Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think free healthcare as we know it won't exist in five/ten or so years from now?

166 replies

flashbac · 14/07/2021 10:46

And the NHS bill going through parliament is a confirmation of that?
Proposals are that:

Private companies will be able to offer services without any tendering processes (we know from the PPE fiasco how bad that is for the taxpayer),

the statutory duty to provide hospital services will be removed

private (FOR PROFIT) corporations to play a huge part in shaping virtually every aspect of our healthcare.

There's a demo about it today.

OP posts:
Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 18:36

@CuteOrangeElephant so you get a discount for dual insurance ? Only asking as I make that 126+100= 226.
Confused.

CuteOrangeElephant · 14/07/2021 18:29

I'm in the Netherlands and my insurance costs 126 euro per month and my husband's 100 euro. Our DD goes free so in total 190 GBP a month. At first it felt strange to pay for health care, but honestly I was shocked by how much better the health care is here.

I can go online and book an appointment with my GP tomorrow. I had a routine cardiologist appointment which was within a month of requesting one. I had two EEGs, an ultrasound, two different blood tests and a conversation with the cardiologist and I was out of the door within an hour and a half. Similar investigations in the UK had me spend the whole day in hospital. That did cost me 380 euros for my deductible, but if I need any further health care this year it would be free. People on low incomes get a subsidy for their health care costs.

pubble · 14/07/2021 18:10

I love how you think health insurance is £50 a month.

Someone said on another thread that no families should be struggling if a parent dies or becomes incapacitated because it's easy to get cheap insurance that mitigates any financial impact of a death/injury/illness.

Someone asked what 🦄 insurance the poster used that offered that & unsurprisingly the poster didn't even have insurance but was sure it was available 😆

WB205020 · 14/07/2021 18:05

The NHS as we know it is doomed but its also a poison chalice and whoever is HS at the time will be reluctant to change anything major as whenever any changes are proposed pitch folks are out and its career ending. Look at Andrew Langsley i'm not getting into whether his changes were right or not but when he made changes it cost him his job because a baying mob wanted blood.

I genuinely fear the only way the NHS will change is when it has completely collapsed as trying to change it before only seems to end in career ending pushback and i doubt any MP will step up to the plate to do that only to have their career ended as a result.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 18:05

@Taliskerskye

If you can afford a fancy phone contract. You can afford healthcare, £50 p/m
My fancy phone contract is £20 per month. Couldn’t get an eye test for that let alone fancy private insurance! Private health insurance is way, way out of our league.
pubble · 14/07/2021 18:04

If you can afford a fancy phone contract.You can afford healthcare,£50 p/m

Which provider do you recommend? I'd like to see what it covers

SimonJT · 14/07/2021 17:59

@Taliskerskye

If you can afford a fancy phone contract. You can afford healthcare, £50 p/m
Comprehensive health insurance for a healthy adult who doesn’t smoke and doesn’t have any health conditions is around £300-350 per month, on top of that you have a yearly co-pay.
RedFaerieBoots · 14/07/2021 17:47

a lot of dosh

RedFaerieBoots · 14/07/2021 17:47

I love how you think health insurance is £50 a month.

Heres a wee search from Google on American health insurance (which will give the Tories who have fingers in the right pies at of dosh)

"In 2020, the average national cost for health insurance is $456 for an individual and $1,152 for a family per month"

Hardly £50

Taliskerskye · 14/07/2021 17:13

And I’m not saying you should. I’m just saying it’s doable for most people

Taliskerskye · 14/07/2021 17:13

If you can afford a fancy phone contract. You can afford healthcare,
£50 p/m

LobotomisedIceSkatingFan · 14/07/2021 17:10

I'm pretty left-wing, but I got Benenden Health cover for me and my three kids about two ago principally because of the difficulty of getting a GP appointment at our surgery. I work 50+ hrs a week and don't yet drive so I can't take just any appointment (I pay out a fortune in public transport and taxi fares for various hospital appointments as it is). It's tighten my sphincter when it comes out each month but I've had to use it once and it was so fucking smooth it removed any lingering doubts about whether to keep paying the month dd.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 17:06

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

I suspect that charging like that would be more expensive than direct taxation from wages. Therefore those that can least afford it, pay more as the additional recovery costs need to be covered.

pubble · 14/07/2021 17:05

How many people could afford to pay over $4,000 every single year of their life to stay alive? Thats before we consider other associated health issues that those of us with type one diabetes are vulnerable to, plus how much will annual check ups of sight, feet etc cost?

Not many.

pubble · 14/07/2021 17:02

Another thing I question re private healthcare is how people are supposed to afford it. We have very housing costs in this country & a decade of wage stagnation, even those earning well may struggle.

Jackofallsorts · 14/07/2021 17:01

The NHS is now beyond reproach and criticism. Having 100% free healthcare for 60m+ people to the standard that's expected is not feasible.
There is a disconnect between the cost of providing even basic healthcare and what people's perception of the cost is.
If something is free it looses its value.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 14/07/2021 17:01

I think if changes are needed to ensure we have the system then they should be for all or none, not layered depending on salary etc.
I think there are plenty of ways to raise funds, charge for a gp appointment, prescription charges for all, missed appointments at hospitals charged etc. Better than just raising taxes as the extra is funded by those using it.

pubble · 14/07/2021 16:58

We are going to have to address the fact we have an ageing population & the burden that comes with that but no one wants to "pay" n

pubble · 14/07/2021 16:56

I think it will definitely become less 'free' over time. The sad thing is that you could do it in a fair way -- you could adopt the French model where you pay according to your means. A huge percentage pay nothing at all, lower income pay a few quid, and even the highest income people don't pay loads (25 quid for the GP). And French health care is very good.

I like the French system.

pubble · 14/07/2021 16:55

also think state pension age will move out.

pubble · 14/07/2021 16:54

I've thought this for years, there will be no free at the point of care or prescriptions when I approach retirement.

Baystard · 14/07/2021 16:52

The difference between a private corporate provider and an NHS lab doing certain tests, say, is that the private provider can be sacked and replaced with someone else if they're not up to scratch.

If we had a track record of funding healthcare appropriately I would agree with you. As it is we will invariably procure on price. Sacking a cheap and poor quality private provider and replacing them with a competent but more expensive one just won't happen.

Baystard · 14/07/2021 16:50

Our routine NHS provision is bad, the GP is over-worked, the receptionist has no concept of customer care, appointments are given seemingly grudgingly. Consequently I often use the good private GP and consultant led services nearby for routine things, it's not that expensive, they're civil on the phone, and an appointment is routinely 20 mins so you don't feel horribly rushed.

I would be happy paying the NHS more for better service but I fear that privatisation, without paying any more overall, will just further erode the quality of care. What motivation do private providers have to provide a good service? Their contract will undoubtedly be awarded on the basis of price and they'll provide a cheap poor quality service through NHS, and a good service for private-paying clients. We'll be exactly where we are now.

The £350m on the side of the bus was criminal, the NHS desperately needs the money and has been starved for years, and then using the false promise of giving it more funding to make citizens vote for something which isn't actually in their best interests. Pah.

RandomLondoner · 14/07/2021 16:47

No, it is not all that matters. A private company is not operating health services out of the goodness of their hearts, they are in it for profit.

Each and ever healthcare worker is a private provider. They, quite rightly, don't work for free, out of the goodness of their hearts, as you put it.

The difference between a private corporate provider and an NHS lab doing certain tests, say, is that the private provider can be sacked and replaced with someone else if they're not up to scratch.

Presumably the people who think the NHS should be a monolithic organisation that subcontracts nothing, not even catering and cleaning, believe that the Soviet Union failed because over a period of 70 years they just didn't try hard enough to make communism work, there weren't enough five-year plans to raise production and standards. They believe its failure had nothing to do with the absence of market forces to price goods and labour accurately, facilitating accurate allocation of resources.

CounsellorTroi · 14/07/2021 16:24

@Whycangirlsbesonasty

I worry that by banning all discussion of an alternatively funded NHS we are going to end up with a choice between an American system for those that can afford it or an unworkable NHS for those that can’t. Bad for the UK public regardless of which we choose.
Could I just point out that this bill will affect only England. Westminster has no say in how the NHS is run in Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland.
Swipe left for the next trending thread