Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU London weighting

87 replies

Ewe202 · 14/07/2021 14:57

My firm has said that anyone who wants to work from home will have to have a change of contract and will lose their London weighting. Everyone seems to think LW is just travel costs but I need LW to be able to afford my mortgage. Price of houses is mad enough and we only just managed to get on the ladder. If I lose my LW I’m worried we’ll struggle to renew next year and will never be able to move up the ladder. My health has massively improved with wfh and even my boss says my work has been great over the pandemic. But I simply can’t afford to lose the LW. AIBU to be annoyed at people who just see it as covering travel costs?? It’s more to do with property and living costs as a whole bunch surely???

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 14/07/2021 19:16

@vivainsomnia

problem is the London housing market has crashed and some people will be left in negative equity, so moving is not so simple.

It should be paid on residence, working from home or not. I have a friend who works for a London employer, but she's been working from home for 6 years now. Yet she continued to get London weighting.

Why should it be based on residence though?

If the employers don't require her to live in London, and could just as easily hire someone from Hull, why should they subsidise her living costs? Some parts of London are cheaper than some naice Home Counties towns. Should people who live there also be paid more 'based on residence'?

Tealightsandd · 14/07/2021 19:06

LW is to cover the cost of living in or commuting to work in London.

Btw re the cost of living in London. It's sky high. Tony Blair made it into a playground for the rich. He saw it solely as a place to make money out of. Consequently it's no longer as it was when LW was first introduced - a little bit more expensive to live there. It's many times more. It's now one of the most expensive cities in the world to live. Hence its status as the UK's capital of homelessness. 165,000 homeless Londoners. More people than the entire populations of many other UK towns and cities.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 14/07/2021 18:57

Well, luckily for you you have a choice. If you want LW, you can go back to work

Canigooutyet · 14/07/2021 16:44

Companies are also having to look at ways to save money. As places start to reopen I can also see many removing staff perks like free tea/coffee, no authorised overtime, people having to reapply for their jobs and more. Especially those companies that was furloughing staff. If they haven't been making money or worse losing money they have to recoup that money from somewhere and not all those costs will be passed onto the consumer. How many companies can afford to write off their debts? How many companies can afford to have them written off?

One of the many reasons for not wanting the lockdown was the economical impact this will have because all that money need to be paid from somewhere.

If your not happy with the conditions of your work, regardless of the reason why stick around making yourself miserable? Look for something that fits more with your wants. I've left loads of jobs because I wasn't happy, life is too short to waste on being miserable.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 16:41

Your friend is either lucky or HR have missed that one - or both?!

vivainsomnia · 14/07/2021 16:37

problem is the London housing market has crashed and some people will be left in negative equity, so moving is not so simple.

It should be paid on residence, working from home or not. I have a friend who works for a London employer, but she's been working from home for 6 years now. Yet she continued to get London weighting.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 16:34

London weighting was regarding travel cost OR higher living costs eg if you had to rent somewhere mon-fri and travel home for the weekend. So up to you how it was spent, but wouldn’t cover both. (1970s/ 1980s civil service).
But you did have to actually work in London, so if you are currently not doing so, I would expect a change in contract and payment to reflect that.

Twentypast · 14/07/2021 16:23

My job has been permanently wfh for 10 years. When my contract changed, I was offered wfh with no London weighting or office based with.
I live in London but the advantages of wfh for me were more inportant than London weighting.

LakieLady · 14/07/2021 16:15

@emmathedilemma

I've always understood it to be to cover the higher costs of living but then other cities have high costs of living (admittedly probably not as high as London) and we don't get an uplift.
That's always been my understanding, too, and I agree with you about other areas being as expensive as some parts of London.

My house in Sussex is now worth 25% more than the one I sold 30 years ago in Croydon, but back then they were worth the same amount. And my council tax is £300 a year more.

I get where your employer is coming from though, OP. If you wfh, you could move to a much cheaper area and be quids in. I think you need to decide what's more important to you, your health or the money. And look at economies you could make if you really want to to continue to wfh.

Also bear in mind that losing £1kpa gross only results in a net pay reduction of £680 (less when you factor in pension contributions or are a higher rate taxpayer), so the financial hit may be less than you think.

Might your employer be prepared to offset the saving from you wfh a little by paying an allowance towards the extra costs in energy, water etc? I used to get £25 a month plus internet and line rental paid when I worked from home in a previous job. You might be able to recoup a bit that way.

MaggieFS · 14/07/2021 16:10

@PairOfPears

I agree that the OP no longer needs to live near London but the fact remains she does and surely you can’t expect someone to sell up and move, potentially uprooting a whole family, and incurring lots of moving costs because her employer is quite suddenly proposing a significant reduction in salary?

OP, do you have the option to continue working in the office and maintain your upweighted salary?

Agree with you, but from what was said, I read it as being her choice to remain WFH, therefore she can't have it both ways.

WTFisNext · 14/07/2021 16:09

YABU because they don't need to pay you the premium for living close to/in London if you're not working from the office. At least they're giving you an option rather than arbitrarily deciding either way for you.

Ask how often you need to be in the office to keep your London weighting then make a decision on what's best for you and your family.

Option 1: Losing money and accepting the trade off is better health for you but having to change how you handle your finances/tightening your belts

Option 2: Stick with WFH but move somewhere more compatible with your salary

Option 3: Go back to the office for the minimum amount of days required

Option 4: Do option 3 but actively look for work elsewhere that matches your salary and WFH needs

LIZS · 14/07/2021 16:05

Could you not opt to return to office and keep it?

MojoMoon · 14/07/2021 16:00

London Weighting is just a premium that some employers pay to attract and retain staff in London.
It's not for housing or travel or any specific purpose (maybe you inherited a house? Maybe you cycle? Who knows or cares?).

It's just a higher salary to attract and retain staff. Lots of companies don't call it a London Weighting at all - it's just your salary and it is as high as it needs to be to have staff do the job

If they feel they can attract and retain staff without paying them more, then they will. If they think working from home is a sufficient attraction to get good staff and keep existing good staff, then they don't need to pay higher salaries.
If you want to work from home, they can usually pay you less because it is seen as a benefit in itself. Maybe that is because you move somewhere cheap or because you live more frugally or because you marry rich. They don't care why.

They are making a bet that some people will prioritise working from home over a higher salary.

They don't work out your living or commuting costs - how could they possibly do that? They just pay you to do a job.

Basically you have to pick working from home OR a higher salary.

That's how business works - they exist to make money not to try and assess the needs of each employee in their life.

MiniCooperLover · 14/07/2021 15:59

A friend works for HR quite high up and said she's had loads of people ask to remain WFH and has said similar to them. That's fine if you're job is doable however your contract will change which to me sounds fair 🤷‍♀️

OliviaWainright · 14/07/2021 15:57

We're keeping LW (or 'high cost area' allowance. So other cities also get this) but been told we can't move more than 90 minutes away in case of urgent requirements in the office.

Crunchymum · 14/07/2021 15:54

"My firm has said that anyone who wants to work from home will have to have a change of contract and will lose their London weighting"

Tell them you don't want to WFH then @Ewe202 ?

TiddyAndFletch · 14/07/2021 15:52

Would moving out of London be an option?

Yellow85 · 14/07/2021 15:52

Any form I’ve worked for have approached it as a cost of living differential. That being said, only central London got the full differential and it was reduced as you moved outwards. For any home workers we used their home postcode to determine the additional %.

It depends on the differential, for some the saving in commenting would far outweigh. I assume that’s not the case for you?

WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 15:49

You'll have to go back out to work then.

onlyhereforthecake · 14/07/2021 15:48

If you are no require to go to the office AT ALL (or any more than once a month at most), then you don't have to live in or around London.

I have colleagues who have basically relocated in various parts of the country (some people were lucky to have a holiday home etc...). Would it be fair for them to get the London weighting?

Your employer cannot reasonably pay people according to their post code! Same rules need to apply to everyone really.

It's frustrating when you are caught in the changes and it's all new, but they are likely looking in general and long term, it makes sense.

MrsFin · 14/07/2021 15:47

Your employer isn't requiring you to be in London. It's your choice to stay there.
Therefore they don't need to pay you a London weighting.

Chloemol · 14/07/2021 15:44

London weighting is to cover the up higher costs of living in London, or travel to london

As you are now working from home there won’t be any travel costs, and therefore you won’t require any weighting

Harsh as it is it’s not your employers problem if it affects your mortgage. Why should they pay you for something that’s not happening?

Essentialironingwater · 14/07/2021 15:32

Yes but if you're WFH full time why should the company pay you LW and not just employ a remote worker from somewhere with a much lower cost of living. Surely it's all about that?

TedMullins · 14/07/2021 15:30

YABU and I say this as someone who lives in London and likes wfh. Just go into the office a couple of days a week if your firm is offering hybrid working. If they offer full time wfh as an option there’s no need for anyone to be in London - a similar thing happened at my work. My team was proposed to move out of London to a different office and we were told that while we may be able to continue living in London and working remotely, we’d lose London weighting if we chose to remain there rather than move to the new area. As far as the business was concerned the role wasn’t London based so it didn’t qualify for the weighting. If your role is made fully remote then it isn’t a London role.

PairOfPears · 14/07/2021 15:30

I agree that the OP no longer needs to live near London but the fact remains she does and surely you can’t expect someone to sell up and move, potentially uprooting a whole family, and incurring lots of moving costs because her employer is quite suddenly proposing a significant reduction in salary?

OP, do you have the option to continue working in the office and maintain your upweighted salary?