Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is she not safeguarding her child?

136 replies

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:16

I've changed my username as this could be quite outing.

This is about my nephew who is almost 2. My Dsis hired a nanny a few months ago and she told me last weekend some concerning things.
This nanny takes my nephew out 1 day a week to a toddler group. My nephew came home saying "Andy gone" ( not the persons name). My sister thought it was odd but realised it was the name of her nanny's husband. She questioned the nanny and apparently she got awkward and said " errrrr, yea maybe ben (not his name) did meet andy, i can't remember"
My sister was annoyed because she had not given permission for ben to be around anyone else. Also the fact the nanny didn't tell my Dsis sounds off. My Dsis also said she swears after the nanny had been out she looked like she was in different clothes, but she cannot be sure. Said the nanny lives within walking distance of this group.
My Dsis also has said this nanny will be on her phone when she is supposed to be looking after Ben and not engaging with him. This nanny is not young, so it is not lack of experience she over middle age.
The thing i'm most concerned about is that apparently my nephews behaviour has changed and he is being aggressive especially at his nursery.
Me and my DM have said to my Dsis to get rid of her. My Dsis agreed. Today i found out my Dsis is cutting this woman's days down to one but is still letting my nephew go out with her every other week!!!
Why would you do this when this woman has broken her trust and let some stranger see her son. The nanny tried to hide it by not telling my Dsis. In my eyes that would be the end of the working relationship.
I just don't get why she is still letting him go with her, I've even told her if she wants a break I will have my nephew.

OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 16:29

Just my Dsis noticed she was in different clothes and no explanation was given.

My Dsis also said she swears after the nanny had been out she looked like she was in different clothes, but she cannot be sure

Well if she can't be sure, then she might've been wrong, which is maybe why no explanation was given?

knittingaddict · 14/07/2021 16:27

It always happens. You get a few people with all this faux "I can't see what the issue is" stuff when it is glaringly obvious what the concerns are. I don't understand it either.

Sally872 · 14/07/2021 16:27

If my sister cancelled her nanny because she couldn't trust her then continued to allow nanny to take child out I would be involved too.

Sister "do you trust nanny or not? If not stop letting her take nephew"

Also when nanny takes him out is this paid or unpaid?

AnUnoriginalUsername · 14/07/2021 16:27

I completely agree with you but I don't know what you can do. He's too young for you to try to get him to tell you if anythings wrong.
When I found out my dog walker was bringing her boyfriend to walk my dog I sacked her, I can't imagine feeling differently concerning DS.

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 16:26

@Ellmau

Is she actually a qualified nanny?

No references is a really big red flag. Please say she has been CRB/DBS checked...

I have no clue, my sister did not mention any references though or ringing up any or speaking to anyone. Think she said she has certificates but i mean anyone can print those off.
OP posts:
Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 16:24

@RafaIsTheKingOfClay

If the nanny’s house is round the corner from the toddler group, I wouldn’t necessarily jump to the conclusion that the trip to the house was instead of the group. Most likely it was on the way there/back.

I’m pretty sure I’ve done similar and not mentioned it, whereas when I was planning to take the kids I was looking after round mine for the afternoon I’ve asked permission first.

Yes i was not saying she took him there instead. My Dsis knew he went to the group that day as she received pics. Just my Dsis noticed she was in different clothes and no explanation was given.
OP posts:
Chikapu · 14/07/2021 16:24

Can you explain what exactly you think has happened to your nephew that's made you so concerned?
Strangers are going to see your nephew all the time, some may even gasp interact with him.

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 16:23

@Merryoldgoat

So my summary is:

Your sister has a new nanny
Nanny has no references
Nanny is supposedly taking child to toddler group but toddler talks about Nanny’s husband.
Nanny offers no plausible explanation about how toddler met husband.
Toddler has become aggressive for no discernible reason.

It sounds to me like instead of going to toddler group your nanny may have been taking him to her house instead.

Not necessarily an issue on its own but I would expect to be told. There is no reason to take him there. There is no reason for the child to meet her husband. That’s not to say he shouldn’t - the why is what’s important.

Eg. We were at toddler group. A baby vomited on me. We nipped to mine so I could change and husband met baby.

An easily explained incident.

I wouldn’t jump to the worst conclusion but I’d be concerned too.

Yes, this summary is put perfectly my thought process. The nanny provided no explanation as to why Ben had met her husband. Eg. ah we bumped into him, i quickly nipped home to change. Instead she got cagey and odd.
OP posts:
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 14/07/2021 16:21

Is the nanny supposed to be caring for your nephew at your sister’s home with the baby only taking him to that toddler group?

KateTheEighth · 14/07/2021 16:19

I sacked a nanny for lying about who she was spending time with when she was looking after my children. My kids were tiny so not able to tell me what was going on

I came home early one day and her boyfriend was there. She said he had dropped off her phone because she had left it at his flat the night before and she had offered him a cup of tea. I let that go even though he had clearly been there a while and certainly longer than it takes to have a cup of tea

A week or so later she said she was taking them to the beach to meet her friend who was also a nanny and who would have her charges with her. One of my friends saw her at the beach with her boyfriend and my children. Children asleep in the double buggy, nanny and boyfriend all over each other, ds2 came home with horendous suburn

WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 16:14

@butterpuffed

Everyone has assumed the nanny doesn't have references but OP said she doesn't think she does ~ big difference.

The aggression at nursery, OP, has the nursery mentioned this ?

Yep and OP's sister can't even be sure the Nanny changed clothes.
gillysSong · 14/07/2021 16:12

None of your business, why you sticking your trunk in?
Someone will throw you a bun, if you aren't careful. Put your own house in order.

butterpuffed · 14/07/2021 16:11

Everyone has assumed the nanny doesn't have references but OP said she doesn't think she does ~ big difference.

The aggression at nursery, OP, has the nursery mentioned this ?

Roomonb · 14/07/2021 16:09

I’d be concerned about this. If I leave my child in someone elses care I’d like to know where they are and who they are in contact with. If the nanny had said “toddler group is near my house so I nipped home to pick up x” I would be fine with that however lying about it would really worry me.

I remember threads where someones MIL has taken a baby for a walk and then disappeared off to their mates house and it was all “go NC, never leave your child with her again”. I would have thought this would be way worse.

Pebbledashery · 14/07/2021 16:06

I am not saying you shouldn't be concerned.
But you do sound like you're putting 2 and 2 together and getting 1,957

zoeydollie · 14/07/2021 16:02

The complaint about the nanny going home/meeting her husband sounds a little petty.

However, it does sound a bit weird that your sister didn't bother doing any background checks before hiring her? Though you'd be surprised how many parents don't bother checking references!

melj1213 · 14/07/2021 15:57

@RafaIsTheKingOfClay

If the nanny’s house is round the corner from the toddler group, I wouldn’t necessarily jump to the conclusion that the trip to the house was instead of the group. Most likely it was on the way there/back.

I’m pretty sure I’ve done similar and not mentioned it, whereas when I was planning to take the kids I was looking after round mine for the afternoon I’ve asked permission first.

This.

Since the group and the nanny's home are close I can imagine something like a cup of coffee/juice etc being spilled so nanny thinks nothing of popping home on the way back to change and her husband is at home.

Instead of having to wrangle the child while getting changed she asks her husband to watch him (I wouldn't want to leave a child unattended in my home but I equally wouldn't want to be getting changed in front of someone else's child) and maybe takes the opportunity to get changed, nip to the loo, refresh deoderant or make up/brush teeth etc and is gone for 5-10 minutes, at which point the husband and child are playing happily. So when nanny returns child doesn't want to leave as they are having a great time exploring a new place and so they have to say bye bye and leave.

She thinks nothing of it until the child mentions her husband and then she is made to feel awkward, as though she has been caught actively lying, but by which point she feels that the mother is judging her and so doesn't want to be totally honest in case she is accused of lying or being irresponsible etc.

1forAll74 · 14/07/2021 15:52

Surely your Sister has to weigh up all the circumstances surrounding the Nanny issues, and decide if things are ok or not. If your Sister is a caring and sensible woman, she can make her own decisions.

Kokosrieksts · 14/07/2021 15:52

Not saying you shouldn’t have concerns, but toddlers change very quickly and go through all sorts of stages - angry, throwing tantrums, shy, not liking strangers etc.

diddl · 14/07/2021 15:45

I think it's odd that the nanny didn't know whether or not "Ben" had met her husband.

When I was nannying we happened to meet my mum in the park, fed the ducks & all had an ice cream.

I didn't think to tell the mumBlush, but the boys did, so I was able to explain it & that of course I had been looking after the boys the whole time.

Anonymous48 · 14/07/2021 15:45

"I don't understand what the issue with the nanny taking the child out and meeting people is.

She was suppose to take him to a baby group, not meet up with her husband who my Dsis has never met. It's the not telling my sister and acting odd when put on the spot that is concerning. Obviously if the nanny spoke to someone at the baby group thats hardly concerning."

TBH I found your original post kind of confusing to read. I thought you were upset that the nanny had met up with her husband while taking care of your nephew. To me that doesn't seem the slightest bit strange. I would hope that your sister trusts her nanny without micromanaging how she spends her time when caring for her son.

Acting odd when put on the spot about it is a little strange though, but maybe the nanny was confused about why she was being questioned about it?

Ellmau · 14/07/2021 15:41

Is she actually a qualified nanny?

No references is a really big red flag. Please say she has been CRB/DBS checked...

thefirstmrsrochester · 14/07/2021 15:41

Today 15:39 RafaIsTheKingOfClay

If the nanny’s house is round the corner from the toddler group, I wouldn’t necessarily jump to the conclusion that the trip to the house was instead of the group. Most likely it was on the way there/back.

From reading the OP this is the scenario which came to mind too.

Merryoldgoat · 14/07/2021 15:40

@Pebbledashery

Blush
HarveySchlumpfenburger · 14/07/2021 15:39

If the nanny’s house is round the corner from the toddler group, I wouldn’t necessarily jump to the conclusion that the trip to the house was instead of the group. Most likely it was on the way there/back.

I’m pretty sure I’ve done similar and not mentioned it, whereas when I was planning to take the kids I was looking after round mine for the afternoon I’ve asked permission first.