Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘All women should be offered pain relief for coil fitting’

359 replies

mrsgrealish69 · 14/07/2021 09:49

I’ve just read a news story about a lot of women finding coil fittings painful and traumatic (certainly was the case for me a decade ago) I think naga munchetty said on the radio or in an interview somewhere that it was an excruciating experience for her.
I’ve seen an NHS response that apparently guidelines state women are offered appropriate pain relief for a fitting. Does anyone know what they mean by this?

I was advised to take a paracetamol beforehand, is this what they are referring to?

OP posts:
luxright · 15/07/2021 16:34

My experience having a coil fitted was simply horrendous. I asked several times were they sure they knew what they were doing because the pain was so intense only to be told to calm down and I was 'working myself up' and 'If a baby will come out, a coil will go in!' Shock. I have a reputation for being hard as nails. I have skied down a mountain with a broken arm, had a tooth extraction without anesthetic and merrily hobbled around for a few days on a snapped achilles tendon...NONE of these compared to the coil fitting. Really glad Naga has spoken out, the standard of care for women when it comes to birth and contraception appears to be stuck in the dark ages.

ShitPoetryClub · 15/07/2021 16:03

I have a high pain threshold (3 big babies all born without pain relief and I never bother with anaesthetic for dentistry).
But OMG, the pain of having that coil fitted was the worst in my life. Good luck to Naga for speaking out.

Moggymoggymogmogs · 15/07/2021 15:57

I've had 2 fitted, 12 years apart.

The first one was absolutely horrific. Getting it fitted was one of the most painful things ever experienced and because it wasn't fitted properly my body kept on trying to expel it. Think labour cramps. In the end I pulled it out myself because my then GP wouldn't remove it and told me I needed to give it time to settle. Fuck that.

Second one was a completely different experience. Because I was well aware how much the first one hurt I went to the appointment stoned to the wide on prescription hard-core painkillers. Unsurprisingly it didn't hurtprobably because I was on a different planet I had to get DH to drive because I could barely walk in a straight line, let alone drive.

People's pain is subjective though and women should be listened to and given appropriate pain relief. Just because one person has a coil fitted and it doesn't hurt doesn't mean this goes for all people. And if it wasn't for the oramorph I took, which on the face of it sounds like overkill then I fully expect that round 2 would have been just as painful as round 1.

Oramorph wasn't prescribed for the coil fitting by the way, I have it for a totally different reason.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 15/07/2021 14:58

@minty133

Fitting a coil is just like bad period pains/cramps. Only lasts a few minutes and a bit of stomach ache afterwards. These posts could scare off women wanting effective contraception. The coil is fantastic and no more heavy periods! I had a broken leg and subsequent infections on an Ilazarov frame, you don't know what pain is if you think a coil is painful!
I realise this is going to come as an awful shock to you, @minty133 - but every woman in the world is NOT the same, and just because YOU experienced coil insertion in a particular way does NOT mean every other woman will have the same experience as you.

Frankly, I should not be having to explain this to an adult.

A less skilful HCP doing the insertion can cause more pain than an experienced one. Different women will have different levels of sensitivity in their cervix. They may have different pain thresholds - and having a lower pain threshold is not a moral failing, it is a physical fact, and requires correct treatment/analgesia.

There are plenty of reasons why some women feel more pain during a coil insertion - and as the accounts on this thread clearly demonstrate, it is agonisingly painful for some women - and I believe them. I sincerely hope you are not calling them liars.

Sillyduckseverywhere · 15/07/2021 13:33

@minty133

Fitting a coil is just like bad period pains/cramps. Only lasts a few minutes and a bit of stomach ache afterwards. These posts could scare off women wanting effective contraception. The coil is fantastic and no more heavy periods! I had a broken leg and subsequent infections on an Ilazarov frame, you don't know what pain is if you think a coil is painful!
Really? I snapped my tibia and fibula, dislocated it and had to wait nearly a week for surgery to repair it. Was a walk in the park compared to my coil insertion. Stop minimising everyone's experiences. You sound like a fucking HCP
wishawish91 · 15/07/2021 12:40

Mine was awful. My heart rate dropped to 37bpm and they had me laying down for 30 minutes sipping lucozade through a straw.

musketeersmama · 15/07/2021 10:58

Thank goodness someone is finally talking about this!
My first coil was fitted in hospital 3months after I gave birth to DC2 (without pain relief) & the coil fitting was much worse than than childbirth, absolutely breathtakingly painful.
The second was by a gynaecologist who whipped it out & reinserted without ANY pain - I wasn’t even there to have that procedure done, I was actually having investigation into suspected endometriosis but he went ahead with the coil change as it was due.
Third was in hospital clinic again & toe curling lay sore. No pain relief offered and was cramping/bleeding for the rest of the day. That’s me now til menopause I hope! The reason I persevered with the coil was that I ceased to have any periods at all (previously had endo symptoms) so it felt worth it to me. It’s been bloody blissful (pun intended) to not have periods for a decade!!

MissMooMoo · 15/07/2021 10:49

I had one fitted in March. The DR fitting it used a numbing gel first. I honestly didn't even feel a thing. I also went during the first 5 days of my cycle which apparently makes it much easier for them to fit the coil.

TheSoapyFrog · 15/07/2021 09:28

I guess I've been lucky that I didn't experience any pain when I had the coil fitted (have had 3), although it was suggested to take some paracetamol beforehand.
The fact that so many women are having such horrific experiences means that they absolutely should be offering some decent painkillers.
And I thoroughly believe if it was men having this done, they'd be sedated up to the eyeballs.

Rach212 · 15/07/2021 09:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

deeplyambivalent · 15/07/2021 09:24

I consider myself pretty hard, and took all the paracetamol beforehand, but it was bloody painful. I came out of it feeling a bit traumatised. The strings have since disappeared, and I'm terrified of the day it has to get replaced. This thread makes me feel more determined to demand proper pain management.

NotMyCat · 15/07/2021 09:19

@Brefugee definitely. I need non hormonal so.. condoms. Except I got pregnant on the pill so there's no way I'm trusting condoms alone!
They won't tie my tubes as I'm "too young" Hmm

Maddiemademe · 15/07/2021 09:16

I had a great doctor who gave me local anaesthetic without having to ask. Not sure if it makes a difference that I am disabled/wheelchair bound. I also have a cervix who likes to play hide and seek!

Conchitastrawberry · 15/07/2021 09:15

I had one fitted years ago. It was bloody awful. I removed it myself and didn’t feel a thing. I was offered gas and air.

Brefugee · 15/07/2021 09:12

People do have choices of contraception this isn't the only option out there and if people find it painful I'd avoid it

Just stop it.. RTFT - the coil is a mandatory first treatment for endometriosis as PP have posted. You can't opt your way out of that. It is also one of the HRT delivery methods.

For non-hormonal and controlled-by-the-woman contraception, I can't think of any others. And when you're in tge stirrups with a doctor rummaging around in tour vagina it's a bit late fir "Oops - we should have offered pain relief"

NotMyCat · 15/07/2021 08:02

I think the two issues are
Previously the NHS were saying "MOST women experience some discomfort"
Well discomfort to me is pins and needles or a tight waistband, not pain that makes me faint, and the survey recently done showed most women experienced significantly more pain
Second issue that pain relief isn't routinely offered when women need to know it's an option

For @minty133 I've broken both feet and ankles and walked on one of them, had cauda equina and drove myself to hospital then had 5hr spinal surgery. I still think having a coil fitted hurts!

BoringBettie · 15/07/2021 07:52

I had one put in when I was about 20 (before dc). I feel like I was pushed into it to be honest - but went ahead because I was young and thought they knew best. It was truly one of the most agonising experiences I have ever been through, I was in agony when they fit it and I remember shouting!! For the next two days I was in tremendous pain. I had to call in to work on the first day, the second day I was sent home from work as I couldn’t do anything due to the pain. I think everyone thought I was just being dramatic. I had it in for 2-3 years and then had it removed as it caused me so many problems, including hair loss :( I would never have it again. (This is just my experience, if it is something that works for others that’s great - but unfortunately I have nothing but regrets when it comes to the mirena coil).

toastantea · 15/07/2021 07:35

@lifehappened

Okkkkk I considered having one of these now I'm done with babies but I think I'll pass on that now. Sorry you all went through this. Sounds rank! Although *@toastantea* it's not the earlier posters fault if it didn't hurt them! Ffs she's allowed her own experience, she's not negating anyone else's! It's absolutely not her fault that this is, in the main barbaric!

Another poster who has misread me. I'm not saying it's anyone's fault it didn't hurt them. That would be utterly ridiculous. Mine didn't hurt either. My whole point was that in a discussion about why we should have pain relief offered, as a minimum btw it's basic care, it is unhelpful for posters to simply say 'mine didn't hurt'

It doesn't matter that some people had good experiences in the context of the thread because even those who had no pain should still be able to understand that others do, and recognise that optional pain relief for women is something that we should have.

Telling everyone 'mine didn't hurt' and adding absolutely nothing more to the thread is backwards. Nobody is asking if it hurt, the thread is about pain relief being available if needed, not whether the individuals insertion hurt.

I have already said mine didn't hurt (in response to people misunderstanding what I am saying, not as my initial reply) but I absolutely recognise the need to shout for pain meds for women.

RickiTarr · 15/07/2021 07:27

One thing with mine was that he told me to make an appointment when i had my period - several appointments were kept free for people like me with irregular cycles - as it is less painful at that time because the cervix is softer. Is that a thing in the UK?

Yes that’s a thing. However insertions and removals are mostly done in primary care surgeries by nurses or GPs who have done the training, but not necessarily much practice, apparently.

There does seem to be a perpetual shortage of appointments and trained personnel. I had my first one 22 years ago and this has been the case whenever I’ve needed insertion, removal or - once - a position check. Which might contribute to the other problem; That NHS staff often refuse to remove them when women request it. They stall, wheedle and generally try to put you off.

habibibibi · 15/07/2021 07:23

@Brefugee

So in the UK it isn't fitted by an OB/GYN? I had one many years ago (pre DCs) and it was hugely painful getting it in and out but nothing like some of the really bad stories here. I'm really sorry anyone has to go through that and really angry that any woman is just told to suck it up and that the disbelief in the agony is on an industrial scale.

Here in Germany it is done by an OB/GYN in their surgery (I guess that's still true) but I'm not sure if they offer pain relief. One thing with mine was that he told me to make an appointment when i had my period - several appointments were kept free for people like me with irregular cycles - as it is less painful at that time because the cervix is softer. Is that a thing in the UK?

I had my last one fitted by an OB/GYN in the US. Extremely painful and not offered any pain relief (so not just a NHS thing).
habibibibi · 15/07/2021 07:22

@LilyTheMink
I also don't think anyone should be put off IUDs. They are indeed really a good contraceptive choice.
All people are saying here is that women should be OFFERED adequate pain relief. That's all. Even if you don't need it, surely it's reassuring that it's there in case you do!

Brefugee · 15/07/2021 07:21

So in the UK it isn't fitted by an OB/GYN? I had one many years ago (pre DCs) and it was hugely painful getting it in and out but nothing like some of the really bad stories here. I'm really sorry anyone has to go through that and really angry that any woman is just told to suck it up and that the disbelief in the agony is on an industrial scale.

Here in Germany it is done by an OB/GYN in their surgery (I guess that's still true) but I'm not sure if they offer pain relief. One thing with mine was that he told me to make an appointment when i had my period - several appointments were kept free for people like me with irregular cycles - as it is less painful at that time because the cervix is softer. Is that a thing in the UK?

RickiTarr · 15/07/2021 07:16

@ASpoolofBlueThread

To be honest, I could've done with proper pain relief when I had a smear test. There's a systemic issue in healthcare with expecting women to suck up pain relating to their reproductive organs. Whether it's endo, period pain, menopause, smears, coils or giving birth. There seems to be an expectation that we just suck up the pain. It's a massive issue and it needs sorting! Angry
TBH, any pain a woman might have is poorly treated. Odds on medics will either ignore female pain, under-treat female pain, or miss the correct diagnosis altogether and ascribe the symptoms to somatic illness. It’s absolutely endemic.
ASpoolofBlueThread · 15/07/2021 07:12

To be honest, I could've done with proper pain relief when I had a smear test. There's a systemic issue in healthcare with expecting women to suck up pain relating to their reproductive organs. Whether it's endo, period pain, menopause, smears, coils or giving birth. There seems to be an expectation that we just suck up the pain. It's a massive issue and it needs sorting! Angry

LilyTheMink · 15/07/2021 07:05

I've had two and they were a little bit uncomfortable- definitely no more than that.

They are amazing and totally stop my periods.

My periods used to hurt a lot, every month.

Please dont be too put off if you are thinking of getting one.