Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.. to move to a village?

36 replies

MarvEll · 14/07/2021 07:36

We need to move as rental is coming to an end and have enough saved to buy. We currently live quite remotely outside a small town which has all the basics but isn't that nice. DH is very keen to move to a small town / village like how he grew up. Wants DC to walk to school, have local friends etc. This all sounds lovely and I am on board... Except I'm getting a bit nervous about neighbours, lack of space, limited village parking. We have a beautiful house we've put an offer on. Gorgeous house, private road, pretty central in the village - so also quite near the neighbours. Help convince me moving to a village is going to be all we're dreaming of!
YABU - Village life is the bomb, you're going to love it
YANBU - it's hell on earth, you're going to miss the rolling hills currently outside your door

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SarahAndQuack · 14/07/2021 23:21

There's a fair point about Daily Mail readership though.

I live in a very small village (a hamlet), where I think we are the only non-Tory voters. Everyone is very kind, but our Tory-voting neighbours were shocked and surprised to find we couldn't get married in the local church (it's C of E; we're lesbians), and truly didn't believe that was the case. I expect if we had happened to be black, or disabled, or whatever else, they would have been politely shocked at racism or disablism, too.

It really is a particular kind of problem when you move somewhere where people's main response to discrimination is to be shocked and upset at the idea, and yet where their voting habits/media consumption lead them to presume everything is already ok and no one needs to complain.

AdoptedBumpkin · 14/07/2021 23:12

it’s not as though it’s some niche hobby paper for Methodist Goths who like caravanning.

Quote of the day Grin

DoorAjar · 14/07/2021 23:09

[quote Snog]@DoorAjar I read the guardian myself but it's not mainstream.

Daily Mail is mainstream.

Check the circulation figures here:

[[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List]]offnewspapersinntheUniteddKingdombyycirculation

[/quote]
But it’s a mainstream daily newspaper, even if it’s circulation is smaller than the DM — it’s not as though it’s some niche hobby paper for Methodist Goths who like caravanning.

SarahAndQuack · 14/07/2021 23:00

I'm not sure if I'm understanding what's the most important bit of your question. If I understand you rightly, you're saying you are currently very isolated/rural, so the move to a village would be a move into a community, but you're also concerned about the smallness of a village community as compared to the local town/other places you've lived?

I can't answer the first bit, as the hamlet I live in is the most rural place I've ever lived. I know people who've moved here from somewhere more isolated, who find it smothering how quickly gossip spreads and how much people want to be involved in your life.

Otherwise, though: what's the deal with limited parking? That sounds really dubious. If there's not proper parking, what on earth is the point of being out of town? We viewed a house in a large village recently that had no parking - it was a full 100k less than other similar houses with easy parking. Are they planning to develop nearby?

I mention that because, where I live, there's a lot of building work going on in what used to be sleepy little villages, which are rapidly becoming suburbs of the local city. The town next to me was once a large village with a few shops - pub, post office, butchers, etc. It's served by a one-way bridge over the river, controlled by traffic lights. All very quaint, until someone got planning permission to built a large estate on the edge, and then another beyond that.

I would be really cautious about buying in a village that was about to expand massively, unless you see advantages for yourself in that expansion.

Redhound · 14/07/2021 22:41

I moved to the very edge of a small village/hamlet, best of both worlds; peace, space and fields but a friendly community for events and support if needed.

JellyBabiesFan · 14/07/2021 22:37

Also a majority of the other residents were right wing, Tory voting daily Mail readers, so it was difficult to find my tribe

Sounds awesome.

DdraigGoch · 14/07/2021 22:34

Best way to find out what your village is like is to go there. Have a wander around at different times of day and night. Is it quiet? Are parking spaces available on a weekend?

Ask a few people what village life is like locally, too.

Snog · 14/07/2021 22:16

@DoorAjar I read the guardian myself but it's not mainstream.

Daily Mail is mainstream.

Check the circulation figures here:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ListoffnewspapersinntheUniteddKingdombyycirculation

lactofree · 14/07/2021 17:15

I grew up in a village, really liked it however it isn't now the same village

Back then everybody knew each other but now after a lot of house building in the last twenty years it feels like a small town full of strangers

Every village is different though

DoorAjar · 14/07/2021 17:14

@Snog

Regarding finding friends locally, it's much harder to find your tribe from a small pool of people. Especially if your interests or politics aren't mainstream.
Yes, but remember that what you may consider 'mainstream' may not be considered that way in your new environment. I don't see my politics as any kind of alternative lifestyle choice, but when I first moved to the village and ordered a newspaper delivery, the (extremely nice) postmaster looked at me and said, deadpan, 'If you like, I can introduce you to the only other person in the village who reads the Guardian.' Grin
DoorAjar · 14/07/2021 17:10

Think very carefully. I grew up in the countryside (not UK) and have lived all over the world in urban and rural environments, am confident, sociable and arrived with a small baby, a predisposition to like the place and a will to get involved, but the only place I have been entirely miserable was a large, pretty, prosperous Midlands village.

Despite volunteering, attending baby groups, going to the pub, using local businesses, getting involved in local events, having a child in nursery and later the village school, and working locally (as did DH), I have never met people who were so utterly insular.

I concluded after a while that if the majority of a population have never left the locality, and have always known one another, living surrounded by family and people they have known since childhood and marrying among them, they simply never acquire the normal skills the rest of us develop in how to behave around people you don't know.

It wasn't even that they weren't open to making new friends which obviously was their right it was that they'd never had to think of themselves and their environment as not always already utterly familiar to everyone they encountered. It was simply too much trouble to them to have to get their head around someone who hadn't always known them, or who had come from somewhere else.

I did try for seven years, getting involved in stuff and having people over, and then gave up and moved away. I have a rather lovely watercolour of the extremely pretty main village street that I bought from the local art circle's annual exhibition because it's the only place DS remembers living, and obviously it's important for him to remember it and every time I see it on the wall, I remember how miserable an experience living there was.

Snog · 14/07/2021 16:47

Regarding finding friends locally, it's much harder to find your tribe from a small pool of people. Especially if your interests or politics aren't mainstream.

Snog · 14/07/2021 16:44

There can be flip sides to living in a village. I was brought up in one and would never live in one again due to

Dependency on driving everywhere. I really hate wasting my time in the car.
Cannot drink alcohol except at home due to needing to drive
Crap public transport
Lack of independence for kids as need to rely on lifts - this one is huge. I see friends providing taxi services and am extremely grateful that is not my life.
Small Mindedness
Everyone knowing your business
Often nowhere to walk as lack of pavements and lots of mud
Limited deliveroo options
Limited leisure and recreation options

Obviously if you don't drink or find a village with good public transport that would mitigate.

MarvEll · 14/07/2021 11:31

Thanks for the input- you're right, there's quite a difference in what you get! The village is pretty well connected to the nearby small city, nearby nice town as well as other little villages. I think secondary they all get a bus to the college.
I think we can walk to baby groups, a couple of cafes and a half hour walk or so to the library, a really nice restaurant etc.
I am quite sociable and looking forward to having local friends hopefully, as I don't have any nearby here. So hard to tell if there's much of a community as altho we've been a few times, it's covid, so not giving a fair reflection probably!

@Twisky I totally get what you mean for the older teens etc as I grew up rurally and had to get lifts or very complicated busses which wasn't ideal. The village should be much better than that as there's a train station to London about a ten min drive, a bus to the nearest town & city so hoping that will be easy enough. Only have very small DC at the moment so things may well have changed in ten years!

@DrCoconut these squabbles are exactly what I'm worried about! Because we're on our own out here we don't have any drama like that currently

@ineedaholidayandwine sounds like it's really worked out for you! Yours sounds lovely!!

OP posts:
Twisky · 14/07/2021 10:57

Think about your children! Does it have adequate public transport? How are you placed for secondary schools? Will there be friends and others from school in the same village that they can walk to?

I grew up in a small village and whilst I can appreciate it had values - striong community, friendly etc etc as a secondary school child I didnt like it - there were no buses and so I had to ask parents for lifts everywhere or cycle and there was no chance of going out to the shops or 'into town' as my school friends did - it all had to be coordinated with lifts etc. I felt trapped and envied the freedom that my town-living peers had - they could just walk to school, could walk out or catch a bus to meet up with others or go the cinema, bowling, nightclub etc in the nearyby bigger town. It was hard on my parents too as they had to be constantly driving me around. Town life allows much more freedom and independence!

ineedaholidayandwine · 14/07/2021 10:19

Just moved from rural to a village for the same reasons your husband states. We've sacrificed a big garden being here but we love it, the neighbours are nice but keep to themselves, the garden is sufficient to sit out, host a small BBQ etc, we have the park/pub/dr's and shop all within a 7 min walk, the school is a 10 min walk so it's great for us and our daughter getting out and socialising, i'm so happy we made the move, as is our daughter, she loves her friends can now come round easier, that she can walk to the park etc.

VestaTilley · 14/07/2021 10:18

Totally depends on the village, whether you’ll work and/or commute, whether you’re sociable and outgoing and whether or not you have very small children.

Nobody can advise as different people like very different things. I thought I wanted village life, but actually DH and I have settled on a small cathedral
city with great access to the countryside in walking distance. I think it’ll suit us very well; really rural wouldn’t have suited me as we’d like more DC (eventually...) and I like to be in walking distance of baby groups, etc.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

DrCoconut · 14/07/2021 10:16

I know I would find it very hard to live in a village. I'm used to having facilities nearby and I'd hate people meddling in my business. Everyone I've known who lives in a village has had what to me are horror stories about squabbles over fence colours/parking/lawn mowing etc. The relative anonymity of my town street suits me. However, it's right for some people and I guess that is the main thing, if it suits you.

newnortherner111 · 14/07/2021 10:10

Has no-one mentioned connectivity, broadband, mobile phone reception? I'd be checking that before considering any village.

Also worth checking home food delivery, in case you are unable to travel .

AdoptedBumpkin · 14/07/2021 10:07

It depends on the village to some extent. Some villages will be like goldfish bowls; others will be like small towns.

My experience has been mixed but overall pretty good. One down side which I noticed pretty early was there are a few people who seem to be involved in every community thing, and also a few people who gossip which I suppose happens in many small communities.

On the whole - neighbours are friendly or neutral, there is a peaceful atmosphere at weekends, and DD attends a school with a community feel - the teachers recognise all the children and parents.

Brainwave89 · 14/07/2021 09:45

I moved out to a village a number of years ago, and I am very happy here. That being said I think there are a couple of points to take into account. Firstly, villages like towns have different personalities, and some can be quite unfriendly, so do your normal house moving due diligence on local media, walk round at different times of day and one I always find useful, a couple of visits to the pub if there is one.

Typically in village life everyone will know everything about you. This can be very supportive at times of need. When I was looking after my late FIL, I got lots of help from people I did not know. Conversely, there will be times when it might feel intrusive.

The isolation is a positive and a negative. I like the quietness and open spaces, the nature and the other things that come with village life, but be really honest with yourself if this is for you. Some people really do not like it. I have access to some great meat and vegetables here, but the best restaurants, nightlife etc are a good distance away. I do a number of overnight stays in London, so this is fine for me but I would consider if this is doable.

Think about the sighting of the village you are moving to. What are transport links like? For us our village is ten miles from the nearest (Small) city, which is quite good but does mean as teens the taxi of mom and dad was very active indeed.

For a short while our teens hated living here... but now love it again, so this is also worth considering.

Mischance · 14/07/2021 09:37

I live in a very small village and love it. There is a real sense of community; people look out for each other; I can look out on beautiful hills.

We have a primary school (where I am governor), an ancient church, a community hall (where the post office visits for 2 hours on a Tuesday), a pub - that's it.

I love it and am very happy indeed that my children were brought up with the sense of security that being part of a small community brings. They loved it too.

But we are all different - cities make my heart sink - especially when I see everyone walking past homeless beggars.

In a small community there is a real sense of being neighbours - of us all being in it together and part of a whole.

cadburyegg · 14/07/2021 09:32

We moved to a village 4 years ago. I had my reservations, because I grew up in a city and we were living in a market town. It was a really good decision. I am a single mum now but I’ve met friends for life here through baby and toddler groups that were running pre covid. I help to run one of the toddler groups in normal times. It’s generally quiet and safe, my children (age 3 and 6) scoot to school most days. I love being able to walk to school, whenever we go to a playground we often see people we know/DS1’s friends, I like that my children will have local friends.

The village does have a co op and another small shop for amenities and post office, I wouldn’t have moved here without that. It has a pub too but I rarely visit tbh. There is another village close by with a large supermarket and a few other shops.

We have a very decent garden for the kids and a driveway, but I wouldn’t want too much, more to maintain!

The city is only 6 miles away. You do have to be able to drive to get to other places though, which I’m assuming you already do based on where you live. The bus service is dire.

Pinkdelight3 · 14/07/2021 09:30

I can't vote as I'm a city girl so a village would be hell for me yet in your circumstances I'd definitely go village over your remote alternative. Your DH's perspective seems very sensible. Mumsnet is full of threads from rural parents bemoaning issues with school catchments and transport, how their DC would have to walk miles along unlit country roads etc., and then issues around distance to friends, hospitals, work opportunities etc. In light of that and putting my own village feelings side, I'd go for it. Your new house sounds lovely, you might like your neighbours or at least benefit from having some, and if you have parking there and the rest is walkable then why would village parking be an issue?

Calmdown14 · 14/07/2021 09:23

I always wanted to live remotely like you are now but having lived in a village, I wouldn't swap it.
Helps my neighbours are lovely though!
We are right on the coast path so plenty of walking from the front door but enough here that not stuck without the car and don't have to drive everywhere.
How old are your kids? Sadly some things you just can't know until you try them but cutting out on ferrying them about everywhere sounds a decent trade off to me