Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To my half siblings shouldn’t get 50% of my parent’s house?

282 replies

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 01:06

Paternal half siblings. They are 20 and 22 years older than me. Their mum joint owns with their stepdad and she was better off after the divorce as he left her the house. Me and my full brother raised in social housing as my mum and dad always struggled for money.

My parents ended up expressing a wish to purchase their property with Right To Buy in my late teens. They had a fair amount saved up but nowhere near enough. The property is in a desirable area and I saw it as a steal to get it with the Right To Buy Discount, so I agreed to save up and then give the money to my parents to use to be able to use Right To Buy. I ended up providing about 75% of the money (it took a good few years and meant I spent bugger all on fun and delayed my own life events) used for it. My full sibling has a learning disability and can’t live independently. The deal between me, my mum and dad was if I helped them to be able to buy the house, once they go I could have it and use 25% of the money on supporting my brother. None of the house is mine legally but we knew it’d benefit me and my brother in future if I helped them buy it now.

This was a few years ago. DF has now decided to write a will, he isn’t ill but wants to in the event of a sudden death. He has decided he’d feel guilty doing the original plan and excluding his older children. He now wants us to have 25% of the house each. He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free. I’ve not expressed this to him but I’m quite annoyed. My mum was also the bigger contributor for their portion of the deposit out of the 2 of them. I also know that when they go, all of the care for DB will go on me. I’ve already been told I’ll be his power of attorney, will manage his money etc. My half siblings are significantly older with their own well established lives. Mum is upset as well but doesn’t want to rock the boat.

Aibu to think DF is being unfair?

OP posts:
Billybagpuss · 15/07/2021 07:11

I’d also ask your dad where he expects your SN DB to live when the house is sold?

SherryPalmer · 15/07/2021 07:11

Are you certain that your half-siblings haven’t also been providing financial support over the years? We’ve paid MIL’s rent for years and nobody knows except her and us.

honeylulu · 15/07/2021 07:10

Solicitor here (not my area but I know a bit from law college days).
From what you have said it seems you are a beneficial owner of a share in the property, despite what the land registry says. This means that the legal owners (your parents) hold your share in trust and should not dispose of it.

I say "should not" because it will be down to you to prove it and that might be tricky without a written agreement, as you understandably trusted your dad to do the right thing/what he had agreed.

I agree that it will be worth spending a bit of money getting legal advice on what to do, unless you feel it is very clear. First, get together all the proof that you can - all evidence of you providing the 75% (bank records etc), any correspondence referring to the agreement etc. Your share can be protected from a future sale or transfer by entering a notice or restriction on the land register BUT if you dad/parents challenge it you will need to provide the evidence. This guide tells you a bit more:

www.gov.uk/government/publications/notices-restrictions-and-the-protection-of-third-party-interests-in-the-register/practice-guide-19-notices-restrictions-and-the-protection-of-third-party-interests-in-the-register

I think your dad has behaved like an utter shit and your mum should challenge him but it sounds like she won't. His excuse "we let you live here for free" is bullshit. Your parents also lived there themselves "for free". You have already paid for the right to live there AND the right to own a fair share beneficially.

Eviethyme · 15/07/2021 07:05

No that isn't right, you should get your share back of what you purchased and then the rest split.

At the end of the day your going to be getting that house but your half siblings have another set of parents to inherit off.... Its not fair and I wouldnt be silent about it.

It's a shame your father is sabataging his relationship with you right at the end but also let me guess. He gets old and needs care and it'll be you they go to

Manista · 15/07/2021 07:03

My partner helped his Dad to buy the council house they both lived in. An agreement was drawn up making them tenants in common with my partner owning 100% of the house as he paid deposit and took out a mortgage for the rest. His dad lived there but never contributed to the mortgage or other bills. In his will he left his "share" to my partner. It didn't stop partner's sister trying to get her grubby hands on 50% when dad died, but she didn't succeed. It did however take me a lot of time kicking the executor solicitors and used up all of the money in his dad's savings (which had been left to the sister so kind of served her right as she got nothing in the end). I am shocked that the solicitor dealing with this for you wasn't more vigilant in setting up something to protect at least your 75% investment. Get legal advice immediately, and have a really frank conversation with your dad because on the face of it 75% of that house is rightfully yours. If you can get your dad to recognise the rights of this it's not too late to set up a proper legal arrangement to protect you. Act quickly.

CrouchEndTiger12 · 15/07/2021 07:01

They think letting you live rent free in a council house with cheaper rent was enough consideration for buying them a house?!

I would not have bought it unless the house went in my name and I would have allowed them to still live there.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 15/07/2021 06:58

He wouldn't have a house to leave without your very substantial contribution, which you made on the particular understanding that the property would ultimately be yours and your brother's.

You need a solicitor - but posing this in legal will let you know where you stand more clearly.

Billybagpuss · 15/07/2021 06:57

Also have his dc been putting any pressure on him?

Ledgeofglory · 15/07/2021 06:56

Do you have proof of your original money transfer etc

Schmoana · 15/07/2021 06:54

Do your mum and step dad have 50:50 ownership? If yes he can make his own will for his half, and your mum make a will for her half. You have no say at all in what happens but you could try reasoning with them. If your mum goes first without a will her side of the money would probably go to him. She should probably leave her half to you and your brother, in trust so that step dad can continue to live in it.

If he gets her half, he could then change his will to give it all to just his biological kids so you get nothing at all.

I’m not a lawyer but if you didn’t give them the money as a loan with paperwork I’d be very surprised if you now have any legal claim. It’s pants but you were too trusting.

Uramaki · 15/07/2021 06:50

I think it's because you've paid so much money into it and are looking after DB after their death that this is so wrong. Not because they are half siblings.

Zilla1 · 15/07/2021 06:49

Is he proposing mirror wills or will his plan be dependent on your DM passing first or do they own the house as tenants in commons (as opposed to joint tenants when his share will pass to your DM)? It may be is his passes first and isn't aware, the issue might go away if your DM isn't willing to rock the boat. His decision is entirely inappropriate. He could equally be said to have lived in your 75% of the house without paying rent to you if that is his argument.

Good luck and let's hope your DM fronts him up.

Cooldryplace · 15/07/2021 06:47

I don't know. I can see you point, but I absolutely hate it when children of council tenants "see a steal" and try to play the system in the expectation that they will inherit much more than they paid for and deprive future generations of much needed housing, so I can have limited sympathy, I'm afraid.

HumousWhereTheHeartIs · 15/07/2021 06:46

There's always lots of legal advice on this threads but this could all be wholly incorrect, depending where you live. Where I live, you can't disinherit your children at all. Your mum could legally disinherit her step-children, though.

newnortherner111 · 15/07/2021 06:44

YANBU to feel upset even if all that your DF intends is perfectly legal.

DeciduousPerennial · 15/07/2021 06:39

You and your mother both need to rock the boat by reminding him that he has gone back on a pretty significant agreement. This isn’t about rent: you not paying rent enabled them to buy that house by allowing you to save and give them your money. You both also need to remind him that whilst this was a private agreement, in law, you may actually have rights because of providing money for the deposit so it may not be as simple as he thinks, or remain a private agreement. He also needs to remember that it’s not just his house - your mum has a say too, and she’s clearly not happy.

It’s not about ‘the money’; it’s about what’s right, especially considering you have a sibling with care needs and this arrangement factored that in.

Basically, he’s being an arse. Your mum is being avoidant and weak. You’re not being unreasonable and you do need legal advice. Then you both need to tell him take his head out of his arse.

CrikeyPeg · 15/07/2021 06:34

Oh no, that's not fair at all. Maybe talk to a lawyer first, to get an idea of you could possibly do and, depending on what sort of a relationship you have with him, take it from there.

Mummyoflittledragon · 15/07/2021 06:29

I also think you need lawyer advice. They may be able to help you try to engage with him in writing to get him to admit you gave him money based on the agreement. This is awful.

Your parents actually should have succession planned a long time ago to ensure the money from the house isn’t eaten up in care home fees. Shame on him.

Goldielow · 15/07/2021 06:29

There's no nice way to go about it other than being straight with him and saying you invested a lot in that house and you find it unforgivable for your father to even consider not giving you the bulk of the house if something should happen. Fair enough for any savings he has, he can split those 4 ways if he wishes. But if you invested in the house you need to be upfront. If he's really determined I don't know legally how much you can do. Something similar happened with a woman I worked with when her mother and her and gone halves to buy the council house they shared but in her mum's name and it was knowing she would get it when her mum died, her mum instead wanted to sell the house after a while and buy another house but split that one between all her other children in the will not seeing that the money should have been half her daughter's. She got legal advice and was told she didn't have a claim because her name was nowhere in writing and it would have cost a lot to go to court.
So unless you had some kind of contract as evidence I'd say it might be difficult for you to prove this.
Just the threat of legal action could cause a huge family bust up that you don't want and then lead nowhere. Your best bet IMO is to speak to your father and be upfront about how angry you are.

Billybagpuss · 15/07/2021 06:02

What does your mum say about all of this and do you still have proof of your original savings?

Uramaki · 15/07/2021 06:00

Get legal advice

Sciurus83 · 15/07/2021 05:54

Rock the boat!!

HeartIess · 15/07/2021 05:35

Can’t believe that right to buy is still continuing 🙄

fourminutestosavetheworld · 15/07/2021 05:02

Also, a £5000 contribution - or whatever it was - does not warrant a 100% (or 75% if 25% goes to your brother) share in a house that will be worth hundreds of thousands by the time of inheritance. What was your deposit contribution as a % of value at the time? That same % should be ringfenced imo.

fourminutestosavetheworld · 15/07/2021 04:57

For me, it depends how much money you provided so that they could take advantage of the Right to Buy, and how long you have lived rent free.

Has the will been finalised? When it comes to it, his solicitor may have some fairer suggestions for him.

It would be usual, on his death, for your mum to be able to live there for the rest of her life. Then, upon her death, 50% is split between her two children and 50% is split between your dad's four children.

I do think that your contribution to the deposit should have been ringfenced. But did you provide £5000 and live rent free for ten years or did you provide £30,000 last year? I think the amounts are important.

Of course your dad wants to leave something to his other two children, who he loves just as much as you and your brother. It would be very unfair imo, on his death, for them to receive no inheritance from his estate.

It is not for you to decide that they are unworthy because they are older and have well established lives, or because they will also inherit from their mother. You cannot know their financial situation and it is irrelevant anyway - your dad wants to leave something for all of his children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread