Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think free healthcare as we know it won't exist in five/ten or so years from now?

166 replies

flashbac · 14/07/2021 10:46

And the NHS bill going through parliament is a confirmation of that?
Proposals are that:

Private companies will be able to offer services without any tendering processes (we know from the PPE fiasco how bad that is for the taxpayer),

the statutory duty to provide hospital services will be removed

private (FOR PROFIT) corporations to play a huge part in shaping virtually every aspect of our healthcare.

There's a demo about it today.

OP posts:
flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:51

@FightingtheFoo

For example when I was pregnant my repeated requests to have an elective Csection - rather than induction followed by the inevitable emergency C-section due to health condition + giant baby - were ignored until I started getting v v vocal.

Why? Because C sections cost the NHS more.

If you think the public NHS as it has your best interests at heart you're fucking joking. Just look ask all the bereaved mums who gave birth in Shropshire.

With all due respect that's a symptom of misogyny in the NHS and not because it public sector. With private sector c sections will be on the increase because they make more profit.
OP posts:
Whycangirlsbesonasty · 14/07/2021 11:50

But Germany. They still have a state run healthcare system. Just one that works. Can we copy them, not America?

FightingtheFoo · 14/07/2021 11:48

For example when I was pregnant my repeated requests to have an elective Csection - rather than induction followed by the inevitable emergency C-section due to health condition + giant baby - were ignored until I started getting v v vocal.

Why? Because C sections cost the NHS more.

If you think the public NHS as it has your best interests at heart you're fucking joking. Just look ask all the bereaved mums who gave birth in Shropshire.

rookiemere · 14/07/2021 11:47

It makes me laugh a bit when we talk about saving the NHS now. When I'm older and likely in need of it I doubt it will exist in any meaningful format at all, but still there's a reluctance to tax rich pensioners (natural Tory voters) and instead continue to gouge working age people for a service they are unlikely to continue to be able to use.

RedFaerieBoots · 14/07/2021 11:47

I do love how the inevitable comments of ach I'll just go private/get insurance. I appreciate Bupa isn't bad but this isn't what the American style system that the Tories want to open us up to.

You know how your pet when sick can cost thousands in the blink of an eye? That's exactly it.

My friends son has PCD. Due to her studying and then getting stuck here with Covid (son had to officially shield) her son has only spent just over 11yrs in the US. Only had 2 ops. He has spent 8yrs in Scotland.

His medical bill is in excess of $11 million.

They charge for every plaster, tube, oxygen mask, needle and swab. Ambulance also costs a fortune.

Other American friends.

  1. One spends nearly $1000 a month on her health plan which is a 3rd of her benefits via employer. This is before she pays rent and other bills or buys food.
  2. Another had to save up to get her ovarian cyst removed by taking on a second job. She had fallen off her parents insurance, retail doesn't offer benefit packages and she couldn't afford health insurance herself.
  3. Disabled friend (many immune conditions) had one important medication she needed that she was expected to pay $28,000 for. In the US if your registered disabled you can't work at all. So she had to crowd fund her treatment.

In the US diabetics will eek out insulin or use out of date insulin. Quite a few die because they run out and can't afford it.

65% of bankruptcies in America are health related.

The reason the NHS is in difficulty is because its been deliberately underfunded for decades by both Tory and Labour parties. The reason its creaking is their fault not the staff who have tried their best.

I know many Americans who would love to have the NHS. Yet many are so bloody willing to let it be destroyed because they can't be arsed fighting for it.

flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:47

@Nengineer

I think it's a good idea. The NHS is over and has been for a long time. People should have a choice.
What about people who can't afford it?
OP posts:
Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 11:46

According to our patient app which I’ve just checked we would be expected to pay for
Physio, counselling, podiatry, dietician, blood tests, vaccinations, covid - all tests, dentist, and optician and that’s just the first page. So it definitely happening. I suspect that over the next year even more services will added to the list.
We do need our nhs to be free at point of care. I think there needs to be hard choices to be made. If the nhs should be there for all in order to save lives, so the list of services needs to be addressed. Maybe we should pay for bunion surgery as it won’t actually kill you, for example? It’s that or people pay a lot more for an ever expanding service, but historically people don’t vote for tax increases or can afford them even if they would.
I do believe that it won’t be an easy solution making everyone happy but nor do I believe a privatised nhs is in anyway a good thing.

MarshaBradyo · 14/07/2021 11:46

[quote Taliskerskye]@user27424799642256
Yeah I will. That’s my worry actually! I’m fit and healthy now. But if I got a chronic condition I really don’t think I could rely on the nhs which is pretty terrible[/quote]
Yes do

Usually exemptions though even within it

flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:46

And private sector money making will only increase dependency. They dont want to treat you and sign you off, they want you to be a cash cow for years to come because they are looking at their turnover not you.

OP posts:
Nengineer · 14/07/2021 11:45

I think it's a good idea. The NHS is over and has been for a long time. People should have a choice.

Taliskerskye · 14/07/2021 11:45

And god only knows what awaits us when it comes to social care in the future.
I’m not saying this as a boomer basher, but basically the only people who will have had anything decent are the boomer generation.
How we’ve gone so downhill from there I don’t know

sashh · 14/07/2021 11:45

I'm surprised that they've not even tried charging for missed appointments. Even £5 per missed appointment would make sense considering that many GPs have a miss 3 appointments and you're off their list policy

Because it costs more than £5 to collect £5. Because for some families that would mean going without.

When I rule the world all NHS managers and gov ministers dealing with health will have to spend a week a year 'at the shape end', managers should come from the NHS. The number of times new managers arrive, try to implement the same change the last 5 managers did and it didn't work but then brand NHS staff as 'old fashioned' for not trying the same thing the 6th time is doing no one any good.

FightingtheFoo · 14/07/2021 11:44

The NHS already do that @Flamingo49 because they're trying to save as much money as possible.

flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:44

Exactly @Flamingo49, people don't understand that private sector = for PROFIT. You are just a number, a unit. How much money can they make from you? How cheaply can they do it? And who can you complain to if they cut corners?

OP posts:
Whycangirlsbesonasty · 14/07/2021 11:41

Is the plan if the service provided is bad enough then those that can afford to will turn to private and then the strain on the NHS will reduce? Because it seems that way. It doesn’t seem like a very well thought through plan if that is the case.

Taliskerskye · 14/07/2021 11:40

@user27424799642256
Yeah I will. That’s my worry actually! I’m fit and healthy now. But if I got a chronic condition I really don’t think I could rely on the nhs which is pretty terrible

flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:40

I agree the system needs to change but I dont trust people with disdain for poor people, with disdain for fair and open processes, who funnel cash to their mates and donors, to do it!
Look at the test and trace fiasco. Do we really think the people who were in charge of that to bring about efficiency and value for money in the NHS?

OP posts:
Flamingo49 · 14/07/2021 11:39

@FightingtheFoo

I think there's a lot of confusion about what privatising the NHS means. A lot of people (myself included) have only the most basic understanding of how the NHS works eg the fact that hospitals are managed and paid for by trusts.

The key point is that regardless of who is providing the care (whether a state funded or private company) as long as it is free at point of care that is all that matters.

So it is, in theory, irrelevant whether it's a private clinic doing your scan or one run by a health trust as long as you don't have to pay for it.

The pros and cons of those services being provided by a private company vs a public one are a separate conversation.

From your post I can't see anything suggesting that care will no longer be free to users - if you can point me to something that does I would be interested to see it.

The US system is barbaric but I cannot imagine that is what is being proposed here.

No, it is not all that matters. A private company is not operating health services out of the goodness of their hearts, they are in it for profit. So, for example, if you sought mental health support from a service run by a private provider, perhaps they might not offer you a clinical psychologist, it might be an unqualified mental health worker with minimal training. And you might be offered 6 sessions instead of the necessary 16. Anything to make a profit!
AluckyEllie · 14/07/2021 11:35

I work for the nhs and yes, it will be completely different. Have you seen the Cleveland Clinic that is being built in London? American healthcare firms are ready to pounce- and their recruiting from the nhs. They are currently looking for icu nurses and after the year we’ve had..:. It’s tempting.

Scrunchies · 14/07/2021 11:34

I’m at Gp and I think that there should be some form of privatisation. I don’t have all the answers but think the nhs at the moment is a failing system. As PP says camhs is absolutely atrocious service provision.

Overall there is too much demand, it tries to cover too many things. It simply cannot provide everything for everybody, and sadly it does get abused. Usually this means that the people who rarely use it struggle to even get basic needs met, and high frequency users become more and more dependant and have higher expectations about what they are entitled too. And nobody ends up happy.

I agree with pp that nhs staff are often rude and aloof - I certainly have been previously and it was because I was utterly burnt out, overworked, put upon and became emotionally detached. I stopped caring. The system needs to change.

flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:33

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

Yes, I expect there will come a time we'll need to have private insurance. They'd better bloody well not take the tax off us too though!
We'll still be taxed. Someone has to pay for them to get rich after all. That is what this is. It's not to save tax. It's so that there is more for them.
OP posts:
notanothertakeaway · 14/07/2021 11:32

I believe that one of the issues is that the NHS now covers so many treatments that weren't even contemplated at the time it was set up

I had a minor health scare a year or two ago, and I was beyond impressed at how well I was treated. I'm sad it's not always like that for everyone

TotorosCatBus · 14/07/2021 11:29

I agree.
We already have dentistry that we pay for even if it's NHS treatment abs I can imagine other services doing the same.
I'm surprised that they've not even tried charging for missed appointments. Even £5 per missed appointment would make sense considering that many GPs have a miss 3 appointments and you're off their list policy

hazandduck · 14/07/2021 11:27

I recently had a couple of issues that I paid for private consultations because I didn’t want to wait for my NHS appointment. Since then, DH and I have looked at healthcare packages for the 4 of us because we realised we actually spend more on tv and internet a month than the cost of health cover! It’s something we’ve realised we should prioritise especially with the knock on of covid and the waiting lists growing all the time. I really think we will be seeing the impacts of healthcare services being so reduced and restricted these last 18 months for at least the next 5 years. And if we are going private it frees up a spot for someone less able to afford it.

I do think healthcare in the UK needs a big rethink. It’s almost like a blind religion the way people bark ‘Save the NHS’ without any sort of criticism allowed.

Whycangirlsbesonasty · 14/07/2021 11:25

There does seem to be such a suspicious attitude to anything to do with the NHS. The recent ‘GPs selling your data’ nonsense when the GP data was merely to be totally anonymised and passed to the UK Biobank for use in medical research. Yet the assumption was that your data would be sold to e.g. your car insurance company to know whether to increase your premiums, or life insurance companies, or Stannah to know where to send their stairlift advertising.

Swipe left for the next trending thread