Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is she not safeguarding her child?

136 replies

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:16

I've changed my username as this could be quite outing.

This is about my nephew who is almost 2. My Dsis hired a nanny a few months ago and she told me last weekend some concerning things.
This nanny takes my nephew out 1 day a week to a toddler group. My nephew came home saying "Andy gone" ( not the persons name). My sister thought it was odd but realised it was the name of her nanny's husband. She questioned the nanny and apparently she got awkward and said " errrrr, yea maybe ben (not his name) did meet andy, i can't remember"
My sister was annoyed because she had not given permission for ben to be around anyone else. Also the fact the nanny didn't tell my Dsis sounds off. My Dsis also said she swears after the nanny had been out she looked like she was in different clothes, but she cannot be sure. Said the nanny lives within walking distance of this group.
My Dsis also has said this nanny will be on her phone when she is supposed to be looking after Ben and not engaging with him. This nanny is not young, so it is not lack of experience she over middle age.
The thing i'm most concerned about is that apparently my nephews behaviour has changed and he is being aggressive especially at his nursery.
Me and my DM have said to my Dsis to get rid of her. My Dsis agreed. Today i found out my Dsis is cutting this woman's days down to one but is still letting my nephew go out with her every other week!!!
Why would you do this when this woman has broken her trust and let some stranger see her son. The nanny tried to hide it by not telling my Dsis. In my eyes that would be the end of the working relationship.
I just don't get why she is still letting him go with her, I've even told her if she wants a break I will have my nephew.

OP posts:
Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 17:59

@supersonicsue

If you are not prepared to do anything about the violence your nephew has witnessed between his parents, perhaps the nanny will. If the nursery doesn't report to CS first of course.
Christ, i never said i werent going to do anything did i!
OP posts:
user27424799642256 · 14/07/2021 17:58

Ok, so your nephew is in an abusive home. You can't do anything about that (have you reported it?) so you're reacting to this situation instead and transferring all your emotions about the actual known abuse onto the nanny who hasn't been involved in any abuse.

They have both been physically violent towards each other in front of their children

Logically, and having read the further details you've added, this would be the obvious explanation for a child repeating violent or aggressive behaviour themselves. Especially if, as you say, this has been an ongoing situation throughout their development.

This is also a clear safeguarding issue and a pretty massive omission from your op.

Maybe it felt easier to project the issues onto the nanny - and the posters trying to say you might be overreacting to that situation - because she could be fired whereas your sister isn't able to address her abusive relationship?

Perhaps you owe the people you've called names an apology.

notalwaysalondoner · 14/07/2021 17:56

I’d give her the benefit of the doubt and assume she wasn’t honest about taking him to her home and meeting her partner as she knows she’s not supposed to do that sort of thing in work time and was found out. Just because she’s shifty about it doesn’t mean her partner is a child molestor for goodness sake… I think if you’ve raised your concerns there’s nothing else you can do, it’s your sister’s decision to make.

WorraLiberty · 14/07/2021 17:55

@Chikapu

I think there's red flags all over. She's not got references. They've moved areas. She's taken the child to her home and not mentioned it. The child has met an unknown man in a private space. It would be different if they met in the park, in full view of anyone and everyone. She's changed her clothes while at a house with an unknown man. That would have me questioning what they've been doing. And then the change in behaviour.

You've pretty much made all that up, there is no evidence to suggest any of that happened.

I know, I thought I'd stumbled into a creative writing class for a second Confused
supersonicsue · 14/07/2021 17:49

Also he is lucky he has a caring family around him

Are you serious? A family that is aware of his parent's violence towards each other and do nothing about it. I don't consider that to be caring.

supersonicsue · 14/07/2021 17:47

If you are not prepared to do anything about the violence your nephew has witnessed between his parents, perhaps the nanny will. If the nursery doesn't report to CS first of course.

whatinthenameofhen · 14/07/2021 17:46

Meeting the husband without prior consent is unacceptable. Covering this is even more suspect. Best case nothing untoward but trust broken. Get new nanny. Also he is lucky he has a caring family around him.

supersonicsue · 14/07/2021 17:43

Yes, they had to have a word with Dsis as nephew had actually hurt another child quite badly.

You have said their is violence between your sister and partner. This is most likely the reason he has been aggressive at nursery. And witnessing violence between his parents is FAR more of a safeguarding issue then anything you have said regarding the nanny. I am quite shocked you are quick to accuse the nanny and her boyfriend, yet stand by and allow the violence between your sister and her partner to continue...or rather stand by and do nothing about it. WOW. Just WOW.

hidethesquirrelsnuts · 14/07/2021 17:40

@Blessedbethefruit01 you can make an anonymous referral to children's social care via the nspcc. Your nephew is living in a violent and abusive household. The quality of the nanny/her activities are concerns but far lower level than the domestic violence background. Your sister her husband and the child/ten need social care input and a full assessment which will also look at carers and contact with other adults.
You are anxious about the least significant issue in the mix here. Do your vulnerable nephew a favour and get the spotlight on these circumstances and continue to step up and offer to be a safe, positive person for this little boy

MzHz · 14/07/2021 17:39

Well it’ll only be a matter of time before we see the post from the sister
“My family trying to call the shots with my ds childcare”

Thereareliterallynonamesleft · 14/07/2021 17:35

It sounds very different from experiences I’ve had with childminders and their partners/family members, eg one childminder I had told me upfront her husband worked nights so would be in the house, but asleep, most of the day, would never be alone with the children and was DBS checked and was I ok with it. One time she had a hospital appointment and asked if I was ok with him looking after my daughter for an hour or so, all very transparent. My current childminder told me her husband is WFH due to the pandemic but in a different part of the house, might come into the kitchen occasionally, was that ok? But I agree with @strawberrydonuts that it might just be someone without proper safeguarding training etc who doesn’t realise how to approach this. I’m not sure what you can do though other than keep encouraging your sister to find someone else/find someone on childcare.co.uk or similar and suggest she switches to them.

Chikapu · 14/07/2021 17:30

I think there's red flags all over. She's not got references. They've moved areas. She's taken the child to her home and not mentioned it. The child has met an unknown man in a private space. It would be different if they met in the park, in full view of anyone and everyone. She's changed her clothes while at a house with an unknown man. That would have me questioning what they've been doing. And then the change in behaviour.

You've pretty much made all that up, there is no evidence to suggest any of that happened.

HOkieCOkie · 14/07/2021 17:29

She is a nanny too

HOkieCOkie · 14/07/2021 17:29

I’m a nanny, my friends husband was working near the park and came to say hi one day. I really don’t see the issue.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 14/07/2021 17:24

You are also just assuming the Nanny has no references, you actually don't know. This sounds more and more like Nanny is entirely blameless whilst sister isn't. And if your partner is genuinely a safeguarding leader he would be telling you to report your sisters behaviour

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 17:19

@LondonElle

I think you are trying to process all the issues regarding your nephew and perhaps due to your sisters behaviour you don't trust her to make good parenting choices including this nanny. I personally think the nanny issue is secondary to the violence and aggression that is going on more at home and perhaps this should be your first focus. The aggression your nephew displays is more Likely to be from the actual aggression he witnesses/ hears at home than the fact that the nanny has been around her husband with him.. there is no proof anything untoward has happened whereas there is definitely proof that he is from a violent home which is much more likely to be where the aggression comes from ( learnt behaviour) I know your concern is with your nephew which is lovely to see but perhaps your projecting his issues onto the nanny as she is an " easier rather for won't of a better word" than your sister.
Yes I think you are right. I probably am being harsh on the nanny it could all be very innocent and you're right about maybe projecting. My Dsis doesn't actually know I know about the violence. I only know of 2 times but who knows what else has happened. I know the 1st my nephew was there any a baby not sure on the 2nd. Still no excuse though. I know she has issues and it makes me so sad to see her repeating my parents relationship that me and her witnessed growing up. I am not a perfect parent but I promised I would never behave the way my parents did. I have actively done that. Where as she hasn't. I just want to shout at her and saying what you're doing is damaging and your decision making is poor! She can be selfish at times too. Agh it's all a bit of a mess really
OP posts:
Dutch1e · 14/07/2021 17:16

Do you feel comfortable that everyone was talking about the same Andy?

Coyoacan · 14/07/2021 17:13

Frankly I'd have to be really stuck to leave my child with someone I didn't trust in the first place.

Surely with this level of worry, your sister would be better sending her child to a registered childminder or a nursery.

As for a toddler changing, that is what toddlers do, all the time, so I don't think that is a suitable measure

Greenmarmalade · 14/07/2021 17:11

Stay involved!
I certainly would if it were my nephew.

You’re right to be concerned. I would keep pushing this with your sister until she drops the unsafe, dishonest, no-references nanny. Shocking.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 14/07/2021 17:10

@3Britnee they weren't sure she had changed clothes. The only definite is the violence. This is what needs addressing not vague maybes

LondonElle · 14/07/2021 17:10

I think you are trying to process all the issues regarding your nephew and perhaps due to your sisters behaviour you don't trust her to make good parenting choices including this nanny.
I personally think the nanny issue is secondary to the violence and aggression that is going on more at home and perhaps this should be your first focus.
The aggression your nephew displays is more
Likely to be from the actual aggression he witnesses/ hears at home than the fact that the nanny has been around her husband with him.. there is no proof anything untoward has happened whereas there is definitely proof that he is from a violent home which is much more likely to be where the aggression comes from ( learnt behaviour)
I know your concern is with your nephew which is lovely to see but perhaps your projecting his issues onto the nanny as she is an " easier rather for won't of a better word" than your sister.

3Britnee · 14/07/2021 17:07

I think there's red flags all over. She's not got references. They've moved areas. She's taken the child to her home and not mentioned it. The child has met an unknown man in a private space. It would be different if they met in the park, in full view of anyone and everyone. She's changed her clothes while at a house with an unknown man. That would have me questioning what they've been doing. And then the change in behaviour.

It could be innocent, she could gave spilled something all over her at the group, gone home, got changed and the husband was in (in which case why not mention it?).

But it might not be.

yeOldeTrout · 14/07/2021 17:07

There's no evidence she met up with husband specifically in her home; could have been unintended meeting on street or planned meeting in a crackden. Anyway, I agree leave it with the people who have the relationship of employer-employee.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 14/07/2021 17:06

You have actually no idea if she took him to her house or not, you are just assuming she did because she said she can't remember if the child has met her husband or not. If they live close by its not impossible she may bump into him occasionally. Its not impossible a child at the group has the same name as her husband. All these weird assumptions whilst ignoring the real and known safeguarding issue of violence in the home.

AlternativePerspective · 14/07/2021 17:05

How do you know? For all anyone knows, the husband is a paedo and the nanny is taking the kid to her home, not the group. or more likely the sister and her husband are not only beating the crap out of each other but the kids as well.

And he’s mirroring the behaviour he sees at home at nursery.