Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that discussion of criminal acts towards children and who the perpetrators are , are of importance to MN users , and threads should remain in AIBU with polls attached.

132 replies

Thevenerableswede · 14/07/2021 10:39

This refers to the thread about an abuser in Canada which was moved, but has happened with other similar posts to the feminist boards. I imagine that everyone here has concerns , not just feminists.

OP posts:
Comingoutfighting · 14/07/2021 21:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

AngeloMysterioso · 14/07/2021 21:26

@itcouldhave what? Where have I referred to you at any point??

Chicchicchicchiclana · 14/07/2021 21:20

@Comingoutfighting

Can somebody who has an interest in keeping the AIBU threads pure please explain what they are actually for? If not to draw attention to matters that concern the vast majority of us, what?
AIBU to ask what is the age gap between your children?

AIBU to ask about your opinion on margarine vs butter?

AIBU to think dog shit left in parks is disgusting?

AIBU to think male crimes being recorded as female crimes is wrong?

Can you not see the difference?

Comingoutfighting · 14/07/2021 20:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

itcouldhave · 14/07/2021 20:38

@AngeloMysterioso Yes, I’m aware it’s happened. My point was that you assumed I thought child safeguarding was unimportant and I don’t think that at all.

As it happens, I agree that the impact on crime reporting and statistics of men identifying as women is a huge issue and one which clearly was not properly thought through.

The response to this concern shouldn’t be to flood random areas of MN with clumsily-worded threads to try and avoid being moved to the correct topic. It should be to make the correct topics appear more in Active. The whole reason topics end up as tumbleweed is because people consistently refuse to use them and post in AIBU and Chat ‘for traffic’. If people posted in the correct topics and MN actually moved threads, the topics wouldn’t be tumbleweed.

AngeloMysterioso · 14/07/2021 20:24

@AuntieStella

Can you post a link to Mumsnet’s Child Safeguarding section?

If you think MN should have one, then ask in Site Stuff and one will be created if there is enough traffic, reflecting both the importance and the interest - actual interest, that is, not what people think others are interested in when they are MNetting (which of couse does not map to RL priorities)

I don't remember anyone ever asking for such a topic

Until your request can be considered, you could try Parenting, Education, News, possibly General Health or Children's Health (depending on what aspect of safeguarding you want to talk about) or if more ephemeral the Chat

Ahem @itcouldhave it’s not presumption, it’s already happened.
itcouldhave · 14/07/2021 20:21

@AngeloMysterioso

Imagine thinking the issue of child safeguarding is so unimportant that it should be shunted out of the most widely read topic board on Mumsnet and into one that rarely sees the light of day.
Imagine being so presumptuous that you know exactly what someone else is thinking.
irresistibleoverwhelm · 14/07/2021 20:00

YANBU. This is a society-wide issue about sexual exploitation, and it shouldn’t be moved to other boards to hide it. Imagine if threads on Sarah Everard or MeToo were automatically moved to “feminism chat”, or threads on racism against the England team were moved to Black Mumsnetters?

This looks like a concerted attempt to bury serious issues around sex crimes because they might reveal some inconveniently hugely important issues.

MrsRockAndRoll · 14/07/2021 19:56

@Floisme

Can you link the story please? The problem is that if we do, this thread will probably be reported and no doubt moved, as was the previous one. You will have to ask the posters doing the reporting what their reasons are.
Good point. I'll google it
Floisme · 14/07/2021 19:54

Can you link the story please?
The problem is that if we do, this thread will probably be reported and no doubt moved, as was the previous one. You will have to ask the posters doing the reporting what their reasons are.

MrsRockAndRoll · 14/07/2021 19:52

Sorry shouts say "that"s ridiculous .....

MrsRockAndRoll · 14/07/2021 19:49

@334bu

Recently unnecessary confusion was caused regarding a person who was described by victims as male but later as female when arrested . This resulted in a great deal of concern in the community as to whether the perpetrator, who was attacking random women, was still at large. Surely , when a dangerous perpetrator is at large, an accurate description from the authorities is the least that we should expect. In the case of this sex offender an inaccurate description might very well result in other victims not coming forward and this is a travesty of justice.
@334bu sets ridiculous. Surely getting accurate descriptions for communication/photo fits can highlight serial criminals & allow the public to help.

Can you link the story please?

AngeloMysterioso · 14/07/2021 19:45

Imagine thinking the issue of child safeguarding is so unimportant that it should be shunted out of the most widely read topic board on Mumsnet and into one that rarely sees the light of day.

itcouldhave · 14/07/2021 19:42

@334bu

*Except some posters are blatantly gaming AIBU by creating polls and framing trans rights issues as an AIBU because they don’t agree with the creation of the new topic.*

So you think that deliberately not giving accurate descriptions of offenders against women and children is not a safeguarding issue? How are people expected to look out for predators or come forward to report a similar attack if the description of the assailant is being deliberately falsified? In what way is this just a " feminist" issue?

Not sure why you’re telling me what I think since you can’t possibly know.

It’s obvious to me at least that a number of posters disagree with the creation of a separate trans rights topic under Feminism and are attempting to evade it by using AIBU to discuss it by framing trans-related discussions as an AIBU.

It’s irritating enough that MN don’t move topics out of AIBU as it is. Frankly, if they’re going to move trans threads out of AIBU they should move all the incorrectly posted threads.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 14/07/2021 19:40

@itcouldhave

Except some posters are blatantly gaming AIBU by creating polls and framing trans rights issues as an AIBU because they don’t agree with the creation of the new topic.

For once, MN is doing the correct thing by moving the trans discussion threads to the appropriate topic.

Also, you are being incredibly transphobic by suggesting that because a male abuser identifies as a woman they are trans.
ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 14/07/2021 19:39

@itcouldhave

Except some posters are blatantly gaming AIBU by creating polls and framing trans rights issues as an AIBU because they don’t agree with the creation of the new topic.

For once, MN is doing the correct thing by moving the trans discussion threads to the appropriate topic.

I'd be fine with that, but they are leaving non-feminism related posts in FWR and not moving them.

They could at least pretend to be even handed.

334bu · 14/07/2021 19:31

Except some posters are blatantly gaming AIBU by creating polls and framing trans rights issues as an AIBU because they don’t agree with the creation of the new topic.

So you think that deliberately not giving accurate descriptions of offenders against women and children is not a safeguarding issue? How are people expected to look out for predators or come forward to report a similar attack if the description of the assailant is being deliberately falsified? In what way is this just a " feminist" issue?

itcouldhave · 14/07/2021 19:25

Except some posters are blatantly gaming AIBU by creating polls and framing trans rights issues as an AIBU because they don’t agree with the creation of the new topic.

For once, MN is doing the correct thing by moving the trans discussion threads to the appropriate topic.

Carriemac · 14/07/2021 18:47

YANBU

AlfonsoTheMango · 14/07/2021 17:31

YANBU.

334bu · 14/07/2021 17:28

Recently unnecessary confusion was caused regarding a person who was described by victims as male but later as female when arrested . This resulted in a great deal of concern in the community as to whether the perpetrator, who was attacking random women, was still at large. Surely , when a dangerous perpetrator is at large, an accurate description from the authorities is the least that we should expect.
In the case of this sex offender an inaccurate description might very well result in other victims not coming forward and this is a travesty of justice.

invisiblesuit · 14/07/2021 16:57

I must say, looking at the police photo of that person, I'm not sure how the person responsible at MN can sleep at night - having ensured that as few people as possible read about what has happened (is happening and will no doubt happen more and more).

Mummyoflittledragon · 14/07/2021 16:50

YANBU
I had a thread a few days ago on the same sort of theme www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4289011-AIBU-to-ask-Mumsnet-to-reconsider-a-decision?pg=1 results weren’t as positive as yours.

I think the more threads like this one and mine. And the more threads are worded in a way to be able remain on AIBU the better.

queenMab99 · 14/07/2021 16:43

This was not a feminist issue, you could be a 'surrendered wife' or a believer in womens inferiority, and still object to men self identilfying as women. It has connotations of interest to feminists, but not limited to that.