Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To my half siblings shouldn’t get 50% of my parent’s house?

282 replies

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 01:06

Paternal half siblings. They are 20 and 22 years older than me. Their mum joint owns with their stepdad and she was better off after the divorce as he left her the house. Me and my full brother raised in social housing as my mum and dad always struggled for money.

My parents ended up expressing a wish to purchase their property with Right To Buy in my late teens. They had a fair amount saved up but nowhere near enough. The property is in a desirable area and I saw it as a steal to get it with the Right To Buy Discount, so I agreed to save up and then give the money to my parents to use to be able to use Right To Buy. I ended up providing about 75% of the money (it took a good few years and meant I spent bugger all on fun and delayed my own life events) used for it. My full sibling has a learning disability and can’t live independently. The deal between me, my mum and dad was if I helped them to be able to buy the house, once they go I could have it and use 25% of the money on supporting my brother. None of the house is mine legally but we knew it’d benefit me and my brother in future if I helped them buy it now.

This was a few years ago. DF has now decided to write a will, he isn’t ill but wants to in the event of a sudden death. He has decided he’d feel guilty doing the original plan and excluding his older children. He now wants us to have 25% of the house each. He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free. I’ve not expressed this to him but I’m quite annoyed. My mum was also the bigger contributor for their portion of the deposit out of the 2 of them. I also know that when they go, all of the care for DB will go on me. I’ve already been told I’ll be his power of attorney, will manage his money etc. My half siblings are significantly older with their own well established lives. Mum is upset as well but doesn’t want to rock the boat.

Aibu to think DF is being unfair?

OP posts:
LumpyandBumps · 15/07/2021 09:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

QuizzlyBear · 15/07/2021 09:32

I would tell your DF that if that's the route he wants to go down, they'll have to make other provisions for your DB's care because without a home or the money you supplied back, you won't be in a position to house him.

Maybe your half siblings could step up and care for him? 🤔

RadandMad · 15/07/2021 09:27

I would be absolutely furious. Incandescent. I know someone else who pulled this trick with his kids, saying one thing about money, then doing something else entirely years down the line. I really hope you can do something about this legally, because it's so blatantly wrong. Wishing you the best of luck.

BoxHedge · 15/07/2021 09:27

Your DF is making my blood boil. Is he actually just quite stupid? If not then he’s horrible.

Your parents need to make proper arrangements for the care of your brother for a start. Are they going to pay you for a lifetime of providing his care? He needs more than 25% surely?

I hope the legal route works as you should be entitled to a good chunk of the house.

The cheek to say you were living in the house rent-free when you’d paid for most of the bloody thing!

mm8989 · 15/07/2021 09:23

Yes its very misleading, I had to reread it too.

I think the issue is they now own the house and dads probably thinking giving one child everything is unfair.

It is unfair, but I can also see OPs frustration, they made an agreement.

If this is a council house in London, it might be worth 700K..

ChargingBuck · 15/07/2021 09:17

[quote mm8989]@ChargingBuck

she ONLY paid 75% of the deposit! not the full purchase price.[/quote]
Oh! Cheers MM. Very unclear in the OP. I've just read it back 3 times!

Same principle applies though.
The DF is a tricky fucker.

ancientgran · 15/07/2021 09:16

@Wannakisstheteacher

First family children are always fucked over like this. Your Dad has 4 DC, not just 2. You are just a greedy chancer.
The mother only has 2 children, why can't she leave her half to her children?
LaProcureure · 15/07/2021 09:14

Don’t take legal advice from mumsnet, what people feel must be the case, often isn’t.

The only advice I would give (as a lawyer) is get a lawyer! Google “direct access chancery barrister”. This will be the cheapest way to get you the advice you need, but also ironically most likely the most accurate advice.

mm8989 · 15/07/2021 09:13

@ChargingBuck

she ONLY paid 75% of the deposit! not the full purchase price.

Wannakisstheteacher · 15/07/2021 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ChargingBuck · 15/07/2021 09:12

He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free

"Rent free" - in a house *you paid 75%% of the purchase price of?!
I am so sorry your generosity has come back to bite you on the arse.
Also, that your contribution was not legally documented.

Also, gobsmacked at how unfair your folks are being.

DF feels guilty about the other siblings? - why? - did they buy him 3/4 of a house?
DM "doesn't want to rock the boat"? What?! the boat that you paid for?!

I agree with you that he has tricked you.
Do you have a paper trail of your payments, or any written agreements at all?

As you used all your money to buy his security, he has now compromised yours. I don;t know how he can live with himself, let alone the DD he has ripped off.

It's also disrepectful & mean toward your DB, who you will be caring for when your parents are no longer here to do so. That money you 'invested' for your parents current security, & your & DB's future security, should not be compromised. I can't belief the selfishness of a man who would watch his own DD working to buy him a house, going without fun or building up her own savings, & effectively steal most of it back from you.

He is putting his wish not to feel 'selfish' to his other 2 kids ahead of all your hard work & sacrifice. He needs an MN Hit Squad!
Your DM is being a wet fucking lettuce too. I cannot believe she will sit passively by & let you be ripped off like this.

Agree with PP about getting this moved to Legal.
Your dad has crapped on you from a great height, & it seems your mum is going to be useless in persuading him to see how unfair he is being to the person who paid for his house.

OhNoNoNoNoNo · 15/07/2021 09:08

If your half siblings were offered the opportunity to help buy the house and profit from the right-to-buy discount I wonder if they would have done so.

IcedSpice · 15/07/2021 09:08

Definitely need to know how much you put in

You should be able to have that removed before the inheritance is shared (Morally at least)

gogohm · 15/07/2021 08:58

Fairer is your parents own 50% each, you get half of your mums portion (25%) and 25% of your dads portion (12.5%) meaning you get 37.5%

Bluntness100 · 15/07/2021 08:57

Have they paid you any of the money back?

twiggytwoo · 15/07/2021 08:56

Even without the issue of the 75% loan and brother's care costs, the house should not be split this way.

Your half siblings will then be inheriting from 3 people: their mum, your dad AND your mum. Whereas you and your brother are only inheriting from two.

The starting point should be: half siblings: 12.5 % each (your dad's share split into 4) and you and your brother 37.5% each.

Are your parents making joint wills? Your mum should also be fighting your corner on this.

SmokeyDevil · 15/07/2021 08:54

@Cooldryplace

I don't know. I can see you point, but I absolutely hate it when children of council tenants "see a steal" and try to play the system in the expectation that they will inherit much more than they paid for and deprive future generations of much needed housing, so I can have limited sympathy, I'm afraid.
This really. I hate the right to buy scheme because you've taken a house away from a family in need and now you're squabbling over money from it and your parents aren't even dead yet. It's brought out the best in you hasn't it? Hmm

You should have had your name put on the deeds, I would have refused point blank to contribute any money towards a house unless my name is on the deeds. Think you are now stuck with whatever your dad decides, and that's down to your mistake.

mynameisbrian · 15/07/2021 08:52

Well your mum is going to have to do her own will and ensure it is different from your dads. Assuming he dies first then it won’t be an issue.

OhNoNoNoNoNo · 15/07/2021 08:52

@burnoutbabe

From my study of resulting and constructive trusts, yes a claim for a share is possible but as lady hale said, often the cost of these things is out of all proportion to the actual amounts at stake.

It's usually cohabiting couples when they split who have this issue when one is not in the deeds. You contributed to the deposit so have a fair shot (Lloyds bank v rossett) but need up prove there was also an intention to share.
You probably need to prove all this before any deaths and get your share noted now. Even the threat of legal action may make him give a share.

(Of course 75% of a low deposit may not be much and dad also contributed the council discount which is counted in these cases as a contribution towards purchase price)

The last paragraph of this post seems like it might be very relevant !

OP, can you give us the numbers. I think they are relevant.

mm8989 · 15/07/2021 08:48

Completely unfair to you. The more I think about it the more outrageous it gets. Who asks their child to stump up the cost of the house (more or less)----
---

she paid 75% of the DEPOSIT not the house, it may have only been 3 K

Busybee5000 · 15/07/2021 08:42

Completely unfair to you. The more I think about it the more outrageous it gets. Who asks their child to stump up the cost of the house (more or less) and then reneges the deal. And you have your brother to look after. What is wrong with people?!

But remember that in the end nobody might end up getting the value of the house if one or both have to pay for care. That is a very real fact and so you may get nothing anyway.

ihtwsf · 15/07/2021 08:40

You need to follow honeylulu's advice.

It's well out of order. Your Dad should be prioritizing your brother who has a learning disability rather than the two other well-established children.

MinkyWinky · 15/07/2021 08:34

I'm so happy to hear it's working out for you Smile He sounds lovely!

PrinnyPree · 15/07/2021 08:31

He said your financial support in buying the house is negated by the fact he let you live there rent free? If you put 75% of the value down wasn't it you who let them live there rent free?

Radio4ordie · 15/07/2021 08:29

YANBU but I guess the real question is how to resolve it with the least upset possible.

A possible option is saying to your DF that no you won’t accept that, that you understand the emotions involved which is why you think registering an interest with land registry (get legal advice) in the house is the best option. That way you get your agreed share of the house and his estate can be split equally. It’s formalising the reality that he isn’t free to give all the house away because he didn’t own all the house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread