Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these groups of men in the park are a bit weird

243 replies

SinoAZ · 15/07/2021 04:55

I'm not in the UK so I guess there's cultural expectations that might be different but I'm British and would like to know what other British mums think/how you'd react to this. Do people even do this in the UK?

Since restrictions lifted I've been taking my 18 month old DD to the park. We used to go before restrictions and we'd see old people walking, other families etc and sometimes chat to them. Now because of continuing restrictions there are lots of people not working so there are largeish groups of young men who hang around the park (maybe 6 or 7 of them). They sit at the picnic benches or swing on the swings which of course is fine, it's a nice place to be. But they keep shouting at my DD. They'll call out to her "hello baby girl" repeatedly and wave and make faces/silly noises which, to me, just feels a bit inappropriate. Like yes say hello/wave to her if she comes near you but to shout so repeatedly makes me uncomfortable.

DH says they're harmless and probably just miss their own kids (I think they're immigrants like me but will have come to work here and left their families in their home country). I don't feel threatened by them at all but I can't help feel that they wouldn't be shouting at her if she was with DH and it feels like that male entitlement to women's time/attention again. AIBU to feel a bit uncomfortable with this?

Maybe it's just a lifetime of experiences like this with men colouring my view but I hate that expectation that when a man wants to speak to you he can be so insistent and refuse to take no for an answer. I don't want that to be happening to my daughter before she's even two.

Sorry that was long, a bit of a vent as well as an AIBU.

OP posts:
StarCourt · 15/07/2021 09:22

@SinoAZ you aren't being ridiculous. I lived abroad for a number of years, not Malaysia but def similarities in culture and came across this type of behaviour all the time. It never felt dangerous but always felt uncomfortable and inappropriate.

SinoAZ · 15/07/2021 09:20

[quote MrsMayJune]@Naunet I’m making no excuse for men’s harassment whatever their colour but I will not be complicit in demonising men and engaging in extreme descriptions where they pose no danger or threat.

The language used paints an extreme picture of them and if you remove all the extreme language, what you get is a group of men with nothing else to do using the swings in a public park and saying hi to a toddler.

No excuse for abusive behaviour from men and no excuse for women demonising men for just daring to exist in the same space as them.[/quote]
They're not just existing though, they're demanding DD and I interact with/entertain them. You sound like you have a massive chip on your shoulder about this - are you a man?

The first time they called out I did what I'd do with anyone - reciprocate their interaction so say hello back, wave back or have a conversation. But it quickly became clear that wasn't enough and they wanted repeated attention/hellos/waves. I'm just trying to exist in the park with DD, I'm not there as their entertainment. Writing all this has made me realise I don't think IABU at all.

I will update with DH's experience if I remember/if it happens. He's a man and local so it would be interesting to see if they did it to DD when he's there.

OP posts:
Naunet · 15/07/2021 09:16

@Naunet I’m making no excuse for men’s harassment whatever their colour but I will not be complicit in demonising men and engaging in extreme descriptions where they pose no danger or threat

But you’re happy to demonise women. Got it, you’re a misogynist.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/07/2021 09:13

MrsMayJune now you are minimising to such a brazen extent you sound as though you haven't actually read the op.

Repeatedly shouting out and making noises is not "saying hi" and anyone who can't understand the word repeatedly, or thinks its "extreme language" isn't in a position to lecture others on their use of language.

godmum56 · 15/07/2021 09:13

"Yjay" =that....I am all fingers and thumbs today

godmum56 · 15/07/2021 09:12

I do think that there is a "cultural norms" element to this. I have no idea how you are in Malaysia or whether its even possible but are you part of a "sensible" expat group? Yjay may sound weird but I met a couple of expat groups in America who were decidedly NOT sensible. Could you get some input from them about how common it is and what the risk/situation actually is?
I genuinely don't think that those of us who have only lived in the Uk are in a position to judge or to advise.

Livelovebehappy · 15/07/2021 09:12

YANBU. It’s intimidating to have a group of men shouting out persistently when you’re just trying to get on with your own thing. A ‘good morning’ or ‘hi’ is fine, but the shouting out is what men do to show off in front of their peers. It would probably stop me wanting to go there..

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/07/2021 09:09

MrsMaizel the thing is it is both male entitlement and just life. Life and people are complex mixes of baggage - history, culture, religion, upbringing, education, lived experience - even in simple everyday situations.

Men behaving in a demanding way in which women don't behave is both male entitlement and just life, and the social norms and expectations around the extent and expression of male entitlement varies by culture.

MrsMayJune · 15/07/2021 09:06

@Naunet I’m making no excuse for men’s harassment whatever their colour but I will not be complicit in demonising men and engaging in extreme descriptions where they pose no danger or threat.

The language used paints an extreme picture of them and if you remove all the extreme language, what you get is a group of men with nothing else to do using the swings in a public park and saying hi to a toddler.

No excuse for abusive behaviour from men and no excuse for women demonising men for just daring to exist in the same space as them.

MrsMaizel · 15/07/2021 09:03

@SinoAZ

I'm not in the UK so I guess there's cultural expectations that might be different but I'm British and would like to know what other British mums think/how you'd react to this. Do people even do this in the UK?

Since restrictions lifted I've been taking my 18 month old DD to the park. We used to go before restrictions and we'd see old people walking, other families etc and sometimes chat to them. Now because of continuing restrictions there are lots of people not working so there are largeish groups of young men who hang around the park (maybe 6 or 7 of them). They sit at the picnic benches or swing on the swings which of course is fine, it's a nice place to be. But they keep shouting at my DD. They'll call out to her "hello baby girl" repeatedly and wave and make faces/silly noises which, to me, just feels a bit inappropriate. Like yes say hello/wave to her if she comes near you but to shout so repeatedly makes me uncomfortable.

DH says they're harmless and probably just miss their own kids (I think they're immigrants like me but will have come to work here and left their families in their home country). I don't feel threatened by them at all but I can't help feel that they wouldn't be shouting at her if she was with DH and it feels like that male entitlement to women's time/attention again. AIBU to feel a bit uncomfortable with this?

Maybe it's just a lifetime of experiences like this with men colouring my view but I hate that expectation that when a man wants to speak to you he can be so insistent and refuse to take no for an answer. I don't want that to be happening to my daughter before she's even two.

Sorry that was long, a bit of a vent as well as an AIBU.

Your very first paragraph shows a great deal of naivety . What on earth does it matter what people in the UK do IF you are in Malaysia ? Any ex pat can tell you that things like this will happen living in other countries . As you say there are lots of "bachelors" working in such countries and yes they do gather and yes any person of an obviously different look especially Western gets attention . You must know what nationality they are - are they for example Bangladeshi which many of the bachelors are ? I would suggest that you take your husband one time and he speaks to them . It's not male entitlement - it's just life .
unwuthering · 15/07/2021 09:02

I am concerned that the OP is feeling uncomfortable around the behaviour of a group of men, and is being told to ignore her feelings and chastised for expressing her discomfort, uneasiness, and concern.

Booboobadoo · 15/07/2021 09:00

Group of men in children's play park. Men repeatedly calling to child. OP uncomfortable with this. Repeated posts defending men's behaviour. Odd.

Naunet · 15/07/2021 08:57

Reminds me of the lady in Central Park who was being attacked by a black man who was several metres away from her

Yeah we get it, you want to cape for men whilst throwing women under the bus. Well done, extra woke points for you.

You know holding men of colour to a different standard to that of white men, is actually racist on your part?

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/07/2021 08:45

BTW I completely agree that what the men are doing is male entitlement!

Male entitlement is entrenched in all cultures but in many its completely open and unashamed, where in much of northern Europe and other countries its just as real but most of the time slightly disguised or hidden and regarded as not appropriate to admit to or exhibit openly.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/07/2021 08:42

Doublestar groups of adults do hang around in parks in some countries though! It isn't "a race thing" but cultural - what's weird in one country isn't weird in another! Some posters are so determined to virtue signal that they're ignoring the utterly enormous difference between race and national cultural norms! Exactly the same way its normal for six year olds to walk to school without an adult in Germany or four year olds to go to the shop or take the underground unaccompanied in Japan, but if a Londoner let their children do those things they'd be condemned.

PaleGreenGhost · 15/07/2021 08:40

What op has described is male entitlement, whether those particular males mean anything worse by it or not. Even lovely men can act with male entitlement, unawares.

I'm sorry, sitting in a playground, repeatedly calling goes way beyond saying hello, or even making a huge fuss of a cute foreign toddler. They are in the child's space that is for playing, not appeasing males.

Maybe they're decent enough and unaware of this, but their behaviour is part of chip chip chipping away of children's, especially girls', boundaries. Part of the global grooming of women so that they know their place.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/07/2021 08:37

MrsMayJune it isn't remotely the same! I suspect that you're deliberately twisting what you're reading - nobody can be that obtuse!

Doublestar · 15/07/2021 08:37

Ridiculous all the posters trying to make this a "race thing" but it was obvious that was how it was gonna go.

Yeah, a group of men hanging around a children's play park and repeatedly shouting at a child is weird behaviour. They could be trying to do it to get attention from the OP and assert authority (I suspect, if they do have ulterior motives it is probably the attention of the mothers they want - not the children - maybe they are sexually frustrated if they don't have their own wives/girlfriends around).

It boils down to:why on earth are a bunch of grown men hanging around on swings harassing mothers and their kids?
It's not like it's a one off if they're there every day.
They're not necessarily going to do anything but why should women have to put up with this kind of shit?

DottyHarmer · 15/07/2021 08:37

If someone feels intimidated, shouldn’t you believe her rather than jumping to the “Karen” accusation (as per pp mentioning Central Park incident)?

I think I know when a group are being merely friendly or inappropriately friendly. We are conditioned to be polite but sometimes you get a gut feeling of discomfort.

GalaxyGirl24 · 15/07/2021 08:34

I think it's very weird and I wouldn't like them shouting hello to my child either! One hello is sufficient but if it's a children's park they shouldn't be on the swings and equipment anyway! Very odd

MrsMayJune · 15/07/2021 08:30

OP when you say repetitive calling to your DD what do you mean? I’m trying to picture what’s happening.

They repeatedly call to your DD and did you say anything to them? The intervals of these calls? Were there no other people or kids about?

You also describe it as catcalling. To me catcalling has a sexual element to it. If they were repeatedly catcalling her, did no one intervene?

I’m just trying to understand what was going on with these immigrants, loitering and repeatedly catcalling a toddler to “demand” her attention.

Reminds me of the lady in Central Park who was being attacked by a black man who was several metres away from her.

ancientgran · 15/07/2021 08:24

@nancywhitehead

I don't think grown ups should be out playing on swings in a large group - that's a bit odd if they don't have their own kids there too. Why would a group of adults choose to hang around in a children's playpark?

I can understand sitting on a picnic table or on the grass or whatever as a group, but actually playing on the swings is weird.

I'm not saying there's anything dodgy going on but I just think it's odd and I'd be uncomfortable about it too - parks are for kids, if you don't have kids, why are you there? And especially shouting out to children that you don't know?

I don't know what you should do about it, but I can understand your concern.

Do you know any other parents who use this park? If so maybe you could ask around, find out if other people are also finding this uncomfortable and go from there.

I'm nearly 70, admittedly if I go to the park I am with GC but if it's quiet I always have a go on the swings. It never occurred to me it was weird. I wouldn't do it if there were kids wanting to go on the swings but if they are empty I can't see I'm doing any harm.
Member589500 · 15/07/2021 08:23

Reminds me of when I used to live in the Middle East and people were very friendly towards my three DC. It was (mostly) lovely and I think related to a lot of people being away from their own families.
There was a bit of a fright one day though when I was walking through an underground car park with them and the car park security guy picked one of my 3yr old twins up and pretended to run off. He was laughing and saying ‘I take this one’. I guess it was good that he saw it as obviously innocent fun but did give me a moment of worry.
It was sad to see the huge numbers of people in the ME away from their families though. Sounds as though Malaysia has similar issues.

Uramaki · 15/07/2021 08:21

lottiegarbanzo Cross post. That's exactly what I tried to explain. There is such a difference between normal interaction with a child and pressuring them to wave/demand attention.

Regularchoice · 15/07/2021 08:20

It's not massively different from the many ways that men try to get women's attention pretty much anywhere in the world. Certainly I was constantly pestered by men as a young woman in London. It doesn't mean that they're going to do anything terrible, but it does mean that as women we can't go about our business undisturbed.
Has anyone ever seen groups of women in parks calling out to dad's with babies?