Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think free healthcare as we know it won't exist in five/ten or so years from now?

166 replies

flashbac · 14/07/2021 10:46

And the NHS bill going through parliament is a confirmation of that?
Proposals are that:

Private companies will be able to offer services without any tendering processes (we know from the PPE fiasco how bad that is for the taxpayer),

the statutory duty to provide hospital services will be removed

private (FOR PROFIT) corporations to play a huge part in shaping virtually every aspect of our healthcare.

There's a demo about it today.

OP posts:
FlowersinJune · 14/07/2021 16:00

Totally agree with those saying nhs not fit for purpose. Child has been ill since Jan and the care he has received has been non-existent and dire. Worse thing is when we have offered to go private we have been told we can, but no team has the experience they do and he won’t get care and treatment he needs. So I stuck with them and am just exhausted now. We were told we would have appointment in June. Got cancelled day before and we are waiting for a new one and told unlikely to be before September.

You send emails. If you get a reply it generally contradicts what someone else says.

The nhs is used as a political football. Tories don’t want to touch it (I know there are something things, but not wholesale reorganisation) as then they are accused of privatisation. Labour the same but they don’t want to be accused of being blue Labour or pissing off unions.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 14/07/2021 15:35

@Whycangirlsbesonasty

Indeed. But the NHS in its current form is totally unaffordable, and every year that passes only makes it more so. We have some of the lowest doctor to patient ratios in Europe, the worst cancer outcomes in Europe too. It’s underfunded, and we cannot keep throwing money at it in the hope that things improve as the nhs in its current form is unaffordable.

We need to look at how other European health services are funded and take the best system they have. Germany for instance has a public healthcare system funded by employer and employees. We don’t want to end up like America but is it such a bad thing to try to aim to be a bit like Germany?

But, whenever changing the funding of the NHS is raised, so many different groups start screeching like banshees that the plans get shelved and we end up with the same underfunded, failing system we have now. A prime example is CAMHS. We don’t have a CAMHS that works even slightly in this country. If you can afford it you go private, if not your child sits on a waiting list for years. Things HAVE to change!

Absolutely this
Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 15:27

@AlternativePerspective

Brave! I have always believed that the nhs should treat life threatening conditions from which you could die. There are a lot of things which are sad but not life threatening. Totally agree with you on not funding things like ivf and cosmetic procedures.
Fully expect someone to to come along and say that they would have died without a nose job/boob reduction/ ivf etc. As I’ve had that in real life.
The reality is people expect too much from the nhs and medical breakthroughs have meant that more can be done, but it needs paying for - and a lot of people do not want higher taxes but not do they want some things to no longer be available on the nhs.
Would I be happy to see a reduction in services and pay a higher tax - yes, if it meant not waiting months for a GP /nurse appointment and hospital waits were down to weeks. That’s the pay off for me. Less services/ higher taxes but a better service for life threatening conditions.

AlternativePerspective · 14/07/2021 15:15

The NHS as it is is not fit for purpose now though.

So many conditions and treatments available for them which weren’t available at the inception of the NHS, and everyone believes that their issue is important and should be funded when actually there needs to be more consideration given to what should and shouldn’t be funded.

Fertility treatment for instance which has an extremely low success rate (approx 30%) shouldn’t be funded on the NHS. it’s sad but the NHS should be saving lives not creating new ones.

One of the reasons why the policies for implanting embrio’s was changed was because it increased the number of premature births which in turn increased the amount of pressure on neonatal units, now the reduction in the number of embrio’s put back means that the success rate of IVF has dropped.

Cosmetic surgery for anything other than disfigurement due to e.g. car accident etc shouldn’t be funded.

There are so many things which other people will feel shouldn’t be funded and there needs to be an overhaul of what is and isn’t eligible for funding.

The NHS simply isn’t a bottomless pit, and something has to give.

Nengineer · 14/07/2021 15:04

With dentistry she can pay. Getting a GP referral for private treatment if a routine condition is almost impossible. She could and now would pay. She tried with her knee and ended up flying to me and paying for it just so she could remove the agony.

Nengineer · 14/07/2021 15:02

@flashbac at the moment people who don't work DO have full access to medical and dentistry and SEN assessments. It's unlikely to change but how about creating equality to people who can afford it to have the same standard of care? My mum is 77 and spending thousands on her teeth. Her cleaner (cash in hand because my family are champagne socialists) has so far paid nothing for the same treatment because she doesn't work. She comes from a horrendous background and I went to school with her but she's fit and healthy and never worked legitimately.

JonahofArk · 14/07/2021 13:33

For those with private medical cover, which company have you gone with?

Sidge · 14/07/2021 13:31

I work in the NHS.

It needs depoliticising. No single party should decide how the NHS is funded or run. (I think the same about education).

It needs total reform but to do that piecemeal is virtually impossible. It’s huge and unwieldy.

I don’t have an issue with private providers tendering for NHS work if they can offer a better service for the same or less money as the NHS - they can mop up maybe less acute services such as dermatology, ophthalmology, podiatry, outpatient physiotherapy, etc. As long as the patients receive quality care and in a timely fashion without paying at the point of delivery who cares whether it’s a private or public provider?

I also think those that can pay, should pay, even a nominal amount. Not a two tier service, just a way of charging those that can afford it. A European model is far preferable to an American one though.

People don’t value that which is perceived as free. If they had to pay for it in the same way they do other life essentials such as housing, utilities and food they might appreciate it more.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 13:20

Not to me room how many would just pay up not realising. (That would be me) @VeryQuaintIrene

VeryQuaintIrene · 14/07/2021 13:13

Anything other than the US system, which is awful mostly because of the insanely greedy and inefficient insurance companies. I had some dental work done a while back, was told it would be covered by my insurance and then received a huge bill. When I called up my dentist to find out why it wasn't covered they just told me that this is what the insurance companies do, just to see if you will pay their inflated sums without complaint. After several back and forth communications, they accepted a smaller amount of money from me. But multiply that by millions and it's an absurd waste of money and time. A single-payer seems essential to me.

Whycangirlsbesonasty · 14/07/2021 13:11

The NHS is underfunded and unaffordable as the vast amount of money we send it’s way is not enough and we can’t afford to pilot in more. In Germany the health service is funded half by employees and half by employers, whereas here we have an NHS funded by the government which is on its knees and BUPA etc funded by companies and private individuals. Why not send the company money to the NHS instead of BUPA?

BlueCupOrangeCup · 14/07/2021 12:53

I have had private Healthcare with all of my employers since about 2012.

It's not the silver bullet that people seem to think it is.

I take immune suppressant injections biweekly for a condition that up until age 30 was making my life miserable. (Age 30 I got access to these eyewateringly expensive injections and my life changed, frankly.)

It is a condition I have had since age 11.

Are my injections covered by any private Healthcare provider I have ever had? Are they f*ck.

Private Healthcare care providers are insurance companies really, and they behave like them.

Thank goodness for the NHS. I honestly don't know what my plan B would be. I dread to think.

squid12346 · 14/07/2021 12:44

I feel like the NHS wastes a lot of money and are pretty inefficient in some areas. So maybe this is a way to try and get it working better. Well one can hope!

FixTheBone · 14/07/2021 12:40

@Whycangirlsbesonasty

Indeed. But the NHS in its current form is totally unaffordable, and every year that passes only makes it more so. We have some of the lowest doctor to patient ratios in Europe, the worst cancer outcomes in Europe too. It’s underfunded, and we cannot keep throwing money at it in the hope that things improve as the nhs in its current form is unaffordable.

We need to look at how other European health services are funded and take the best system they have. Germany for instance has a public healthcare system funded by employer and employees. We don’t want to end up like America but is it such a bad thing to try to aim to be a bit like Germany?

But, whenever changing the funding of the NHS is raised, so many different groups start screeching like banshees that the plans get shelved and we end up with the same underfunded, failing system we have now. A prime example is CAMHS. We don’t have a CAMHS that works even slightly in this country. If you can afford it you go private, if not your child sits on a waiting list for years. Things HAVE to change!

How can it be underfunded AND unaffordable at the same time.

The decision to underfund the NHS is political one. We spend less per person per year than almost any other developed nation, and we are supposedly one of the wealthiest.

If you're saying we cant afford it, and the stats say we don't spend that much on healthcare, then someone, somewhere is lying.

The money spent on Brexit for example would pay for the NHS for the next ten years. The money we're going to lose from Brexit each and every year going forward, would have paid for the NHS EVERY year. HS2, Trident would go a long way towards it as well.

I agree things have to change, but instead of tearing everything down and starting again, maybe start by just spending as much as some of these other countries and having similar numbers of doctors, hospital beds, MRI scanners.

IHTC · 14/07/2021 12:25

@LookABabyShark

I know this isn’t a popular opinion here, but the NHS as it is at present is nowhere near fit for purpose. I have had a couple of health conditions pretty much my whole life, and I can honestly, hand on heart say that I do not recognise the selfless, kind, caring “angels” the NHS have been promoted as over the last year or so. My PERSONAL experience has been very, very different even pre-Covid; rude, impatient sometimes aggressive medical staff, delayed or cancelled appointments with no notice, being left waiting weeks for important test results, only to be told they have been lost, the sense that I should be grateful that they are doing their jobs and treating me (almost verbatim from one nurse)...the Covid crisis has just highlighted that this is NOT a system fit for purpose, and the government have been trying to distract us from that with the constant fawning and sob stories. I’m not saying private is the way to go, but something definitely needs to change in my experience 🤷🏻‍♀️
Couldn't agree more with this.

The NHS is dying and has been for years and years. It can no longer meet the needs of the amount of people that live in this country.

Flamingo49 · 14/07/2021 12:16

@FightingtheFoo

The NHS already do that *@Flamingo49* because they're trying to save as much money as possible.
I agree (I work in the NHS) but there is a big difference between trying to save money and trying to make money. I manage our team's budget and I am always trying to save money where I can, but my intent is always to provide the best service we possibly can, I'm not thinking about how we can make as much money as possible. The pathways and decisions made would be very different.
laura246810 · 14/07/2021 12:16

The UK pays 7 percent of GDP on healthcare (nhs + private). The US pays 18 percent (12 percent for free healthcare for poor/ elderly, 8 percent private). Germany pays 12 percent of gdp (private + public).

Of course your taxes wont go down if we all get private healthcare. Wed have to pay for the poor (such as disabled) and elderly (quite rightly) who obviously use a lot of healthcare. We may even need to pay more taxes for healthcare (such as the US and their 12 percent). Japan has 10x more CT scanners per capita than we do.

The NHS should be criticised how else can it improve! But people saying we shouldnt fund the nhs more because it already gets a lot of funding clearly dont understand how poorly funded it is. Wed have to almost double the funding to be near a european healthcare spend average.

SimonJT · 14/07/2021 12:16

I have type one diabetes and I lost most of my spleen as a small child, as a result my two chronic health conditions need a lot of careful management. When I worked in the States for a short time my insulin and strips were not covered by the very good policy provided by my employer. I was paying around $360 a month in insulin, now diabetics vary hugely, I’m not a big user of insulin, some people need more, so their costs would be higher.

How many people could afford to pay over $4,000 every single year of their life to stay alive? Thats before we consider other associated health issues that those of us with type one diabetes are vulnerable to, plus how much will annual check ups of sight, feet etc cost?

chocolateorangeinhaler · 14/07/2021 12:03

I've worked in the NHS for a long long time and sadly I think it needs to happen. It was fine when people respected it and didn't abuse it but the public expectations are now that you can have what you want when you want from the NHS and if you don't get it then make a compensation claim.

FightingtheFoo · 14/07/2021 11:58

Yes absolutely - I don't trust private doctors because I always suspect they're trying to squeeze more money out of me and I don't trust NHS doctors because I know for a fact they are offering me shitty, inadequate care to save themselves money.

I don't know what the answer is. But I absolutely do not treat the NHS like some sort of bastion of holiness. Believe me, I am extremely grateful that I get my (literally) life-saving medication (insulin) for free but the day to day care is woeful especially in terms of management.

Here's a great example. As a diabetic I need annual foot check ups. I went to the GP to get a referral to podiatry. Podiatry checked my feet, said they're fine and discharged me. I'm fucking diabetic. I will never not be diabetic. I need my feet checked annually.

So now I have to waste my time and the GP's to get an annual referral? It's ridiculous.

Equally people abuse the NHS and we should be given lessons on how to use it properly. The only time I ever went to A&E I was sat near reception and some of the things I heard people come in for was absurd - and this was pre-pandemic so no excuse - one came in for ringworm, another was a woman who'd fainted 2 days ago and proudly said she hasn't been to her GP in 7 years ago. Why was she at A&E?

The NHS is a mess. There is an argument that private companies providing services would be better run. I'm not saying I necessarily subscribe to it but it's not the same as a US insurance-based system.

Taliskerskye · 14/07/2021 11:57

We are going to end up with an American system by stealth.
If it was honestly talked about we might stand a chance at a decent system. But no government will do that.

Cowbells · 14/07/2021 11:56

@Taliskerskye

I’m genuinely thinking of getting private healthcare. I think if anything serious goes wrong with me in the next few years I will be fucked
Me too. We already pay for NHS (I'll provide my own biscuit OP Biscuit Grin) but the service we get is so awful I don't trust it to meet my medical needs over the years to come. So yes, OP I agree. It's being dismantled but I bet our taxes don't go down.
Whycangirlsbesonasty · 14/07/2021 11:54

I worry that by banning all discussion of an alternatively funded NHS we are going to end up with a choice between an American system for those that can afford it or an unworkable NHS for those that can’t. Bad for the UK public regardless of which we choose.

flashbac · 14/07/2021 11:52

@Whycangirlsbesonasty

But Germany. They still have a state run healthcare system. Just one that works. Can we copy them, not America?
But that won't enrich the Tories at the top you see. The donors need to be fed.
OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 14/07/2021 11:51

I wouldn’t go to US for model but there are others

Aus has a different one which has small fees

Swipe left for the next trending thread