Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think free healthcare as we know it won't exist in five/ten or so years from now?

166 replies

flashbac · 14/07/2021 10:46

And the NHS bill going through parliament is a confirmation of that?
Proposals are that:

Private companies will be able to offer services without any tendering processes (we know from the PPE fiasco how bad that is for the taxpayer),

the statutory duty to provide hospital services will be removed

private (FOR PROFIT) corporations to play a huge part in shaping virtually every aspect of our healthcare.

There's a demo about it today.

OP posts:
Hardbackwriter · 14/07/2021 19:30

@UndertheCedartree

I don't recognise a lot of this waiting for years etc. My DS needed to see CAMHS - he was seen within a few weeks and they referred him to the Child Development Centre He saw a paediatrician a few weeks after that. Covid has affected things, of course but he has continued to have OT appointments when possible (some in person, some by telephone/Teams). He has been assessed and diagnosed by a Specialist. I can't fault his treatment at all. It seems such a postcode lottery.
Were things very serious? Twice in my life I've found the NHS has suddenly gone into hyper-efficient mode. Once when I was pregnant with DS1 the consultant listened to his heartbeat and said he needed a scan and I said 'will I get a letter with the appointment?' and she said 'no, I'm taking you for it now'. The other time was when I had this suspected cancer and they needed to remove it because the original biopsy was inconclusive and it was growing rapidly and I asked when the operation would be and the doctor said 'I'm just going to ring to see if it can be tomorrow' (it was the day after that). Tbh it was absolutely terrifying both times because I know the pace at which things normally moved and so I knew they thought things might be really bad.
Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 19:30

@Hardbackwriter

Yep and brings in additional questions over wether we should as a nation decide when enough is enough treatment. Do we allow euthanasia? Do we treat at all costs regardless of outcome (happens currently), Do we allow people to actively make choices about their care/health choices in the event of serious illness or accident AND respect and enforce them? By which I’m talking about friends/family/society and Drs.

pubble · 14/07/2021 19:28

I know the threshold is low but what does that mean in practice?

It's only if you go into an actual care home that your property value is taken into account not if you have care at home.

Even if permanently in a care home, the value of your property is not included if your partner still lives in the home or a child is there.

unidentifed · 14/07/2021 19:28

I really just wish we could follow a country with a good model like Sweden.

The NHS in its current form isn't working. Being totally private like the US won't work either, there really has to be a bit of both.

I'm in Canada (used to live in the UK) and here it's all national health with zero option to go private. That doesn't work either.

UndertheCedartree · 14/07/2021 19:26

I don't recognise a lot of this waiting for years etc. My DS needed to see CAMHS - he was seen within a few weeks and they referred him to the Child Development Centre He saw a paediatrician a few weeks after that. Covid has affected things, of course but he has continued to have OT appointments when possible (some in person, some by telephone/Teams). He has been assessed and diagnosed by a Specialist. I can't fault his treatment at all. It seems such a postcode lottery.

Hardbackwriter · 14/07/2021 19:25

[quote pubble]@Hardbackwriter I was in a ward last yr & everyone was elderly except myself (30s) & a women in her 50s. What also struck me is how some needed additional attention & couldn't advocate for themselves. One had dementia & was quite aggressive. The nurses understandably really struggled to manage it all as some frankly needed 1:1 care. [/quote]
Yes, that's a good point and a really big part of the issue - as you get older you aren't just more likely to need any care, you're also much more likely to have multiple, comorbid conditions that make providing that care really difficult. A few years ago (I was 31) I needed an operation (suspected cancer - and I will say the NHS went into an amazingly efficient mode when they thought it could be serious for me; very luckily it wasn't) and again was the only person under about 70 there and the nurse talking through the pre-operation form actually laughed at how quick and easy it was to do it because I didn't have any other conditions 'and that never happens'.

I'm very conscious that this sounds almost like I'm saying older people are getting 'too much' or that they're a burden. I'm very much not and absolutely want people to have all the treatment they need throughout their lives but it's foolish to pretend that this can be done easily or affordably giving our ageing population.

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2021 19:23

@pubble

The boomer generation is selling its houses to fund social care.

Are they? The dementia tax which had some merit caused outrage.

Yes, they are. Lots of them. You’re living under a rock if you don’t know this. Our kids are well aware that if we live long enough there will be no inheritance.

The proposed dementia tax was different. It brought your house into the equation if you needed non residential care. You could live in it until you died, then the local authority took its money back.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 19:23

@pubble. It would seem that quite a few are. The threshold at which the state will pay is very low. Even if you can get deferred payments to pay for the care home, the house is normally sold in order to pay back that loan. Once the cash runs out assets do have to be realised until you reach the threshold for council payments. Not many families are able to step in to save the ‘family’ home.

pubble · 14/07/2021 19:20

A family friend needed an op but the wait was very long & condition very likely to deteriorate. They could afford the not so insignificant private operation but what about those that can't?

hopeishere · 14/07/2021 19:18

It might be free but where I am (NI) it's crap. You've no chance of getting a knee or hip operation for example. Huge waits for everything else. So it's not a "service".

There needs to be a more open discussion about alternatives it's not a choice between NHS and a US system.

pubble · 14/07/2021 19:17

The boomer generation is selling its houses to fund social care.

Are they? The dementia tax which had some merit caused outrage.

Blossomtoes · 14/07/2021 19:13

@Taliskerskye

And god only knows what awaits us when it comes to social care in the future. I’m not saying this as a boomer basher, but basically the only people who will have had anything decent are the boomer generation. How we’ve gone so downhill from there I don’t know
The boomer generation is selling its houses to fund social care. We fully accept that we’re going to have to pay if we need it. Hell, we’ve even got a “care home fund” and that’ll be gone and we’ll be onto the house in no time if we both need care.

We’re both in our sixties so deep in boomer territory.

pubble · 14/07/2021 19:11

@Hardbackwriter I was in a ward last yr & everyone was elderly except myself (30s) & a women in her 50s. What also struck me is how some needed additional attention & couldn't advocate for themselves. One had dementia & was quite aggressive. The nurses understandably really struggled to manage it all as some frankly needed 1:1 care.

CastawayQueen · 14/07/2021 19:09

@Hardbackwriter

Sometimes I feel like quitting my job and joining politics so I can fix all this annoying shit.

If you do you might find it's all a bit harder than you currently realise...

I know - that’s why I haven’t done it (also because I’m a foreigner). I’m on committees etc at work and getting 6 people to agree on things is hard enough let alone entire parties 😂 Probably why negotiation and ‘soft skills’ command a premium but let’s not go there. Also ‘Why we get the wrong politicians’ by Isabel Hardman … enlightening
pubble · 14/07/2021 19:07

I think younger people do already - when I’ve received NHS prescriptions have had to pay

Yes they are means tested except for children & over 60s. Obviously those with lifelong conditions should still get the certificate thing but I think not means testing over 60s is ridiculous & it's not sustainable.

"By 2030, one in five people in the UK (21.8%) will be aged 65 or over, 6.8% will be aged 75+ and 3.2% will be aged 85+ (ONS, 2017b)."

Also I find people who need healthcare being able to leave lots of money to their children obscene. Your money is for your life and if you have that much extra everyone else’s shouldn’t be paying for you.

I agree but unfortunately it's deeply unpopular in part because the housing market is so screwed many need that inheritance to get on the ladder. It's all a bloody mess.

FlowersinJune · 14/07/2021 19:07

@Hardbackwriter so true. My friend is a GP and she always despairs when people say “charge for missed GP/hospital appointments”. Cause as she points out probably 95% of missed appointments are elderly/children/those with mental health issues, where it would be completely inappropriate to charge/you would never recover anyway.

Hardbackwriter · 14/07/2021 19:06

Sometimes I feel like quitting my job and joining politics so I can fix all this annoying shit.

If you do you might find it's all a bit harder than you currently realise...

Hardbackwriter · 14/07/2021 19:03

@pubble

We are going to have to address the fact we have an ageing population & the burden that comes with that but no one wants to "pay" n
Absolutely. Someone upthread said the NHS will become only free for pensioners, children and those on benefits - keeping it free for children and the elderly would mean it was barely worth charging. Every time I go to hospital or the GP I'm struck by how dominant little children (usually the reason I'm there) or the elderly are. I went to the eye clinic at the hospital recently - which was actually for me, for once - and was the only patient under pension age out of about 40 people; I'd say around half were clearly over 80. Which is in many ways a wonderful sign of progress - there are all these older people needing treatment now because we've done so well at extending life spans - but it leaves the NHS in such a fundamentally different position from when it was created and it's increasingly clear that the original model can't adapt to this.
Countrydiary · 14/07/2021 19:02

I think part of the trouble with the debate is that the private healthcare offered in the UK at the moment is not a full health service. Maternity services for example aren’t really available unless you go super rich levels and go the The Portland like The Duchess of Cambridge. For a lot of complex or chronic conditions you are turfed off private cover immediately. Degenerative conditions that often affect elderly people which will increase with an aging population are not covered. Something goes wrong in an operation in a private hospital and the NHS will pick up the pieces.

An American system terrifies me as in theory you could be bankrupted if you have the (already) bad luck to get really sick.

A lot of Europe and New Zealand/Australia seem to have good systems, though I don’t know how they work to be able to comment on them properly. However, there is something wonderful about the concept of free at the point of use which would be such a shame to lose.

I think as a country we also need to properly look at everything that feeds into the NHS- preventative healthcare, social care, the welfare state, and working conditions of NHS staff. It feels like the idea of a welfare state to provide a safety net for people (which must have a massive impact on mental health) or it not being ideal for doctors to work whilst absolutely exhausted are quaint ideas from years gone by at the moment.

CrouchEndTiger12 · 14/07/2021 19:00

The Canadian system is a cross between private and state

Oh and Michael got a new job over here so we get to move to the city in a few weeks 😀

Once you’re actually in hospital it’s all free but if you need an ambulance you have to pay for it (about $150). Prescriptions are quite expensive so most people get a basic insurance policy if you need regular ones but that’s like, $20 a month.

I don't agree the NHS is underfunded. It has huge sums of money thrown at it, it's how those funds are used.

CastawayQueen · 14/07/2021 19:00

[quote pubble]@CastawayQueen I agree there a number of strains but the issue with an ageing population is more general strain on the healthcare service & a smaller tax paying population.

I think prescriptions should be mean tested [/quote]
Ah yes agreed.
Also I think people who can pay for their care should.
I think younger people do already - when I’ve received NHS prescriptions have had to pay

It shouldn’t be ‘free’ healthcare but ‘affordable’ healthcare. And I say this as someone who’s a potential high earner. The issue is that means testing is a lot of admin and income doesn’t always correlate to more disposable spending money.

Also I find people who need healthcare being able to leave lots of money to their children obscene. Your money is for your life and if you have that much extra everyone else’s shouldn’t be paying for you.

Bargebill19 · 14/07/2021 19:00

[quote Sidge]@Bargebill19 she quoted in euros and converted to sterling 🙂[/quote]
Ah thank you missed that. No wonder I was confused. 😊

pubble · 14/07/2021 18:56

@CastawayQueen I agree there a number of strains but the issue with an ageing population is more general strain on the healthcare service & a smaller tax paying population.

I think prescriptions should be mean tested

CastawayQueen · 14/07/2021 18:53

@pubble

We are going to have to address the fact we have an ageing population & the burden that comes with that but no one wants to "pay" n
We have it in all directions IMO. More disabled children surviving leading to lifetime medical care needs. More need for mental health etc provision for all walks of life. This doesn’t even count public health provision like regular check-ups.

And the truth is - there are clear efficiency gains.
For a developed country the majority of trusts run on PAPER records. Which even my third world country’s hospitals don’t do.
No online appointment booking, needing people to ring up. All of these are basics.

But the worst as people mentioned is political will.

Sometimes I feel like quitting my job and joining politics so I can fix all this annoying shit.

Sidge · 14/07/2021 18:52

@Bargebill19 she quoted in euros and converted to sterling 🙂

Swipe left for the next trending thread