation for not listening. My sister pointed out yet again that he was profoundly deaf and had been put at the back of the classroom. Similarly he get detention for not doing homework that was not written on the board, not on the learning system but the teacher told them to do whilst everyone was packing up at the end of the lesson. "Everyone else heard".
That would infuriate me and I would be pointing out that the school is being disablist but not properly accommodating your nephew. I’m deaf so this riles me up even more
SeaPinks · 15/07/2021 15:13

@SparrowNest

Has anyone got any advise on how to avoid sending my kids to a school like this, or is it increasingly that they’re all like this? That Birbalsingh woman makes my blood run cold.
You could look up the behaviour policy on the school website. Ours has got a detailed grid showing how it works.
SparrowNest · 15/07/2021 15:11

Has anyone got any advise on how to avoid sending my kids to a school like this, or is it increasingly that they’re all like this? That Birbalsingh woman makes my blood run cold.

Iquitit · 15/07/2021 15:08

@ASpoolofBlueThread

Use hand sanitiser to get it off! My DS draws on his hands all the time, drives me mad. Thankfully school don't care!
Was just going to suggest that! The alcohol gel that we use at work is great for removing pen from skin without too much irritation!

And yes, I think it's a bit ridiculous really.

LittleTiger007 · 15/07/2021 15:08

@ahoyshipmates

We were threatened with detention for drawing on our hands, so we didn't do it - and that was in the 1970's. I doubt that much has changed.
Exactly. If it’s the rule then it’s the rule whether we agree or not.
LittleTiger007 · 15/07/2021 15:06

This will be a matter for the individual school. If the rule there is no tattoos or other adornments on the skin then that’s the rule. He had an opportunity to wash it off… so he used a sharpie. Stupid and teenagers do do stupid things. Lesson learned. He won’t break the rules next time.

ASpoolofBlueThread · 15/07/2021 14:59

Use hand sanitiser to get it off! My DS draws on his hands all the time, drives me mad. Thankfully school don't care!

SpiderinaWingMirror · 15/07/2021 14:57

My nephew was put into isolation for not listening. My sister pointed out yet again that he was profoundly deaf and had been put at the back of the classroom.
Similarly he get detention for not doing homework that was not written on the board, not on the learning system but the teacher told them to do whilst everyone was packing up at the end of the lesson. "Everyone else heard".

Bumblenums1234 · 15/07/2021 14:52

Isolation for uniform infringements (which I think this is what this all boils down to really) are ridiculous.

QuestionableMouse · 15/07/2021 14:42

@NeverDropYourMoonCup

If it hasn't come off, doesn't that mean he's used permanent ink, like a sharpie or marker?

Even when I was at school, permanent markers were strictly forbidden and everywhere I've worked since, sharpies have also been banned, because they are the pens used for graffiti.

Perhaps the school rules at your DS's place are similar, so the isolation was for having a pen he isn't allowed to have, not the writing on his hand in itself?

www.amazon.co.uk/Pentel-Medium-Waterproof-Resistant-Document/dp/B000SHQWPM?tag=mumsnetforu03-21

There's pens like this that are permanent but not classed as permanent markers. I used these in my uni exams.

ahoyshipmates · 15/07/2021 14:42

We were threatened with detention for drawing on our hands, so we didn't do it - and that was in the 1970's. I doubt that much has changed.