Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a ridiculous reason for DS to be put into isolation?

211 replies

varskudd · 15/07/2021 11:13

DS(15) came home from school very annoyed yesterday, he said he was put into isolation for having a drawing on his hand/wrist. He got bored so he drew on his hand with a pen, but it's not just scribbles.

Apparently, he was told to go to the toilet and wash it off and he tried to but it wouldn't come off so they sent him to isolation. He tried to get it off at home and it wouldn't, I tried to this morning and it slightly faded but it's still there.

Aibu to think this is ridiculous?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
itsgettingwierd · 16/07/2021 16:27

@Blossomtoes

I really feel one of the greatest problems in society currently is the fact that too many children never received any sort of teaching in critical thinking, hence problems like the acceptance of stupid rules and, indeed, hence the fact that we currently have the most corrupt and stupid government in the western world. And, of course, they utterly love schools like Michaela

Nail on head.

Totally.

Isolation has its place in school.

But it's meant to be for students at risk of exclusion to prevent that and work with them to integrate.

Nowadays it's used for minor discretions.

There's no denying teaching is hard and teachers struggle in classrooms full of disruptive children and this is an easy way to remove them.

But it doesn't get to the heart of the problem.

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 11:27

Even if they hadn't argued, the child was clearly not paying attention to the lesson if they had time to be doodling on their hand

A lot of people find doodling aids concentration. I happen to be one of them. Once again, presumably doodling is fine as long as it’s not on a body part. Which is completely illogical.

Lilypansy · 16/07/2021 11:13

I used to be paid quite a lot of money write for publications you’ve almost certainly purchased yourself. My ability to think and express ideas clearly were what was valued. We had subeditors. This is irrelevant to your defence of harsh, borderline cruel discipline though, as you well know.
I know nothing of the sort. Discipline at Michaela is strict but very far from being 'borderline cruel.'
As for your job, you seem to be implying that no one who has attended a school such as Michaela, with strict discipline policies, will be capable of thinking for themselves when they leave school. A very sweeping, ill thought out assumption by someone who obviously prides themself on their analytical thinking skills.

I think there must be more to the isolation story as recounted by the OP. It's more likely to have been a result of arguing back when asked to remove the drawing. Even if they hadn't argued, the child was clearly not paying attention to the lesson if they had time to be doodling on their hand.

lazylinguist · 16/07/2021 10:38

Lemonmelonsun - I absolutely agree about the impact of disruptive pupils. But there is absolutely zero evidence that the OP's ds falls into that category. I mean...it's possible, but you really can't assume that.

I asked my dc about this subject yesterday, due to this thread. Dd15 says she doesn't know if there's a rule about it at their school. Certain teachers make a big fuss about it, but the vast majority don't notice or care. Dd sometimes doodles on her hands, but has never got in trouble for it, or for anything else except occasionally handing a homework in a bit late, so I don't think it's a reliable proxy for 'disruptive child' Grin.

lazylinguist · 16/07/2021 10:32

I don’t know the reason behind the no drawing on hands rule. The school felt it was necessary for whatever reason

And there we have it.

and my point is that a blanket rule saying ‘No drawing on hands’ is easier to understand and enforce than ‘No drawing on hands, unless/except…’

Has anyone suggested on this thread that there should be exceptions due to situations where students specifically ought to be allowed to write on their hands? Nope. They are pretty much saying that writing on your hands isn't really a big deal, but that it's fair enough to ask them not to (and maybe even give a detention for persistent repeat offenders?), but that putting them in isolation for it is massive overkill.

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 10:27

@lazylinguist

If you're trying to avoid the drawing/writing of offensive and inappropriate things, then I don’t see how a blanket 'Don't draw on your hands' rule adds anything to the presumably already existing 'Don't draw/write anything offensive or inappropriate' rule, since the latter would cover writing on anything (hands, desks, paper, walls etc).
Exactly that. Not just me then.
lazylinguist · 16/07/2021 10:27

The rule around what they are or aren’t allowed to draw on paper/desk/walls are a separate matter.

Why? You're the one complaining about multiple rules and exceptions, and yet you're suggesting there need to be different rules for offensive writing on different surfaces. Grin

Elisheva · 16/07/2021 10:26

I don’t know the reason behind the no drawing on hands rule. The school felt it was necessary for whatever reason and my point is that a blanket rule saying ‘No drawing on hands’ is easier to understand and enforce than ‘No drawing on hands, unless/except…’

Lemonmelonsun · 16/07/2021 10:25

Bingo exactly what child would really admit to being rude or defensive or disruptive and there is only so much teachers and school can do

The upset one disruptive child can do! The impact is extraordinary.
Parents need to step up and whilst of course supporting their dc also make efforts to really see what they are loos at school
Sometimes dc with overly strict parents can act out as a release at school.
It's better to be honest and get a true picture of what's going on, it could simply be a clash with that one particular teacher.
If parents backed teachers more over all it would help enormously, it really would which is why I have been encouraging the op to ask honestly about his general attitude and be prepared for some negative feedback.

lazylinguist · 16/07/2021 10:24

If you're trying to avoid the drawing/writing of offensive and inappropriate things, then I don’t see how a blanket 'Don't draw on your hands' rule adds anything to the presumably already existing 'Don't draw/write anything offensive or inappropriate' rule, since the latter would cover writing on anything (hands, desks, paper, walls etc).

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 10:16

The rule around what they are or aren’t allowed to draw on paper/desk/walls are a separate matter.

It’s not a separate matter at all. It’s the same issue. If this is the way you reason with kids it’s no wonder they run rings round you. It’s like shooting fish in a barrel.

Elisheva · 16/07/2021 10:14

So essentially you’re saying they can draw what the fuck they like as long as it’s not on their hands?
What? Not at all. The rule here is that you are not allowed to draw on your hands, which everyone else has tried to justify by saying it is okay as long as…
My argument is that a clear, unambiguous rule is much easier to follow than one with a hundred different exceptions.
The rule around what they are or aren’t allowed to draw on paper/desk/walls are a separate matter.

Often apparently stupid rules have had to be introduced following even more ridiculous behaviour from teenagers.

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 09:44

@Elisheva

Kids would understand that. No, they wouldn’t. They would take the edges of that rule and start to push them. They would argue that what they had written/drawn was okay because of reasons. And then all of the teachers time is spent negotiating. For whatever reason that particular school has made a rule that you may not draw on yourself. It’s not exactly hard to follow.
So essentially you’re saying they can draw what the fuck they like as long as it’s not on their hands? Which is an utterly ridiculous rule which you’ve completely failed to justify in any rational way in God only knows how many posts. No wonder kids push boundaries when having to deal with such illogical adults.
Elisheva · 16/07/2021 09:39

Kids would understand that.
No, they wouldn’t. They would take the edges of that rule and start to push them.
They would argue that what they had written/drawn was okay because of reasons.
And then all of the teachers time is spent negotiating.
For whatever reason that particular school has made a rule that you may not draw on yourself. It’s not exactly hard to follow.

Blossomtoes · 16/07/2021 09:30

@Elisheva

I can understand dicipling the student if the doodles were outright innaproptiate (racism, making fun if other student etc.) But random doodles?

Can you see how this is actually more complicated and difficult to understand and enforce, especially for students with additional needs?
Your rules: you can draw on your hand, unless it is inappropriate eg making fun of another student.
Can they make fun of a student at another school? Of a famous person?
Writing ‘Fuck’ is inappropriate, but what about ‘F*#k’ or ‘Fock’?

One rule - don’t draw on yourself. Easy to understand, easy to enforce.

But that’s completely illogical. You can’t draw on your hands but you can draw on paper and there are no rules about appropriateness.

It’s tackling the wrong issue. The rule should be that wherever you draw we don’t make fun of other people or swear - to use your example. Kids would understand that. Not drawing on your hands is just trivial and fails to address the real issue.

Elisheva · 16/07/2021 09:21

I can understand dicipling the student if the doodles were outright innaproptiate (racism, making fun if other student etc.) But random doodles?

Can you see how this is actually more complicated and difficult to understand and enforce, especially for students with additional needs?
Your rules: you can draw on your hand, unless it is inappropriate eg making fun of another student.
Can they make fun of a student at another school? Of a famous person?
Writing ‘Fuck’ is inappropriate, but what about ‘F*#k’ or ‘Fock’?

One rule - don’t draw on yourself. Easy to understand, easy to enforce.

Rewis · 16/07/2021 07:50

I don't know if this is a mumsnet thing and in reality most schools have less rules regarding appearance. But I'm not originally from UK and these kinds of threads make me worry about sending my kids to school. I know it's a small thing but I find these very infuriating.

I can understand dicipling the student if the doodles were outright innaproptiate (racism, making fun if other student etc.) But random doodles?

SparrowNest · 16/07/2021 07:23

@SeaPinks

:34Lilypansy 25SeaPinks. Why? Do people who go to Michaela not have autocorrect on their phone? I very much doubt that Michaela pupils are allowed phones in school. (Happy to be corrected on this) My point is that the children there emerge with an education that enables them to distinguish between advice/ advise without needing technological help My point was that the person who wrote advise instead of advice may have had a word altered wrongly by autocorrect, regardless of what school they went to. Happens all the time. It's a bit of a cheap shot. There may even be kids at Michaela with an SEN which means they make spelling mistakes after they leave school that aren't caused by autocorrect.
I used to be paid quite a lot of money write for publications you’ve almost certainly purchased yourself. My ability to think and express ideas clearly were what was valued. We had subeditors.

This is irrelevant to your defence of harsh, borderline cruel discipline though, as you well know.

Terhou · 15/07/2021 23:44

Who pays for all these pens!! The kids don’t give them back.

It is or should be routine for the teacher to stand by the door and not let them leave till they've given back the pens. If that's the routine, it's generally accepted IME. It also incentivises them a bit either to remember their pens or remember to give borrowed ones back, otherwise they'll be delayed going out and potentially look a bit stupid in front of their mates.

Blossomtoes · 15/07/2021 23:40

I really feel one of the greatest problems in society currently is the fact that too many children never received any sort of teaching in critical thinking, hence problems like the acceptance of stupid rules and, indeed, hence the fact that we currently have the most corrupt and stupid government in the western world. And, of course, they utterly love schools like Michaela

Nail on head.

Terhou · 15/07/2021 23:38

Dc are put in isolation booths as a deterent to being disruptive and for defying the 'engage to learn' strategy... In isolation you aren't enforced to do any work at all. They booths aren't manned by specific teachers.. Sheets are given out and are optional

This. And when they are used for days at a time, it means pupils are being denied their legal right to full time education.

There was a dreadful case around three or four years ago where a child with SEN was constantly in isolation without being given anything to do, so that she was just staring at blank walls for hours. She ended up making a very serious suicide attempt. When she eventually returned to school, they started using the same tactic. It took a serious threat of legal action to make them see sense.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 15/07/2021 23:34

Put

Terhou · 15/07/2021 23:34

@SamusIsAGirl

I wonder what happens when people leave Michaela schools and actually have to do independent, critical thinking? Grades or not, that's then the wheels come off.
Apparently that is a very real problem, because they're spoon-fed standard answers even in subjects like Humanities.

I really feel one of the greatest problems in society currently is the fact that too many children never received any sort of teaching in critical thinking, hence problems like the acceptance of stupid rules and, indeed, hence the fact that we currently have the most corrupt and stupid government in the western world. And, of course, they utterly love schools like Michaela.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 15/07/2021 23:34

Call the school and find out why he got out in isolation for that. Probably more to it.

Terhou · 15/07/2021 23:27

It's important for parents to be on the same side as the school when it comes to discipline or it sends your child mixed messages, and the next time the school try to impose another rule, they'll question it again.

Far too many schools have zero tolerance rules that don't take account of disability. So no, parents shouldn't support a school which is effectively punishing a child for being autistic, dyslexic or whatever, and the school absolutely should be questioned. Not least because in that situation it is the school that is breaking considerably more important rules.