Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is she not safeguarding her child?

136 replies

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:16

I've changed my username as this could be quite outing.

This is about my nephew who is almost 2. My Dsis hired a nanny a few months ago and she told me last weekend some concerning things.
This nanny takes my nephew out 1 day a week to a toddler group. My nephew came home saying "Andy gone" ( not the persons name). My sister thought it was odd but realised it was the name of her nanny's husband. She questioned the nanny and apparently she got awkward and said " errrrr, yea maybe ben (not his name) did meet andy, i can't remember"
My sister was annoyed because she had not given permission for ben to be around anyone else. Also the fact the nanny didn't tell my Dsis sounds off. My Dsis also said she swears after the nanny had been out she looked like she was in different clothes, but she cannot be sure. Said the nanny lives within walking distance of this group.
My Dsis also has said this nanny will be on her phone when she is supposed to be looking after Ben and not engaging with him. This nanny is not young, so it is not lack of experience she over middle age.
The thing i'm most concerned about is that apparently my nephews behaviour has changed and he is being aggressive especially at his nursery.
Me and my DM have said to my Dsis to get rid of her. My Dsis agreed. Today i found out my Dsis is cutting this woman's days down to one but is still letting my nephew go out with her every other week!!!
Why would you do this when this woman has broken her trust and let some stranger see her son. The nanny tried to hide it by not telling my Dsis. In my eyes that would be the end of the working relationship.
I just don't get why she is still letting him go with her, I've even told her if she wants a break I will have my nephew.

OP posts:
user27424799642256 · 14/07/2021 15:37

Sorry, are you basically accusing this nanny of delivering your nephew to her husband for him to abuse?

Pebbledashery · 14/07/2021 15:37

@Merryoldgoat

So my summary is:

Your sister has a new nanny
Nanny has no references
Nanny is supposedly taking child to toddler group but toddler talks about Nanny’s husband.
Nanny offers no plausible explanation about how toddler met husband.
Toddler has become aggressive for no discernible reason.

It sounds to me like instead of going to toddler group your nanny may have been taking him to her house instead.

Not necessarily an issue on its own but I would expect to be told. There is no reason to take him there. There is no reason for the child to meet her husband. That’s not to say he shouldn’t - the why is what’s important.

Eg. We were at toddler group. A baby vomited on me. We nipped to mine so I could change and husband met baby.

An easily explained incident.

I wouldn’t jump to the worst conclusion but I’d be concerned too.

Stunning summarisation skills :)
Merryoldgoat · 14/07/2021 15:30

So my summary is:

Your sister has a new nanny
Nanny has no references
Nanny is supposedly taking child to toddler group but toddler talks about Nanny’s husband.
Nanny offers no plausible explanation about how toddler met husband.
Toddler has become aggressive for no discernible reason.

It sounds to me like instead of going to toddler group your nanny may have been taking him to her house instead.

Not necessarily an issue on its own but I would expect to be told. There is no reason to take him there. There is no reason for the child to meet her husband. That’s not to say he shouldn’t - the why is what’s important.

Eg. We were at toddler group. A baby vomited on me. We nipped to mine so I could change and husband met baby.

An easily explained incident.

I wouldn’t jump to the worst conclusion but I’d be concerned too.

TiredButDancing · 14/07/2021 15:29

If your sister has made it clear that the nanny should not be introducing the child to her husband, then a) the nanny probably thinks your sister is bonkers and b) would explain why she was cagey if they did meet up with him.

I've never understood people who hire a nanny and then get so restrictive on what the nanny can and can't do. You trust this person with your child so really, you can't get upset because they popped home with your child at lunch time and the child met their partner. It's bizarre.

Pebbledashery · 14/07/2021 15:27

Is it possible she could have just bumped into her husband if she lives locally to this group??
You are right to be concerned, but what do you believe is the connection with her taking your nephew to meet this husband and him being aggressive at nursery?
I would be concerned too, but I also know that children can change like the wind! - my daughter will be the loveliest little girl then the next day at Nursery she's bitten someone or snatched a toy off someone and sometimes has been described as "aggressive"
What do you think the connection is?

sillysmiles · 14/07/2021 15:24

What was the concern about her wearing different clothes? I didn't understand that bit

I'm guessing that the thought is, that instead of taking the child to playgroup, she took him to her home, where he met her husband and potentially others.

But equally the kid could have split something yuck on her, so she swung by home to change.

Ultimately no one knows, and unfortunately your mind off going to worse case scenarios.

snoobydoo · 14/07/2021 15:22

i think you are hundrend percent right but what your sister says for this concerns? and of the day her child? it is for me big no to see someone else and not mentioning to mum. i worked for a nanny with multiple families in the past you cant do this type things.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 14/07/2021 15:20

I’m a very, very overprotective parent but even I’m struggling here…

What are the main concerns?

Could you simply bullet point them and the reason for the concern?

Is it not possible that the husband went to the playgroup with them? Or they all went to the park together?

What’s the difference between the husband being there and other dad’s at the playgroup/ park?

Is it not possible that the child minder spilt something down her top so quickly went to change?

Am I being completely stupid here?

sillysmiles · 14/07/2021 15:16

Today i found out my Dsis is cutting this woman's days down to one but is still letting my nephew go out with her every other week!!!
Why would you do this when this woman has broken her trust and let some stranger see her son.

I'm guessing because she needs the childcare. And it's fair enough to have your concerns, and he is family, but you need to offer helpful practical suggestions - between myself and DM we'll cover DN's care until you can get another nanny. Piling on her is probably not helping if she is already feeling concerned.

HarveySchlumpfenburger · 14/07/2021 15:11

But being transparent doesn’t necessarily mean saying every single thing.

The references is a red flag, but should have been a red flag before she started, the bumping into her husband or nipping home when she’s nearby, not so much.

WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 15:07

Yeah, totally 'ignorant to the world' having spent 52 years living in it 😂

Look, some people have thoughts and opinions that differ to yours and they make their own risk assessments accordingly.

This is what your sister has done.

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 15:07

@viques

I don’t understand why you are posting on here OP and not lurking outside your sisters house wearing a trench coat , sunglasses and clutching a camera with a photo lens
Aren't you hilarious!

So sorry for caring about family, what a strange thing to do eh??

OP posts:
supersonicsue · 14/07/2021 15:06

I can't help but sometimes think it is sad that every action or word can be deemed as a "safeguarding" issue. As a foster carer I've had to go on a million courses and of course have been involved in many serious cases of child abuse. But I still somehow think that jumping to the worst possible conclusion on no evidence can often be damaging too. I'd probably be struck off for saying so though.

viques · 14/07/2021 15:03

I don’t understand why you are posting on here OP and not lurking outside your sisters house wearing a trench coat , sunglasses and clutching a camera with a photo lens

SeaPinks · 14/07/2021 15:02

What was the concern about her wearing different clothes? I didn't understand that bit

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:57

@WorraLiberty

And it's not 'minimising', it's just different people's viewpoints.

Some are more relaxed than others and some are obsessed with the word 'safeguarding', which seems to be very popular of late on MN.

"more relaxed"....... Meaning letting children be more vulnerable to abusive situations. I think you are very ignorant to the world. Maybe nothing has happened to my nephew and I pray it hasn't but you never know people. Especially ones you hardly know and not being transparent with my Dsis.
OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 14:53

And it's not 'minimising', it's just different people's viewpoints.

Some are more relaxed than others and some are obsessed with the word 'safeguarding', which seems to be very popular of late on MN.

WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 14:50

If she lives that close to the group, how do you know she didn't take him and then pop home?

The behaviour change can be pretty normal for 2 year olds and your sister should've had a word with the Nanny about her phone when she saw her using it.

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:50

@Merryoldgoat

I find all the minimising here very strange.

YANBU to be concerned OP. And your sister has been very lax if she’s not got references!

Thank you, i know i'm quite baffled too! Would these posters let their child go off with anyone? Meet anyone without them knowing? Maybe they are being naive to the potential some people have.
OP posts:
Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:49

@KrisAkabusi

And now my original message disappey,! FFS!

Anyway, what I had typed basically said

I wouldn't be concerned at all about a child meeting the nanny's husband. Kids meet people all the time and should for normal development. It wouldn't be a case of giving permission to meet, it wouldn't even occur to me that they wouldn't. Unless there's some child protection backstory, I would think of it as entirely normal.

It's not the meeting the husband, it's the not telling my sister and acting odd when asked if my nephew had met him. She was being very vague apparently. Why not say to my Dsis " oh i met up with andy today, Ben thought he was funny" If you are taking care of someone's child you need to be transparent.
OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 14/07/2021 14:49

I find all the minimising here very strange.

YANBU to be concerned OP. And your sister has been very lax if she’s not got references!

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:46

@Anonymous48

I don't understand what the issue with the nanny taking the child out and meeting people is.
She was suppose to take him to a baby group, not meet up with her husband who my Dsis has never met. It's the not telling my sister and acting odd when put on the spot that is concerning. Obviously if the nanny spoke to someone at the baby group thats hardly concerning.
OP posts:
Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:45

[quote drpet49]@SmidgenofaPigeon this is her nephew. So it is her business.

I would feel the same as you OP. But what worries me is your Nephews sudden change of behaviour. That is a red flag[/quote]
Yes my thoughts exactly. It is a red flag to me too.
My partner is a safeguarding lead and also agrees with me that this is concerning.

OP posts:
Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:44

@SmidgenofaPigeon

But nothing has actually happened. What do you actually think you should do? Call the police?
How would you know though? A almost 2 year old can't told you if anything inappropriate has happened. Why would she not tell my Dsis that she met up with her husband while she was suppose to be at a baby group with my nephew? She knew she wasn't suppose to and that is why she didn't tell my Dsis.
OP posts:
KrisAkabusi · 14/07/2021 14:43

And now my original message disappey,! FFS!

Anyway, what I had typed basically said

I wouldn't be concerned at all about a child meeting the nanny's husband. Kids meet people all the time and should for normal development. It wouldn't be a case of giving permission to meet, it wouldn't even occur to me that they wouldn't. Unless there's some child protection backstory, I would think of it as entirely normal.