Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letting someone fail at work - aibu to let it happen?

182 replies

MrsBede · 14/07/2021 17:38

In brief, I have a deputy who has failed to perform since appointment. I have followed all procedures to deal with this but my organisation is poorly led and I have limited support from those above - eg I should have a line manager but the post is vacant. We're public sector.

A senior manager has now told me my deputy needs to be given a project to lead on and when it flops it will be the point at which the lack of performance is finally dealt with. It's horrible, but the team and our clients are being detrimentally affected by this person's lack of competence so it has to happen - I've tried so much to bring them on but they just haven't responded.

So the project has been explained to them and they have got started. There are already issues becoming apparent but they have now sent me details of their next steps and it's really poor. Do I intervene or just let it play out? It will be a fuck up (not dangerous or anything) and should bring things to a head, but what if they come back and say they ran it past me first and I didn't voice concerns?

My problem is lack of support from above but there is none, so MN - please help!

OP posts:
ToastieSnowy · 14/07/2021 18:14

You need to give feedback on their next steps and offer suggestions for improvement. That way if they fail to take the suggestions it’s poor performance on their part. Withholding that feedback would be poor management on your part.

NoiceDifferentUnusual · 14/07/2021 18:14

Setting up someone specifically to fail is weak, unprofessional and cruel. I’m public sector of many years and I’ve never heard of this tactic - in fact, it could result in them having a case against you. Have you asked this person how well supported they feel?

Unsoliciteddeckpic · 14/07/2021 18:13

but what if they come back and say they ran it past me first and I didn't voice concerns?

I have seen really poor performers, go into quarter reviews and come out with top marks because they come evidence exactly this. They had evidence they sought feed back and guidance and it wasnt mentioned.

And then, their manager ends up being the one with a verbal warning.

Whatever you think op, you would be doing your job, if you ignore this.

Igmum · 14/07/2021 18:13

Speak to HR. Document the fact that you have spoken to HR. Give them feedback. Provide your manager and HR with a report detailing what they were going to do, why it is poor and what you advised them to do. Frankly they probably won't do it. I can see your dilemma but, as this person's line manager, unless you have explicit written instructions not to comment (which I would query) I think you have to respond. Feel free to say in your report on this that this person SHOULD have been able to run this project alone.

SheilaWilcox · 14/07/2021 18:12

The thing with following the capability procedure fairly, is that by the time you get to dismissal, you can hand on heart say you have given them every opportunity and support to improve their performance, but they are just not CAPABLE of doing the role. Letting them fall flat on their face leaves you open to them saying they received no support. They could also claim they can't have been doing badly as they were trusted to take on a project on their own.
If you don't want to help them (as their manager I think this is unwise,) then you could reply saying that you don't think their plan will fulfil the project brief and you think they should take another look at it before proceeding, that way, you're not approving or ignoring.

Another thing to bear in mind, is that most people WANT to do a good job. They may know they are not performing and be thoroughly miserable. That alone can lead to people feeling paralysed and lacking enough confidence to perform.

Imagine if it were you. What would you want from your boss?

AlexaShutUp · 14/07/2021 18:11

Sounds like terrible management from above you tbh. Staff being treated like shit and public money being wilfully wasted!

If you stand by and knowingly allow the project to fail, then you will be failing in your duty as a line manager. If the employee later tries to appeal on the grounds that he/she was set up to fail and wasn't given appropriate support, then you will struggle to defend yourself against those allegations.

You need to take the employee through a proper capability process - one that is fair and transparent. Be clear about your expectations, and the potential consequences of not meeting them, and then document and feed back where they are not adequately met. If you have concerns about the project that this person is leading on, then address those concerns properly and try to get things back on track, but document your intervention and make it clear that you would have expected the postholder to operate at that level without such a high level of support.

Talia99 · 14/07/2021 18:11

If they try and go after her for errors, she will produce the email to you and you will get the blame from her. If she has any sort of decent union, you and your manager will get shredded for setting her up.

Blowingagale · 14/07/2021 18:09

OP I can imagine that management may rate you. However if this went to an employment tribunal and the management of this employee was criticised then they might change their tune. (Not saying you are doing the wrong thing just an outsider might see it differently.)

I think you are right to get everything in writing. Make sure that you have followed and documented procedures that you have followed. If you are in a union then you might want to discuss with them. Also maybe put in writing somewhere to management that you need more direct line management.

Terminallysleepdeprived · 14/07/2021 18:08

You might find yourselves up for constructive dismissal if you do what you are proposing.

Legally you have to document performance reviews and support to bring the person up to competence before going down the dismissal route. I would make sure everything is done correctly or you could find yourself in trouble

I suggest seeking professional guidance from acas or the likes to protect yourself

Raaaaaaarr · 14/07/2021 18:08

So this person has been set up to fail? This is so unprofessional on so many levels. Why hasn't a performance improvement plan been put in place? This is a very odd approach to a performance issue and I'd want no part of it from a professional standpoint. It's actually quite dark.

seepingweeping · 14/07/2021 18:07

Who will be affected by the fuck up? Employees? Children? Other managers? Will it cause a massive dip in staff morale?

Do they not have a performance review? Have they been trained properly with consistent and current ongoing training?

gamerchick · 14/07/2021 18:07

I wouldn't. He's obviously covering his back and it's a pretty shady way to deal with an employee to get rid of them.

You're can't ignore his mistakes if he's sent them to you to check over first.

chickenyhead · 14/07/2021 18:06

Have they been adequately trained?

Do you have evidence of this?

Unless adequate training and settling in is provided, it will be you who takes the flack.

Civil service 20 years.

warmfluffytowels · 14/07/2021 18:06

As their manager, what have you put in place to help them? You say they've gone through capability twice, but what does that mean exactly?

MoiraNotRuby · 14/07/2021 18:06

Maybe you could say you don't have time to review it (due to other projects or holiday or something) and get the senior person to be a point of contact whilst you are temporarily unavailable? I think you are caught in the middle of an impossible situation and need to side step.

TiddyAndFletch · 14/07/2021 18:05

That doesn't sound like an effective way of managing performance, either for the colleague or your organisation as a whole. Someone will be left to clean up the mess, needlessly duplicating hours of work.

Unsoliciteddeckpic · 14/07/2021 18:04

As a head of department, I think its a really shitty thing to do. Assuming this person is a direct report of yours, It absolutely would reflect on you and I would expect to see complete capabilities to show you and done everything you can to avoid a project failure. They have updated you and you are managing them.

Or, I would want it on writing that the senior manager told you to not intervene. And then it would back fire on the senior manager.

If this person doesn't even have completed capabilities, it's very unlikely they havebhad the support they need at all. If the company is shit, it means you aren't getting the support to sort this employee out and they aren't getting support to be better.

Its entirely possible this person would be much better, in a better environment.

This senior manager has put you in a very poor position.

updownroundandround · 14/07/2021 18:04

I'd definitely be seeking written instructions which detail the previous concerns about capability, as well as the instruction to then give this employee the 'lead'.

I'd also be documenting details of previous training and learning opportunities given to this employee, as well as detailing the various 'steps' they have shown you in their action plan and all the 'interventions' required by you to 'correct' all misconceptions/ gaps/ reminders of protocols and procedures etc

I don't think that giving the employee a task that you know they are unable to do in order for them to 'fail' before being able to begin any capability procedures is helpful.

The employee should be consulted along with HR, and any concerns re capability voiced, as well as a definitive plan to help support them, with an appropriate timescale in place. There may be more going on with the employee than you are aware of (illness/ divorce/ death/ mental health/ domestic violence etc etc), which should all be considered.

If the employee then fails to meet the agreed targets within the agreed timescale, this can be documented and the employee eventually let go. But it's a long road, and you need to ensure that you have ensured that you have followed the correct procedure and been supportive throughout the whole process.

TerribleZebra · 14/07/2021 18:03

I was in exactly the same position OP. Told to let someone fail becsuse that was the only way my manager thought HR would pay attention - they knew but wouldn't deal with the problem. I couldn't do it as it would have reflected very badly on me and others so I spent a year picking up the mess and raising the issues with HR, whilst finding another job. I no longer work there and neither do many of my colleagues. The person who was /is failing is still in post

Blowingagale · 14/07/2021 18:02

Who does the project matter to? May not be life and death but I assume it has some value. It obviously takes at least some skill. Do one of your clients know that their work is being used and not done in the best/most timely manner? Assuming this is either a different department in public sector or someone private It isn’t their fault that you have poor management.

Get everything in writing. Also offer guidance- don’t take over but offer feedback on what they have planned otherwise what is the point of them running things past you? Yes as the Deputy I would feel set up because I was.

Is this person in any kind of capability management as you say that you have followed procedures? Are they meant to be supervised more rather than less?

How clear was the Deputy job description? Do you think this person knows that they are out of their depth?

Aquamarine1029 · 14/07/2021 18:01

I've tried so much to bring them on but they just haven't responded.

Eh? What has your response been to their lack of one? You've just allowed them to carry on without demanding answers as to why your directions/corrections aren't being followed? If they are that incompetent or arrogant, they should have been sacked long ago.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 14/07/2021 18:01

Send back a list of questions that would point them in the right direction if they were competent. If they fail to act on them you can say guidance was offered in a form that encouraged reflection and reassessment of the proposed approach without stepping in and taking over as this was a development opportunity for x.
Document everything and keep Senior Manager updated so they don’t have plausible deniability.

maddening · 14/07/2021 18:00

Also, their failure should not be a surprise to them, they shouldn't be presented with a failure to manage them out and this be the first they have heard.

Would it not be a case of calling out the issues as you go along?eg you have made these mistakes, why? Work through corrections off they go. Then the next fail point again call out the mistakes and explore, then correct. This would provide an audit trail of their fail points?

Rubyrecka · 14/07/2021 17:58

Isn't that a little negligent - Knowingly placing someone as the lead of a project when they've demonstrated they don't have the skill or competence to execute?

As it's public sector I would imagine that a business case will have been presented and the spend for the project justified so it seems a waste of public spend to knowingly allocate this to someone where it will fail. There has to be another way to deal with this persons performance issues.

HollowTalk · 14/07/2021 17:55

Has anyone checked that they were actually telling the truth when they applied for the job?

Swipe left for the next trending thread