Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exes and DSC

190 replies

Saveit · 14/07/2021 14:43

Following several threads on here about first wives, step children and the tsunamis of hate towards step mums, anyone else want to raise their hands with me and say that factoring in DSC, exes and the often ridiculous demands is bloody hard work?!

How dare we have more children with a man who’s obviously fucked over his first family and clearly isn’t fit to be a father! HmmHow selfish of us to sometimes not want to dance to the monotonous tune that the ex continually bangs. How evil to want to fight for the needs of our children, when surely this is all that the ex is wanting?

Before I get shot down, I don’t display these feelings in any way to DSC and they are made to feel most welcome in their home. I enjoy spending time with them and they get on really well with their half siblings. They have a great relationship with their dad too. However, we are allowed to secretly not want to play happy families every breathing moment and want some space from it all from time to time (like the time I was in early stages of labour and the ex kicked off because the weekend with the DSC had to be swapped. ‘But surely you’d want them there to share such a special time like childbirth. They’re old enough to experience such a special time…’ Confused)

OP posts:
SpongebobNoPants · 15/07/2021 14:40

I’ve only made it to page 3 of this thread and it shows how completely unfair posters are to SMs in particular and biased towards SCs/EWs.

People are saying “why didn’t dad sort childcare instead of expecting mum to have them”… so essentially it’s not mum’s problem, she shouldn’t have to help out/ parent her own kids/ put her own kids first when it’s on dad’s time.

Ok that’s fine except on every other single thread about Stepparenting the complete opposite trope is spouted about the dad or subsequent kids.
“He doesn’t stop being a dad to his first kids when they are at their mums”…

Why is it ok for the mum to say she’s not having them on dad’s time but if dad said he isn’t having the kids when it’s supposed to be mum’s contact time he’s called a shit dad… even when custody is 50:50.

The double standards on here are grotesque.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 15/07/2021 13:50

That fact - and it is a fact - is lost by step mothers on this site who defend poor step parenting beyond all reason

That's bollocks. I've never defended anyone who I genuinely thought was a poor step parent. I've offered constructive advice.

Woodmarsh · 15/07/2021 13:45

@Sixsillysausagessizzlinginapan
. wanting space away from them - that isn't really something you get from children of your family.

Yes it is lots of parents arrange time out and even holidays without their kids

Getawaywithit · 15/07/2021 13:03

The stepchild’s behaviour sometimes gets mentioned as a reason why the stepmum is frustrated with the child themselves, but I feel that’s justified as children should behave and follow rules and be considerate of others. That’s something that their actual parents should want too

I expect polite, decent, kind behaviour from my children. But they also have been taught to stand up for themselves. When their former step mother behaved badly towards them, I encouraged them to first look at the situation from her perspective (largely that having three extra children around is tough so try and be good) and then challenge what they considered to be unreasonable. An excellent example was one of my children taking his birthday money my mum had given him to show his dad. My ex took it off him because apparently I would have allowed him to spend it on sweets - a blatant untruth (it’s just a way of having a dig at my weight). Step mum told him it would be put in his bank account. Child unaware he had a bank account. Child waited a few weeks and then asked to see evidence that the money had been put in his bank account - he did that off his own back and hadn’t asked my advice. Step mum told him he was ‘a fucking rude little shit, just like your bitch of a mother’. He concluded - probably correctly - that there was no bank account and that in effect, step mum had stolen his money as she was the last one he saw handle it. It’s hard to suggest otherwise.

Not all step mums are angels. Some of them treat our children appallingly. That fact - and it is a fact - is lost by step mothers on this site who defend poor step parenting beyond all reason. Sure, children should be polite but they shouldn’t have to put up with abuse.

funinthesun19 · 15/07/2021 12:28

In most cases I don’t think stepmums have an issue with the children but with the situations surrounding the stepchildren created by the adults involved with the children like their parents and grandparents.

The stepchild’s behaviour sometimes gets mentioned as a reason why the stepmum is frustrated with the child themselves, but I feel that’s justified as children should behave and follow rules and be considerate of others. That’s something that their actual parents should want too.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 15/07/2021 12:15

His ex is the issue, not his child. I fully accepted his child, he lived with us for a few years. He wasn't and isn't my issue. His mother is.

crabette · 15/07/2021 12:14

@Sleepyquest

I just don't understand why so many women are willing to start a new family with a man who has other children but then not accept his other children! Do these step children come out of the woodwork after you're married or do you get told about them up front?

I personally would never get involved with someone who already had DC because it all sounds awful.

@sleepyquest It's not his children that are the issue? I fully accept my DSD, love her to bits, and my DP is the best man I've ever met.

It's her DM who causes me constant grief! And that's not one you always think about in advance.

RosieGuacamosie · 15/07/2021 12:08

@Sixsillysausagessizzlinginapan

It's almost as if she thinks you go to the husband shop and just order to requirements
Well yes, most people get to choose their partner, unless they’re so desperate they just take the first man that comes along Confused
newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 11:56

@aSofaNearYou

I think YABU because you formed a relationship with someone with dc and don't really view the dc as children of the family, e.g. wanting space away from them - that isn't really something you get from children of your family.

I'll tell that to my step son who is absent for at least 80% of my life.

I'll tell that to my teen DD as well who I barely see these days as she's always off out with friends or holed up in her room ........ 😬

aSofaNearYou · 15/07/2021 11:45

I think YABU because you formed a relationship with someone with dc and don't really view the dc as children of the family, e.g. wanting space away from them - that isn't really something you get from children of your family.

I'll tell that to my step son who is absent for at least 80% of my life.

Sleepyquest · 15/07/2021 11:43

I just don't understand why so many women are willing to start a new family with a man who has other children but then not accept his other children! Do these step children come out of the woodwork after you're married or do you get told about them up front?

I personally would never get involved with someone who already had DC because it all sounds awful.

crabette · 15/07/2021 11:39

@Thatsmydaughterinthewater .... "I don’t blame first wives for championing the kids needs and not being cooperative with their ex. Most men can’t afford to properly support two lots of children so the ex wife is often carrying the majority of the financial burden. They probably have been treated poorly by their ex husband - statistically men commit DV at vastly higher rates, but in my experience they are also responsible for more low level nastiness and abuse. After all, it’s more often than not women who file for divorce isn’t it? Not to mention the sheer number of men who do so little for their kids even when they do live with them full time."

....eh? Confused This is a huge sweeping generalisation. Not being cooperative with an ex is different from not being cooperative with the father of your kids, if he is being a decent dad, which many still try their hardest to be. And being openly uncooperative in that circumstance out of spite or pettiness or due to your own relationship breakdown is bad for the kids.

In terms of the financial burden, DP pays ex on the basis of DSD staying with us only one night per week. This week she has been here all week, as DM is out partying and DSD doesn't like how aggressive she becomes whilst drunk. She is generally here at least 50% of the time, and gets all her new clothes, haircuts, items, while here. DP would never challenge this as doesn't want DM to reduce contact, which I've seen before on threads here saying that the DM doesn't want to increase contact time as it would reduce her maintenance payments.

And as for "they've probably been treated poorly by their exh?" A lot of the time that's the other way around. Women can be nasty af too.

Stompythedinosaur · 15/07/2021 11:36

I think YABU because you formed a relationship with someone with dc and don't really view the dc as children of the family, e.g. wanting space away from them - that isn't really something you get from children of your family.

I think "fighting for" your privileged dc who live in a stable home with both parents against the less privileged dc who haven't had that advantage is uncomfortable tbh. Your dc already have so much more than they do.

newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 11:31

SM's get an awful time of it on here. If I actually posted the reality of DSD's DM's behaviour without saying I'm the SM, I'm sure it wouldn't be defensible. But as I'm the SM I'm automatically the wicked one!

I often think this too. If I posted what DP's ex has done over the years and didn't describe it as an exW / SM dynamic, there would be a totally different response as no person in their right mind could defend her behaviour!

crabette · 15/07/2021 11:25

I'm with you OP.

I think it definitely depends on the individual dynamics - my weekend plans have to change regularly as DSD's mum's plans change (parties, nights out, whatever,) and her go to childcare is to call DP, who would understandably never turn down extra time with his DD... but he works nights, so then I'm her childcare.

I don't mind it, I like seeing DSD, but it annoys me that it's relied upon last minute, where if we called ex last minute with a child care issue she'd blow up and say DP wasn't considerate of DSD's needs, bad father, new family priorities, etc etc.

SM's get an awful time of it on here. If I actually posted the reality of DSD's DM's behaviour without saying I'm the SM, I'm sure it wouldn't be defensible. But as I'm the SM I'm automatically the wicked one!

LizzieW1969 · 15/07/2021 11:23

I’m not a stepmum, and I wasn’t a stepchild, so I have no personal experience to go on. I have, however, seen my DSis’s experience as a very loving stepmum to her DSS and has always treated him exactly the same as her own. (She was his primary carer through his teen years, when he went to his mum’s EOW.)

That didn’t mean that she wasn’t tearing her hair out sometimes, particularly as she wasn’t allowed to discipline him. (That did change, as it was unworkable, especially when she had her own DC.) I’m sure if she had put some of her feelings into an AIBU thread rather than in a moan to me she would have been told that she was totally unreasonable and resentful!

A lot of the AIBU threads I’ve seen have been simply a stepmum tearing her hair out and needing to vent, as they have no outlet in RL. Other times, yes, the stepmum does appear to be trying to exclude her DSC and deserves to be told YABU.

But mostly it really isn’t as black and white as sons posters want to make it appear.

newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 11:03

@aSofaNearYou

Of course YANBU OP. The fact that there are genuinely so many people telling you you are BU purely for acknowledging that it can be difficult, says an awful lot 😂

This!!

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 15/07/2021 10:31

@vivainsomnia

That isn't my fault, or dps fault. It's her fault This, which comes thread after thread, is as frustrating to read as 'you made you bed, you lie in it' comments.

In situations where conflicts has reached the point where communication is almost completely impossible, it is very rarely a case of all the problems being only completely one sided. Even if it was fully started by one party, it's almost inevitable that the other party reacted in a defensive manner that fueled more conflict.

i think matters get to a stage of constant conflict and total inability to resolve anything when neither party are willing to look at their own contribution to the conflict because they are too engrossed in desperately trying to convince themselves and everyone else that all the problems are the sole doing of the other party, whilst the other party thinks exactly the same.

Very rarely? Well my case is the rare one.

Dp did nothing wrong. He simply moved on and she did not like it. He has tolerated being both mentally and physically abused. He had his child taken away from him.

He's never even raised his voice at her and actually I wish he had because we would be in no worse of a situation but maybe the horrible arsehole would have realised he's not a doormat.

I'm sick and fucking tired of being told who's fault it was in my own situation. I was there. You fucking weren't. Your opinion matters not a fucking shit.

aSofaNearYou · 15/07/2021 10:29

Of course YANBU OP. The fact that there are genuinely so many people telling you you are BU purely for acknowledging that it can be difficult, says an awful lot 😂

newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 10:25

@ILikeYouALoaf

And I do think it's naive to expect people to just know immediately what it will be like. It seems things often develop and change over time. It doesn't always stay the same as "what you signed up for" initially.

My own situation, even though it's overall good between us all, has had ups and downs over the years, occasional fall outs and unreasonable behaviour from everyone involved, it hasn't always just stayed the same. That's life.

This. 100%. No knows exactly "what they are signing up for" unless they have a crystal ball.

vivainsomnia · 15/07/2021 10:24

That isn't my fault, or dps fault. It's her fault
This, which comes thread after thread, is as frustrating to read as 'you made you bed, you lie in it' comments.

In situations where conflicts has reached the point where communication is almost completely impossible, it is very rarely a case of all the problems being only completely one sided. Even if it was fully started by one party, it's almost inevitable that the other party reacted in a defensive manner that fueled more conflict.

i think matters get to a stage of constant conflict and total inability to resolve anything when neither party are willing to look at their own contribution to the conflict because they are too engrossed in desperately trying to convince themselves and everyone else that all the problems are the sole doing of the other party, whilst the other party thinks exactly the same.

newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 10:22

My dp fucked over nobody. His ex on the other hand very much did.

Same. Funnily enough though, that's never mentioned .... 🤷‍♀️

vivainsomnia · 15/07/2021 10:13

Too many generalisations are thrown out whether your an ex or SMs.The 'should have known what you were getting into' is the most common one. It applies sometimes, it doesn't in other circumstances.

An ex who moans that her OH wants to have contact on Xmas day, father's day etc.., who moves miles away and then expect the ex to do all the travelling and moans when he doesn't should certainly have thought at what she was getting into when she left him and moved.

The Ex who moved because her ex was abusive, who moans that he only wants to see the kids when it suits him, who is doing everything to hide income to pay as little maintenance as possible doesn't fall into that category.

The SM who finds herself criticized because she didn't buy her SC the same luxury present to her own child, who gets told off for not cooking a separate meal to suit SC, who is expected to look after SC when she is off on maternity leave doesn't fall into the category of 'you should have known what you were getting into'.

The SM who has an affair, move in with him within a few months, falls pregnant when she's hardly met the SCs, and then moans because mum is not happy with them staying overnight when the kids don't even have a bedroom for themselves because the spare room is being used as a nursery should have known what she was getting into.

All in all, I think that a lot of problems stem from the SM taking for gospel all what their partner is telling them. They seem to know everything about the ex, details that there is no reason to know about. I do think many dad like to draw their new partner in their drama and then even let them lead it because it suits them. They tell them what will get them steered up so that they can get all their sympathy and support and then take the crap for them. The new partner is in love and so take on everything they say and vilify the Ex. Just as the Ex assumes that everything they are not happy with comes from the new partner leading on their ex.

ILikeYouALoaf · 15/07/2021 10:06

And I do think it's naive to expect people to just know immediately what it will be like. It seems things often develop and change over time. It doesn't always stay the same as "what you signed up for" initially.

My own situation, even though it's overall good between us all, has had ups and downs over the years, occasional fall outs and unreasonable behaviour from everyone involved, it hasn't always just stayed the same. That's life.

Chartreuseglass · 15/07/2021 10:00

There are many families where the step arrangement works perfectly, including my own. But the issues it can bring are so well documented that it should serve as a warning. Post divorce I would never have become involved with a man with kids, and didn’t. And notwithstanding the good relationship I have with my sons step mum, I’m so glad on reading these boards I avoided becoming a step mum myself.