Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To my half siblings shouldn’t get 50% of my parent’s house?

282 replies

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 01:06

Paternal half siblings. They are 20 and 22 years older than me. Their mum joint owns with their stepdad and she was better off after the divorce as he left her the house. Me and my full brother raised in social housing as my mum and dad always struggled for money.

My parents ended up expressing a wish to purchase their property with Right To Buy in my late teens. They had a fair amount saved up but nowhere near enough. The property is in a desirable area and I saw it as a steal to get it with the Right To Buy Discount, so I agreed to save up and then give the money to my parents to use to be able to use Right To Buy. I ended up providing about 75% of the money (it took a good few years and meant I spent bugger all on fun and delayed my own life events) used for it. My full sibling has a learning disability and can’t live independently. The deal between me, my mum and dad was if I helped them to be able to buy the house, once they go I could have it and use 25% of the money on supporting my brother. None of the house is mine legally but we knew it’d benefit me and my brother in future if I helped them buy it now.

This was a few years ago. DF has now decided to write a will, he isn’t ill but wants to in the event of a sudden death. He has decided he’d feel guilty doing the original plan and excluding his older children. He now wants us to have 25% of the house each. He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free. I’ve not expressed this to him but I’m quite annoyed. My mum was also the bigger contributor for their portion of the deposit out of the 2 of them. I also know that when they go, all of the care for DB will go on me. I’ve already been told I’ll be his power of attorney, will manage his money etc. My half siblings are significantly older with their own well established lives. Mum is upset as well but doesn’t want to rock the boat.

Aibu to think DF is being unfair?

OP posts:
BackAwayFatty · 15/07/2021 16:48

I can only imagine your frustrations of your dad changing his mind.

100% agree you should seek legal advice. I think as a minimum it's fair that you get your deposit back & then the remainder is split between all siblings.

Roodicus21 · 15/07/2021 16:43

Is there not a paper trail for the money you gave? I know that when I got a gift off my parents towards a deposit they had to write a letter which I gave to the mortgage company saying it was a gift and there wouldn't be any recourse. Did you do similar?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2021 16:42

That was another option as well, keeping the property as a ‘base’ for me as DB so to speak. A bit would have been remortgaged for half siblings

Given that would mean a mortgage for 50% of an already expensive property, could you afford it - especially if your earning capacity was limited by DB's care needs if you decided to take this on?

And what would you do if the half siblings start pressurising you to sell in order to release the capital for them?

Zilla1 · 15/07/2021 16:41

When you front up your DF, OP, ask him and your DM when they decided their current position was fair? Was it recently and did they previously agree the split with your DB and you was fair? If not, did they always intend for you to fund most of the deposit, contribute to the mortgage but to have equal shares? If so, why didn't they say this?

Ask them to set out their intentions regarding your DB? If they intend you to continue, how would that work when the place needs to be sold to give their other DC 25% each? If you get hit by a bus, will the other DC step up?

It might make them uncomfortable but try and make them unpick their thinking.

Good luck.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2021 16:36

I wonder if this was DF’s intention all along

It's possible - I know someone in a very similar position where it certainly was - but you're past that now and he'll certainly never admit it

I mean the next bit a lot more kindly than it'll probably sound, but I'm afraid it sounds as if you're still being pretty naive; indeed some might even say you're making a mug of yourself, particularly over your DB. Of course you want him to be properly cared for, but that doesn't necessarily mean it has to be by you, and certainly not just because "they expect it"

How would you do that anyway, with 25% of the house proceeds and another suitable one to buy in an expensive area? And that's assuming your DPs don't have to spend it all on care for themselves

Time, I'd suggest, to start prioritising your own needs rather than dancing to their tune any further

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 16:32

That was another option as well, keeping the property as a ‘base’ for me as DB so to speak. A bit would have been remortgaged for half siblings.

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 15/07/2021 16:28

OP, please don't settle for the £42k back. Think of the opportunity cost. You might not have been able to afford their house without the Right to Buy discount but you might have used the deposit and income for smaller place that would be worth much more. Or you might have been able to study and have a much more lucrative career. It won't be easy but you might need to front up your DM and DF separately. And, although you know you would not leave your DB in the lurch, ask them what their plans are for his care rather than let them get away with assuming you'll do this.

Good luck.

Hankunamatata · 15/07/2021 16:25

Make sure there is legal protection in place for yourself and your brother that you can both live in the property until your death

Soontobe60 · 15/07/2021 16:25

[quote RincewindsHat]@soontobe60 you must be one of the OP's parents! It's not grabby, it's how asset appreciation works. The £42k was not a gift. It was an investment on the OP's part with the understanding she would eventually inherit 75% of the property. If that had not been the case, the money would not have been handed over. Her father is the grabby ungrateful one here.[/quote]
Why would she inherit 75%? She didn’t pay 75%, she paid 14%. At best she may be entitled to 14% of the total value of the property and the rest split equally between all the siblings. On a property with a value of £500k, that would give her £177,500 and her siblings £107000. Not a bad return on her money I’d say.

Thehop · 15/07/2021 16:20

Or tell them to deduct your rent for the months you lived there from the £42k, add interest at bank rates and that’s what they owe you, then the balance can split 25% each

Thehop · 15/07/2021 16:19

Your dad has played a right blunder here, the bastard.

Get in touch with land registry and register your interest in the house as your 42k

mm8989 · 15/07/2021 16:18

42K is a huge amount of money.If the house was valued at 300K all those year ago, i'm guessing you are in London and its worth 700K+ now?

Your dad is just seeing that amount and thinking he can be the big man giving everyone a huge chunk of money. You need to forget about what your half siblings have received, that's not relevant.

It's not OK, I can see why you are aggrieved. however a 42K investment wouldn't have bought you the house.

Personally i'd be withdrawing all offers to help DB, until they return the 42K (they can't they don't have the cash) or they allowed a charge against the house. He's not your child and its not your duty to care for him. Strong words with your mother may help, does she want to die knowing no one is looking out for DB?

You can challenge the will, but it would be a nightmare, better to get your mum on board. Unfortunately this will always sour your view on you dad.

If you post the actual figures, someone can help you work out what is a fair appreciation for the investment.

Thiscantreallybehappening · 15/07/2021 16:14

@reannneeee
Once they are no longer capable it’s on me. I never offered, it’s expected of me. And I’d never abandon DB. I will absolutely make sure he gets the best care. DB’s future is a massive worry of mine.

That isn't fair either. Your parents need to acknowledge the situation with your DB and put plans in place. OP, I know you are saying you wouldn't abandon your DB and I know you mean that but you don't know what life is going to throw at you. It really isn't right that you are carrying this massive worry. Your DF is not acknowledging your contribution and the difficulties with your DB and your DM is not being assertive. Please get some legal advice.

maddening · 15/07/2021 16:13

Can you register an equitable interest against the property now?

quizqueen · 15/07/2021 16:06

You should have protected your contribution to house deposit in the first place by ring fencing it, I'm afraid, and your sibling will probably be looked after by the state if he has severe special needs so won't benefit from any inheritance. However, you dad only owns half the house so he can only leave half its value in his will, as he sees fit, as your mum owns the other half.

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 16:06

DB currently lives with them. They get his DLA and make his medical decisions.

Once they are no longer capable it’s on me. I never offered, it’s expected of me. And I’d never abandon DB. I will absolutely make sure he gets the best care. DB’s future is a massive worry of mine.

OP posts:
maddening · 15/07/2021 16:05

He can pay you back what you put in to the house and then leave it 25.% to each of you. That is not his money to go giving people imo.

Thiscantreallybehappening · 15/07/2021 16:04

@reannneeee

What plans are they putting in place for your DB?

Do you have any proof of your investment?

If you make an appointment to get some legal advice your DF might realise that you are serious and that you need some return for your contribution.

If your mum agrees with you, she should be talking to your DF about this.

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 16:03

I wonder if this was DF’s intention all along and I feel really used.

He does have guilt over his elder 2 daughter’s. He had them 50/50, saw them right financially etc. They say that themselves. This was before I was even born. But the divorce was down to him being unfaithful to their mum (not with my mum, years before) and I don’t think he’s ever gotten over the guilt.

It isn’t my fault though. Or my mum’s or brother’s. He tricked us.

OP posts:
reannneeee · 15/07/2021 16:00

I was only 18 when it all started and quite naive.

OP posts:
reannneeee · 15/07/2021 15:58

It probably was stupid of me to expect 75% of the property, but that was the mutual agreement with my parents. They never stated otherwise at any point until DF made this decision.

I don’t even care about 75% anymore. I just want my contribution to them owning their house acknowledged. I want my 42k back as a minimum. And an apology from DF.

I don’t understand why he thinks this is okay.

OP posts:
AOwlAOwlAOwl · 15/07/2021 15:50

Sorry you need to go to a lawyer. How DARE your dad give away your money? And say that he let you live there rent free when your money paid for 75% of the house! He needs some home truths and you need legal advice.

I know it's hard but this is your life, you only get one, and you need to drive it, not your dad.

Twylar · 15/07/2021 15:50

If they are doing that get whatever you paid back off him

MrsMillhouse · 15/07/2021 15:47

OP I think what your father is doing is morally wrong. But I’m not a legal expert, and a lot of the folk on here won’t be (even if they have the best intentions or slight knowledge). Please go see a solicitor

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2021 15:42

DF won’t even consider giving me the 42k back and then splitting the rest 25% each because it’s not fair on half-sibs apparently

Have you tried pointing out that had it not been for you contribution they wouldn't have a house to bequeath at all?

As said, I'd tell your DF to either think again or make other future plans for your DB, whether you mean it or not ... though as I asked before, why are you so willing to take on all his care?