Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a ridiculous reason for DS to be put into isolation?

211 replies

varskudd · 15/07/2021 11:13

DS(15) came home from school very annoyed yesterday, he said he was put into isolation for having a drawing on his hand/wrist. He got bored so he drew on his hand with a pen, but it's not just scribbles.

Apparently, he was told to go to the toilet and wash it off and he tried to but it wouldn't come off so they sent him to isolation. He tried to get it off at home and it wouldn't, I tried to this morning and it slightly faded but it's still there.

Aibu to think this is ridiculous?

OP posts:
Terhou · 15/07/2021 23:23

It’s so frustrating for teachers. They start a lesson, 30 plus kids, they ask them to take out their pen. If even 5 of them don’t have a pen then that is so disruptive.

So you could send those 5 to isolation, disrupting the class whilst you do so, causing them to miss out on valuable learning and risking a disability discrimination action in relation to the kids with executive function difficulties/dyslexia etc; or you could just keep a few spare pens or pencils and lend them out. I know which makes more sense to me.

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 23:20

@MrsTWH

“ And for what it's worth Isolation at my school is very much a nurturing and safe environment - students who have been removed from a lesson will be put in there until their next lesson begins or they may be kept in there if they are on a self-destruct mission that day (so work can be done to see wtf is going on), a student who is struggling emotionally may be using it as a safe, quiet place to sit, a student who cannot manage a particular lesson might be in there working independently.”

Right - that’s not isolation then is it?!

What is it then?
MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 23:17

“ And for what it's worth Isolation at my school is very much a nurturing and safe environment - students who have been removed from a lesson will be put in there until their next lesson begins or they may be kept in there if they are on a self-destruct mission that day (so work can be done to see wtf is going on), a student who is struggling emotionally may be using it as a safe, quiet place to sit, a student who cannot manage a particular lesson might be in there working independently.”

Right - that’s not isolation then is it?!

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 22:57

No, I don't think so either. Which I why I suspect there was a little more to it than op has disclosed.

lazylinguist · 15/07/2021 22:54

Yes. Isn't it just the removal of an audience for their antics?

Kind of, yes. But I'm not sure you could call doodling on your arm 'antics' or something asking for any kind of audience. I'm very much all for isolation for disruptive behaviour in class. Not for having the wrong colour pen or ink on your arm.

Elisheva · 15/07/2021 22:29

Bingowingslikeashieldofsteel

👏 👏 👏
Much more eloquent than me.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 22:22

In my experience deliberate defiance of rules purely for the sake of it by both students and their parents who invariably back them up is more about control and territorial pissing...

Nothing of the sort. If there are rational reasons for rules for which students and parents can see the logic, of course rules should be obeyed. I’d never have backed violation of them.

But drawing on hands, a hair bobble on a wrist, just no. No parent should back nonsensical rules, if there’s no good reason for them they shouldn’t exist.

Lilypansy · 15/07/2021 22:15

My point was that the person who wrote advise instead of advice may have had a word altered wrongly by autocorrect, regardless of what school they went to
I doubt that very much. Far more likely that the poster complaining about isolation is, in fact, not terribly well educated herself/ himself.
Michaela School has an excellent approach to SEN children.

SeaPinks · 15/07/2021 21:57

:34Lilypansy
25SeaPinks. Why? Do people who go to Michaela not have autocorrect on their phone?
I very much doubt that Michaela pupils are allowed phones in school. (Happy to be corrected on this)
My point is that the children there emerge with an education that enables them to distinguish between advice/ advise without needing technological help
My point was that the person who wrote advise instead of advice may have had a word altered wrongly by autocorrect, regardless of what school they went to. Happens all the time. It's a bit of a cheap shot. There may even be kids at Michaela with an SEN which means they make spelling mistakes after they leave school that aren't caused by autocorrect.

Bingowingslikeashieldofsteel · 15/07/2021 21:55

@SamusIsAGirl *These stupid rules seem to be about control and territorial pissing rather than aiding an educational environment.
*

In my experience deliberate defiance of rules purely for the sake of it by both students and their parents who invariably back them up is more about control and territorial pissing...

Students who don't have a pen are a pain in the arse, and most of them don't have a pen because they can't be bothered to ensure they've got one. The same students rarely forget their mobile phone... Any of my students know that if they don't have a pen/pencil they come to me or their form tutor and they bloody well get one - if they choose not to do that (read also, can't be arsed to) then I have no sympathy if they get given a detention. I know the difference between the kids that can't afford one and those who can't be arsed and I deal with them accordingly...

If you send your child to a school then please trust the professionals that work with them. If you don't, by all means take your concerns to their HOY where they can get a trawl done of the behaviour of your child in all areas of school (unstructured times included) and they can share that information with you so you can see the bigger picture.

Every child I've ever removed from a classroom because of their behaviour has insisted they have done nothing wrong (until we've had a conversation and they've usually then conceded that the rest of the class don't really want to be distracted by them messing about...) The same children go home and tell their parents that they've done nothing wrong too. It usually starts with 'can you stop drawing on your arm please' or ironically 'why haven't you got a pen' and escalates because kids can be belligerent buggers and there is a huge pressure on teachers to get a lesson started so that they can get the whole class engaged. Everyone is under pressure so you know what, the teacher gets frustrated and removes them, they then argue and then I get called to come along and take the child to 'isolation'.

There seems to be a misconception on here that students sit silently waiting for their lessons to start while small woodland creatures hand out pens and ask students to remove coats/earbuds/put their phones away etc and that any naughty kids (who are just having a laugh anyway) are routinely ignored by the rest of the class until they realise, and then they sit up straight and start paying attention. Even the best student in the world will turn into a PITA if their attention isn't grabbed immediately...

And for what it's worth Isolation at my school is very much a nurturing and safe environment - students who have been removed from a lesson will be put in there until their next lesson begins or they may be kept in there if they are on a self-destruct mission that day (so work can be done to see wtf is going on), a student who is struggling emotionally may be using it as a safe, quiet place to sit, a student who cannot manage a particular lesson might be in there working independently.

It's a good job I absolutely adore the kids I work with and love my job because Jesus the posts on this thread (and other recent ones) are just soul destroying to read.

@itsgettingwierd That sounds like utter shit and you are completely right to complain as loudly and to as many people as possible Flowers

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 21:25

Glad you got him out of there, itsgettingweird. Sounds like a complete hellhole.

itsgettingwierd · 15/07/2021 21:21

@GreyhoundG1rl

Christ alive! Why was the other boy being protected, do you know?
Because the school were crap and bullies.

Very much the stereotypical academy you hear about.

They gaslighted me terribly and refused to engage in his ehcp process because they didn't think he should have one.

We have no idea why they did what they did but 8 children with send ended up leaving in the space of 15 months.

Followed by the HT a few months later.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 21:15

@Lilypansy

:25SeaPinks. Why? Do people who go to Michaela not have autocorrect on their phone? I very much doubt that Michaela pupils are allowed phones in school. (Happy to be corrected on this). My point is that the children there emerge with an education that enables them to distinguish between advice/ advise without needing technological help.
It’s the technology that needs educating! Are you really expecting us to believe that autocorrect has never provided you with an incorrect (in context) spelling? What a pedantic and snarky post.
GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 21:11

Christ alive! Why was the other boy being protected, do you know?

itsgettingwierd · 15/07/2021 21:11

@MrsTWH

It wouldn’t be isolation. It would be here’s the spare kit. It would be let’s call home and find out why. It would be a discussion with the child about why they were avoiding x/y/z. It would depend on the kit they were missing. A pen - borrow one and get on with it. Missing ingredient for food tech - well if you haven’t got it, obviously you can’t do the practical. Missing PE kit every week - why are they avoiding it? Do they have kit? Is mum/dad in financial difficulty and can we use pupil premium to buy new kit?

It’s not rocket science in my opinion. How does removing them from the classroom address the underlying issues?

Again spot on.
itsgettingwierd · 15/07/2021 21:10

@GreyhoundG1rl

The bulky eventually pulled a knife on my ds in a classroom. They blamed my ds Shock How?
The DHT said the boy said he brought the knife to school because he was scared of my ds Confused

That's right - my ds who he was bullying.

It was just scrambling for anything to say because 2 weeks prior to this we had arranged to meet his HOY to discuss how to stop the bullying and when I turned up I was asked to go in alone at first and in the room were 5 members of slt who ambushed me and told me to remove ds if I didn't trust them.

I minuted the meeting and asked for any discrepancies to be corrected. They thought they were clever by simply relying "your opinions have been acknowledged".

2 weeks later this kid pulled a knife on my son in class.

They went into panic mode.

TheNoodlesIncident · 15/07/2021 21:09

@Elisheva

Can’t they learn with blue hands and arms? There’s no need for them to leave the lesson to wash. They’d stop doing it if it was ignored. Do you think they’re sitting there in silence turning themselves blue, or do you think they’re laughing and showing their mates? And what about the other kids in the class who want to learn but are constantly distracted and disrupted by stupid, petty behaviour which shouldn’t need to be punished but has to be because some students have such a poor attitude to learning. If kids stopped when a teacher said ‘Stop it’ then there really wouldn’t be a problem, but they don’t.
I'm with you @Elisheva, the amount of low level disruption in classes is absolutely dreadful. When DS was isolating and working online, I could hear what was going on in the classroom and it was horrifying how often the teacher had to pause the lesson to sort out some kid who wouldn't behave as required. I asked DS incredulously "Is it always like that?!" and some classes are. I could hear the same kids' names being called out by the teacher, so clearly repeat offenders (which DS confirmed). The problem I have with this is that DS can't cope with disruption (he has ASD) and is in the process of getting an EHCP, as his capacity for coping in school has just tanked... Junior school behaviour was fine, but secondary is another kettle of fish and it's becoming increasingly difficult for him to deal with it. If these kids don't want to learn, fine - I don't give a crap what that does to their prospects in life - but it pisses me off massively that they don't care about the impact of their behaviour on the kids who want to learn and the teachers who want to teach effectively!

That said, I do think some of the punishments imposed for trivial infractions seem unduly harsh, but if the school doesn't cover all bases then some kids will take the piss, and their parents will back them up. It's the same old story - the minority ruin it for the majority.

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 20:45

To be fair, 'isolation' in schools isn't solitary confinement! It's just a room
Yes. Isn't it just the removal of an audience for their antics? Not exactly chokey.

lazylinguist · 15/07/2021 20:41

At the last meeting before ds left his head of year showed no remorse in her expectation that ds 'serve' 18 hours in isolation over 3 days. My older ds is a soldier and didn't endure that in his training days...

To be fair, 'isolation' in schools isn't solitary confinement! It's just a room. With a teacher and often multiple kids in it. Some children quite like being in there. Not that I'm defending it as a punishment for trivial misdemeanours.

Lilypansy · 15/07/2021 20:34

:25SeaPinks. Why? Do people who go to Michaela not have autocorrect on their phone?
I very much doubt that Michaela pupils are allowed phones in school. (Happy to be corrected on this).
My point is that the children there emerge with an education that enables them to distinguish between advice/ advise without needing technological help.

30degreesandmeltinghere · 15/07/2021 20:28

Ask if they use engage in learning. It is being started in another of our local schools come September.. Our current school has a fast turnover of staff. Now I know why. Must take a special type of teacher who leaves a dc in isolation for 6 hours. Plus the hour after for the detention that earned them the isolation initially..
At the last meeting before ds left his head of year showed no remorse in her expectation that ds 'serve' 18 hours in isolation over 3 days.
My older ds is a soldier and didn't endure that in his training days...

SeaPinks · 15/07/2021 20:25

Why? Do people who go to Michaela not have autocorrect on their phone?

Lilypansy · 15/07/2021 20:12

Has anyone got any advise on how to avoid sending my kids to a school like this, or is it increasingly that they’re all like this? That Birbalsingh woman makes my blood run cold
If your children were to attend a school like Michaela, there is every chance that they would emerge knowing the difference between 'advice' and'advise.'

MrsTWH · 15/07/2021 20:09

Clear expectations for behaviour, appropriate sanctions and appropriate support.

This I agree with. Isolation isn’t it!

Lilypansy · 15/07/2021 20:08

I wonder what happens when people leave Michaela schools and actually have to do independent, critical thinking? Grades or not, that's then the wheels come off
That is pure speculation, since the students have not been in the workplace yet.
Why wouldn't Michaela students adapt well to their next stage in life? At least they have been taught to be super organized, to stay on task and to concentrate. All useful qualities in the world after school.
I have nothing but admiration for the Michaela approach, and I am hoping that many more schools will adopt it in time.