Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letting someone fail at work - aibu to let it happen?

182 replies

MrsBede · 14/07/2021 17:38

In brief, I have a deputy who has failed to perform since appointment. I have followed all procedures to deal with this but my organisation is poorly led and I have limited support from those above - eg I should have a line manager but the post is vacant. We're public sector.

A senior manager has now told me my deputy needs to be given a project to lead on and when it flops it will be the point at which the lack of performance is finally dealt with. It's horrible, but the team and our clients are being detrimentally affected by this person's lack of competence so it has to happen - I've tried so much to bring them on but they just haven't responded.

So the project has been explained to them and they have got started. There are already issues becoming apparent but they have now sent me details of their next steps and it's really poor. Do I intervene or just let it play out? It will be a fuck up (not dangerous or anything) and should bring things to a head, but what if they come back and say they ran it past me first and I didn't voice concerns?

My problem is lack of support from above but there is none, so MN - please help!

OP posts:
Anon987654 · 14/07/2021 21:13

I think there's more to this.

Employee saying can't do right for doing wrong means you're inconsistent in your managing of them.... This is coming back to bite you for sure.

RealBecca · 14/07/2021 21:02

You and your colleague are both victims of shit management. If i was in your situatiin id be asking whoi was reporting to, ccing HR, and having a mediation meeting, formally noted by a third party on next steps to deal with capability. Like fuck would i be dealing woth poor perfornance without proper suppirt, its a nightmare at the best of times, never mind your circumstances in your DIS-Organisation.

Dontwatchfootball · 14/07/2021 21:00

Couldn't you use the fact you had to give so much feedback and input as evidence of the lack of competence? Something along the lines that you would not expect to have had so much input for someone at her level. That way you can help the project succeed but still hold them accountable for their lack of ability?

Griefmonster · 14/07/2021 20:46

@MrsBede You need support from above. You are being left to do the work that no-one else is willing to do and giving everyone higher up the chain and in HR plausible deniability. I will say honestly that if you don't get more support and back up you would be better off leaving. Your own mental health is already suffering. It will not get better as long as you are tackling this alone .

Poolbridge · 14/07/2021 20:45

I now have the good fortune of working for the second time in a workplace where I know I am supported by my colleagues and managers, and helped to succeed. To be in a collegiate, happy and supportive environment where you know your manager has your back, and you do what you can in return to support your colleagues, the workplace objectives and your managers work also - is a wonderful thing. I enjoy my work and it is a joy to attend now.

To set someone up to fail, and not assist them to succeed when they have especially asked for it, is disgraceful. It reminds me of some of my prior public sector roles with 2 nasty bullies in a really lousy working environment. You should be supporting this staff member not setting her up to fail.

Noterook · 14/07/2021 20:44

I think you probably need some support in effective performance management. You say they don't listen to feedback, that's not a reason not to send it. It all sounds very unprofessional to be honest, and getting involved you're likely to get burnt.

Merryoldgoat · 14/07/2021 20:42

How long has this been going on OP and when did you realise they were so poor?

And what level are they and you in the organisation?

MrsBede · 14/07/2021 20:35

Yes, sorry, they have sent me the overview but they won't be receptive to anything I say and I also get accused of blocking them if I point out really serious issues. I'm all too aware they have an email trail and sometimes I even think they are emailing me with ideas/requests they know are shit so that I have to say no and they can accuse me of being negative/blocking them. When I first raised concerns I was told that they felt like they 'couldn't do right for doing wrong', which is actually a pretty apt description.

OP posts:
Spaceash · 14/07/2021 20:27

Look, this person isn't asking for help

They have emailed you though? You intervening would be helping them and therefore they will be gaining experience for the next project??? I am not sure of the sector but I've always received and given support whenever needed.

Wheretobuy · 14/07/2021 20:24

@MrsBede

Look, this person isn't asking for help. In fact a colleague said their whole demeanour and attitude screams "why don't you just leave me alone to be shit...".
Do you have a policy for performance management? I suspect that you have and you and/or your senior manager are trying to find a way around the performance management steps laid out in it.
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 14/07/2021 20:23

@MrsBede

Look, this person isn't asking for help. In fact a colleague said their whole demeanour and attitude screams "why don't you just leave me alone to be shit...".
They've sent you their proposals for review though. They may not be asking for help, or receptive to constructive feedback, but they are making damn sure they have an audit trail to show they sought your input into this project.

As a pp said: "the incompetents always have a list and documents. They're stupid, but they ain't stupid"

Wheretobuy · 14/07/2021 20:22

@TwoYearsSince

I've been set up to fail. It's self-fulfilling prophecy. You're being asked to bully this person. I wish I had an alternative for you.

It makes me think our employment rights are not worth having. It would better for everyone if you could just fire the person right now like you could in America.

I have seen performance measures that were designed to specifically kick out certain employees (someone somewhere had thought we had to achieve an arbitrary target of course!). So the employees were given projects which were doomed to fail due to the enormity of tasks. These experiences have made me really cynical about any action that people are not ready to put in writing aka goes so much against the company handbook and the law that we can be sued potentially.
Wheretobuy · 14/07/2021 20:17

@VerticalHorizon

If the senior manager won't put it in writing, it tells you all you need to know about the ethics of what you're doing.

ALWAYS be wary of any policy that someone's not prepared to document.

This x 100.
MrsBede · 14/07/2021 20:16

Look, this person isn't asking for help. In fact a colleague said their whole demeanour and attitude screams "why don't you just leave me alone to be shit...".

OP posts:
VerticalHorizon · 14/07/2021 20:15

Imagine being at a tribunal and these words were uttered...

"Let them fail..."

The immediate conclusions is
a) You were aware of an impending failure
b) You did not intervene to prevent it, and quite possibly
c) You initiated the the process in anticipation of it failing

The incompetence would be placed at your door. Now, I'm not saying you ARE incompetent, I'm saying how it would look if such a policy was documented i.e. 'LET them fail'.

TwoYearsSince · 14/07/2021 20:14

I've been set up to fail. It's self-fulfilling prophecy. You're being asked to bully this person. I wish I had an alternative for you.

It makes me think our employment rights are not worth having. It would better for everyone if you could just fire the person right now like you could in America.

Wheretobuy · 14/07/2021 20:12

@MrsBede

1984isnow

Sorry to hear that you're going through this but even worse by the sounds of it Flowers. Good luck finding something better.

Ha! The senior manager will never put this in writing. On a hiding to nothing with that one.

Exactly - he rarely replies to emails and even in meetings says things like "I'll deny this, but...", "don't minute this, but..." It's a bloody nightmare.

It looks like a shit place to work at. you appear to be managing out an employee who is asking for help. No wonder your mental health is affected.
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 14/07/2021 20:11

Warning: the incompetents always have a list and documents. They're stupid, but they ain't stupid.

100% this. Been there, got the t-shirt.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 14/07/2021 20:10

If it was documented in writing, and you provide appropriate guidance / support to the individual, at least the appalling approach of your senior management won't come back on you.

That's not much comfort though.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 14/07/2021 20:09

HR were in the meeting with the senior manager and agreed the plan.

Bloody hell....

Although does that at least mean it was documented in writing?

MrsBede · 14/07/2021 20:03

@TSSDNCOP

Lots of posters have asked, but I can't see your answer, have you taken this to HR?

This colleague sounds more clever than they've been given credit for. The e-mail to you is your clue. If you don't reply honestly it will be you that hangs, not them.

Warning: the incompetents always have a list and documents. They're stupid, but they ain't stupid.

So true Sad.

Yes, I will reply as people have advised with guidance but not doing the job for them. It's just the cycle beginning all over again. I'll ensure the don't fuck up disastrously while doing my own stuff too. Then there won't be enough evidence I'll be told, and/or there'll be another period of sickness...and so it will go on.

HR were in the meeting with the senior manager and agreed the plan.

OP posts:
TitsInAbsentia · 14/07/2021 19:58

So typically bloody public sector. I don't have anything new to add as previous posters have covered it all - covering your arse is so important. Even if you don't get replies to emails just by way of you sending an email to say:

"To confirm our earlier discussion you requested x y z "

Should be enough - they'll either say they didn't ask you to do that so you can change tack, or they'll not reply which is damning.

Keep copies of everything. Remember anything you do send by email can be requested/seen via an foi request.

There's something going through a tribunal from my old employer at the moment and unsurprisingly the senior staff are wearing their teflon shoulder pads.

Good luck!

Kolo · 14/07/2021 19:55

This is public sector? This is awful. Surely you have a capability procedure to follow. Setting someone up to fail with no support, while they're asking you for guidance, is really wrong.

Get the capability procedure out and do this fairly and properly.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 14/07/2021 19:55

You are their manager therefore you are responsible for managing them through the capability process.

It should be you identifying gaps, you documenting training needs, you putting in place an improvement plan, then you inviting them to first, 2nd and final capability meetings. I don't understand why it would be the fault of any of your managers if this hasn't been completed?

Even so, this approach is unfair to your employee and to the rest of the teams who will need to work on the project.

Have an honest and Frank discussion with your employee, documented in full, explaining that performance has been below expected standard, the improvements needed and how they can be demonstrated by completing this project. Set clear achieveable objectives, with relevant and structured support/training in place, agree intervals and mechanisms for the employee to update you on progress and for you to assess whether the objectives are being met. Make clear what the next steps will be if those objectives are not met.

TSSDNCOP · 14/07/2021 19:55

Lots of posters have asked, but I can't see your answer, have you taken this to HR?

This colleague sounds more clever than they've been given credit for. The e-mail to you is your clue. If you don't reply honestly it will be you that hangs, not them.

Warning: the incompetents always have a list and documents. They're stupid, but they ain't stupid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread