Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘All women should be offered pain relief for coil fitting’

359 replies

mrsgrealish69 · 14/07/2021 09:49

I’ve just read a news story about a lot of women finding coil fittings painful and traumatic (certainly was the case for me a decade ago) I think naga munchetty said on the radio or in an interview somewhere that it was an excruciating experience for her.
I’ve seen an NHS response that apparently guidelines state women are offered appropriate pain relief for a fitting. Does anyone know what they mean by this?

I was advised to take a paracetamol beforehand, is this what they are referring to?

OP posts:
Hullabaloo31 · 14/07/2021 13:15

They've been around long enough now for the people who fit them to know there's a massive range of responses, and to advocate doing something about it.

I barely felt anything going in or taking out, but they seemed to expect me to be a bit uncomfortable. I don't remember being told to take anything though.

TheHoundsofLove · 14/07/2021 13:15

It’s a shame as I actually get on extremely well with the copper coil - doesn’t cause me any problems whatsoever. But, I don’t think I could go through having another fitted. My doctor did provide what she thought would be adequate pain relief - I said it was Naproxen before, but I think I could be wrong there and it was something else. It was still excruciating though.

NormanStangerson · 14/07/2021 13:15

@Aprilinspringtimeshower I was basically saying the bickering about pain threshold was a distracting nonsense, as women should all be offered pain relief before enduring any kind of gynaecological procedure. And it is their choice if they take it.

Of course there’s wild variation to anatomy, skill of the administering medic, point in the hormonal cycle, mental well-being (of both patient and clinician), time of day….all these things will impact upon an individual experience and level of pain experienced. So accepting all of that, I simply think women should be offered pain relief and it’s bordering on barbaric that we aren’t.

irregularegular · 14/07/2021 13:14

Are we including mirenas in this or just the copper coil?

Of course women who experience pain or who are likely to experience pain should be offered/given appropriate pain relief. I suppose you don't want to go straight in with significant pain relief that may have detrimental effects of its own when most (not all!!!) women only feel brief cramps.

I'm on my third mirena now and don't remember anyone every offering or suggesting pain relief. But I've never really felt anything either. The replies on here may not be representative.

Notaroadrunner · 14/07/2021 13:12

The coil will be the next thing for me if mini pill doesn't work. I won't have it without general anaesthetic.

icelollies · 14/07/2021 13:12

From reading the thread it seems that you just wont know if its going to hurt or not, so the choice to have pain relief needs to be offered.

For me, i had a mirena the same time as a hysteroscopy, so i did have pain relief. But it felt uncomfortable, and I also had ‘cervical shock’ which left me feeling very nauseous and faint.

I think honesty all round needs to be the best policy, and not just assume you will be fine!

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 14/07/2021 13:09

@NormanStangerson

I also think the argument between those who were in agony and those who found it a walk in the park, to be moot.

Who gives a shit about apparent pain thresholds? The point is, we should be offered anaesthetic. Whether you choose to have it or not is up to you.

I don’t think it is a simple as pain threshold. It is to do with your individual anatomy. People always say pain thresholds- but people don’t have a high or low threshold generally. There are certain things some people find painful and the same person can feel excruciating pain for something someone else breezes through.
AnUnoriginalUsername · 14/07/2021 13:09

@PragmaticWench
Sorry, it only took a second.

No way I'd let a GP try for an hours though! Jesus Christ.

I think it massively comes down to who does it, the woman who did mine did multiple a day, she was a wizz, the nurse who booked me in told me that GPs don't don't nearly as many so aren't as good.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 14/07/2021 13:07

I've never had a painful coil fitting but then again all three fell out within two weeks.
I'm wondering if the birth of DS caused over stretching of my cervix.

jenjen517 · 14/07/2021 13:06

And getting it out was another story. 3 different nurses had a go, couldn't get it, they then let 2 drs in for a few goes each. It was horrendously painful and traumatic. Never again.

jenjen517 · 14/07/2021 13:04

Dr did mine at a sexual health clinic. I was about 20/21. It really, really hurt. I wasn't offered anything for the pain or advised to take anything beforehand.

I breathed through it, she said well done at the end and that she was surprised I hadn't screamed?

Odd comment from her I thought, I was too embarrassed to make a sound. Never mind scream!

luckylavender · 14/07/2021 13:04

It wasn't great but taking it out was much worse than childbirth

Aprilinspringtimeshower · 14/07/2021 13:03

@sandgrown

I don’t remember it hurting much . Maybe it depends on the skill of the fitter ?
No it depends on your cervix and reproductive organ anatomy. If you have given birth vaginally it may be slightly easier/less painful . But there again it might not. Everyone has a different anatomy and everyone will have a different experience around pain and which part of the procedure they feel pain.
SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 14/07/2021 13:01

I'm one of the lucky ones who didn't find it more than a bit uncomfortable.

But they shouldn't be working with my experience as the norm, because that will mean women suffering during coil fittings - if they assume everyone will need pain relief, and give it to them all, then the women who wouldn't have found it painful will have had a bit of pain relief they didn't need - which is way better than women being in pain that could have been avoided.

Matrons · 14/07/2021 13:00

I had a mirena fitted at a sexual health clinic and it was uncomfortable going in but not agony i was advised to take ibuprofen prior. I guess it varies person up person but absolutely agree women's experiences are minimised.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 14/07/2021 12:59

Anecdotally, I’ve noticed more women are getting the coil than ten years ago.

Have the numbers actually gone up?

Is there a reason coils are chosen over the implant? They’re completely pain free. They give a local anaesthetic

Zealois · 14/07/2021 12:58

@flutteredby

Zealois, are you still in pain now? That sounds awful, very similar to my experience.
I'm sorry you had a bad experience too.

I had sharp cramps (again very different to period cramps) for about 3 weeks after, and now 2 months later, I get the pains randomly but thankfully they don't last as long now. I'm trying to work up the courage to go back and get it checked to make sure it's all okay.

After I literally passed out from the shock, the doctor said "it's nothing compared to labour at least!" which I found completely unhelpful...

mindutopia · 14/07/2021 12:56

I believe I was advised to take a paracetamol just before. I didn't because I'm fine with pain. Both fitting it and taking it out were no big deal to me. But I agree that more pain relief options should be available to those that request them.

That said, from a practical perspective, I suspect that gas and air may be tricky for a GP or a standalone sexual health service to administer (particularly if it's one that doesn't do terminations).

ZombeaArthur · 14/07/2021 12:56

I was advised to take paracetamol prior to my appointment which unsurprisingly did absolutely nothing. I was in agony throughout the procedure and passed out later in the day. There’s no way on Earth a man would be expected to undergo anything like this without pain relief!

WendyYourExcellency · 14/07/2021 12:55

My first - before I had kids was very painful. I’ve since had around three more, I don’t find it painful personally since birth. However, some of what you are reporting sounds horrendous. I’m so sorry you’ve been through that and I hope more relief is offered in future.

Re a colonoscopy - I also didn’t have sedation for this (though it is routinely offered). It was far less invasive in my opinion than a coil going in, it was more like an internal pregnancy scan, and certainly far less traumatic than my ex-husband’s attempts at encouraging me to take it up the you know what.

NormanStangerson · 14/07/2021 12:55

@DeathByMascara

Mine got lost and so I had to go to the sexual health clinic to get it removed. I was offered a local anaesthetic, which I took as the first time was so awful. Sadly, the anaesthetic only worked for the cervix and not for the uterus, which took a bit of a bashing when the coil got stuck and had to be hauled out. It was really painful and traumatic.

There are examples of minimising on here from women suggesting those who found it painful had a lower pain threshold than themselves - is just like to point out that I live with a chronic pain condition and am well used to pain and coping with it. But the coil fitting and removal was horrific.

My experience was similar, everything felt pulled and wrenched for ages afterwards. Only I wasn’t offered any local anaesthetic for my cervix. It was absolutely horrific. So much so, the consultant was convinced that from how brutal she’d had to be to get it out, that I was going to pass out and she wouldn’t let me leave. I didn’t pass out, but I was very shocked.
Redwinestillfine · 14/07/2021 12:54

It should be offered. The problem is unless you've had it done before how do you know whether it's going to hurt you or not? I had mine done without any pain relief ( I didn't know that it was something that could hurt, I expected it to be similar to a smear test and for me it was). Since then friends have said they had a horrendous time so it is very individual

duvetdrama · 14/07/2021 12:53

My first one (post birth) didn't hurt much at all but the second one...a different story. I am so glad this has come to light as I was offered no pain relief (done at the doctors surgery) and the female GP fitting it made a comment to me about being too tense - that's because I was in a lot of pain but that made me feel like I was being a bit ridiculous so I didn't say anything Hmm

DeathByMascara · 14/07/2021 12:51

Mine got lost and so I had to go to the sexual health clinic to get it removed. I was offered a local anaesthetic, which I took as the first time was so awful. Sadly, the anaesthetic only worked for the cervix and not for the uterus, which took a bit of a bashing when the coil got stuck and had to be hauled out. It was really painful and traumatic.

There are examples of minimising on here from women suggesting those who found it painful had a lower pain threshold than themselves - is just like to point out that I live with a chronic pain condition and am well used to pain and coping with it. But the coil fitting and removal was horrific.

Spruced · 14/07/2021 12:51

I found it MUCH worse than a smear! I was in pain for days. Taking painkillers beforehand wasn't enough to stop the pain of having it put in.

I can't see any good reason for not offering women something stronger. Some people not finding it that painful is irrelevant. What's the downside of offering? That some people who wouldn't have needed it are given some extra pain relief? Surely that is massively outweighed by the advantage of women who would otherwise have been in horrible pain being spared it.

Looking at the smear test example - I don't find them particularly bad, but if lots of women did and there was a question about potentially offering pain relief routinely, of course I'd say yes. Why wouldn't you?

It doesn't matter if it's down to the skill of the person doing it if lots of women find it painful - that implies that even if it is because of lack of skill (which I don't agree with, based on the nature of the procedure), then enough practitioners are sufficiently unskilled that pain relief should be offered as standard.

I can't see any point in arguing that because you didn't find it painful, other people shouldn't be offered pain relief. It actually seems like an unkind and potentially harmful argument to make.