Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a ridiculous reason for DS to be put into isolation?

211 replies

varskudd · 15/07/2021 11:13

DS(15) came home from school very annoyed yesterday, he said he was put into isolation for having a drawing on his hand/wrist. He got bored so he drew on his hand with a pen, but it's not just scribbles.

Apparently, he was told to go to the toilet and wash it off and he tried to but it wouldn't come off so they sent him to isolation. He tried to get it off at home and it wouldn't, I tried to this morning and it slightly faded but it's still there.

Aibu to think this is ridiculous?

OP posts:
Elisheva · 15/07/2021 20:02

Who pays for all these pens!! The kids don’t give them back.

Isolation means that Dave and his attitude does not have an impact on the other 32 students in the class.
However in a competent school there should always be a system in place to identify and support Dave. This is where the liaising with parents, pastoral support, behaviour interventions should kick in.
Clear expectations for behaviour, appropriate sanctions and appropriate support.

honeyytoast · 15/07/2021 19:59

Lots of teachers just don’t like anything being on visible parts of your body like doodles etc, even if done in own time. I remember once being told I’d get blood poisoning Hmm

lazylinguist · 15/07/2021 19:54

Next day Dave hasn’t got a pen, teacher has run out of spare pens because they never get returned.

The teacher needs to remember to ask the students for the pens back at the end of the lesson. Yes it's annoying when a student doesn't have a pen, but it's not the end of the world. Giving a pen takes no longer than issuing a punishment. A detention for repeatedly coming to school without any pen is fair enough. An isolation for not having a particular colour pen on one occasion- not acceptable.

MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 19:51

I take your point, Elisheva, I do. But sending Dave to isolation (where he still hasn’t got a pen?) and where nobody is going to talk to him isn’t going to teach him anything either. It isn’t going to fix the problem. It just means he’s not your problem any more and removes him from lessons where he might still engage in some learning. And tomorrow when he still hasn’t got a pen? Back to isolation? A week of isolation? A fixed term exclusion for “persistent breach of the rules”? And then what effect does this have on Dave’s life? Schools can fixed term exclude/suspend for 45 days. What is this doing to Dave? That’s my point. No I don’t have all the answers but isolation is not going to work.

SamusIsAGirl · 15/07/2021 19:49

I wonder what happens when people leave Michaela schools and actually have to do independent, critical thinking? Grades or not, that's then the wheels come off.

LakieLady · 15/07/2021 19:46

@SparrowNest

Has anyone got any advise on how to avoid sending my kids to a school like this, or is it increasingly that they’re all like this? That Birbalsingh woman makes my blood run cold.
It sounds bonkers to me, and that Michaela school sounds awful, in every respect bar exam results.

My school (indpendent single sex grammar) was very strict compared to most, but would be a beacon of liberalism compared to most of the schools I read about on here.

Mind you, it may have been something to do with it being the "premissive" '60s.

Elisheva · 15/07/2021 19:46

So what would you do about the missing pen?
I know it seems like I’m being disingenuous but in reality this takes up so much time in schools.
Dave arrives in class, he hasn’t got a pen. Teacher gives him pen
Next day Dave hasn’t got a pen, teacher has run out of spare pens because they never get returned.
Dave can’t do any work because he hasn’t got a pen.
Dave gets a detention
Mum won’t let Dave do the detention because he only forgot his pen.
Next lesson, Dave doesn’t have a pen. And nor does Barry, or Lucy.

SamusIsAGirl · 15/07/2021 19:42

These stupid rules seem to be about control and territorial pissing rather than aiding an educational environment.

I'm more sympathetic to parents who might not have give a shit about schools if it is an echo about how they were treated in school. You will not support a child's learning if this is how you think this is a good way to treat children and families.

I understand the need to be ready to function in employment but this to be less on how to learn and interact in a workplace and more about how to accept bad treatment and work-grooming to be a drone. As an autistic person this is a fast tract to meltdown city.

My current DS1's school is an academy and it seems to be one of the better ones that actually tries to be a school but I'm watching it like a hawk if they change. My child's education is an N = 1 experiment but I'll pull him out in a heartbeat if they pull any of these stunts.

MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 19:40

@Elisheva

Spare kit? In one of the schools I work in there are 1500 students. If even 5% of those don’t have a pen then that’s 75 pens per day. 75 phone calls home to find out why. 75 discussions to find out why they haven’t go a pen.
Now you’re deliberately being disingenuous. Obviously I wouldn’t be calling home to report a missing pen. Hmm

Does it have to be a teacher who calls home or follows up? Could it be a TA or support staff or key worker?

Elisheva · 15/07/2021 19:37

Spare kit?
In one of the schools I work in there are 1500 students. If even 5% of those don’t have a pen then that’s 75 pens per day.
75 phone calls home to find out why. 75 discussions to find out why they haven’t go a pen.

30degreesandmeltinghere · 15/07/2021 19:36

A fact to ponder on

Dc are put in isolation booths as a deterent to being disruptive and for defying the 'engage to learn' strategy... In isolation you aren't enforced to do any work at all. They booths aren't manned by specific teachers.. Sheets are given out and are optional
.
My obviously in need of diagnosis ds was put in for 2 days for trivial shite. I removed him from the school and will be naming and shaming it to the trust after tomorrow.. The 'engage in learning' system has 53 pages for new teachers to remember..
Yet the symptoms of ADHD are a basic 8 short lines of info to look out for...
Do not accept this method if you suspect your dc needs any sort of extra support...

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 19:35

@MrsTWH

It wouldn’t be isolation. It would be here’s the spare kit. It would be let’s call home and find out why. It would be a discussion with the child about why they were avoiding x/y/z. It would depend on the kit they were missing. A pen - borrow one and get on with it. Missing ingredient for food tech - well if you haven’t got it, obviously you can’t do the practical. Missing PE kit every week - why are they avoiding it? Do they have kit? Is mum/dad in financial difficulty and can we use pupil premium to buy new kit?

It’s not rocket science in my opinion. How does removing them from the classroom address the underlying issues?

Far too sensible.
MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 19:31

It wouldn’t be isolation. It would be here’s the spare kit. It would be let’s call home and find out why. It would be a discussion with the child about why they were avoiding x/y/z. It would depend on the kit they were missing. A pen - borrow one and get on with it. Missing ingredient for food tech - well if you haven’t got it, obviously you can’t do the practical.
Missing PE kit every week - why are they avoiding it? Do they have kit? Is mum/dad in financial difficulty and can we use pupil premium to buy new kit?

It’s not rocket science in my opinion. How does removing them from the classroom address the underlying issues?

Elisheva · 15/07/2021 19:26

Just think about one of your rules - bring the right kit.
What would be your sanction for not bringing the right kit?

MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 19:21

@Elisheva

*1. Come to school ready to learn (right kit, right attitude).
  1. Treat yourself, others and property with respect at all times.*

And if the students don’t follow these rules?

Then as I said in my previous response, the natural, proportionate consequences should be applied and the school should actually try to unpick why that child is unable to follow the simple rules.
Elisheva · 15/07/2021 19:21

If they can’t obey two simple rules, there’s not much point in introducing more, is there? It’s just setting them up to fail.

Yes, but how are you going to get them to obey these ‘simple’ rules?
E.g. “Ready to learn - bring the right kit”
How do you get them to do this?

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 19:15

@Elisheva

*1. Come to school ready to learn (right kit, right attitude).
  1. Treat yourself, others and property with respect at all times.*

And if the students don’t follow these rules?

If they can’t obey two simple rules, there’s not much point in introducing more, is there? It’s just setting them up to fail.
GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 19:14

The bulky eventually pulled a knife on my ds in a classroom. They blamed my ds Shock
How?

Elisheva · 15/07/2021 19:12

*1. Come to school ready to learn (right kit, right attitude).

  1. Treat yourself, others and property with respect at all times.*

And if the students don’t follow these rules?

itsgettingwierd · 15/07/2021 19:07

@MrsTWH

I really hope Elisheva isn’t a teacher.

The examples you’ve given - of the bobble causing low level disruption because the teacher has to stop and explain why they’ve broken the rules is utterly laughable. In that instance, can’t you understand that it’s the TEACHER disrupting the learning rather than the child? What possible need is there to start publicly shaming a child when they are otherwise engaged in the lesson but just writing with a different coloured pen? It is the Head Teacher that sets the ethos for a school and a zero tolerance policy works for nobody except possibly teachers with poor classroom management or poor relationships with their students.

Just have a green and red pen in your bag and a spare? Ok, what about the kids whose parents can’t afford it or who don’t give a shit whether their kids have the right kit? Let’s punish the child for their unfortunate circumstances! Why not simply remove that battle altogether, and the teacher has a couple of pen pots around the room where the kids know they can borrow one and get on with the work?

My teens are allowed to wear black Air Force Ones to school as part of uniform policy - weird, but there’s never been anarchy because of it!? A lot of uniform and hair policy is outright discriminatory. Boys and girls wearing different uniforms? Discriminatory. Afro hairstyles not allowed - discriminatory. Neither of these things have an affect on learning.

Nobody is suggesting at all that children should not behave or not take responsibility for their actions - of course they should. But let the sanction be a natural consequence of their actions and proportionate. Covered yourself in pen and missed the task? Well then obviously you’ll have to go and wash it off then stay behind after class to finish it. Punched someone in the playground? Well obviously we can’t let you out at lunchtime until you’ve proved you’re not a danger to other pupils and done some work around the reasons why you lashed out. Restorative practice, emotional literacy, these are the policies that work. Isolation, where they are sent to work in a cubicle and not allowed to interact with anyone all day) is disgusting - it is exclusion.

Do you know how many children in a class of 30 have had social care involvement or are not neurotypical? Do you understand what Adverse Childhood Events (ACEs) are and how they effect people? The bedrock to good learning for these pupils is good relationships with adults and mental well-being. Zero tolerance policies are traumatic and disproportionately disadvantage groups of pupils who have SEND, social care involvement, ethnic minorities, etc. School needs to be a protective factor for these pupils and not somewhere where they don’t feel safe. This should be mandatory training for school staff.

A good, trauma aware school only really needs two simple rules.

  1. Come to school ready to learn (right kit, right attitude).
  2. Treat yourself, others and property with respect at all times.

What else is there?!

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Spot on.

My ds ended up leaving his first secondary because they broke down the relationship with him.

He has a disability.

One day a child who bullied him pinned him up against the wall by his neck. He couldn't break free so eventually stamped on his foot.

He was out in inclusion "for using violence".

We couldn't sort it because the school wouldn't move from "if a child is being bullied they must report it to an adult" and refused to answer "how can he twirl it to an adult when he's struggling for breath whilst being pinned against a wall".

They simply repeated the mantra "school rules are report".

We had reported, we continued to report. We called meetings in which they told me to remove ds if I didn't trust them.

The bulky eventually pulled a knife on my ds in a classroom. They blamed my ds Shock then refused to authorise his absense the following day for a GP appointment due to anxiety after suffering all this.

They reported me to EWO. Said I was making it up. Said it was mine and ds fault. Blah blah blah.

Da ended up under camhs and having intense support from victim support.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 15/07/2021 19:02

@Blossomtoes

Blimey *@NeverDropYourMoonCup*, who knew?
Anybody who has worked in a rather challenging school, I guess.

By the way, in that school, a significant number of kids would play up precisely because they preferred to go into isolation rather than General Pop. They liked the lack of distraction and quiet.

Hankunamatata · 15/07/2021 19:00

It looked like a tattoo?

MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 18:57

Oh and uniform policy should be for health and safety reasons - no open toe/open back/heeled shoes for example. They should foster a sense of belonging. They should not be a stick to beat a child with.

MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 18:51

I really hope Elisheva isn’t a teacher.

The examples you’ve given - of the bobble causing low level disruption because the teacher has to stop and explain why they’ve broken the rules is utterly laughable. In that instance, can’t you understand that it’s the TEACHER disrupting the learning rather than the child? What possible need is there to start publicly shaming a child when they are otherwise engaged in the lesson but just writing with a different coloured pen? It is the Head Teacher that sets the ethos for a school and a zero tolerance policy works for nobody except possibly teachers with poor classroom management or poor relationships with their students.

Just have a green and red pen in your bag and a spare? Ok, what about the kids whose parents can’t afford it or who don’t give a shit whether their kids have the right kit? Let’s punish the child for their unfortunate circumstances! Why not simply remove that battle altogether, and the teacher has a couple of pen pots around the room where the kids know they can borrow one and get on with the work?

My teens are allowed to wear black Air Force Ones to school as part of uniform policy - weird, but there’s never been anarchy because of it!? A lot of uniform and hair policy is outright discriminatory. Boys and girls wearing different uniforms? Discriminatory. Afro hairstyles not allowed - discriminatory. Neither of these things have an affect on learning.

Nobody is suggesting at all that children should not behave or not take responsibility for their actions - of course they should. But let the sanction be a natural consequence of their actions and proportionate. Covered yourself in pen and missed the task? Well then obviously you’ll have to go and wash it off then stay behind after class to finish it. Punched someone in the playground? Well obviously we can’t let you out at lunchtime until you’ve proved you’re not a danger to other pupils and done some work around the reasons why you lashed out. Restorative practice, emotional literacy, these are the policies that work. Isolation, where they are sent to work in a cubicle and not allowed to interact with anyone all day) is disgusting - it is exclusion.

Do you know how many children in a class of 30 have had social care involvement or are not neurotypical? Do you understand what Adverse Childhood Events (ACEs) are and how they effect people? The bedrock to good learning for these pupils is good relationships with adults and mental well-being. Zero tolerance policies are traumatic and disproportionately disadvantage groups of pupils who have SEND, social care involvement, ethnic minorities, etc. School needs to be a protective factor for these pupils and not somewhere where they don’t feel safe. This should be mandatory training for school staff.

A good, trauma aware school only really needs two simple rules.

  1. Come to school ready to learn (right kit, right attitude).
  2. Treat yourself, others and property with respect at all times.

What else is there?!

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 18:33

Blimey @NeverDropYourMoonCup, who knew?