Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my Dad being brainwashed by alt-right anti vaxxers?

60 replies

AbitSceptical · 14/07/2021 13:01

I'm not sure if this is really an AIBU but I don't know where else to post and maybe IABU for being worried about this...

My Dad, in his 70s, lives alone, has always been free-market right (socially he's more liberal).

He subscribes to e-news sites and gets update emails from right wing media sources, which are all anti-lockdown, anti-vax, anti-woke. He often sends us (his children, sometimes his siblings) long ranty emails, forwarding 'The Truth' about 'Covid lies'.

He uses terms like 'face nappy' for mask, 'sheeple' for anyone who doesn't agree with him, and talks about 'that commie on sage' - not sure if he means Whitty or Valence or someone else.

He is convinced that his grandchildren are in grave danger of hospitalisation if we have them vaccinated.

He doesn't listen to reason - I've tried telling him that no-one has offered to vaccinate my children yet, that all his children and their spouses are double vacc'ed (we did think long and hard about accepting the vaccine, we're not idiots, and we are all fine.)

He went through a similar phase around the time of Brexit - he was an ardent Leaver.

What can I (we - my siblings have the same problem) do? I don't have the energy to engage with his nonsense. We've already told him not to send on these emails, but he sent 3 just last night. If you argue back he gets very aggressive.

I'm worried about his mental health. Has anyone experienced anything similar / got any ideas about what to do to help him?

FYI so as not to drip feed - 2 of his 4 kids live abroad, myself and one other in the UK, we have our own families / jobs / school aged kids and live 2-3 hours drive from him, so are not in a position to check up on him in person on a frequent basis.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AmyVindaloo · 28/07/2021 11:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Charliebradbury · 28/07/2021 11:10

Don't engage with his rants, either try to steer the conversation elsewhere or just end the conversation. A differing of opinion is fine but ranting and raving at people is not.
One of my friends has fallen down the same rabbit hole, intelligent 30 something woman, but is very isolated in many ways. I tried to argue with her once but it just made it worse. I've since decided to disengage, and ignore it. She is becoming worse and worse but there is nothing anyone can do as she isn't interested in hearing anyone else's opinion but thinks the world should listen to hers

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 28/07/2021 10:46

I suppose you could discover in yourself a passion for something unexpected, I don't know, seventeenth century century lyric poetry (does that even exist? never mind), or the interesting effects of colour on mood with reference to room decoration and music, or gymnastics as an art form, or something, and bang on about it in long emails back... I'm sure there must be things on the internet you could lift whole and send, which have nothing to do with covid or brexit or anything political at all.

At best it might serve to confuse his focus and make him argue against you about something that is not so dangerous and silly.

Flossatops · 28/07/2021 09:30

junebirthdaygirl: I think your advice works. Don't respond or engage and just delete the emails as soon as they arrive - reading them will just enrage you. Reply when you're calmer with something totally unrelated. I've pretty much followed this path with a similar problem and I don't get the emails anymore.

Iwantatrio · 27/07/2021 23:57

My sister’s ex husband is like this OP. It’a not just a difference of opinion in how govt etc have managed covid - it’s following that down the rabbit hole of plandemic, bill gates, new reality or whatever, all this vague stuff, possibly involving the Illuminati and implants, who knows. To me it seems illogical that a collection of disparate governments who are all different degrees of incompetent, are capable of collaborative working to orchestrate a conspiracy of a never seen before scale. Her ex is like many people who get pulled into this way of thinking - lonely, isolated, general stuff under the heading of “other issues”. OP I second the comments about not engaging with your dad in any of these topics - the advice to foster his engagement with other interests is very good.

toconclude · 27/07/2021 23:42

@Valeriekat

How very totalitarian of you!
ODFOD
Justanotherlurker · 27/07/2021 23:16

And we have outright 'muh russia' and brexit, this is a thread to appeal to a crowd.

This is why MN has been wrong on every major political decision for well over a decade, I remember when MN was waxing lyrical over Macron, outraged about kids in cages in America etc etc, it's all memory holed, and some still seem to think MN is infested with right leaning daily mail readers or pretend it is full of highly educated critical thinkers, it's becoming nothing more than twitter hot takes without the likes.

Dogvmarmot · 27/07/2021 23:07

@AbitSceptical

I'm not sure if this is really an AIBU but I don't know where else to post and maybe IABU for being worried about this...

My Dad, in his 70s, lives alone, has always been free-market right (socially he's more liberal).

He subscribes to e-news sites and gets update emails from right wing media sources, which are all anti-lockdown, anti-vax, anti-woke. He often sends us (his children, sometimes his siblings) long ranty emails, forwarding 'The Truth' about 'Covid lies'.

He uses terms like 'face nappy' for mask, 'sheeple' for anyone who doesn't agree with him, and talks about 'that commie on sage' - not sure if he means Whitty or Valence or someone else.

He is convinced that his grandchildren are in grave danger of hospitalisation if we have them vaccinated.

He doesn't listen to reason - I've tried telling him that no-one has offered to vaccinate my children yet, that all his children and their spouses are double vacc'ed (we did think long and hard about accepting the vaccine, we're not idiots, and we are all fine.)

He went through a similar phase around the time of Brexit - he was an ardent Leaver.

What can I (we - my siblings have the same problem) do? I don't have the energy to engage with his nonsense. We've already told him not to send on these emails, but he sent 3 just last night. If you argue back he gets very aggressive.

I'm worried about his mental health. Has anyone experienced anything similar / got any ideas about what to do to help him?

FYI so as not to drip feed - 2 of his 4 kids live abroad, myself and one other in the UK, we have our own families / jobs / school aged kids and live 2-3 hours drive from him, so are not in a position to check up on him in person on a frequent basis.

i am sorry about your dad. since brexit came upon the scene it appears many people refuse to acknowledge how complex situations are - like the EU/trade deals, regulation between countries etc, are very complicated. As is science. Its a desire for everything to be reduced to a simple solution without the effort of thought. Thats why they don't like 'experts'. They genuinely think trading internationally is like just setting up a market stall in the local market, unaware of the many barriers between countries and other trading blocs.. And science - I have gone past a anti marks/vaccine protest - crackpot signs/jesus/anti abortion. Maybe only engage in topics like gardening etc.
JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 27/07/2021 22:59

To this day nobody can explain what Dominic Cummings was doing in Russia for years before coming back to infiltrate our government to cause chaos. People like him and that Marjorie Taylor Greene in America are working to destroy our way of life through confusing and radicalising susceptible people.

Arguing with your dad or blanking him will not work. You have to cancel the negative with the positive.

Dogvmarmot · 27/07/2021 22:57

@Emilyontmoor

I won’t debate you here but let’s just say the experts have failed us badly. I think all sides can at least agree upon that.

Good grief, and people with no scientific expertise, like the lonely man next door who sits at his kitchen table in a ketchup stained t shirt leaning over his computer or the deranged attention seeking ex nurse who scared her 11 year old son witless with tales of genocide that never materialised would have served us better? Or indeed Heneghen, Gupta, the Fat Emperor etc who have never published any data to back up their theories (and have suspicious finding links to Trump supporting organisations in the US). Far more sinister than membership of a now irrelevant (in spite of the ridiculous right wing Hoover type US rhetoric you get on these websites) U.K. Communist Party.

The Scientists have responded to a novel virus to try to fill the knowledge gap from the start. From the Wuhan doctors who risked their livelihood and lives to get the information they had gathered in the virus’s DNA, infectiousness and death rates to the rest of the world including publishing then in the Lancet in mid January when Xi had not yet owned up. Right to the people who delivered vaccines in record time, not because they cut corners, or were acting for Bill Gates to implant us with chips or change our DNA but because they had the funding to implement the existing vaccine science. (I didn’t get this from a website I spoke to a vaccine expert back in May 2020 about the amazing progress being made.

I have a family member who has spent two hours each end of long days commuting in London to make their contribution, starting to deliver testing to London hospitals in March 2020 when Dido’s operation was still a complete shambles, catching Covid and giving it to me in the process. They have made amazing leaps in research into treatments and understanding of the disease compressed into such a short time, and in some countries where political ideology did not trump science they kept case and death rates low.

They did not understand the true nature and origins of SARS for 10 years but countries who put those lessons into practise have done far better than countries who thought they were exceptional.

Look at the map of death rates - the experts are worldwide but the countries that have done worst are where right wing ideology and western exceptionalism were most prevalent. We have been failed by right wing populism and croneyism not the experts.

thank you. people who spout 'experts have failed us' have a gross misunderstanding of how science and research works, people with vast education and experience responding to an ever changing situation with remarkable effort and results. They are not omnipotent. But of course, dumb and dumber with zero education or experience of public health, virology, etc, know exactly how this should have played out. Just had the woman (60s?) working at the counter to sell moving boxes explain to me that vaccines don't work and she wont get covid as she is so healthy. Refuses to wear mask. Thanks for the tip box lady, I will now ignore Professor of medicine in charge here, with her 30 years background of epidemiology, public health and experience of various epidemics around the world.
JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 27/07/2021 22:56

Unfortunately radicalisation on the net is a genuine and growing threat. I fear that many young, isolated men have been radicalised by QAnon etc and we are all in for a rough ride. Anti western countries have realised that turning susceptible western citizens in to sleeper agents is easier and more effective than wars and terror attacks.

The only thing you can try to do is help keep him otherwise occupied and drown out the destructive messages. Send him lots of forums, articles etc on gardening. Divert his attention to more positive things. Try and go and visit him as soon as you’re able. Get him out and about in the real world.

junebirthdaygirl · 27/07/2021 22:48

To get back to your dad Op just ignore everything he says that is contentious and respond to everything else. Do not enter into any discussion as that only fuels the fire. Let him believe anything he wants. But keep the door open. Send him pictures of your dc on days out/ your garden etc with cheerful messages. When you see an email that is fired up with nonsense just immediately delete. I have this in my family and l find the total not engaging is what works. I know straight away where message is heading so l just zap without reading. They enjoy the row so don't buy into it.

Justanotherlurker · 27/07/2021 22:43

Is your dad piers corbyn, that famous right winger who has led marches.

Anyone trying to turn this into a right v left issue isn't as educated that they like to profess.

Emilyontmoor · 27/07/2021 22:36

Cross posted but point made.

Emilyontmoor · 27/07/2021 22:33

Usedup thank you for illustrating my point about context and perspective. There is no single definition of lockdown, just a series of measures you can take to limit transmission. Taiwan for instance did not lockdown for the first 15 months of this pandemic, their economy thrived in a country with a densely populated capital the size of Manchester. However they responded to the signals coming outbid Wuhan in mid December and started screening plans coming out of Wuhan, then at the start of January they locked down their borders and restarted their SARS trace track and isolate. They have only messed up recently (and on nowhere the scale we have) because they did not increase the testing capacity to anticipate a more transmissible variant).

Your definition of lockdown, the extent to which we limited people’s activities, was only necessary because we let the case numbers rise. High cases equal not just high deaths (if that does not bother you), it is also maximum economic damage.

UsedUpUsername · 27/07/2021 22:22

They did not understand the true nature and origins of SARS for 10 years but countries who put those lessons into practise have done far better than countries who thought they were exceptional

You do know that most of East Asia did not use lockdowns. With the exception of China, of course.

Here’s where you might suggest masking worked, well, it sure didn’t work out too well in Europe despite strict mask mandates in most countries.

Look at the map of death rates - the experts are worldwide but the countries that have done worst are where right wing ideology and western exceptionalism were most prevalent

Can you really say that about South American countries like Peru, Argentina and Colombia, which have been hit very very hard?

Also, everyone hates on Sweden’s approach but it’s kind of ridiculous to call them a right-wing, populist regime.

You should really stop looking at this from a political lens.

We have been failed by right wing populism and croneyism not the experts

Yes, blame the little people for not masking harder or staying at home when their livelihoods were being destroyed (while their betters were comfortably working from home despite being in low risk categories).

Not the experts who flipflopped on everything from travel bans to masking to venting.

They dropped the ball by not admitting that the virus spreads via aerosols until far too late in the game.

The experts are wrong on pretty much everything COVID related and then whine when people don’t listen to them wrt vaccines. (As it happens, I think they are mostly right on vaccine)

Emilyontmoor · 27/07/2021 22:19

I think the real problem is an outbreak of an inability to understand context and perspective amongst non experts. Of course N95 correctly used is better protection, but with 65m people involved any barrier to aerosol transmission is going to reduced transmission. Infection control is a series of leaky sieves. If anything worked 100% then we would have done it and Covid would be history. But each thing that reduces transmission in 65m is less of us catching the bigger. There is certainly no evidence that wearing a “face nappy” causes you any harm. Ironically the rhetoric implies it is catching shit which is a decent metaphor.

UsedUpUsername · 27/07/2021 22:00

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Masking and lockdowns are pseudo-science and have never been demonstrated to work

Lockdowns clearly reduce transmission

You can achieve the same results with focussed protection (ie using a scalpel instead of a blunt hammer). You can compare various US states, and find that those with strict lockdowns don’t fare any better than those who didn’t.

It shouldn’t be a surprise. The WHO pandemic playbook pre-COVID never recommended lockdowns.

UsedUpUsername · 27/07/2021 21:43

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime

UsedUpUsername Masking and lockdowns are pseudo-science and have never been demonstrated to work.

And that, children, is why nurses and surgeons wear masks during surgery; because they don't work.

Omg do you actually think this?

It’s to prevent infecting their patient’s wounds with bacteria, which is magnitudes larger than viruses. Also to protect them from getting splashed with bodily fluids.

They don’t actually think it’s a barrier against viruses. You’d have to have at least a professionally fitted N95 or better.

Comedycook · 27/07/2021 21:34

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime

UsedUpUsername Masking and lockdowns are pseudo-science and have never been demonstrated to work.

And that, children, is why nurses and surgeons wear masks during surgery; because they don't work.

At the beginning of the pandemic I remember at one of the press conferences they told us that masks weren't necessary and the general public didn't need to wear them. Then the advice changed. Yet we should blindly believe every single thing they tell us and if we don't we're brainwashed conspiracy theorists. Righto
Flossatops · 27/07/2021 21:00

I honestly don't know how you overcome this problem. I have discussed this topic with a few friends who live in the US. It's a huge problem over there and many people are very worried and believe it poses a real threat. It seems it's gaining ground here. My sister refuses to have the vaccine for the same reasons and I've given up trying to reason with her as we'd end up not talking at all. Her partner's very ill and has no immunity but she's still resistant. Like all extremists, left or right, they get aggressive when you disagree with them. Many are victims of social media and not thinking for themselves, preaching other people's words and are glued to their laptops. The pandemic has compounded the anger felt from the Brexit divide and leaves most of us feeling helpless.

Aloethere · 27/07/2021 20:50

I'm not sure what you can do about it but try and connect in little ways like gardening or other things you know he likes.

It is scary how many people have been sucked into conspiracy theories over the last year and a bit, you can see evidence of that even on mumsnet. There isn't really any point in arguing back though, they become so entrenched in it. I have a friend who speaks of nothing else these days, it's very tiring to be around but I just smile and nod now because I know that nothing I say will make any difference.

Emilyontmoor · 27/07/2021 20:47

I won’t debate you here but let’s just say the experts have failed us badly. I think all sides can at least agree upon that.

Good grief, and people with no scientific expertise, like the lonely man next door who sits at his kitchen table in a ketchup stained t shirt leaning over his computer or the deranged attention seeking ex nurse who scared her 11 year old son witless with tales of genocide that never materialised would have served us better? Or indeed Heneghen, Gupta, the Fat Emperor etc who have never published any data to back up their theories (and have suspicious finding links to Trump supporting organisations in the US). Far more sinister than membership of a now irrelevant (in spite of the ridiculous right wing Hoover type US rhetoric you get on these websites) U.K. Communist Party.

The Scientists have responded to a novel virus to try to fill the knowledge gap from the start. From the Wuhan doctors who risked their livelihood and lives to get the information they had gathered in the virus’s DNA, infectiousness and death rates to the rest of the world including publishing then in the Lancet in mid January when Xi had not yet owned up. Right to the people who delivered vaccines in record time, not because they cut corners, or were acting for Bill Gates to implant us with chips or change our DNA but because they had the funding to implement the existing vaccine science. (I didn’t get this from a website I spoke to a vaccine expert back in May 2020 about the amazing progress being made.

I have a family member who has spent two hours each end of long days commuting in London to make their contribution, starting to deliver testing to London hospitals in March 2020 when Dido’s operation was still a complete shambles, catching Covid and giving it to me in the process. They have made amazing leaps in research into treatments and understanding of the disease compressed into such a short time, and in some countries where political ideology did not trump science they kept case and death rates low.

They did not understand the true nature and origins of SARS for 10 years but countries who put those lessons into practise have done far better than countries who thought they were exceptional.

Look at the map of death rates - the experts are worldwide but the countries that have done worst are where right wing ideology and western exceptionalism were most prevalent. We have been failed by right wing populism and croneyism not the experts.

Sugarandtime · 27/07/2021 20:43

You really just need to accept that you have your views and he’s had his.
You think he has been taken in by certain views and he thinks you have.

Just talk anything’s that don’t involve this virus.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 27/07/2021 20:42

Masking and lockdowns are pseudo-science and have never been demonstrated to work

Lockdowns clearly reduce transmission