Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To my half siblings shouldn’t get 50% of my parent’s house?

282 replies

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 01:06

Paternal half siblings. They are 20 and 22 years older than me. Their mum joint owns with their stepdad and she was better off after the divorce as he left her the house. Me and my full brother raised in social housing as my mum and dad always struggled for money.

My parents ended up expressing a wish to purchase their property with Right To Buy in my late teens. They had a fair amount saved up but nowhere near enough. The property is in a desirable area and I saw it as a steal to get it with the Right To Buy Discount, so I agreed to save up and then give the money to my parents to use to be able to use Right To Buy. I ended up providing about 75% of the money (it took a good few years and meant I spent bugger all on fun and delayed my own life events) used for it. My full sibling has a learning disability and can’t live independently. The deal between me, my mum and dad was if I helped them to be able to buy the house, once they go I could have it and use 25% of the money on supporting my brother. None of the house is mine legally but we knew it’d benefit me and my brother in future if I helped them buy it now.

This was a few years ago. DF has now decided to write a will, he isn’t ill but wants to in the event of a sudden death. He has decided he’d feel guilty doing the original plan and excluding his older children. He now wants us to have 25% of the house each. He says that my financial support in making it possible for them to buy the house is negated by the fact that they let me live there rent free. I’ve not expressed this to him but I’m quite annoyed. My mum was also the bigger contributor for their portion of the deposit out of the 2 of them. I also know that when they go, all of the care for DB will go on me. I’ve already been told I’ll be his power of attorney, will manage his money etc. My half siblings are significantly older with their own well established lives. Mum is upset as well but doesn’t want to rock the boat.

Aibu to think DF is being unfair?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wegobshite · 20/07/2021 06:48

I think You can severe the tennancy and create a lifetime trust so the other parent can live in the house and it can’t be sold
My parents did this and when my mum died me and my sister got her half of the house but my dad was able to still live in the house
Now he’s about to go into a care home and the house will be sold
My sister and I will get our half and dads half will be used to fund his care
Mumblechum ( Marlowe Wills) did this for us a few years ago
But this only really works if one of the parents dies in the op case it would need to be the mother so that the OP inherits the mums half

if they both live long enough to need go into a care home then the OP gets nothing

reannneeee · 19/07/2021 21:43

Oh ffs bloody brilliant

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 16/07/2021 02:51

My initial thought on the idea of severing a joint tenancy was great. But what happens if ops dad dies first and the 2 step children each holding 1/8 share demand part of the property while op’s mUm is dtill alive?

You don’t need to pay to have a legal document drawn up to sever a joint tenancy. A letter making this clear to the other party will suffice. Plus informing the land registry via .form SEV. More info online.

timeisnotaline · 15/07/2021 23:50

@reannneeee

DF says I’ll probably get more than the money I put back in from price rises anyway so doesn’t see what I’m ‘moaning’ about. DB and half siblings will get the same so happy days Confused Doesn’t see why I’d want the £42k back when I’ll probably get more in my 25% share. It isn’t fair though. DB wasn’t able to help them by the house, my half siblings didn’t (not that they did anything wrong in not doing so), I helped them! They point blank wouldn’t own it without me!

And me getting more than my 42k from my 25% share isn’t guaranteed. They could decide to build bloody HS2 100 metres away for all we know. I know I should have considered that back when I decided to do this but I was only 18. They say me down and said “Would you like to help us do this as a great investment for your future?”.

I am so angry.

Wow. They manipulated their barely adult child into buying them a house and your dad now wants to trick you out of your fair share. I’d go nuclear- not sure I’d care about the relationship with a dad who can do that. I hope you can express how you feel.
GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 19:44

[quote RoseMartha]Your parents could sever the joint tenancy. They would need to have legal document drawn up.

Then your mum should be able to leave her half to you. Your dad can divide his into 4.

www.geoffreylurie.com/property-ownership-query-joint-tenancy-whether-to-sever/[/quote]
Seems the most sensible suggestion.
Is your Mum on your side, op?

RoseMartha · 15/07/2021 19:39

Your parents could sever the joint tenancy. They would need to have legal document drawn up.

Then your mum should be able to leave her half to you. Your dad can divide his into 4.

www.geoffreylurie.com/property-ownership-query-joint-tenancy-whether-to-sever/

whatthejiggeries · 15/07/2021 18:14

This happened in my family but my aunt drew up a legal agreement as to her share of the ownership. If you didn't do that I'm not sure what you can do but your DF is being unreasonable. I think at the very least you should have your mothers 50 percent between you and you half sibling and then the other 50 percent split into four. I would take legal advice now

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 17:42

‘But also once my parents go I don’t think they’d refuse the money which is fair enough because who would?‘

By that I mean if DF got his way and they got 25% each. Not the original plan, their share would be theirs fair and square in that case.

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 15/07/2021 17:42

@reannneeee

I don’t think they’ll get the mortgage paid off or that close to it tbh though. But that’s not relevant to how the equity of what is paid of gets shared out.
Never get mortgage paid off? What makes you think that?

When did all this happen?
What was length of mortgage?

It would be odd for them to have been sold a mortgage that goes beyond an age at which they could pay it off. Are you sure?

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 17:40

I’m not close to my half-siblings due to the age gap but when we do see each other we get on fine. They aren’t grabby and AFAIK they don’t even know of DF’s plans. They know I helped with the house deposit.

They absolutely are entitled to some of their DF’s estate and they would have gotten their fair share. I presume they are expecting a proportionate amount of their dad’s half of the house with the knowledge in mind that me and my mum are the main contributors. But also once my parents go I don’t think they’d refuse the money which is fair enough because who would?

So I don’t think they’d insist DF is right. They aren’t that type. I don’t know whether I’d want to drag them into all of this though when it’s a dispute that could go on for years to come.

OP posts:
OhNoNoNoNoNo · 15/07/2021 17:33

Is there any chance you could speak to your step siblings and see if they would back you up.

Cvxnnjj · 15/07/2021 17:33

You are right to seek legal advice.

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 17:20

If I knew DF would fuck me over like this I really wouldn’t have bothered.

I can’t save up for my own property now. I now rent and have bills to pay and have a child. My chance has been and gone because I helped my parents under a false promise.

Perhaps I will get legal help. I felt it’ll likely be a non-issue as DM is younger than him but if they both died suddenly next (god forbid) week I’d be snookered.

OP posts:
reannneeee · 15/07/2021 17:14

I don’t think they’ll get the mortgage paid off or that close to it tbh though. But that’s not relevant to how the equity of what is paid of gets shared out.

OP posts:
diddl · 15/07/2021 17:13

Well it could be that 25%-when you get it! could be more than you paid in.

I'm in my late 50s & only recently lost my remaining parent.

House was sold for care fees.

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 17:12

It was always meant to be:

I help them with the deposit=I make money from the house when they go hopefully with no/not that much mortgage left by then, use some money to support DB and give half-sibs a fair amount too.

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 15/07/2021 17:11

You won't be complaining when you ask leading questions, OP. When did he decide this? Did he always think this? Why didn't he tell you as soon as he knew this was his decision? How much would a small place be worth that you could have funded with a £42k deposit? Would there be any inheritance to give to your step=siblings if you hadn't contributed to most of the deposit and to the mortgage? How is it fair to give 25% to four people, only one of whom funded most of the deposit and contributed to the mortgage? What are their plans for DB? Where will DB live when the property is sold to give 50% to the two other siblings? Ask detailed questions requiring factual answers so he has to own this. Did your step-siblings get a deposit given to them?

Get your DM to repeat those answers so she owns them or disagrees with them.

Good luck.

GreyhoundG1rl · 15/07/2021 17:04

@reannneeee

I was only 18 when it all started and quite naive.
He's an absolute dick to allow his 18 year old dd to finance his deposit, I won't argue against that.
Charley50 · 15/07/2021 17:00

I don't blame you for being angry, but you need to take action. Presumably there is a paper trail of your money leaving your bank account and going into theirs. If not get your dad to acknowledge this in an email as 'evidence.' Don't tell him. Then get legal advice. You don't need to go in hard with solicitors, but it will really help you decide what action to take. You obviously don't want your relationship with your parents to break down, but you also don't want to continue to be walked over.
Yes you only could have bought a small place of your own with that money initially, but it would have acted as a springboard to the next, bigger, place.
Although it's very hurtful, try and take emotion out of it now, and see what legally you are entitled to regardless of future inheritance.

JacquelineCarlyle · 15/07/2021 16:56

You should as a minimum get the £42k back and then 25%! Can't believe he can't see that!

FWIW, I think you should get much more, but at the very least you should get your money back and then your inheritance share.

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 16:56

I have complained to DF a bit but haven’t pushed it.

Mentioned that I’m not happy but haven’t expressed to him I feel he’s planned it, I’m pretty sure he has though.

OP posts:
Mickarooni · 15/07/2021 16:56

@reannneeee

This is very important, please read.

If your parents leave any assets to your brother and he needs social care, the assets will be taken into consideration when he is financially assessed. If, for example, it is decided he needs to move into supported living accommodation, part ownership of a property will mean he may be required to pay for some or all of his care. Currently, anyone who has property (that they’re not currently living in), shares or savings etc over £23,250 will be expected to pay for their care.
You need specific legal advice for this matter.

reannneeee · 15/07/2021 16:54

DF says I’ll probably get more than the money I put back in from price rises anyway so doesn’t see what I’m ‘moaning’ about. DB and half siblings will get the same so happy days Confused Doesn’t see why I’d want the £42k back when I’ll probably get more in my 25% share. It isn’t fair though. DB wasn’t able to help them by the house, my half siblings didn’t (not that they did anything wrong in not doing so), I helped them! They point blank wouldn’t own it without me!

And me getting more than my 42k from my 25% share isn’t guaranteed. They could decide to build bloody HS2 100 metres away for all we know. I know I should have considered that back when I decided to do this but I was only 18. They say me down and said “Would you like to help us do this as a great investment for your future?”.

I am so angry.

OP posts:
JacquelineCarlyle · 15/07/2021 16:48

Oh Op, that's awful of your DF - I'd see a solicitor if I were you to establish your legal rights and see if there's a way to get your contribution to the deposit ring-fenced. From the sounds of it, you'll need that money to look after your DB in the future so if you don't want to do it for yourself, do it for him. Good luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread