Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To my half siblings shouldn’t get 50% of my parent’s house?

282 replies

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 01:06

Paternal half siblings. They are 20 and 22 years older than me. Their mum joint owns with their stepdad and she was better off after the divorce as he left her the house. Me and my full brother raised in social housing as my mum and dad always struggled for money.

My parents ended up expressing a wish to purchase their property with Right To Buy in my late teens. They had a fair amount saved up but nowhere near enough. The property is in a desirable area and I saw it as a steal to get it with the Right To Buy Discount, so I agreed to save up and then give the money to my parents to use to be able to use Right To Buy. I ended up providing about 75% of the money (it took a good few years and meant I spent bugger all on fun and delayed my own life events) used for it. My full sibling has a learning disability and can’t live independently. The deal between me, my mum and dad was if I helped them to be able to buy the house, once they go I could have it and use 25% of the money on supporting my brother. None of the house is mine legally but we knew it’d benefit me and my brother in future if I helped them buy it now.

This was a few years ago. DF has now decided to write a will, he isn’t ill but wants to in the event of a sudden death. He has decided he’d feel guilty doing the original plan and excluding his older children. He now wants us to have 25% of the house each. He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free. I’ve not expressed this to him but I’m quite annoyed. My mum was also the bigger contributor for their portion of the deposit out of the 2 of them. I also know that when they go, all of the care for DB will go on me. I’ve already been told I’ll be his power of attorney, will manage his money etc. My half siblings are significantly older with their own well established lives. Mum is upset as well but doesn’t want to rock the boat.

Aibu to think DF is being unfair?

OP posts:
IAmWomxxnHearMeRoar · 15/07/2021 10:26

You defo need to take legal advice. I'm a lawyer, although this is not my area at all, so can't help, but don't assume there is nothing there.
My parents gave me money to purchase my first property and the mortgage co insisted on a signed document that this was an advancement of inheritance (ie I didn't owe my parents anything!). Was anything similar done here? Really you should have put your name on the title deeds at the time, but easy to say from hindsight.

Your mum however can do something - she can claim she owns 50% of the house and give it all to you, or in whatever proportion she wants to. Again, she will have to take legal steps, but this is really basic legal stuff and could be done cheaply when she writes her own will. Therefore your Dad can only give half the house as he wants, or an 1/8 to each of his 4 kids.

Also, with respect to your brother, your parents need to set up a trust and leave everything to the trust for him (otherwise it will affect his benefits and other things). As a term of the trust, get it to state that anything left over at the end of his life goes to you, or if you have died, your own kids. My own brother is sadly in the same situation and this is what my parents have done. As I'm sure you are aware those with severe disabilities, even with no health problems, have substantially shorter lives.

Is it worth talking to your 2 older half siblings? Unless they are total bastards, aren't they going to take your side?

Oh, and YANBU!!!

Cooldryplace · 15/07/2021 10:22

@saymynames

He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free.

I'd be telling him that it's you that's been letting them live there rent free

That's blatantly not true though. OP had no right to buy the house, that why it couldn't be done in her name.
TestingTestingWonTooFree · 15/07/2021 10:22

If your mum severs their joint tenancy, she can what she likes with her half. It’s not a complete fix, but it stops part of his plan.

Grossly unfair of him given his promise, your reliance on it and your contributions.

There are more legal options, but they are likely to be more difficult. Is he planning to write a will that would have your mum out of her own home on his death?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 15/07/2021 10:21

@shedofdread

The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 establishes that children are entitled to provision from their dad's estate. So he wouldn't be able to write them out of the will altogether without a good reason. The law also says that it's reasonable to make different provision for your children.

If your brother has a learning disability and relies on carers, your parents are likely to need a Will with a discretionary trust to prevent his share to stop his benefits.

Practically, if your name wasn't on the tenancy and you contributed the money to buy it with no formal agreement regarding what would happen after he died, I suspect you'll be giving a couple of solicitors major gifts from your parents estate after arguing this one out.

If you're living with your mum and stepdad, you could argue that his gift is leaving you without the means to live.

Your parents need proper legal advice on this and from what you've told us it could be a real mess.

This is a complete misunderstanding of the law in England & Wales, as regards children generally. There is absolutely no barrier to the DF excluding the older half-siblings from the will - this is extremely well-established law in E&W. The OP, because of her residency, and her DB, because of his dependency, are more complicated. The OP needs to speak to an actual solicitor.

With regards to Power of Attorney, no one can have POA for the DB because POA can only be conferred by people who have legal capacity, then lose it. The OP could apply to be her DB's advocate, which carries many of the same responsibilities and powers as POA, but no one can force her to do this.

Melroses · 15/07/2021 10:18

The op doesn't say how much money is actually involved. Deposit on a council property may not have been that much.

We don't know unless OP tells us.

I do know someone who gave their parents a considerable sum to purchase their council house so in effect owned most of it (I don't know whether in name, or through the parents honouring the debt in the Will). However the sibling was not pleased that they would inherit less house than it was worth and drained the elderly mother's savings.

Ideally, these arrangements would be made legally watertight and above board at the time, but if the OP was young and living in the home at the time, and thinking of the brother, then they are at a disadvantage.

It is hard to work out if they have given a gift, a loan, or part of the house.

saymynames · 15/07/2021 10:18

He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free.

I'd be telling him that it's you that's been letting them live there rent free

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2021 10:17

she ONLY paid 75% of the deposit! not the full purchase price

Are we sure about this? The OP kind of suggests both ...

As PPs have said, the key to it all will probably depend on whether there's an evidence trail of what OP put in - also how much it actually was and how it relates to the value of the property now

Either way it does seem she's been dumped on, not least by the expectation that she'll take on her brother's care (which indidentally she's not obliged to do)

If you do choose to become DB's carer, OP, I imagine that could affect your employment capacity? If so you could always tell your DF that you'll be unable to shoulder his care unless he thinks again ... not a very principled thing to do perhaps, but then neither is the way he's behaving

OhNoNoNoNoNo · 15/07/2021 10:15

@LaProcureure

Don’t take legal advice from mumsnet, what people feel must be the case, often isn’t.

The only advice I would give (as a lawyer) is get a lawyer! Google “direct access chancery barrister”. This will be the cheapest way to get you the advice you need, but also ironically most likely the most accurate advice.

This is the correct advice. I’m not a lawyer but I read a lot of bonkers posts from posters who think they know what they are talking about but don’t!
RandomLondoner · 15/07/2021 10:13

But ultimately it is their house and they have paid for most of it

I thought they'd only paid for a quarter of it, one third as much as OP.

RandomLondoner · 15/07/2021 10:13

I agree with others who say it is him who is in debt to you, to the extent that he lived there rent-free after your 75% contribution.

peachgreen · 15/07/2021 10:12

It's unfair and upsetting that they've gone back on their commitment for sure. But ultimately it is their house and they have paid for most of it. Although if they want to split it four ways you should be given your deposit back first and then the remainder split four ways.

RandomLondoner · 15/07/2021 10:12

A house has two components of return, capital appreciation and (if you live in it) notional rental income. If you are own 75% of it, you are entitled to both, 75% of the increase in price as well as 75% of occupation.

Your father is wrong to think your benefit from living there can be set against capital appreciation benefit, you should be fully entitled to both.

Melroses · 15/07/2021 10:10

@lottiegarbanzo

Your mum has the power here surely? If they own the house together, it isn't his to give away.

Your Mum needs to speak up and exert her power. She needs to protect her children. That matters much more than her discomfort at doing so.

This ^
knittingaddict · 15/07/2021 10:07

There is some really bad advice on here and it won't help the op at all.

If they wanted the money from the deposit returned at some point then a legal document should have been made at the time. It will be viewed as a gift otherwise and declaring it as a loan at the time might have had implications for getting a mortgage. The op doesn't say how much money is actually involved. Deposit on a council property may not have been that much.

I think it might be fair to leave op the amount of the deposit and maybe a right more to allow for interest plus a quarter of the house value after that.

In any case the house may have to be used up in care home fees for all they know and there will be nothing left to inherit. Inheritance isn't a right.

lottiegarbanzo · 15/07/2021 10:00

So, your parents need to talk about this, gather all relevant information (especially about your brother's future care needs, living expenses and benefit entitlements), seek advice, discuss, then see a solicitor.

This is a technically complex case. No-one here can solve that at a few strokes of a keyboard.

Morally, your dad is setting himself up to fail and cause huge heartache and resentment. What a way to be remembered. Your mum needs to address that.

FlorenceinSummer · 15/07/2021 09:57

Get your mum to get her own legal advice. This could end up messier going forward based on his attitude change.

This happened with DB and me, mum and stepdad agreed to share the house 3 ways between DB, me and step brother, all good. Mum got sick, stepdad started changing his mind about how it was split (hinting that step bro should get it all) so mum ended up changing the deeds to tenants in common (I think) (so that when she died she could leave her 50% share how she wanted (i.e. to my brother and I and that SD lived in the house until he passed)) and he could do what he wanted with his half (leave it to his son). It all kicked off after mum died as he thought he could change his will to leave the entire house to his son - cutting my DB and I out completely. Thanks to mums foresight that wasn't the case.

knittingaddict · 15/07/2021 09:57

@AquaTorfana

Move this to legal issues. Providing that much money to the deposit on the house means you could have a legal stake if you act now and take legal action to recoup your costs.
On what basis? In England I can't think of one or is it that you think their should be. That won't help the op much.
lottiegarbanzo · 15/07/2021 09:55

Also, given that statistically, your dad is likely to die first, it's in his interests to come to a mutually acceptable agreement with your Mum and for them to write mirror wills. Once he's gone, she is free to cut out the half siblings. His behaviour now is handing her the motivation to do that.

LondonLife3 · 15/07/2021 09:53

I would work out the sum you contributed and ask for a charge of that value to be placed on the house, that way your money is returned before anyone else takes a %

lottiegarbanzo · 15/07/2021 09:51

Your mum has the power here surely? If they own the house together, it isn't his to give away.

Your Mum needs to speak up and exert her power. She needs to protect her children. That matters much more than her discomfort at doing so.

SilverOak · 15/07/2021 09:50

OP have your parents refunded the amount you paid towards the deposit? If not then you’re entitled to have that money back. If they won’t refund you then get a solicitor.

Regarding the house - it’s a bit of a moot point because nobody knows what’s going to happen in the future, there might be nothing to inherit. DF is older so will probably die first and the house will go to DM. She can then will it to anyone she wants, and if she dies without a will then your half siblings won’t get a penny. But she may end up needing care so the home would take the house and nobody would inherit anything.

Under the circumstances I’d take steps to recover the deposit and then just wait and see what happens.

SmokeyDevil · 15/07/2021 09:41

@Movingonupupup

Ring fence your money. Ask for extra money for care -talk to him with a solicitor.

Ultimately F can probably legally do what he wants BUT -this is the issue with family. Consult a solicitor.

I don't get on with my parents -but they seem to want me to care for them -they are 80 plus now on the grounds on my inheritance -if I do it, it will be not expecting anything in return as this is the legal position.

I thought you could only ring fence at the time of signing deeds? Plus you'd need the dads permission now to do that I imagine, unlikely to do it given his stance now.
Porcupineintherough · 15/07/2021 09:40

However much the OP's initial input was, it was only possible to purchase at that price due to her parents long-standing tenancy. So not so clear as "she paid, its hers". Its also not clear whether her parents paid a mortgage to finance the balance of the purchase, or how much the house has appreciated in value since. Certainly the idea that the house should be hers and 25% go to her brother is iffy, if he cant live independently he'll need some sort of trust fund or all inheritance will do is score up his entitlement to benefits.

LumpyandBumps · 15/07/2021 09:39

Ah,
I have just realised OP only paid 75% of the deposit, which makes my post incorrect

Movingonupupup · 15/07/2021 09:36

Ring fence your money. Ask for extra money for care -talk to him with a solicitor.

Ultimately F can probably legally do what he wants BUT -this is the issue with family. Consult a solicitor.

I don't get on with my parents -but they seem to want me to care for them -they are 80 plus now on the grounds on my inheritance -if I do it, it will be not expecting anything in return as this is the legal position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread