Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU London weighting

87 replies

Ewe202 · 14/07/2021 14:57

My firm has said that anyone who wants to work from home will have to have a change of contract and will lose their London weighting. Everyone seems to think LW is just travel costs but I need LW to be able to afford my mortgage. Price of houses is mad enough and we only just managed to get on the ladder. If I lose my LW I’m worried we’ll struggle to renew next year and will never be able to move up the ladder. My health has massively improved with wfh and even my boss says my work has been great over the pandemic. But I simply can’t afford to lose the LW. AIBU to be annoyed at people who just see it as covering travel costs?? It’s more to do with property and living costs as a whole bunch surely???

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tibtab · 15/07/2021 19:46

But the OP can still work from the office and get the London weighting. They haven’t said that everyone is losing it, just people who choose to wfh. It’s a choice.

Dogfan · 15/07/2021 16:14

I agree OP, I took my job for a number of reasons but if it hadn't had London weighting it would have meant a big salary decrease from my previous role (to be clear I have lived in London for 15 years). It is simply the way businesses divide up salary (my previous workplace gave a car allowance for example). For those suggesting OP moves house, buying and selling is hugely expensive once you take into account SDLT, conveyancing, agents fees, move costs so I don't think this is very practical for a lot of people. Also I choose to live in London for a number of reasons and shouldn't have to leave simply because a pandemic means we are now more likely to work from home.

Viviennemary · 15/07/2021 12:57

I think it's a fair rule. But I can see why you don't want it to be applied. I wonder if there will be a legal challenge. I expect so.

thecognoscenti · 15/07/2021 12:54

So move house. Why should they pay you a premium to be near the office if you aren't working in the office? You could go somewhere cheaper and WFH there.

CastawayQueen · 15/07/2021 12:13

OP hasn't been back, probably because everyone disagrees. Waiting for thread to be taken down for being 'too outing'

m0therofdragons · 15/07/2021 10:45

Agree with above. You no longer MUST live in London for work so you lose LW. If you choose to stay there then fine but it is no longer related to a work requirement and is entirely your choice.

EspressoDoubleShot · 15/07/2021 10:40

@user1471548941

Let me reverse the situation for you.

I work in regional office of a firm, no LW. Colleagues doing the same job get 25% extra salary. I didn’t mind, I have shorter cheaper commute, cheaper house prices (still SE) and live near sea/countryside, seemed fair.

Now however, some colleagues with LW have chosen to move out of London during the pandemic. Some live further out of London than I do (and closer to my regional office) so cheaper house prices than my location. They have opted for WFH with 3-4 days per month in the office (approx 1hr 30 commute).

I have gone back to the office 5 days per week (10 min commute, I can’t afford a large enough house to have a separate workplace from my OH). I also am required to spend 3-4 days per month in London but travel paid for by work.

Do you still agree colleague should keep his LW? Gets paid 25% more than me for same job? People from the regional office are now applying for internal transfers to London office but with permanent wfh agreements to get the salary boost. I am unable to do this as I am on an 18 month promotion plan and would set myself back about a year. Definitely doesn’t feel fair to me!!!

Excellent points, clearly put. I agree with this. Also added dimensions to think about.
toastantea · 15/07/2021 08:53

YABU.

If you are working from home your home could be anywhere, whey should your employer subsidise London living?

cheninblanc · 15/07/2021 08:40

Yabu London weighting is for working in London and if you choose to work from home you should loose it.

user1471548941 · 15/07/2021 07:45

Let me reverse the situation for you.

I work in regional office of a firm, no LW. Colleagues doing the same job get 25% extra salary. I didn’t mind, I have shorter cheaper commute, cheaper house prices (still SE) and live near sea/countryside, seemed fair.

Now however, some colleagues with LW have chosen to move out of London during the pandemic. Some live further out of London than I do (and closer to my regional office) so cheaper house prices than my location. They have opted for WFH with 3-4 days per month in the office (approx 1hr 30 commute).

I have gone back to the office 5 days per week (10 min commute, I can’t afford a large enough house to have a separate workplace from my OH). I also am required to spend 3-4 days per month in London but travel paid for by work.

Do you still agree colleague should keep his LW? Gets paid 25% more than me for same job? People from the regional office are now applying for internal transfers to London office but with permanent wfh agreements to get the salary boost. I am unable to do this as I am on an 18 month promotion plan and would set myself back about a year. Definitely doesn’t feel fair to me!!!

PersonaNonGarter · 15/07/2021 07:40

Of course OP should lose London Weighting if she isn’t working in London.

Employers pay LW to facilitate working in London offices. That’s it. WFH should mean no LW.

pubble · 15/07/2021 07:29

And millions are there not for specific jobs but because of that - their links to family, communities, and support networks. They won't sell up and move just because of WFH.

Yep DH & I are Londoners, what keeps me here is family & community as we are 2nd gen immigrants. Otherwise I'd be off like a shot! What will do though is move further out. Maybe many parts of London will become less fashionable again like it was when my parents bought.

Tealightsandd · 15/07/2021 01:29

@EspressoDoubleShot

The London weighting is an incentive & retainer. It’s financial remuneration for being in Ldn If you’re in Home Counties it’s the extra salary to commute and work in Ldn If you’re already in Ldn it’s a retainer Either way,the clue is the term London weighting. Because of the London contact and higher costs.if you’re not in ldn yip can’t get a London weighting
Yes this.
EspressoDoubleShot · 15/07/2021 01:28

The London weighting is an incentive & retainer. It’s financial remuneration for being in Ldn
If you’re in Home Counties it’s the extra salary to commute and work in Ldn
If you’re already in Ldn it’s a retainer
Either way,the clue is the term London weighting. Because of the London contact and higher costs.if you’re not in ldn yip can’t get a London weighting

Tealightsandd · 15/07/2021 01:24

Sorry yes you're right. More accurately to speak of the difference in deprivation. Richmond North Yorkshire is an affluent area. Particularly compared to the most overcrowded part of the UK - the London borough of Newham.

JockTamsonsBairns · 15/07/2021 01:08

@tealightsandd
Yes true. And parts of Cheshire and North Yorkshire. Rishi Sunak's constituency, for example, is more expensive to buy in than some London boroughs.

Really? I haven't kept abreast of London housing prices since I left in 2004, but I now live in Rishi Sunak's constituency in North Yorkshire. In February 2020, I bought a house in Central Richmond, 5 double beds (4 of which en suite), 2 reception rooms, family bathroom, wet room, 22ft kitchen plus utility room, private car parking for 3 cars, and 0.2 miles from an excellent state secondary school. £312,000
Which London borough offers cheaper than that for similar?

Tealightsandd · 15/07/2021 01:05

an incentive to make folk come to London

It was as much to retain Londoners. An incentive for them not to move away from home.

EspressoDoubleShot · 15/07/2021 00:55

You can’t WFH and retain London weighting. You no longer have that raft of costs associated with London and working in a city, the travel, the cost of food, socialising costs,you’re not required to buy as many work clothes, less dry cleaning,etc

London weighting is the premium employers paid to ameliorate the arse ache of working in London, an incentive to make folk come to London. Now that you’re not in London there’s no compulsion for your employer to retain that salary perk

Tealightsandd · 15/07/2021 00:52

Office based industries are about way way more than commercial rents.

Dry cleaners, shoe shiners, sandwich and coffee shops, bars, taxis, buses and trains, office cleaners, postroom staff, maintenance. Just some of many examples of industries related to office based work.

PwC published a report last year estimating that the office based economy is worth several hundred billion to the national economy. It contributes hugely to the funding of the public services that we all use, enjoy, and need.

PickAChew · 15/07/2021 00:45

Well, with those terms, you can reserve the right to live anywhere you like.

Flowers500 · 15/07/2021 00:40

London weighting is for WORKING in London not for living there. If you choose to go WFH permanently and can therefore live with the same expenses as the Leeds office, it’s not brief problem if you choose a more expensive mortgage.

Tealightsandd · 15/07/2021 00:31

@LaurieFairyCake

Well I'm an 'actual Londoner' since I live in zone 3

And I already know office rents are predicted to fall and there may be a glut of empty offices

If Sadiq Khan or any other London born Londoner moved to another part of the country they would be seen by the locals as 'London incomers'. It can't work one way only. London has locals too. And millions are there not for specific jobs but because of that - their links to family, communities, and support networks. They won't sell up and move just because of WFH.
LaurieFairyCake · 15/07/2021 00:20

Well I'm an 'actual Londoner' since I live in zone 3

And I already know office rents are predicted to fall and there may be a glut of empty offices

Tealightsandd · 15/07/2021 00:16

There won't be any housing 'surplus' in London. 165,000 people homeless in London. (And it costs the economy billions in expensive temporary accommodation.)

Not that you're right anyway. First, London isn't just a place for some people to make lots of money out of. Millions of people are actual Londoners. And lots want or need to stay near their families, communities, and support networks. Secondly, the billionaire investors will continue to buy up London homes, to leave empty all year round as investments.

Finally, the office based industries bring in many billions to the UK economy.

LaurieFairyCake · 15/07/2021 00:00

Well yeah Confused that's literally what I've advised - to ask for hybrid working

There are possibly thousands of people who may be forced to lose their weighting because they close offices down - throwing a glut of properties onto the market, lowering house values and disrupting jobs and the economy