Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is she not safeguarding her child?

136 replies

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 14:16

I've changed my username as this could be quite outing.

This is about my nephew who is almost 2. My Dsis hired a nanny a few months ago and she told me last weekend some concerning things.
This nanny takes my nephew out 1 day a week to a toddler group. My nephew came home saying "Andy gone" ( not the persons name). My sister thought it was odd but realised it was the name of her nanny's husband. She questioned the nanny and apparently she got awkward and said " errrrr, yea maybe ben (not his name) did meet andy, i can't remember"
My sister was annoyed because she had not given permission for ben to be around anyone else. Also the fact the nanny didn't tell my Dsis sounds off. My Dsis also said she swears after the nanny had been out she looked like she was in different clothes, but she cannot be sure. Said the nanny lives within walking distance of this group.
My Dsis also has said this nanny will be on her phone when she is supposed to be looking after Ben and not engaging with him. This nanny is not young, so it is not lack of experience she over middle age.
The thing i'm most concerned about is that apparently my nephews behaviour has changed and he is being aggressive especially at his nursery.
Me and my DM have said to my Dsis to get rid of her. My Dsis agreed. Today i found out my Dsis is cutting this woman's days down to one but is still letting my nephew go out with her every other week!!!
Why would you do this when this woman has broken her trust and let some stranger see her son. The nanny tried to hide it by not telling my Dsis. In my eyes that would be the end of the working relationship.
I just don't get why she is still letting him go with her, I've even told her if she wants a break I will have my nephew.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 07:05

Poor little boySad I do hope you do something to help him, OP

AFS1 · 15/07/2021 05:18

If your sister has the capacity to become violent in front of her children, perhaps the nanny was scared to tell her that Ben had met her partner. Perhaps your sister kicks off at the nanny if she thinks she’s done something wrong.

It may be that the nanny has been part of the safety net for your nephew…a few days where he’s protected from his own parents’ volatility. In being in denial about the source of the true abuse in that household, you and your mother appear to have pestered your sister into cutting down the time he has with a potentially safer carer than his own parents. And to try and suggest that the nanny and her partner may be responsible for the change in your nephew’s behaviour when you know that he is witnessing violence between his own parents is pretty despicable.

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 23:19

@Funnylittlefloozie

Thel safeguarding issue here is that your sister employed a nanny without checking her credentials and presumably her DBS etc - was she quite a lot cheaper than a proper nanny, by any chance?
Yes she was
OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 14/07/2021 20:27

Seems like it’s not the nanny but your dsis and her DP who is the problem. If you think they are being abusive then call social services. Don’t hesitate due to some misguided loyalty because by then a child’s life would have been ruined.

^I agree with this, sorry. You have to act in the best interests of your DNephew, and that means involving SS.

ForeverSausages · 14/07/2021 20:21

I really feel for you OP. It's quite obvious why you're concerned. It may well be "innocent" for example, nanny was supposed to be taking child to playgroup but decided to take him to lunch with husband. The behaviour change could also be because he's obviously being brought up in a very unstable home. If it were me, and I have a sister, I would be reporting to social services (all the concerns regarding the nanny & your sister).

Ozanj · 14/07/2021 20:07

Seems like it’s not the nanny but your dsis and her DP who is the problem. If you think they are being abusive then call social services. Don’t hesitate due to some misguided loyalty because by then a child’s life would have been ruined.

Funnylittlefloozie · 14/07/2021 20:01

Oh ffs, I should have rtft... the problem is NOT the nanny, its your violent and collusive family.

Funnylittlefloozie · 14/07/2021 19:58

Thel safeguarding issue here is that your sister employed a nanny without checking her credentials and presumably her DBS etc - was she quite a lot cheaper than a proper nanny, by any chance?

GLTM · 14/07/2021 19:51

This is a red flag, to not check with the mum is concerning. Especially if the mtgs were to happen at the nanny or husband's home. I think you're right to be concerned. Find another nanny for her and reference them perhaps so it's all set up and easy for her to switch

romdowa · 14/07/2021 19:40

Your sister is a violent abuser in front of her children but it's the child minder who is the "safegaurding" concern. Are you actually for real? If you are in anyway bothered about the safety of your nephew... you should be calling social services on your sister! Sometimes posts on here make me dispare but this has to take the biscuit by a clear Mile!

SmidgenofaPigeon · 14/07/2021 19:34

Ugh. Red herrings and drip feeding Hmm

Pebbledashery · 14/07/2021 19:33

This thread has got to be the biggest drip feed ever. The nanny is not the issue here.

MsTSwift · 14/07/2021 19:29

When I had a baby I spent time with a friends nanny who was excellent extremely professional and experienced. She had real concerns about another nanny and after much soul searching told the other nanny’s employer. The mum didn’t want to know 🙁

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 14/07/2021 19:25

So the child is living in an abusive home, but you are blaming the nanny for his change in behaviour at nursery? WTF!

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 14/07/2021 19:24

What if she nust met her partner/husband in the street? You don't know the child went to their home, even if they did for the nanny to change, I don't really see the problem. You r nephew I'd going to meet new people in his lifetime.
How do you know about the use of her phone?

Royalbloo · 14/07/2021 19:18

It doesn't matter who is violent, it's a violent relationship and these situations damage children?! She's obviously not happy and maybe her DH needs protection (but their kid obviously does).

And I didn't say the word "proud"

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 19:16

@Royalbloo

I'd be more invested in helping my sister leave an abusive relationship than worrying about the Nanny, personally.
It's more my sister who is the violent one.

Who ever said I seemed proud about me keeping quiet. No I am not proud of anything! So I dont know where you got that from. Why would I be proud, what an odd thing to say

OP posts:
glitterelf · 14/07/2021 19:04

Major red flags reading your posts and I don't understand why you haven't reported your sister and her partner considering your partners expertise. Children at that age often display unwanted behaviour towards others whilst struggling to communicate but they can also be displayed learnt behaviours from home.
I also find it extremely odd that you raised concerns with the nanny from what your sister had told you yet she's still kept the nanny on so could she be telling you the truth ?
I'm a childminder and a big part of that is taking children out and about we often bump into friends and family not only mine but the children's too. All of the children know my family too and in all the years I've been childminding it's never been an issue.

Royalbloo · 14/07/2021 19:02

I'd be more invested in helping my sister leave an abusive relationship than worrying about the Nanny, personally.

stellaisabella · 14/07/2021 18:45

Likelihood is she popped home to change where the child met her husband -
Throwing safeguarding about over issues that small and insignificant is a bit much is it not? I don't get what on earth the big deal is at all.

The behavioural change at nursery is very likely to do with the fact they've been physically violent to one another in front of their children - the fact you're convinced the nanny is to blame for that rather than the obvious that he's seen it at home is baffling. You should be more worried about your sisters parenting than the nanny.

supersonicsue · 14/07/2021 18:34

I wouldn't say my sister is the most sensible or her partner. They have both been physically violent towards each other in front of their children. There are many things I haven't agreed on but i have always been quiet

Christ, i never said i werent going to do anything did i!

You mention the first violent episode was when your nephew was a baby. Yet seemed proud in the post above that you have kept quiet about it. How long are you going to wait? Do you need any help to know who to contact? It will be much, much worse if the nursery or the nanny report it and it becomes known that family knew and kept quiet.

peboh · 14/07/2021 18:29

I'm slightly more concerned that you're overly bothered about the nanny, but no the fact your nephews parents having been physically abusive in front of him? You're shouting that your sister isn't safeguarding him, and whilst I didn't see that with the nanny it's absolutely true with her and her partner. Why haven't you phoned social services?

MarsandPluto · 14/07/2021 18:22

I would be quite concerned too OP . I wouldn't want my child to be taken to any setting that hasn't been approved by me beforehand. And any vague answers wouldnt cut ice with me either. "Maybe ben did meet andy" is not good enough an answer, he either did or didn't. Surely she'd remember if the child she is looking after has met her family members or not. The only thing I could think of is if Andy had brought one of their grandchildren to the toddler group and they met up there? But if this was the case, she could have just said that and not sounded dodgy. I'd have fired her for that.

MrMeSeeks · 14/07/2021 18:14

Sorry, but you're more concerned about a nanny possibly changing her top than about your dsis and husband being violent towards each other?
Maybe that’s why there is a change and their child is violent Confused
I think that is where your concern should be.

Blessedbethefruit01 · 14/07/2021 18:07

@user27424799642256

Ok, so your nephew is in an abusive home. You can't do anything about that (have you reported it?) so you're reacting to this situation instead and transferring all your emotions about the actual known abuse onto the nanny who hasn't been involved in any abuse.

They have both been physically violent towards each other in front of their children

Logically, and having read the further details you've added, this would be the obvious explanation for a child repeating violent or aggressive behaviour themselves. Especially if, as you say, this has been an ongoing situation throughout their development.

This is also a clear safeguarding issue and a pretty massive omission from your op.

Maybe it felt easier to project the issues onto the nanny - and the posters trying to say you might be overreacting to that situation - because she could be fired whereas your sister isn't able to address her abusive relationship?

Perhaps you owe the people you've called names an apology.

There has been no name calling but i will admit that yes maybe i have projected onto the nanny. She could have done nothing wrong but i still stand by my point that she should be transparent. Anyway yes the violence between my Dsis and her fiance is a bigger issue. I am not sitting here and doing nothing I love my nephew and would not anything to happen to him and i certainly would not want him to witness abusive parents. I know how that feels. I just feel helpless because i can report to SS but what will they do? I didnt witness it, my Dsis told my DM and she wont say anything to SS.
OP posts: