Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Letting someone fail at work - aibu to let it happen?

182 replies

MrsBede · 14/07/2021 17:38

In brief, I have a deputy who has failed to perform since appointment. I have followed all procedures to deal with this but my organisation is poorly led and I have limited support from those above - eg I should have a line manager but the post is vacant. We're public sector.

A senior manager has now told me my deputy needs to be given a project to lead on and when it flops it will be the point at which the lack of performance is finally dealt with. It's horrible, but the team and our clients are being detrimentally affected by this person's lack of competence so it has to happen - I've tried so much to bring them on but they just haven't responded.

So the project has been explained to them and they have got started. There are already issues becoming apparent but they have now sent me details of their next steps and it's really poor. Do I intervene or just let it play out? It will be a fuck up (not dangerous or anything) and should bring things to a head, but what if they come back and say they ran it past me first and I didn't voice concerns?

My problem is lack of support from above but there is none, so MN - please help!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VerticalHorizon · 16/07/2021 08:18

There are so many ways to interpret this.

I've seen plenty of examples where management have claimed 'we have told them to do it, and they keep doing it wrong', and it turns out that their instructions to do things have actually been far from clear, and they've simply repeated the same process (and got the same outcome) multiple times without ever taking a new approach, or attempting to understand where an employee (or entire team) might be going wrong, or what they need in order to do their job.

Of course sometimes, there really is a genuine lack of performance, and it to be so bad that dismissal is the only option, but usually, under performance CAN be corrected if both sides approach it fairly, cut a little slack and get to the root cause of the problem.

A demotivated employee is never going to perform as well as a motivated one. If someone's scared of getting things wrong, they might avoid approaching their manager because it'll be deemed as another example of not being capable.

TwoYearsSince · 15/07/2021 22:44

God this is depressing (not your fault op)

Saltyslug · 15/07/2021 22:07

It’s not necessary to know the line of work, just that the employee has been directed repeatedly and still provided poor outcomes.

Penistoe · 15/07/2021 18:57

It is really difficult without knowing what this employee is getting wrong. Is this is some type of marketing project perhaps?

MrsBede · 15/07/2021 18:33

Thanks Lemon I have sent so many emails like that over the last few years - I realise I need to keep it up!

I did see HR when this started but then the senior manager inserted himself into the situation. When I first went I was praised because I did take a folder of evidence and I had already spoken to deputy and made them aware. HR person said they get lots of people coming who haven't done that and it makes it hard for them to help.

I don't agree that our line of work having an element of subjectivity to it means that deputy must be disillusioned rather than incompetent - there is a creative side to what we do and it's not all done by a clear cut checklist. However, what this person does isn't up to scratch and, while you can't exactly quantify why sometimes, it's plain to see. They do also fuck up objectively by missing deadlines etc too though.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMoonCup · 15/07/2021 18:00

You need a paper trail.

'Could you advise me of the current position with... including the timescales you have identified?'

'Thank you. I need to draw to your attention that the legal requirements (specific laws) are that ... must be completed within ... days of... Could you send me a revised timescale by ... , taking into account the statutory obligations...?'

'Thank you. However, this does not appear to take into account... Could we discuss this tomorrow at xpm?'

'Following our meeting on ....., I would like to clarify that you have ... and ... and will be making the following changes by and we will review this at ... intervals or sooner if necessary'

'Following our conversation on ... here are the links to .... where you will be able to access further information in order to resolve the issue with... If you require further support with this, please let me know by ... as the consequences of ... would result in [negative outcome for clients and organisation]'

'Thank you for your update today, where the revised timescale of ... was agreed in order to comply with .... and that you will be ...... by Tuesday 15th. If there are any problems or you need input from ...., please let me know by 1pm Thursday 10th and I'll be able to ....'

[4.40pm on 15th] 'Good afternoon, just checking in to make sure that .... is progressing as agreed and whether you require me to arrange for input from .... to be able to complete stage 22b/4/d.1234 by Tuesday 15th'

'Thank you for your update. I am concerned that ... has not yet been taken into account. I have contacted ... to ask whether they are able to offer their expertise/experience in...'

'Good morning, ... will be available on .... for you to discuss ... Could you contact them and confirm a meeting, letting me know the outcome by ...?'

It's all a huge arse covering expedition, unfortunately, but documenting all the times that you have contacted them, asked questions, checked for progress, provided information or sources for them to obtain the information and any shitty messages received in response will give HR enough to deal with any grievances raised against you when they realise the shit is about to hit the fan, along with giving HR and the Union enough evidence to be able to say 'Well, all the processes were followed, but x happened/didn't happen, which resulted in y, which the employee was made aware on multiple occasions', which leads to unions saying 'it's less than 50/50, so you don't get legal cover to take this further, we're better off discussing an agreed exit and reference than claiming discrimination or victimisation, and even then, you'll be lucky to get an agreed reference'.

LemonGelato · 15/07/2021 17:36

@MrsBede - I know you said HR are limited but have you actually been in direct contact for advice? If not I'd encourage you to at least try. (See my reply to Bollindger below about going about that). At the very least they can go through your case for under-performance with you. They SHOULD be impartial and fair and challenge you if your case is weak, but support you if the case is strong.

Can I also ask, when you say Deputy has been through capability 'unofficially' does this mean no formal warning/Performance improvement plan was put in place? I got the impression there had been a PiP in place after last meeting? If so in normal civil service procedures that would usually constitute a warning, and even if not a PiP is evidence of a track record of underperformance.

As you hopefully know, if a warning is 'time expired' it cannot usually be used to justify a new disciplinary warning at the next stage but it can certainly be used in reviews to show ongoing performance issues. Referring to it is not forbidden.

As for the subjective nature of feedback, yes that's often tricky (imagine trying to explain to an HR person why the advice they are giving managers about a capability isn't good enough!) But it's still entirely possible - your professional knowledge and expertise counts for a lot.

I know you are fed up and sick of this. And yes I believe you that employees can be lazy or have a 'don't care' attitude as well as incompetent. I had one in my own team a few years ago which was very very painful. But don't give up, either this employee improves and delivers or they don't but you need to keep following the procedures, for your own sake if no other reason.

@Bollindger In all my organisations, copying HR in to random emails would not go down well, we'd just delete them. I'd be responding the first time saying "don't clutter up my inbox with managerial issues that you need to handle". BUT I'd also say do feel free to set up a meeting and come for a chat, and do bring along the bundle of evidence you've been collating showing what the performance issues are, how the employee has been told about these, the targets set and outcomes measured (these can be manager judgement, not just qualitative) and records of training & coaching supplied to support the employee. Oh and if you don't have that bundle? sure we can have a brief chat but then you need ot crack on with the evidence gathering. Only with that can I advise if the case appears strong enough for formal capability action.

And if later a manager wants some support in writing a tricky email response to the employee, or preparing for a feedback session, or me to review an outcome letter from a formal meeting, absolutely send me the draft for feedback. I have the background now and know the manager. In my last job I had 70 managers and team leaders to support and 1500+ staff under them. Drowning me in emails was never going to help me help a manager.

VerticalHorizon · 15/07/2021 17:18

Sometimes, it's just a nice idea / thought process to imagine having to coach people... not that you are necessarily more capable than they are - sometimes, you can manage people far more capable at their jobs than you are, but you are 'managing' them and guiding them in ways to work well as a team, or encouraging them to improve.

That said, sometimes, folks just don't want to improve (and why should they?). They are paid to do a job, and if they do it, it's a fair deal. Not everybody wants to climb a greasy pole or 'buy in' to the next company (HR) initiative (which is a rinse and repeat of something you did 3 years ago, and 9 years ago before that).

Managing is a skill, but it's not always about superiority or hierarchy. Plenty of industries has managers who don't earn as much as those they manage.

Wheretobuy · 15/07/2021 16:55

@Puzzledandpissedoff

A very valid point, Wheretobuy, and I've no doubt Covid's had appalling consequences in some of these areas

That said, I fully expect it to be blamed for everything, whether it's actually had any effect or not ...

It’s hard to measure whether this is covid related, lack of proper capability/recruitment guidelines and procedures (incompetent employee) or just a clash of personalities (subjective feedback). This pandemic is such an unusual and tough situation for junior-level employees.
Wheretobuy · 15/07/2021 16:46

@MrsBede

I have been deliberately vague for obvious reasons and I'm not going to go into detail about this. I'll just say that HR aren't the main people involved and that's normal for my sector. HR is very limited. Yes, there is an element of subjectivity involved and what I say isn't good enough might not match the deputy's idea of not good enough. However, as time has gone by I have done my utmost to model what is expected and give as much detail as possible in briefs.

As I said, the person has not been through capability officially, though they have had 'support' which the majority of people wouldn't ever get nd they certainly know there is a problem. It is unheard f for people to be gone within months in my industry - you'd have to come in drunk or something. I also believe that the person has made a case against me to my manager, unofficially, which I haven't been told about so as not to rock the boat too much.

I love where I work but leadership is appalling at the moment and I have looked at leaving. However, in the role I do (limited sideways moves available and I can't afford to go down, only up or across) there were 140 applicants for the last post I applied for...

Three points stand out from your update OP:
  1. There is very limited HR. This tips the situation in favour of your employee, both ethically and in case of a tribunal. I believe HR is a tick box exercise in most of the mid-level companies in private sector but works well in large multinationals.
  2. You say there is subjectivity involved and that the employee has not been through capability officially. Combine this with Covid’s impact (my comment above) and you have more of a management problem, not an employee problem. In my organisation, I know of at least one manager who simply refused to get off his arse and provide training that he was hired to provide. He still passed his probation. Guess who lost their job? And yes, there was a paper trail but this is what you get in private sector unfortunately.
  3. You admit leadership is appalling and you can’t leave due to lack of opportunities.

All in all, this is turning out to be what I felt from your first post: you may have more of a disillusioned employee than an incompetent one actually. The management will throw you under the bus the moment this goes to tribunal. Seen this happen far too many times.

Unsoliciteddeckpic · 15/07/2021 16:46

No I don't get how it's so poor in the private sector. That someone rubbish can stay in their job, even if they are crap from day one.

However, I have said pointed that out on several threads. And while other people can answer, I wanted to know why from the op in this situation.

I always knew the public sector was a hit if a mess, but this is really shocking. That it's unheard of, to get rid of someone within a few months, even when they clearly can't do their job.

And it sounds like it has always been like that. Even pre pandemic.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2021 16:28

A very valid point, Wheretobuy, and I've no doubt Covid's had appalling consequences in some of these areas

That said, I fully expect it to be blamed for everything, whether it's actually had any effect or not ...

MrsBede · 15/07/2021 16:20

I have been deliberately vague for obvious reasons and I'm not going to go into detail about this. I'll just say that HR aren't the main people involved and that's normal for my sector. HR is very limited. Yes, there is an element of subjectivity involved and what I say isn't good enough might not match the deputy's idea of not good enough. However, as time has gone by I have done my utmost to model what is expected and give as much detail as possible in briefs.

As I said, the person has not been through capability officially, though they have had 'support' which the majority of people wouldn't ever get nd they certainly know there is a problem. It is unheard f for people to be gone within months in my industry - you'd have to come in drunk or something. I also believe that the person has made a case against me to my manager, unofficially, which I haven't been told about so as not to rock the boat too much.

I love where I work but leadership is appalling at the moment and I have looked at leaving. However, in the role I do (limited sideways moves available and I can't afford to go down, only up or across) there were 140 applicants for the last post I applied for...

OP posts:
Wheretobuy · 15/07/2021 14:04

When I say senior managers have been at an advantage, I mean both financial and work-wise. Suppose you are a manager who was receiving London allowance before covid. Now during pandemic, you have next to no commute, you have successfully established yourself and have established relationships at your workplace. A more junior or even a new hire has not got that experience and is likely going to be replaced by someone who is more experienced but is ready to work on the same pay as then because the managers are willing to let them work from home (hence less commuting and related costs).

Wheretobuy · 15/07/2021 13:59

@Puzzledandpissedoff

I don't get how they are still there years later. They should have been gone pretty quickly

Of course they should have been gone, and in many workplaces they would have been, but I honestly don't think some are appreciating the sheer inertia which exists in this sector

I recognise it so well, and applying the norms of the private sector just doesn't work ... maybe this could explain why some are getting a bit frustrated with OP, though it's probably not her fault?

I

I also wonder how much of this has got to do with the pandemic situation. Even in the private sector, senior staff and managers have been at a distinct advantage and the employees lower down the ranks have suffered terribly simply because there was no formal training possible that could work well with the Covid situation. Now the period of 2020-2021 is sufficiently long to disillusion an underperforming junior level employee. In my sector, there simply has been no hiring at that level (a sad sad situation for new graduates), and the hiring of somewhat experienced employees has been on less than ideal contracts and far less pay than before covid. I wonder how much of OP’s situation is a result of these factors. OP also has not answered how subjective the feedback and objectives can be in her/his field of work.
Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/07/2021 13:42

I don't get how they are still there years later. They should have been gone pretty quickly

Of course they should have been gone, and in many workplaces they would have been, but I honestly don't think some are appreciating the sheer inertia which exists in this sector

I recognise it so well, and applying the norms of the private sector just doesn't work ... maybe this could explain why some are getting a bit frustrated with OP, though it's probably not her fault?

I

Wheretobuy · 15/07/2021 13:23

But I don't get how they are still there years later. They should have been gone pretty quickly.
This is what I want to know too.

Unsoliciteddeckpic · 15/07/2021 13:11

All those people decrying bad managers and feeling sorry for the person - I'm guessing you've never been in this position and have no concept that some people just don't care

I get it. I totally do. But I also know that these people know policy inside out.

I also know, that eventually managers get so tired of dealing with it, they end up actually giving the shitty staff a loop hole. And it either back fires on the manager or it just goes round in circles.

Especially when the manger isn't supported. But when the manager gets mental drained with all this, they end up looking like a bad manager. Like they haven't supported and taught, all the way along.

The bit I don't get is how this person even managed to stay in their job for the first few months. Interviews are crap, people who interview well don't always make the best employee. So I get them scoring well in interview but being crap.

But I don't get how they are still there years later. They should have been gone pretty quickly.

thisisnotthewaytomanage · 15/07/2021 13:05

I just don't accept that it's my fault they're shit in the first place! I don't think most people have said that and it isn't possible to tell anyway - some employees do badly because they don't get the right training and support, but it is true that a few would not be able or willing to do the job even with the training and support - but having said this, who hired him? With the right interview questions you can assess apititude and attitude. Sometimes considering offering a sideways move is better than managing someone out too.

Wheretobuy · 15/07/2021 13:03

@MrsBede

Yes, I've said myself that the organisation is badly run and I know that my own manager is out of order. I've said upthread that I won't ignore the email and will be following the advice to encourage reflection and give bullet points etc. I just don't accept that it's my fault they're shit in the first place!
I am still wondering how no formal warning/performance management has been triggered by two capability ‘placements’ (for want of a better word!). It makes me wonder what else has been shit previously. Could you provide a bit more detail about the kind of work you do so we could see how subjective the previous feedback could have been in this case? I strongly suspect it to be subjective because HR does not seem to be with you in this openly. In that case, like others have said, you are being used to manage out a potentially disillusioned employee and will be thrown under the bus as soon as it comes back to bite you in the arse. In my career so far, I have seen a large number of managing out tactics in the private sector, most of which involved employees who were in that job for over a decade and had brought in large chunks of money through their work. On paper, they had done all they were hired to do but didn’t hit that arbitrary number that new managers/owners had in their mind. Admittedly, I have no experience of public sector but it seems to be a capability issues right from the senior management to you and this employee.
MrsBede · 15/07/2021 12:54

Yes, I've said myself that the organisation is badly run and I know that my own manager is out of order. I've said upthread that I won't ignore the email and will be following the advice to encourage reflection and give bullet points etc. I just don't accept that it's my fault they're shit in the first place!

OP posts:
thisisnotthewaytomanage · 15/07/2021 12:48

All those people decrying bad managers and feeling sorry for the person - I'm guessing you've never been in this position and have no concept that some people just don't care. They come to work happy to do a shit job and for others to pick up the slack for them. Then they lie or become aggressive when called out. It's exhausting and no fun at all. This person was employed to do a job they said they were experienced enough for and seemed to be on paper, and they're just not. It's a nightmare Op I inherited an employee who was not able to do what they were supposed to do - when I started out if I had free time I'd spend it reading articles and reading through more senior people's files (with their permission) to see how they handled things - yet this person spent his free time watching cricket or football on his work computer. However, i would still say that what has been suggested here to you is extremely, extremely poor management on the part of your senior manager and HR person, and you appear to be learning poor management skills from them. You need to be transparent and fair with the employee - not "allow to fail" in the way you have described. The fact that you are so unclear about what you are doing you are asking here, not asking your senior manager, indicates, as others have said, you have a senior manager problem as well as a deputy problem.

Saltyslug · 15/07/2021 12:32

Email the deputy a step by step road map for success so that you’re facilitating their success. That way if they fail it’s due to failing to not following direction/guidance and you’ve done your best. It’s really important to write clear expectations into regular supervisions

Bollindger · 15/07/2021 12:27

So send the work back.
Tell them sorry deputy but x is wrong.
Please can you add x, y, z points. No info just as few words as possible.
Bc HR into the message.

MrsBede · 15/07/2021 12:22

I mean, they've done as instructed to a point but interpreted something wrongly in the process or produced materials as asked but of such a low standard that others end up redoing them as they don't feel comfortable using what's been given.

All those people decrying bad managers and feeling sorry for the person - I'm guessing you've never been in this position and have no concept that some people just don't care. They come to work happy to do a shit job and for others to pick up the slack for them. Then they lie or become aggressive when called out. It's exhausting and no fun at all. This person was employed to do a job they said they were experienced enough for and seemed to be on paper, and they're just not. It's a nightmare.

OP posts: